IAA — Merger or Acquisition (February 2023)
81 slides from IAA's merger presentation, Feb 22, 2023
Slide 1: Ritchie Bros.' Acquisition of IAA
Investor Update Ritchie Bros.’ Acquisition of IAA February 22, 2023
Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements
Forward - Looking Statements This presentation contains information relating to a proposed business combination transaction between Ritchie Bros . Auctioneers Incorporated (“RBA”) and IAA, Inc . (“IAA”) in addition to information relating to the investment into RBA by Starboard Value LP and certain
Slide 3: No Offer or Solicitation
No Offer or Solicitation This presentation is not intended to and shall not constitute an offer to buy or sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any securities, or a solicitation of any vote or approval, nor shall there be any offer, solicitation or sale of securit ies in any jurisdicti
Slide 4: Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Non - GAAP Financial Measures This presentation contains certain non - GAAP financial measures, including adjusted EBITDA, adjusted EBITDA margin, adjusted EPS, adjusted net income, adjusted net debt, and free cash flow. These non - GAAP financial measures are not calculated in accordance with GAAP
Slide 5: Disclaimers Regarding Financial Forecasts
Accordingly, RBA cannot assure readers that the Forecasts are necessarily predictive of the future performance of RBA, IAA or th e combined company or that actual results will not differ materially from those presented in the Forecasts. Additionally, the Forecasts cover a number of years into the fu
Slide 6: Addressing Shareholder Concerns, Preserving Long-term Upside
Addressing Shareholder Concerns, Preserving Long - term Upside 5 x Luxor ignores upside potential created through the combination and their standalone valuation of RBA is replete with mathematical errors or purposefully deceptive x RBA investors benefit from Starboard’s investment; any notional "val
Slide 7: Significant Value Creation and Upside Potential Beyond the Standalone Strategic Plan
Significant Value Creation and Upside Potential Beyond the Standalone Strategic Plan 1
Slide 8: Value Creation: Cost Synergies and Revenue Opportunities
Cost Syngs. Only Cost Syngs. + Illustrative % of Revenue Opportunities Realized $100-120+MM 25% 50% 75% 100% ($900M) 16.0x + $9 + $26 + $42 + $59 + $76 14.5x + $8 + $23 + $38 + $53 + $69 13.0x + $8 + $21 + $34 + $48 + $61 Illustrative PF Trading Multiple¹ 1 Value Creation Source: Bloomberg ; IBES Me
Slide 9: Confidence in Initial Cost Synergy Estimates
Executive Leadership Near - Term Focus on “Quick Wins” to Drive Near - Term Value Creation Confidence In Our Initial Cost Synergy Estimates with High Visibility on Expected Time - To - Achieve 1 Public Company Costs Vendor Consolidation Vacant Positions x Consolidation of duplicative roles x Harmoni
Slide 10: Potential Drivers of Estimated EBITDA Opportunity
Note: Potential opportunities and related information included for illustrative purposes only and do not imply future targets , e xpectations or guidance. Estimates do not incorporate potential costs to achieve or specific timeframes. Opportunity Description Potential Drivers of Estimated EBITDA Opp
Slide 11: Integration Planning Is Going Well
1 Value Creation B Integration planning is well underway with goal across all of these areas to have detailed execution plans and accountable owners in place for day 1 post - close Example Opportunity Next Steps Grow Domestic IAA Sales • IAA sales teams currently compiling briefing on top current an
Slide 12: Realization of Growth Opportunities Would Improve Metrics
27.9% 29.4% Potential realization of incremental growth opportunities would drive meaningful improvement of metrics $2.2B $5.1B $137M $375M Note: Forecasts do not imply future targets, expectations or guidance, and should not be relied upon as such. See the section e ntitled "Certain RBA Financial F
Slide 13: Pro Forma Capitalization and De-Leveraging
1 Net debt reflects pro forma total debt less cash. 2 Assumes $110mm run - rate cost synergies. Adj EBITDA per company’s reported definition, which includes add - backs for share - based payments expense, acquisition - related costs, loss / (gains) on disposition of property plant and equipment, cha
