Florida Public Utilities — Merger or Acquisition (October 2009)
31 slides from Florida Public Utilities's merger presentation, Oct 5, 2009

Slide 1: A Strategic Merger That Delivers Shareholder Value
Filed by Florida Public Utilities Company pursuant to Rule 425 under the Securities Act of 1933 and deemed as Definitive Additional Material filed Pursuant to Rule 14a-6(j) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Subject Company: Florida Public Utilities Company Commission File No.: 001-10608 A St

Slide 2: Safe Harbor Statement
Safe Harbor Statement Forward-Looking Statements This document includes statements that do not directly or exclusively relate to historical facts. Such statements are “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 21E of the Securities Exchan

Slide 3: Additional Information and Where to Find It
Additional Information and Where to Find It In connection with the proposed merger, Chesapeake Utilities Corporation (“Chesapeake”) has filed a registration statement on Form S-4 (Registration No. 333-160795) with the SEC, containing a joint proxy statement of Chesapeake and Florida Public Utilities

Slide 4: Introductions
Introductions John R. Schimkaitis Chesapeake Utilities Corporation President & CEO Michael P. McMasters Chesapeake Utilities Corporation Executive Vice President & COO Beth W. Cooper Chesapeake Utilities Corporation Senior Vice President, CFO, Treasurer and Corporate Secretary John T. English Florid

Slide 5: Agenda
Agenda I. Transaction Overview and Strategic Rationale II. Chesapeake: A Proven Track Record of Creating Shareholder Value III. Well-Positioned to Maximize Future Growth Opportunities IV. Conclusion 5

Slide 6: I. Transaction Overview and Strategic Rationale
I. TRANSACTION OVERVIEW AND STRATEGIC RATIONALE 6

Slide 7: The Companies
The Companies Chesapeake Utilities Corporation 909 Silver Lake Boulevard Dover, Delaware 19904 (302) 734-6799 Internet address: www.chpk.com Incorporated in 1947, Chesapeake is a diversified utility company engaged in natural gas distribution, transmission and marketing, propane distribution and who

Slide 8: Transaction Overview
Transaction Overview April 20, 2009 Announcement of Transaction Stock-for-stock transaction Structure FPU will become a wholly owned subsidiary of Chesapeake Combined Company will remain on the NYSE under “CPK” Fixed Exchange Ratio 0.405 shares of Chesapeake stock for each FPU share Merger Considera

Slide 9: Compelling Value to Both Companies' Shareholders
Compelling Value to Both Companies’ Shareholders 9

Slide 10: Increased Scope, Scale and Financial Strength
Increased Scope, Scale and Financial Strength For the year ended December 31, 2008 CPK FPU Combined (dollars in thousands) Company Historical Net Income $13,607 $3,486 $17,093 Market Capitalization $214,918 $64,372 $279,290 Enterprise Value* $339,385 $124,051 $463,436 Average Customers: Natural Gas

Slide 11: Expanded Florida Footprint
Expanded Florida Footprint Holmes Jackson Nassau Gadsden Suwannee Duval Clay Washington Union Calhoun Alachua Flagler Liberty Gilchrist Levy Marion Volusia Citrus Lake Seminole Sumter Orange Hernando Pasco Osceola Hillsborough Polk Indian River Manatee DeSoto Martin Palm 15 Counties Served by CPK Be

Slide 12: A Stronger Post-Merger Utility Platform
A Stronger Post-Merger Utility Platform Enhances Chesapeake’s utility foundation Advanced Further builds upon Chesapeake’s natural Information gas and propane distribution expertise Services Addition of electric distribution to energy Propane Distribution portfolio provides another platform to and W

Slide 13: Significant Synergy Opportunities
Significant Synergy Opportunities Financial Synergies Audit Legal Insurance Information technology Administrative Interest expense Other public company costs Operational Synergies Migrate to one utility billing system Eliminate redundant facilities and related costs ~Significant opportunities for op

Slide 14: Chesapeake's Offer Is Compelling and Superior to Alternatives
Chesapeake’s Offer Is Compelling and Superior to Alternatives Energy, Inc. made an unsuccessful competing bid to acquire FPU and now is urging shareholders to reject FPU’s value-creating combination with Chesapeake. FPU’s Board unanimously determined that Energy, Inc.’s proposal did not provide suff

