NCR Voyix Corporation · NYSE:VYX
NCR Voyix — NCR — Investor Presentation (December 2010)
166 slides from NCR Voyix's investor presentation, December 2010
Slide 1: Production Part Approval Process (PPAP)
Production Part Approval Process (PPAP)
Slide 2: What is PPAP?
What is PPAP? •Production Part Approval Process •Standard used to formally reduce risks prior to product or service release, in a team oriented manner using well established tools and techniques •Initially developed by AIAG (Auto Industry Action Group) in 1993 with input from the Big 3 - Ford, Chrys
Slide 3: Purpose of PPAP
Purpose of PPAP •Provide evidence that all customer engineering design record and specification requirements are properly understood by the organization •To demonstrate that the manufacturing process has the potential to produce product that consistently meets all requirements during an actual produ
Slide 4: When is PPAP Required?
When is PPAP Required? New part Engineering change(s) Tooling: transfer, replacement, refurbishment, or additional Correction of discrepancy Tooling inactive > one year Change to optional construction or material Sub-supplier or material source change Change in part processing Parts produce
Slide 5: Benefits of PPAP Submissions
Benefits of PPAP Submissions •Helps to maintain design integrity •Identifies issues early for resolution •Reduces warranty charges and prevents cost of poor quality •Assists with managing supplier changes •Prevents use of unapproved and nonconforming parts •Identifies suppliers that need more develo
Slide 6: Production Run
Production Run •PPAP data must be submitted from a production run using: Production equipment and tooling Production employees Production rate Production process All data reflects the actual production process to be used at start-up! NCR Confidential 6
Slide 7: Run @ Rate
Run @ Rate •The purpose of a Run @ Rate is to verify the supplier’s manufacturing process is capable of producing components that meet NCR’s quality requirements, at quoted tooling capacity, for a specified period of time •Verification of the Run @ Rate will be at the Supplier Quality Engineer’s (SQ
Slide 8: Official PPAP Requirements
Official PPAP Requirements 1. Design Records 2. Authorized Engineering Change Documents 3. Customer Engineering Approval, if required 4. Design Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (DFMEA) applied in special situations 5. Process Flow Diagram 6. Process Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (PFMEA) 7. Co
Slide 9: NCR's PPAP Requirements
NCR’s PPAP Requirements 1. Design Records 2. Authorized Engineering Change Documents 3. Customer Engineering Approval, if required 4. Design Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (DFMEA) applied in special situations 5. Process Flow Diagram 6. Process Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (PFMEA) 7. Contr
Slide 10: NCR's PPAP Requirements
NCR’s PPAP Requirements 1. Design Records 2. Authorized Engineering Change Documents 3. Customer Engineering Approval, if required 4. Design Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (DFMEA) applied in special situations 5. Process Flow Diagram 6. Process Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (PFMEA) 7. Contr
Slide 11: PPAP Submission Levels
PPAP Submission Levels Production Warrant and Appearance Approval Level 1 Report (if applicable) submitted to NCR Production Warrant, product samples, and Level 2 dimensional results submitted to NCR Production Warrant, product samples, and Level 3 complete supporting data submitted to NCR Productio
Slide 12: PPAP Submission Level Table
PPAP Submission Level Table PPAP Levels for Submission & Retention * = Supplier shall retain Submission Level at appropriate Requirement Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5 locations, and submit to 1. Design Records of Saleable Product R R R * R NCR S upon = Supplier shall request. NCR a. For pr
Slide 13: Definition of Risk
Definition of Risk •High Risk Parts associated with multiple critical features, complex design, or high end technology that is not yet established in the general manufacturing environment Supplier’s quality system and/or quality performance is not to NCR satisfaction •Medium Risk Parts that have
Slide 14: Submission Level Requirements
Submission Level Requirements •New Parts Level 2 is required for Low Risk Parts Level 3 is required for Medium and High Risk Parts •Part Changes Level 3 is required for Parts produced at a new or additional location Supplier Quality Excellence will define the level required for all other changes
Slide 15: PPAP Status
PPAP Status •Approved The part meets all NCR requirements Supplier is authorized to ship production quantities of the part •Interim Approval Permits shipment of part on a limited time or piece quantity basis •Rejected The part does not meet NCR requirements, based on the production lot from
Slide 16: Electronic Submission Requirements
Electronic Submission Requirements •NCR requires that all PPAPs be submitted electronically •Use of paper submission must have prior approval by the SQE •Submission must be received on or prior to the PPAP due date •Review and Approval Process: NCR will attempt to review and provide feedback within
Slide 17: NCR PPAP Playbook
NCR PPAP Playbook •What is the NCR PPAP Playbook? An Excel spreadsheet containing templates of the documents suppliers are required to submit to NCR •Why use the PPAP Playbook? Simplifies the process for suppliers by serving as a “checklist” of what needs to be submitted to NCR Reduces the number
Slide 18: Production Warrant
PRODUCTION WARRANT NCR Confidential 18
Slide 19: Production Warrant
Production Warrant Production Warrant What is It? Part Name NCR Part Number • Document required for all newly Shown on Drawing no. Supplier Part Number Engineering Drawing Change Level Additional Engineering Changes Dated Dated tooled or revised products in which Safety and/or Government Regulation
Slide 20: Production Warrant
Production Warrant Production Warrant Part Name NCR Part Number Shown on Drawing no. Supplier Part Number Engineering Drawing Change Level Dated Additional Engineering Changes Dated Part Name / NCR Part Number Shown on DrawingEngineering released finished Safety and/or Government Regulation Yes No P
Slide 21: Production Warrant