Slide 14: Enhanced Pro Forma Financial Profile and Re-Rate Opportunity
Accretive growth and margin opportunities, coupled with further de - leveraging, expected to transform the financial profile of the pro forma company and, in combination with operational priorities and strong management execution, create a meaningful opportunity to re - rate • IAA’s 2 - year average
Slide 15: A Step-Function Accelerant of Our Strategic Vision
A Step - Function Accelerant of Our Strategic Vision 2
Slide 16: Strategic Vision: RBA Marketplace Flywheel
2 Strategic Vision Onsite, Live Auctions… …Have Evolved into the RBA Marketplace Flywheel As RBA attains “trusted advisor” status via its marketplace offering increased transaction velocity will accelerate profitabl e g rowth Solutions, Insights and Services Offering Will Drive Customer Engagement A
Slide 17: Marketplace Engine Serving Diverse Verticals and Assets
Source: Company information. 1 “Other” includes: Energy, Mining, Forestry & Environmental, Marine, Aircraft & Rail, Asphalt & Concrete, Aggregate, Vocational Trucks, Vehicles & Buses, Trailers, Industrial Support, Demolition & Recycling and Attachments. Powerful Marketplace Engine That Already Serve
Slide 18: IAA Accelerates Our Marketplace Efforts
Marketplace Assets Offerings Today x Proximity Sales Services Automation x Process Automation +210 Yards The Trusted Global Marketplace for Insights, Services, and Transaction Solutions for Commercial Assets and Vehicles 2 Strategic Vision Leveraging marketplace and existing customer base, provides
Slide 19: RBA and IAA Have a Massive Combined Footprint
Source: Company filings and Company materials. 2 Strategic Vision Capital - Efficient Mixture of Leased, Owned and Option - Based Properties x Diverse Array of Yards Ranging from 10 – 60+ acres in size x Strong North American Presence and Accelerating International Footprint x Attractive Metro Locat
Slide 20: Combined Footprint Advances Each Organization's Growth Strategy
IAA Combined Footprint Benefits x Acceleration of “local” yard strategy unlocking new customers and driving incremental GTV x International footprint with “Auction” yards in a combined 11 countries Traditional Yards • Already built • Inexpensive land • Large plots of land • Economies of scale • Sign
Slide 21: IAA Local Yards Allow RBA to Scale More Quickly and Profitably
IAA Possesses a Network of Already - Profitable Yards with Proximity to Customers; Eclipses Existing RBA Pace of ~1 Satellite Yard per Month IAA Yards Possess Key Assets… Trained Staff … And Come With Structural Advantages Built In… Technology Excess Capacity Near Urban Locations Enabling efficient
Slide 22: IAA Can Leverage RBA Yards to Improve CAT Response
Ritchie Bros. “Auction” Yard | Orlando, FL x Ritchie Bros. possesses 41 “Auction” yards globally; these facilities average ~60 acres of usable storage space x Yards are most utilized when live auctions are taking place on - site (fully utilized ~50% of the time) x Ritchie Bros. has numerous “Auction
Slide 23: RBA's International Operations Will Accelerate IAA's Expansion
RBA’s International Operations Will Accelerate IAA’s Expansion in High - Potential Markets RBA Operates Yards in Several Attractive Geographies Where IAA Does Not… …RBA Has the Framework to Accelerate IAA’s International Expansion Region Car Parc 1 Germany 48mm x - Italy 40mm x - France 38mm x - Mex
Slide 24: Our Team Has the Right Experience
Salvage Volume Throughput Speed of Response Carmen Thiede Chief Transformation and People Officer Baron Concors Chief Product & Technology Officer Matt Ackley Chief Marketing Officer Chief Strategy Officer Ann Fandozzi Chief Executive Officer Eric Jacobs Chief Financial Officer Jim Kessler President
Slide 25: Integration Management Office Structure
Integration Management Office (IMO) Structure IMO Guiding Principles Steering Committee Integration Management Office Functional Teams People (Including Comms) Value: Cost Synergies Value: Post - Close Revenue Oppty. Deal Close & Regulatory HR Technology Finance Operations Legal Marketing • RBA has
Slide 26: IAA Operates in an Attractive End-Market with a Complementary Business Model
IAA Operates in an Attractive End - Market with a Complementary Business Model 3
Slide 27: IAA's Business Model Is Highly Complementary to Ritchie Bros.