Slide 15: FPU's Process Led to a Fairly-Priced Transaction
FPU’s Process Led to a Fairly-Priced Transaction That Delivers Significant Value to Shareholders Contrary to assertions by Energy Inc., the lack of a market check by FPU in April of 2009 did not result in a lower value for shareholders. FPU’s Board has for some time considered potential transactions

Slide 16: FPU's Board Conducted an Independent, Objective Evaluation Process
FPU’s Board Conducted an Independent, Objective Evaluation Process Focused on Maximizing Shareholder Value Contrary to Energy Inc.’s assertions, FPU’s Board conducted a process focused on maximizing shareholder value. FPU’s experienced and independent Board was closely engaged in the process of eval

Slide 17: II. Chesapeake: A Proven Track Record of Creating Shareholder Value
II. CHESAPEAKE: A PROVEN TRACK RECORD OF CREATING SHAREHOLDER VALUE 17

Slide 18: Why Join Together?
Why Join Together? The future is brighter on a combined basis. The combination of the two companies will dilute the costs associated with being a public company which have increased in the last five years. Both companies will benefit from increased access to capital, pursuing and executing on projec

Slide 19: Strong Strategy for Past and Future Value Creation
Strong Strategy for Past and Future Value Creation • Chesapeake has a strong balance sheet, an experienced management team and a proven strategy. • Over the long-term, Chesapeake has continued to remain focused in executing its strategy – achieving steady growth in our core energy businesses, making

Slide 20: A Leader in Deploying Capital Effectively
A Leader in Deploying Capital Effectively Chesapeake is one of only two companies within the peer group detailed below that exceed the mean in average ROE and reinvestment of capital. Chesapeake invests almost 85% more capital than the average natural gas utility while still achieving above-average

Slide 21: Consistent Growth in Earnings
Consistent Growth in Earnings Approximately 5% - Earnings Per Share Compound Annual Growth Rate In spite of a struggling economy and stagnant housing market, Chesapeake continues to grow its energy business while making new capital investments to generate future growth. 21

Slide 22: Shareholder Return
Shareholder Return Source: Bloomberg Chesapeake’s shareholder return has exceeded the industry peer group, as well as FPU. 22

Slide 23: Making Capital Investments to Drive Growth in Earnings, Dividends and Market Value
Making Capital Investments to Drive Growth in Earnings, Dividends and Market Value Chesapeake market capitalization has more than doubled over the last 10 years and approximately quadrupled over the last 16 years. 23

Slide 24: Prudent Policy, Steadily Increasing Dividends
Prudent Policy, Steadily Increasing Dividends Chesapeake has paid dividends for 48 consecutive years. Over the last five years, Chesapeake has continued to make capital investments that generate earnings growth, increasing its earnings retention ratio and its dividend per share. Based on the current

Slide 25: Strong, Well-Capitalized Balance Sheet
Strong, Well-Capitalized Balance Sheet Combined Company will have financial strength and flexibility to access capital markets to fund future growth. 41% 59% 25

Slide 26: III. Well-Positioned to Maximize Future Growth Opportunities
III. WELL-POSITIONED TO MAXIMIZE FUTURE GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES 26

Slide 27: Experienced, Capable, Independent Board of Directors
Experienced, Capable, Independent Board of Directors Board of Directors Appointed Ralph J. Adkins Chairman of the Board 1989 Formerly the CEO of Chesapeake (1990-1999) Eugene H. Bayard, Esq. Law Partner 2006 Wilson, Halbrook & Bayard, Georgetown, DE Richard Bernstein President & CEO, LWRC Internatio

Slide 28: Combination of Proven Management
Combination of Proven Management Management Pre-Merger Post-Merger John R. Schimkaitis Chesapeake Utilities Corporation Chesapeake Utilities Corporation President and Chief Executive Officer President and Chief Executive Officer Florida Public Utilities Company Chairman, President and Chief Executiv

Slide 29: IV. Conclusion
IV. CONCLUSION UTILITIES TR MCORPONATION

Slide 30: Closing Remarks
Closing Remarks Chesapeake Utilities Corporation / Florida Public Utilities Company A Solid Combination for Growth Focused on what matters most to investors: Financially conservative company with stable earnings Expectation for Chesapeake continuing dividend policy* Proven execution of growth strate

Slide 31: This is a Solid Combination for Growth. Thank You.
This is a Solid Combination for Growth Thank You. A Solid Combination for Growth
Source: SEC EDGAR · 425 filed Oct 5, 2009