Production Warrant Production Warrant Part Name NCR Part Number Supplier Manufacturing Information Shown on Drawing no. Supplier Part Number Show the name and code assigned to Engineering Drawing Change Level Dated the manufacturing site on the purchase Additional order Engineering/ Changes contract
Slide 22: Production Warrant
Production Warrant Reason For Submission REASON FOR SUBMISSION Check the appropriate box(es) Initial Submission Change to Optional Construction or Material Engineering Change(s) Sub-Supplier or Material Source Change Tooling: Transfer, Replacement, Refurbishment, or additional Change in Part process
Slide 23: Production Warrant
Production Warrant Explanation / Comments Declaration Declaration Provide any explanatory Entercommentsthe Affirmation number onof that the pieces the samples represented submission results or manufactured by the during any deviations warrant theare representative and Supplier Authorized Signature s
Slide 24: Production Warrant Reviewers Checklist
Production Warrant Reviewers Checklist Must be completely filled out Must be signed by the supplier P/N must match the PO Submitted at the correct revision level Submitted at the correct submission level Specify the reason for submission NCR Confidential 24
Slide 25: Authorized Engineering Change Documents
AUTHORIZED ENGINEERING CHANGE DOCUMENTS NCR Confidential 25
Slide 26: Authorized Engineering Change Documents
Authorized Engineering Change Documents The supplier shall provide authorized change documents for those changes not yet recorded in the design record, but incorporated in the product, part or tooling, such as: ECNs (must be approved, not pending) Specifications Feasibility studies Supplier chan
Slide 27: Process Flow Diagram
PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM NCR Confidential 27
Slide 28: Process Flow Diagram
Process Flow Diagram What is It? Operator Separate Cutting Evaluate for • A visual diagram of the entire process from receiving through Tags Corrective Action (31) shipping, including outside Yes Operator Operator Operator Operator Operator Get Traveler and Operator Download Cutting Program Observe
Slide 29: Process Flow Diagrams
Process Flow Diagrams PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM Part Number: Date: ECL: Part Description: Prepared By: Fabrication Product and Inspect Item # Item # Operation Move Store STEP Process Control Methods Description Characteristics 1 The process flow 2 diagram utilizes these 3 symbols to clearly 4 identify ea
Slide 30: Process Flow Diagram - Example
Process Flow Diagram - Example LEO PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM F/QA/05/0 Part No. : 484 -0100264 Customer Name : NCR Doc. No. : PFD/NCR/0264 Shaft Pressure Part Name : : Page : 1 of 1 Rev. No. / Date : O / 10.08.09 Paddle Incoming CNC Sliding Deburring & Cleaning Final Isnpection Inspection Machining 10 15
Slide 31: Star Exercise
Star Exercise •Divide into teams •Distribute supplies −Paper for Stars −Instructions for making Stars −Scissors •Using the instructions handed out in class, make 10 Shuriken Stars •This exercise will prepare your team to complete future exercises 45 Minutes NCR Confidential 31
Slide 32: Process Flow Diagram – Star Exercise
Process Flow Diagram – Star Exercise Incoming Paper Star Final Folding Cutting Folding Tucking Inspection Inspection 05 10 15 20 25 30 Patrol Insp Report Shipping Packing 40 35 Inspection as per If rework 100% Rework Operation layout possible Inspection OK Not OK Scrap Next Operation NCR Confidentia
Slide 33: Process Flow Diagrams Reviewers Checklist
Process Flow Diagrams Reviewers Checklist Process Flow must identify each step in the process Should include abnormal handling processes Scrap Rework Process Flow must include all phases of the process Receiving of raw material Part manufacturing Offline inspections and checks Assembl
Slide 34: Process FMEA
PROCESS FMEA NCR Confidential 34
Slide 35: Process FMEA (PFMEA)
Process FMEA (PFMEA) Failure Mode and Effects Analysis What is It? System/C omponent: Design Responsibility: (Design FMEA) FM E A Number: P age P repared by: FM E A Date (Orig.) of (R ev.) • A tool used to identify and prioritize risk areas C ore T eam: Action Results O D Ite m / O D S Potential Cau
Slide 36: FMEA Origin
FMEA Origin •Created by NASA following Apollo 1 mission failure •Allows us to take a proactive approach to what can go wrong in a process and manage our risks better NCR Confidential 36
Slide 37: Process FMEA (PFMEA)
Process FMEA (PFMEA) POTENTIAL FAILURE MODE AND EFFECTS ANALYSIS (PROCESS FMEA) Print # Rev. FMEA Number Item: Process Responsibility: Prepared by: Model Year(s)/Vehicle(s) Key Date Date (Orig.) Team: Date (Rev.) Action Results Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Potential Failure Cause(s)/ Curre
Slide 38: PFMEA - Step 1
PFMEA - Step 1 Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Class Potential Failure Failure Modes Cause(s)/ Current Process Sev Process Step Effect(s) of Mode Mechanism(s) Controls For each Process Failure Input, of Failure determine the ways in which the Op 70: Manual Insufficient wax Allows integrity 7
Slide 39: PFMEA - Step 2
PFMEA - Step 2 Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Class Potential Failure Cause(s)/ Current Process Sev Process Step Effect(s) of Mode Mechanism(s) Controls Failure of Failure Op 70: Manual Insufficient wax Allows integrity 7 Manually 8 Variables check 5 280 application of coverage over breach o
Slide 40: PFMEA - Step 3
PFMEA - Step 3 Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Class Potential Failure Cause(s)/ Current Process Sev Process Step Effect(s) of Mode Mechanism(s) Controls Failure of Failure Op 70: Manual Insufficient wax Allows integrity 7 Manually 8 Variables check 5 280 application of coverage over breach o
Slide 41: PFMEA - Step 4
PFMEA - Step 4 Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Class Potential Failure Cause(s)/ Current Process Sev Process Step Effect(s) of Mode Mechanism(s) Controls Failure of Failure Op 70: Manual Insufficient wax Allows integrity 7 Manually 8 Variables check 5 280 application of coverage over breach o
Slide 42: PFMEA - Step 5
PFMEA - Step 5 Assign Severity, Occurrence, and Detection ratings Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Class Potential Failure Cause(s)/ Current Process Sev Process Step Effect(s) of Mode Mechanism(s) Controls Failure of Failure Assign Severity Op 70: Manual(HowInsufficient serious wax Allows inte