Large Footprint +210 Global Yards Asset - Light Attractive Consignment Model The Salvage Auction Process Closely Resembles Ritchie Bros.’ Used Equipment Auction Process Sellers Buyers Vehicle is consigned and moved to yard Sale preparation: titling, inspection, imaging Title transfers and buyer retr
Slide 28: Secular Industry Drivers Independent of Economic Factors
23 % IAA Auto Suppliers Auto Dealers Auto OEMs 7% IAA Auto Suppliers Auto Dealers Auto OEMs Secular Industry Drivers are Independent of Economic Factors IAA’s Strong Outperformance During the Financial Crisis Key Demand Drivers Miles Driven Accident Rates Salvage Rates x x Furthermore, salvage volum
Slide 29: Salvage Volume Growth Drivers
$2,425 $3,718 2010 2021 Source: Company Information; IAA Investor Presentations; CCC Intelligent Solutions; U.S. Bureau of Transportation; Goldman Sa chs Global Investment Research; IHS Global Insight; Department of Commerce; Bloomberg LP. Growing / Aging Car Parc Vehicle Complexity / Repair Costs T
Slide 30: IAA's History of Resilient Financial Performance
IAA Has Demonstrated Resilient Financial Performance Through Cycles and Post KAR Spin… '04A - '22A Revenue CAGR 13% '22A Revenue / Y - o - Y Growth '19A - '22A Revenue CAGR 13% '22A Adj. EBITDA 2 / % Outperformance vs. Consensus 3 U.S. Overall Volume Growth 1 / U.S. Insurance Volume Growth 1 5% / 9%
Slide 31: A Deliberate, Thoughtful Process Led by Our Independent Board
A Deliberate, Thoughtful Process Led by Our Independent Board 4
Slide 32: Team Has Transformed RBA's Platform into a Marketplace
Team has transformed RBA’s platform into a Marketplace for Insights, Services and Transaction Solutions, which has led to a series of organic growth opportunities, acquisitions and partnerships: …all while fortifying RBA through expansion of the local yard strategy and new sales coverage model to re
Slide 33: And Markets Have Taken Notice
Innovator of the Year: How Ann Fandozzi is dragging Ritchie Bros. Auctioneers into the digital age “[Fandozzi has pushed] to transform the 60 - year - old company from its auction - house roots into a comprehensive marketplace for the used - equipment sector , offering an array of analytics tools ;
Slide 34: A Robust and Thorough Study of IAA Preceded this Acquisition
A Robust and Thorough Study of IAA Preceded this Value Creating Acquisition 4 x Management began assessing the strategic fit of IAA in early 2020 ▪ As part of regular discussions on M&A pipeline , RBA management presented IAA as a potential combination to the RBA Board in August 2020 x RBA and IAA’s
Slide 35: Discounted Purchase Multiple Underpins Re-Rate Opportunity
Source: Company filings and FactSet. 1 Reflects historical period from the completion of IAA's spin - off from KAR through 11/4/22, the last unaffected trading day before transaction announcement 2 Represents pro forma blended EV / NTM EBITDA Multiple, calculated as Ritchie Bros. EV plus IAA EV divi
Slide 36: Amended Transaction and Starboard Investment
Reduced Consideration $70M Added Special Dividend $45M Improved 1 RBA Pro Forma Ownership Increases 1 RBA’s interest in the RBA / IAA upside potential Increased Cash to IAA Without Adding Debt $10.00 $12.80 x Engaged in extensive discussions with our shareholders x Identified Starboard as potential
Slide 37: RBA Share Price Since Announcement and Investor Reactions
$62.59 $46.00 $48.00 $50.00 $52.00 $54.00 $56.00 $58.00 $60.00 $62.00 $64.00 $66.00 04-Nov 25-Nov 16-Dec 06-Jan 27-Jan 17-Feb RBA Share Price | Since Initial Announcement Undisturbed Share Price (04 - Nov - 2022) $ 62.32 Recent Investor Reactions 4 We've got a lot of confidence in Ann. We think base
Slide 38: Independent Board of Directors Overview
4 x All non - executive directors are independent x 6 of 9 directors have CEO experience x John Kett: CEO of IAA and has extensive senior executive experience in the automotive, insurance claims, technology and services industries x Bill Breslin : Significant experience in claims management and loss
Slide 39: Addressing Shareholder Concerns, Preserving Long-term Upside
Addressing Shareholder Concerns, Preserving Long - term Upside 5