Slide 43: PFMEA - Definition of Terms
PFMEA - Definition of Terms Severity (of Effect) - severity of the effect on the Customer and other stakeholders (Higher Value = Higher Severity) Occurrence (of Cause) - frequency with which a given Cause occurs and creates Failure Mode. (Higher Value = Higher Probability of Occurrence) Detection (C
Slide 44: An Example of Rating Definitions
An Example of Rating Definitions Severity Occurrence Detection* Rating Hazardous Very high and Cannot detect High 10 without almost or detection warning inevitable with very low probability Loss of primary High repeated Remote or low function failures chance of detection Loss of Moderate Low detecti
Slide 45: PFMEA - Step 6
PFMEA - Step 6 Potential Potential R.P.N. Occur Detec Class Potential Failure Cause(s)/ Current Process Sev Process Step Effect(s) of Mode Mechanism(s) Controls Failure of Failure Op 70: Manual Insufficient wax Allows integrity 7 Manually 8 Variables check 5 280 application of coverage over breach o
Slide 46: Analyzing the PFMEA
Analyzing the PFMEA • Once the RPN Numbers are Sort by RPN to determine determined, they can be used to the most significant failure modes prioritize the most significant failure modes. • Sort the FMEA by the RPN numbers. Graphical and statistical tools can help the team select a ? How many items sh
Slide 47: PFMEA – Remediation Guidelines
PFMEA – Remediation Guidelines Severity – can only be improved by a design change to the product or process Occurrence – can only be reduced by a change which removes or controls a cause. Examples are redundancy, substituting a more reliable component or function or mistake-proofing. Detection – can
Slide 48: FMEA – Step 7
FMEA – Step 7 • Determine Actions Recommended to reduce High RPNs Action Results Potential R.P.N. Potential Failure Recommended Responsibility & R.P.N. Process Step Effect(s) of Occ Sev Det Mode Actions Target Date Actions Taken Failure Op 70: Manual Insufficient wax Allows integrity 280 Add positiv
Slide 49: FMEA – Steps 8 and 9
FMEA – Steps 8 and 9 Action Results Potential R.P.N. Potential Failure Recommended Responsibility & R.P.N. Process Step Effect(s) of Occ Sev Det Mode (responsibility) Resp Actions Target Date Actions Taken Failure Assign a specific person Op 70: Manual who will Insufficient wax be responsible Allows
Slide 50: Summary Steps To Complete a FMEA
Summary Steps To Complete a FMEA 1. For each Process Input, determine the ways in which the Process Step can go wrong (these are Failure Modes). 2. For each Failure Mode associated with the inputs, determine Effects on the outputs. 3. Identify potential Causes of each Failure Mode. 4. List the Curre
Slide 51: PFMEA Exercise
PFMEA Exercise Instructions •Open the PPAP Training Templates.xls file, then select the PFMEA worksheet. •Using process steps 20 and 25 from the completed Star Process Flow Diagram handout, complete 2 rows of the PFMEA. 30 Minutes Use the file PPAP Training Templates.xls NCR Confidential 51
Slide 52: Process FMEA Tips and Lessons Learned
Process FMEA (PFMEA) Tips and Lessons Learned • Collaborative Effort: Do not try alone, use a group • Very laborious: Time consuming process. Take necessary breaks. • Action items are required for completion • Train team ahead of time by explaining scoring criteria • Proper preparation is needed for
Slide 53: Process FMEA Reviewers Checklist
Process FMEA (PFMEA) Reviewers Checklist Verify there is a system for prioritizing risk of failure such as RPN numbers of 125 or above Make sure that high RPN process concerns are carried over into the control plan Make sure that all critical failure modes are addressed Safety Form, fit, func
Slide 54: Control Plan
CONTROL PLAN NCR Confidential 54
Slide 55: Control Plan
Control Plan What is It? A document that describes how to control the critical inputs to continue to meet customer expectations of the output. Objective or Purpose • Primary reference source for minimizing process and product variation. • Description of how teams should react to out-of-control situa
Slide 56: Control Plan
Control Plan Tool Interaction Key S O D R E 6 Sigma Project Project Idea Department/Group Project Potential Potential Actions High Level Process Map Process Step Process E Potential Causes C Current Controls E P O Resp. Actions High Level Process Map Failure Mode Failure Effects Recommended Inp ut V
Slide 57: NCR's Control Plan
NCR’s Control Plan CONTROL PLAN Prototype Pre-Launch Production Control Plan Number Key Contact/Phone Date:(Org.) Date (Rev.) Part Number/Latest Change Level Core Team Customer Engineering Approval/Date (If Req'd.) Part Name/Description Supplier/Plant Approval/Date Customer Quality Approval/Date(If
Slide 58: Control Plan
Control Plan 3 Distinct Phases CONTROL PLAN Prototype Pre-Launch Production Control Plan Number Key Contact/Phone Date:(Org.) Date (Rev.) Part Number/Latest Change Level Core Team Customer Engineering Approval/Date (If Req'd.) Part Name/Description Supplier/Plant Approval/Date Customer Quality Appro
Slide 59: Control Plan
Control Plan Administrative Section CONTROL PLAN Prototype Pre-Launch Production Control Plan Number Key Contact/Phone Date:(Org.) Date (Rev.) Part Number/Latest Change Level Core Team Customer Engineering Approval/Date (If Req'd.) Part Name/Description Supplier/Plant Approval/Date Customer Quality
Slide 60: Control Plan
Control Plan Process, Machine/Tools, Characteristics CONTROL PLAN Characteristics Part/Process Define the characteristics Prototype Pre-Launch Production Use this area to define of the product or process Controlpart/process Plan Number number and Key Contact/Phone Date:(Org.) Date (Rev.) description
Slide 61: Control Plan
Control Plan Specifications, Measurement, Sample Size & Frequency Sample Size What is the size of the CONTROL PLAN sample you should gather data from? Prototype Pre-Launch Production Control Plan Number Specifications/Tolerance Key Contact/Phone Date:(Org.) Date (Rev.) Use this area to define upper/
Slide 62: Control Plan
Control Plan Control Method, Reaction Plan Control Method Method that will be used CONTROL PLAN to control the process Prototype Pre-Launch Production Control Plan Number Key Contact/Phone Date:(Org.) Date (Rev.) Part Number/Latest Change Level Core Team Customer Engineering Approval/Date (If Req'd.
Slide 63: Control Plan
Control Plan Audit Plans •Audit plans should be included in the control plan as a separate line. •Auditing is an important tool for control. •Process auditing should be a key element of the quality system of a business. •Audits generally cover: Effectiveness of controls Control plan (say) vs. wh
Slide 64: Control Plan – Example
Control Plan – Example A supplier manufactures a circuit board with electronic components soldered on the board. Properly soldered connections are the major product characteristics. Two major process characteristics for the wave solder machine are solder level and flux concentration. An automated fe
Slide 65: Control Plan Exercise
Control Plan Exercise Instructions • Open the PPAP Training Templates.xls file, then select the Control Plan worksheet. • Using the completed Star Process Flow Diagram (process steps 20 and 25) and the completed PFMEA, complete 2 rows of the Control Plan. • Document potential problems that might be
Slide 66: Control Plan Reviewer's Checklist
Control Plan Reviewer’s Checklist Use process flow diagram and PFMEA to build the control plan; keep them aligned Controls must be used to be effective. Keep it simple. Ensure that the control plan is in the document control system of the business Good control plans address: All testing require
Slide 67: Measurement System Analysis (MSA)
MEASUREMENT SYSTEM ANALYSIS (MSA) NCR Confidential 67
Slide 68: Measurement System Analysis (MSA)
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) What is It? An MSA is a statistical tool used to determine if a measurement system is capable of precise measurement. Objective or Purpose • To determine how much error is in the measurement due to the When to Use It measurement process itself. • On the critical inp
Slide 69: Attribute and Variable MSA
Attribute and Variable MSA – Attribute Data Examples: Count, Pass/fail, yes/no, red/green/yellow, timekeeping buckets – Variable Data Examples: Physical measurement (length, width, area, …) Physical conditions (temperature, pressure…) Physical properties (strength, load, strain…) Continuou
Slide 70: Measurement System Analysis (MSA)
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Measuremen The observed variation in t process output System measurements is not Variation simply the variation in the process itself; it is the variation in the process Observed plus the variation in Variation measurement that results from an inadequate measurement
Slide 71: MSA Observed Variation
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Observed Variation Measuremen t System Variation Observed Variation The output of the process measured by: Process • Cycle time Variation • Dimensional data • Number of defects and others NCR Confidential 71
Slide 72: MSA Observed Variation
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Observed Variation Resolution Precision Repeatabilit (Variability) y Reproducibility Measuremen t System Variation Linearity Observed Accuracy (Central Bias Variation Location) Stability Process Variation Calibration addresses accuracy NCR Confidential 72
Slide 73: MSA Observed Variation
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Observed Variation Resolution Precision Repeatability (Variability) Measuremen Reproducibility t System Variation Linearity Accuracy Observed (Central Bias Variation Location) Stability Process Calibration Addresses Accuracy Variation Let’s take a closer look at Pre
Slide 74: MSA Resolution
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Resolution Error in Resolution The inability to detect small changes. Possible Cause Wrong measurement device selected - divisions on scale not fine enough to detect changes. NCR Confidential 74
Slide 75: MSA Repeatability
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Repeatability Error in Repeatability The inability to get the same answer from repeated measurements made of the same item under absolutely identical conditions. Possible Cause Lack of standard operating procedures (SOP), lack of training, measuring system variablil
Slide 76: MSA Reproducibility
Measurement System Analysis (MSA) Reproducibility Error in Reproducibility The inability to get the same answer from repeated measurements made under various conditions from different inspectors. Possible Cause Lack of SOP, lack of training. Appraiser Variation NCR Confidential 76
Slide 77: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Study
Variable MSA – Gage R&R Study •Gage R&R is the combined estimate of measurement system Repeatability and Reproducibility •Typically, a 3-person study is performed Each person randomly measures 10 marked parts per trial Each person can perform up to 3 trials •There are 3 key indicators EV or Equip
Slide 78: Variable MSA – NCR's Gage R&R Form
Variable MSA – NCR’s Gage R&R Form Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility This spreadsheet is designed for up to three operators, three trials, and ten samples. Enter data ONLY in gray shaded cells. Number of operators Upper specification limit Number of trials Lower specification limit Number of sa
Slide 79: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Steps
Variable MSA – Gage R&R Steps Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 Step 8 Step 9 Step 10 1. Select 10 items that represent the full range of long-term process variation. 2. Identify the appraisers. 3. If appropriate, calibrate the gage or verify that the last calibration date is valid. 4
Slide 80: Steps 1 and 2: Variable MSA - Gage R&R
Steps 1 and 2: Variable MSA - Gage R&R Select 10 items that represent Step 1 the full range of long-term process variation. Step 2 Identify the appraisers. – Should use individuals that actually do the process being tested. – Can also include other appraisers (supervisors, etc.). – Should have a min
Slide 81: Steps 3 and 4: Variable MSA – Gage R&R