Slide 40: Addressing Investor Concerns: Claims and Facts
Claims Facts Deal Will Distract Management and Destroy Value x The Existing RBA Value Creation Roadmap Remains Unchanged x Acquisition of IAA removes existing management distractions (e.g., back - end systems, new yard set up) to enable greater focus on the highest value activities x Core of RBA Is
Slide 41: The Existing RBA Value Creation Roadmap Remains Unchanged
The Existing RBA Value Creation Roadmap Remains Unchanged • Over the last three years, RBA management has worked to position the business through investments in our offerings, systems and people • As the equipment cycle turns to provide a tailwind to our business, we remain uniquely positioned to re
Slide 42: Sales Team Remains Well Positioned to Drive GTV Growth
Ownership Services Transactional Services Omnichannel Platform Drives Buyer and Seller Activity Strategic Accounts Territory Managers Inside Sales No cost synergies attributed to salesforce rationalization Dedicated team pursuing the sourcing of inventory globally, further driving GTV growth Progres
Slide 43: Background of the Evergreen Targets
Source: RBA Management, FactSet, Public filings Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. Background of the Evergreen Targets What are the Evergreen Targets? • The Evergreen metrics were first introduced in 2015, by prior management, as
Slide 44: Background of the Evergreen Targets (Cont'd)
Source: RBA Management, FactSet, Public filings Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. Background of the Evergreen Targets (Cont’d) Ritchie Bros. Evergreen Model (2015 Investor Day) 5 Addressing Investor Concerns B 34 The Evergreen Ta
Slide 45: Historical GTV Performance Demonstrates Aspirational Nature of Targets
35 5 Addressing Investor Concerns B Historical GTV Performance Demonstrates Aspirational Nature of Evergreen Targets Source: Company filings Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. Historical GTV Growth Before 2022, RBA only hit its GT
Slide 46: Hypothetical GTV and Adj. EBITDA Under Evergreen Targets
Source: RBA Management, FactSet, Public filings Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. EBITDA deducts share - ba sed payments expense. 1 Flowthrough reflects Adj. EBITDA as a percentage of GTV . 2 Evergreen Targets applied Year - over
Slide 47: Actual Performance vs. Evergreen Target Implied Performance
$ 9,030 $ 6,026 Hypothetical 2022² 2022 Actual Actuals Came in ~33% Lower Than Implied Hypothetical $ 642 $ 428 Hypothetical 2022² 2022 Actual Actuals Came in ~33% Lower Than Implied Hypothetical Actual Performance vs. Evergreen Target Implied Performance Illustrative Hypothetical GTV ($mm) 5 Addres
Slide 48: Board Approved and Public Record Earnings Growth Targets
Source: RBA Management, FactSet, Public filings Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. Board Approved and Public Record 2022 - 2025 Earnings Growth Targets 5 Addressing Investor Concerns B 38 Commentary Publicly Disclosed Targets for
Slide 49: Board-Approved Compensation Plans Align with Base Case
2021A 2022E 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E $ 362 $ 415 $ 443 $ 484 $ 532 $ 601 2021A 2022E 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E Source: RBA Management, Public filings Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. Base case forecasts do not imply future targets,
Slide 50: Fairness Opinion Based on Board's Best Reasonable Expectations
Fairness Opinion Should Be Based on the Board’s Best “Reasonable” Expectations 5 Addressing Investor Concerns B 40 x The Board’s responsibility is to evaluate any transaction against the reasonable, “best estimates” for the company’s go - forward performance x Concurrent with the “Base Case”, sensit
Slide 51: RBA Base Case Forecasts vs. Consensus
Source: RBA Management, FactSet, Public filings. Note: Forecasts do not imply future targets, expectations or guidance, and should not be relied upon as such. See the section en titled "Certain RBA Financial Forecasts" in the Registration Statement for important information regarding such forecasts.