Steps 3 and 4: Variable MSA – Gage R&R If appropriate, calibrate the gage Step 3 or verify that the last calibration date is valid. Step 4 Open the Gage R&R worksheet in the PPAP Playbook to record the data NCR Confidential 81
Slide 82: Step 5: Variable MSA – Gage R&R
Step 5: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Have each appraiser assess each item 3 Step 5 times. – Each appraiser has to work independently. – Items should be evaluated in random order. – After each appraiser completes the first evaluation of all items – repeat the process at least 2 more times. – Do not let th
Slide 83: Steps 6 and 7: Variable MSA – Gage R&R
Steps 6 and 7: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Step 6 Input data into the Gage R&R worksheet Step 7 Enter the number of operators, trials, samples and specification limits NCR Confidential 83
Slide 84: Steps 8 and 9: Variable MSA – Gage R&R
Steps 8 and 9: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Step 8 Analyze data in the Gage R&R worksheet Step 9 Assess MSA Trust Level. % Tolerance* – Red: > 30% (fail) 30% – Yellow: 10-30% (marginal) 10% – Green: < 10% (pass) NCR Confidential 84
Slide 85: Step 10: Variable MSA – Gage R&R
Step 10: Variable MSA – Gage R&R If the Measurement System needs improvement: Step 10 – Brainstorm with the team for improvement solutions. – Determine best “practical solution” (may require some experimentation). – Pilot the best solution (PDSA) – Implement best solution – train employees. – Re-run
Slide 86: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Example
Variable MSA – Gage R&R Example Problem Statement • The sulfuric acid concentration in process tank 8 is measured at least once per day • Additions/deletions of chemicals and decisions to shut down the process are dependent on these results. • Based on current data, we need to do an MSA. MSA Process
Slide 87: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Example
Variable MSA – Gage R&R Example Entered upper and Entered the number lower specification of operators, trials, limits and samples Gage Repeatability and operators Chose 3 to Reproducibility be appraisers This spreadsheet is designed for up to three operators, three trials, and ten samples. Enter dat
Slide 88: Variable MSA – Gage R&R Example
Variable MSA – Gage R&R Example Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility This spreadsheet is designed for up to three operators, three trials, and ten samples. Enter data ONLY in gray shaded cells. Number of operators 3 Upper specification limit 27 Number of trials 3 Lower specification limit 22 Numbe
Slide 89: Gage R&R Exercise - Setup Instructions
Gage R&R Exercise - Setup Instructions •Divide into teams •Distribute stars (10 per team), measurement devices (1 per team), and markers (1 per team). •Number the stars from 1-10. •Mark the 2 points to be measured on each star (see diagram on next page) •Determine and document the measurement proces
Slide 90: Gage R&R Exercise - Dimensional Information
Gage R&R Exercise - Dimensional Information Each star will be measured as shown. Mark the 2 points to be measured Dimension NCR Confidential 90
Slide 91: Gage R&R Exercise – Inspection Instructions
Gage R&R Exercise – Inspection Instructions 1. All inspectors need to wait outside the room when it is not their turn to evaluate the stars. 2. Open the PPAP Training Templates.xls file, then select the Gage R&R worksheet to record the data. 3. Round 1 Have the 1st inspector come in the room and mea
Slide 92: Gage R&R Exercise - Analysis Instructions
Gage R&R Exercise - Analysis Instructions 1. Complete the top section of the Gage R&R worksheet − Enter the number of operators, trials, and samples − Enter the upper and lower specification limit 2. Assess MSA Trust Level. % Tolerance* – Red: > 30% (fail) 30% – Yellow: 10-30% (marginal) 10% – Green
Slide 93: Tips and Lessons Learned
Tips and Lessons Learned Important: An MSA is an analysis of the process, not an analysis of the people. If an MSA fails, the process failed. A Variable MSA provides more analysis capability than an Attribute MSA. For this and other reasons, always use variable data if possible. The involvement o
Slide 94: MSA Reviewer's Checklist
MSA Reviewer’s Checklist If the gage/inspection affects quality, then conduct a Gage R&R Make sure the study is recent - less than 1 year Compare the control plan gages against the Gage R&Rs If you question that gage, then −Question the technique and part sampling −Ask for additional studies NCR
Slide 95: Dimensional Results
DIMENSIONAL RESULTS NCR Confidential 95
Slide 96: Dimensional Results
Dimensional Results FAI Non-Critical Dimensions Date: Supplier Name: Date Code: What is It? Part Number: Facility Location: Inspected By: Revision: Supplier Code: Verified By: Evidence that dimensional The number of non-critical data points required for part qualification is 5. The non-critical data
Slide 97: NCR Dimensional Report (Critical)
NCR Dimensional Report (Critical) FAI Critical Dimensions Date: Supplier Name: Date Code: The number of critical data points required for part qualification is 35. These data points must be taken from a 35-piece sample. Five parts from a production run must be shipped to NCR for verification of form
Slide 98: NCR Dimensional Report (Non-Critical)
NCR Dimensional Report (Non-Critical) FAI Non-Critical Dimensions Date: Supplier Name: Date Code: Part Number: Facility Location: Inspected By: Revision: Supplier Code: Verified By: The number of non-critical data points required for part qualification is 5. The non-critical data points The number m
Slide 99: Acceptance Criteria
Acceptance Criteria Acceptance criteria for critical vs. non-critical characteristics Critical Non-Critical Decision Red (Bad) <1.33 <1.00 Yellow (OK) 1.33-1.67 1.00-1.33 Green (Good) >1.67 >1.33 Cpk must be greater than or equal to 1.67 for critical processes Cpk must be greater than or equal to 1.
Slide 100: NCR Dimensional Report Example
NCR Dimensional Report Example FAI Non-Critical Dimensions Date: Supplier Name: Date Code: Part Number: Facility Location: Inspected By: Revision: Supplier Code: Verified By: The number of non-critical data points required for part qualification is 5. The non-critical data points must be taken from
Slide 101: Dimensional Results Reviewer's Checklist
Dimensional Results Reviewer’s Checklist Thirty-five critical data points & 5 non-critical data points are required for part qualification Critical and non-critical data points must be taken from the same 35- piece sample Five parts from a production run must be shipped to NCR for verification of
Slide 102: Records of Material / Performance Test Results
RECORDS OF MATERIAL / PERFORMANCE TEST RESULTS NCR Confidential 102
Slide 103: Records of Material/Performance Test Results
Records of Material/Performance Test Results Material Test Results The supplier shall perform tests for all parts and product materials when chemical, physical, or metallurgical requirements are specified by the design record or Control Plan For products with NCR-developed material specifications
Slide 104: Material Results
Material Results Production Part Approval - Material Results Supplier Part Number Revision Level Laboratory Outside laboratory Name of Laboratory Part Name In-house testing Type of Material Spec. No./Date/Specification Supplier Test Results OK Not OK Test Material Results shall include: The name o
Slide 105: Module Test Results
Module Test Results Production Part Approval - Module Test Results Supplier Part Number Revision Level Laboratory Outside laboratory Name of Laboratory Part Name In-house testing Type of Test Test description Parameters Tested Supplier Test Results OK Not OK Module Test Results shall include: The
Slide 106: Initial Process Study
INITIAL PROCESS STUDY NCR Confidential 106
Slide 107: Initial Process Study
Initial Process Study PPAP Levels for Submission & Retention Submission Level Requirement Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5 1. Design Records of Saleable Product R R R * R a. For proprietary components/details R R R * R b. For all other components/details R R R * R 2. Engineering Change Docume
Slide 108: Initial Process Study Capability Analysis
Initial Process Study Capability Analysis What is It? A set of tools used to understand process capability. Objective or Purpose • To evaluate the performance of your process as compared to specification limits. • To determine if the production process is likely to produce product that will meet cus
Slide 109: Steps for Determining Process Capability
Steps for Determining Process Capability Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Step 7 1. Decide on the product or process characteristic to be assessed 2. Validate the specification limits 3. Validate the measurement system 4. Collect data 5. Assess data characteristics 6. Assess process stabili
Slide 110: Step 1: Which Characteristic
Step 1: Which Characteristic Decide on the product or process characteristic to be assessed. Step 1 Required for all critical characteristics If no critical characteristics exist, NCR reserves the right to require demonstration of initial process capability on other characteristics NCR Confident
Slide 111: Step 2: Specification Limits
Step 2: Specification Limits Step 2 Validate the specification limits by talking to: – Customers, suppliers, controlling agencies Why is validation of the specification limits important? – They may not represent what the customer truly desires/needs. – May contain “guard banding” as a result of past
Slide 112: Step 3: Measurement System
Step 3: Measurement System Validate the measurement Step 3 system through the appropriate MSA Why is validation of the Measurement System important? – If there is significant error in your measurement system, then decisions are influenced by the error not just the measurements themselves. NCR Confid
Slide 113: Step 4: Data Collection
Step 4: Data Collection Step 4 When collecting data, consider the following: – Short term data » Free of special causes » Collected across a narrow inference space i.e. one shift, one machine, one operator, etc.. – Long term data » Subjected to the effects of both random and special cause variation
Slide 114: Step 4: Data Collection
Step 4: Data Collection When collecting data, consider the following: Step 4 – Rational sub-grouping » A group of units produced under the same set of conditions » Mean to represent a “snapshot” of the process Example: » Must be taken close together in time, but still be independent of each other A
Slide 115: Step 5: Data Characteristics
Step 5: Data Characteristics Step 5 Assess data characteristics Histogram of Mfg Hours Mean 14.87 20 StDev 3.088 Examine the shape of your data. N 100 15 Frequency – Is it what you would expect? 10 If not, investigate. 5 0 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 Mfg Hours Bimodal Data Histogram of Mfg Hours Histogra
Slide 116: Step 6: Process Stability
Step 6: Process Stability Assess process stability in order to understand Step 6 how your process behaves over time. Control charts are the recommended tool. Control Chart Examples Process is stable and in Process is not stable and control therefore not in control Capability is only valid when the p
Slide 117: Step 7: Process Capability
Step 7: Process Capability Calculate the appropriate statistical metrics in Step 7 order to determine how the “Voice of the Process” compares to the “Voice of the Customer.” Capability Metrics: PPM, DPMO, Cp, Cpk, Pp, & Ppk ; Sigma Levels (Z Scores) Specification Limits Specification Limits Process
Slide 118: Focus on Variable Data
Focus on Variable Data The initial process study should be focused on variable, variable not attribute data Assembly errors, test failures, and surface defects are examples of attribute data, which is important to understand, but is not covered in this initial study To understand the performance
Slide 119: Capability Indices
Capability Indices Capability Formula What it shows Index Relates short term (within subgroup) standard (USL – LSL) deviation to tolerance Cp 6*s Cp/Cpk short-term Sometimes are used to called “Entitlement,” meaning it is the best the current process can do, if centered estimate potential Relates sh
Slide 120: Capability Indices - Cpk
Capability Indices - Cpk Cpk predicts capability Based on short term within subgroup variation Does not include the effect of process variability between subgroups Cpk should be used when: when −Developing new parts −Revising specifications on a part −Materials, processes, manufacturing location,
Slide 121: Capability Indices - Ppk
Capability Indices - Ppk Ppk indicates past performance Based on long term total variation Unlike Cpk, Ppk is not limited to variation within subgroups However, Ppk cannot isolate within subgroup variation from between subgroup variation When calculated from the same data set, Cpk and Ppk can be
Slide 122: Difference between Cp & Cpk
Difference between Cp & Cpk Cp – determines capability of producing to specification Cpk – same as Cp, but also measures how centered the process is It is important to look at both! Cp > 1.67 Cp > 1.67 Cpk > 1.67 Cpk < 1.00 Capable, Capable, Centered Not Centered LSL USL LSL USL Cp < 1.00 Cp < 1.