Slide 52: Capex and Investment in Growth
How does Luxor expect the business to accelerate growth if we do not invest? Their assertions around our financial forecasts highlight their continued fundamental misunderstanding of our business 42 Capex was Partially Offset by Smaller D ivestitures Source: Company filings Note: Forecasts do not im
Slide 53: Nonsensical Assumptions and Math Errors in Luxor's Valuation
Derives enterprise value estimate by incorrectly discounting levered free cash flow using WACC discount rate, rather than unlevered free cash flow 4 Luxor DCF Model Terminal Year '22E - '26E 2026 CAGR Adj. Operating Income $780 19.4% % Growth 19.4% Adjusted Net Income $508 21.8% (+) D&A 150 (-) CapE
Slide 54: Luxor Claims RBA Trades at a Discount to Peers
Luxor Claims That RBA Trades at a Discount to Peers… …But They Are Comparing Apples to Oranges Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. Note: Evergreen targets do not imply, and should not be relied upon as, future expectations or guidance. 1 Based on Capital IQ and Bloomberg finan
Slide 55: Luxor Uses Inflated Estimates and Cherry-Picked Peer Group
Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 1 Based on Capital IQ and Bloomberg financial figures as of February 17th, 2023. 2024 Capital IQ consensus estimates are genera lly in line with RBA’s Base Case, as disclosed in the proxy materials. B Luxor Uses Inflated Estimates and a Cher
Slide 56: Luxor Peer Group Smaller than Proxy Peers
Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 1 Based on Capital IQ and Bloomberg financial figures as of February 17th, 2023. Proxy Peers exclude Grubhub and Stamps.com, which are no longer standalone public companies B Luxor Uses Inflated Estimates and a Cherry - Picked Peer Group Whe
Slide 57: RBA Trades at Premium to Proxy Peers
Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 1 Based on Capital IQ and Bloomberg financial figures as of February 17th, 2023. 2024 Capital IQ consensus estimates are genera lly in line with RBA’s Base Case, as disclosed in the proxy materials. Proxy Peers exclude Grubhub and Stamps.com
Slide 58: Analyst Ratings, Price Targets and Commentary
Broker Pre - Nov. Announcement Current 1 Key Commentary Market Perform Outperform ($65 – 70 / Share) $60 / Share $62 / Share Neutral Buy ($72 / Share) $64 / Share $71 / Share We believe RBA management’s successful track record and ability to enhance IAA’s value proposition/KPIs … high conviction tha
Slide 59: IAA Investments in Growth Drivers
Initiative Key Action Strategic Importance Catastrophic Event Servicing Grew CAT footprint to include 3,500 overflow acres; established CAT - focused response team Ensures IAA has ability to meet customer needs when demands are highest Yard Footprint Expansion 1,100 acres added since spin - off, bri
Slide 60: Luxor's Discussion of the Yard Synergies Is Misleading
Luxor Claims That RBA Can Achieve Its Goals Inexpensively… …But Neglects Several Key Considerations Luxor’s Discussion of the Yard Synergies Is Extremely Misleading Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 1 Reflects 2023E EV / EBITDA multiple paid as at 20 - Jan - 2023, just prior
Slide 61: CAT Response Capabilities Continue to Improve
Despite Claims that IAA’s Service Levels are Declining, CAT Response Capabilities Have Continued to Improve and Are Enhanced by RBA Hurricane Ian (Oct. 2022) • ~18,000 total units • 93% of assignments picked up within 10 days IAA's CAT Approach: 2017 & Prior Continuous Improvement Drives Robust CAT
Slide 62: Starboard Investment Is Convertible Perpetual Preferred Equity
Starboard Investment is Convertible Perpetual Preferred Equity , and NOT Convertible Debt as Some “Detractors” Have Claimed Perpetual Nature & Capital Structure Flexibility • Unlike convertible debt, does not have to be repaid on a fixed maturity date, RBA has ability to manage capital structure thr
Slide 63: Luxor's Valuation of the Preferred Shares Is Misleading
Luxor’s Valuation of the Preferred Shares is Misleading and Inaccurate, and Demonstrates a Lack of Understanding of Security’s Structure 5 Addressing Investor Concerns D Luxor Inaccurately Inflates the Valuation of the Preferred Shares by Ignoring their Perpetual Nature Luxor Materially Overstates t
Slide 64: Luxor's Third-Party Validation Claims
Luxor Claims to Have Third - Party Validation… …But Luxor Actually Asked the Banks to Value a No - Names Security With Completely Different Terms Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 1 Excluding standard change - of - control redemption feature and Ritchie Bros. share repurchas
Slide 65: Preferred Terms Comparison
Terms Date • January 23, 2023 • January 31, 2023 Size • $485M • $900M Initial Dividend Rate • 5.5% • 6.25% Dividend Increases • After 4 years: 7.5% • After 9 years: Greater of SOFR+600bps and 10.5% • Issuer has call rights at par, should the Holder choose to increase the dividend rate • After 7 year