Slide 123: Acceptance Criteria
Acceptance Criteria Acceptance criteria for critical vs. non-critical characteristics Critical Non-Critical Decision Red (Bad) <1.33 <1.00 Yellow (OK) 1.33-1.67 1.00-1.33 Green (Good) >1.67 >1.33 Cpk must be greater than or equal to 1.67 for critical processes Cpk must be greater than or equal to 1.
Slide 124: Initial Process Study Reviewer's Checklist
Initial Process Study Reviewer’s Checklist Ensure that the results are acceptable, and that the process is stable and capable of producing a quality part PPAPs should only be approved if the capability is greater than 1.67 for critical dimensions and greater than 1.33 for non-critical dimensions
Slide 125: Qualified Laboratory Documentation
QUALIFIED LABORATORY DOCUMENTATION NCR Confidential 125
Slide 126: Qualified Laboratory Documentation
Qualified Laboratory Documentation •Inspection and testing for PPAP shall be performed by a qualified laboratory as defined by NCR requirements (e.g., an accredited laboratory). •The qualified laboratory (internal or external to the supplier) shall have a laboratory scope and documentation showing t
Slide 127: Appearance Approval Report
APPEARANCE APPROVAL REPORT NCR Confidential 127
Slide 128: Appearance Approval Report
Appearance Approval Report Appearance Approval Report What is It? Part Number Part Name Drawing Number Buyer E/C Level Application Date • A report completed by the supplier Supplier Name Manufacturing Location Supplier Code containing appearance and color criteria Reason for Part Submission Warrant
Slide 129: Appearance Approval Report
Appearance Approval Report Administrative Section Appearance Approval Report Part Number Drawing Number Application Supplier Sourcing & Texture Information Part Name List all first surface tools, grainingBuyer Pre-Texture E/C Level Evaluation Date Supplier Name Source(s), grain type(s), and grain Lo
Slide 130: Appearance Approval Report
Appearance Approval Report Master Master Material Number DateType Material Source Color Shipping Suffix Color SuffixEnter Enter Identify alphanumeric the date first Identify on surface which firstfinish surface andand Color part number Alphanumeric or master numeric thesubstrate master identificatio
Slide 131: Sample Production Parts
SAMPLE PRODUCTION PARTS NCR Confidential 131
Slide 132: Sample Production Parts
Sample Production Parts What is It? Actual samples that reflect the parts documented in the PPAP. Objective or Purpose • Confirm cosmetic or functional part approval. When to Use It • Sample parts should be delivered WITH the PPAP submission NCR Confidential 132
Slide 133: Sample Production Parts
Sample Production Parts •The sample parts provided should be the same parts measured for the dimensional results •Default quantity for all submissions is 3 parts unless otherwise requested NCR Confidential 133
Slide 134: Sample Production Parts
Sample Production Parts Sample production parts MUST be properly identified – Include the following information on the part label: • Date parts were packed • NCR part number • Quantity See NCR part label examples on the next slide • Serial number • Supplier part number (optional) • Part description
Slide 135: Part Label Example
Part Label Example NCR Confidential 135
Slide 136: PPAP Summary
PPAP Summary •The Production Part Approval Process is an extensive approval process for new or changed designs or processes •It is very formalized, so it inevitably causes some administrative work •Later changes to the product or process can be expensive and time-consuming! NCR Confidential 136
Slide 137: Appendix – Capability
APPENDIX – CAPABILITY NCR Confidential 137
Slide 138: Process Capability Tool Selection Map
Process Capability Tool Selection Map Process Capability can be determined for Binomial Process Process Capability all types of data. However, selecting the Capability correct method is critical. Defective Capability Analysis Normal Data Defect or Yes Variable Attribute for Normal Data Data? Type? D
Slide 139: Index of Capability Examples (Using Minitab)
Index of Capability Examples (Using Minitab) Capability – Normal Capability - Normal Capability – Non-Normal Distribution Identification Central Limit Theorem Box – Cox Transformation NCR Confidential 139
Slide 140: Normal Capability Example Activity
Normal Capability Example Activity Using the data in a Minitab file Capability Example.MTW determine the capability of the PO process in terms of the time is required to process the POs. Time to Process one individual PO Use the file Capability Example.MTW NCR Confidential 140
Slide 141: Normal Capability Example Q A
Normal Capability Example Q Which Capability Analysis applies? Is the data attribute or variable? Is the data normal? Does sub-grouping apply? Yes ??? A Normal NCR Confidential 141
Slide 142: Normal Capability Analysis in Minitab
Normal Capability Analysis in Minitab 1. Open the worksheet Capability Example.MTW. 2. Choose Stat > Quality Tools > Capability Analysis > Normal. 3. Click in the [Single Column] field. 4. Double click [Time to Process] in the column on the left. 5. Click in the [Subgroup Size] 6. Depending on subgr
Slide 143: Normal Capability Analysis in Minitab
Normal Capability Analysis in Minitab 7. Type 20 in Lower Spec. 8. Type 40 in Upper Spec. 9. Select [Options] button. 10.Add target value (if applicable). 11.Under Display select a. Parts per million or Percents b. Capability Stats or Benchmark Z 12.Add Title if desired. 13.Click [OK]. 14.Click [OK]
Slide 144: Normal Capability Analysis Results
Normal Capability Analysis Results Process Capability of Time to Process (subgroup of 1) Sample Mean LSL Voice of the USL Process Data Customer Within LSL 20.00000 Overall Target * USL 40.00000 Potential (Within) Capability Voice of the Cp 0.45 Sample Mean 30.72100 Process CPL 0.48 Sample N 200 StDe
Slide 145: Normal Capability Analysis Results
Normal Capability Analysis Results Process Capability of Time to Process (subgroup of 1) LSL Capability indices: USL Process Data Based on short Within LSL 20.00000 term data. Overall Target * USL 40.00000 Potential (Within) Capability Sample Mean 30.72100 Capability indices: Cp 0.45 Sample N 200 Ba