Slide 66: Entrenchment Claim and Facts
“Agreement Seeks to Entrench Management and the Board” Claim Facts • Starboard’s investment will not vote at the special meeting and Starboard is free to abstain from any subsequent votes, and need not vote with management • Standstill only goes into effect if the deal is approved and goes away once
Slide 67: Concluding Perspectives
Concluding Perspectives
Slide 68: Accelerating Value Creation for Shareholders
+ : Accelerating Value Creation for Shareholders Significant value creation opportunity through faster growth, EBITDA margin expansion, and rapid deleveraging and realization of incremental growth opportunities IAA is a step - function accelerant to RBA’s strategic vision, enhancing customer proximi
Slide 69: Vote Yes on the White Proxy Card to Unlock Shareholder Value
Vote “Yes” on the White Proxy Card to Unlock Shareholder Value Vote Yes on the White Proxy Card! 1 Represented the LTM period as of October 2, 2022 for IAA; IAA reported Adj. EBITDA. The Board unanimously recommends that RBA shareholders vote in favor of the transaction x Management has the capacity
Slide 70: Appendix A: Addressing Other False Claims Made by Luxor
Appendix A: Addressing Other False Claims Made by Luxor
Slide 71: Luxor Stretches the Truth on Harvard Business Review Article
Luxor Routinely Stretches the Truth: For Instance, Luxor Cites a Harvard Business Review Article That Actually Makes The Opposite Argument They Claim Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. Harvard Business Review, 2016. “But the new economics of multisided platforms, which we exp
Slide 72: Luxor's Deceptive Analysis of IAA's Competitive Position
Luxor’s Graphic Shows IAA Having Access to Many Fewer Buyers than Copar t… …But the Metric Is Wrong and the Graphic Is Distorted Luxor Presents a Deceptive Analysis of IAA’s Competitive Position Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. Copart 61% 16% IAA 22% After correcting Luxor’
Slide 73: Luxor's False Claims About the Preferred Financing
Luxor’s False Claims About the Preferred Financing… …Are Entirely Unfounded Luxor’s Criticism of the Starboard Preferred Displays a True Lack of Understanding Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 1 Excluding standard change - of - control redemption feature and Ritchie Bros. sh
Slide 74: Luxor Misrepresents the Standstill Agreement
Luxor Misrepresents the Standstill Agreement in an Attempt to Claim that Ritchie Bros. Is “Buying the Vote” Luxor Misrepresents the Governance Elements of the Starboard Transaction Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. • Luxor implies that Ritchie Bros. is attempting to “buy the
Slide 75: Luxor's Points Conflict With One Another
Luxor Points to RBA’s Strong Growth As Evidence That Forecasts Are Too Low… …But They Also Claim That the Growth in EBITDA Was a One - Time Benefit From COVID Luxor’s Points Conflict With One Another and Are Not Mutually Compatible Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. 63 If Lux
Slide 76: If Copart Is a Comparable Company, How Is IAA Unrelated?
If Copart Is a Comparable Company, How Can IAA Be in an “Unrelated Industry”? Luxor Claims That IAA Is an “Unrelated” Business, Yet Uses Copart As a Comparable Company in Its Valuation Analysis Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. “Note: All comparable companies above use conse
Slide 77: Luxor's Claim on RBA Shareholder Familiarity With IAA
Luxor Offers Little Support for Their Claim That RBA’s Shareholder Base Was Already Familiar With IAA Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. • Many of the research analysts covering Ritchie Bros. were not already familiar with the auto salvage industry • Of the 10 analysts includ
Slide 78: Luxor's Hailstorm Analysis Is Misleading
Luxor Bizarrely Focuses Its Analysis on Hailstorms Rather Than Hurricanes Luxor’s Analysis of Catastrophic Events is Misleading and Limited Source: Luxor Presentation released February 17 th , 2023. • While hailstorms do occasionally create some excess demand for auto salvage, as they can do signifi
Slide 79: Appendix B: Overview of RBA & IAA
Appendix B: Overview of RBA & IAA
Slide 80: RBA: Global Leader in Used Equipment & Services
RBA: Global Leader in Used Equipment & Services • RBA is a world leader in asset management and disposition technologies for commercial assets, primarily related to construction and transportation assets • Sells a broad range of primarily used commercial and industrial assets as well as government s
Slide 81: IAA: Leading Global Marketplace for Vehicles
IAA: Leading Global Marketplace for Vehicles • Expansive omnichannel digital marketplace connecting vehicle buyers and sellers • Strong global relationships with insurance carriers, leading dealerships, fleet lease and rental car companies, and charitable organizations • Multiple bidding / buying di