Slide 146: Non-Normal Capability – Distribution Identification Exercise
Non-Normal Capability – Distribution Identification Exercise Using the data (Time_2) in a Minitab file Capability Example.MTW determine the capability of the PO process in terms of the time that is required to process the POs. Time to Process one individual PO Use the file Capability Example. MTW NC
Slide 147: Non-Normal Capability – Distribution Identification Q A
Non-Normal Capability – Distribution Identification Q Which Capability Analysis applies? • Is the data attribute or variable? • Is the data normal? No • Are the reasons for non-normality understood? • Can the data be described by another distribution? Yes ??? A Non-normal Try Individual Distribution
Slide 148: Individual Distribution Identification in Minitab
Individual Distribution Identification in Minitab 1. Open the worksheet Capability Example.MTW. 2. Choose Stat > Quality Tools > Individual Distribution Identification. 3. Click in the [Single Column] field. 4. Double click Time_2 in the column on the left. 5. Choose [Use all distributions]. 6. Clic
Slide 149: Individual Distribution Identification in Minitab
Individual Distribution Identification in Minitab NCR Confidential 149
Slide 150: Using Individual Distribution Identification
Using Individual Distribution Identification 1. Open the worksheet Capability Example.MTW. 2. Choose Stat > Quality Tools > Capability Analysis > Nonnormal. 3. Click in the [Single Column] field. 4. Double click Time_2 in the column on the left. 5. Select [Fit data with Distribution]. 6. Using pulld
Slide 151: Using Individual Distribution Identification
Using Individual Distribution Identification 9. Select [Options] button. 10. Add target value (if applicable). 11. Under Display select 9. Capability Stats 10. Benchmark Z 12. Add Title if desired. 13. Click [OK]. 14. Click [OK]. NCR Confidential 151
Slide 152: Using Individual Distribution Identification
Using Individual Distribution Identification Overall Capability: Benchmark Z or Capability indices - Sample Mean based on long term data Voice of the Customer Voice of the Process Exp Overall Performance: Observed Performance: Represents long term Represents the sample process capability data NCR Co
Slide 153: Non-Normal Capability – Central Limit Theorem
Non-Normal Capability – Central Limit Theorem Activity Using the data (Time_3 and Time 3 sub) in a Minitab file Capability Example.MTW determine the capability of the PO process in terms of the time is required to process the POs. Average time to process five POs per day Time to process one individu
Slide 154: Non-Normal Capability – Central Limit Theorem Q A
Non-Normal Capability – Central Limit Theorem Q Which Capability Analysis applies? • Is the data attribute or variable? • Is the data normal? • Are the reasons for non-normality understood? • Can the data be sub-grouped? • Is the sub-grouped data normal? Yes No • Can the data be described by another
Slide 155: Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping
Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping Caution! Check sub-group data Time_3 sub for normality. If the data is not normal then this method cannot be used! 1. Open the worksheet Capability Example.MTW. 2. Choose Stat > Quality Tools > Capability Analysis > Normal. 3. Click in the [Single Column] fie
Slide 156: Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping
Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping 8. Select [Options] button. 9. Add target value (if applicable). 10. Under Display select 8. Parts per million or Percents 9. Capability Stats or Benchmark Z 11. Add Title if desired. 12. Click [OK]. 13. Click [OK]. NCR Confidential 156
Slide 157: Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping
Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping Process Capability of Time_ 3 Sample Mean Voice of the Customer LSL USL Process Data Within LSL 20 Overall Target * USL 40 Potential (Within) Capability Sample Mean 31.262 Cp 0.44 CPL 0.50 Sample N 200 Voice of the CPU 0.39 StDev(Within) 7.55396 Process Cpk 0
Slide 158: Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping
Using Central Limit Theorem Sub-Grouping Process Capability of Time_ 3 Capability indices: LSL Based on short USL Process Data term data. Within LSL 20 Overall Target * USL 40 Capability indices: Potential (Within) Capability Cp 0.44 Sample Mean 31.262 Based on long CPL 0.50 Exp Within: Sample N 200
Slide 159: Non-Normal Capability – Box-Cox Transformation
Non-Normal Capability – Box-Cox Transformation Activity Using the data (Time_4) in a Minitab file Capability Example.MTW determine the capability of the PO process in terms of the time is required to process the POs. Time to Process one individual PO NCR Confidential 159
Slide 160: Non-Normal Capability – Box-Cox Transformation Q A
Non-Normal Capability – Box-Cox Transformation Q Which Capability Analysis applies? • Is the data attribute or variable? • Is the data normal? • Are the reasons for non-normality understood? • Can the data be sub-grouped? • Can data be transformed? Yes No • Can the data be described by another distr
Slide 161: Box-Cox Transformation
Box-Cox Transformation 1. Open the worksheet Capability Example.MTW 2. Choose Stat > Control Charts > Box-Cox Transformation 3. Choose [All Observations …in one column] from pull down menu 4. Click in Large Box 5. Double click [Time_4] in the column on the left 6. Click in the [Subgroup Size] field
Slide 162: Box-Cox Transformation Results
Box-Cox Transformation Results Transformed Data Lambda Values Q Is the transformed data normal? NCR Confidential 162
Slide 163: Using Box-Cox Transformation
Using Box-Cox Transformation 1. Open the worksheet Capability Example.MTW 2. Choose Stat > Quality Tools > Capability Analysis > Normal 3. Click in the [Single Column] field 4. Double click Time_4 in the column on the left Use the original data, not the transformed data. 5. Click in the [Subgroup
Slide 164: Using Box-Cox Transformation
Using Box-Cox Transformation 1. Select [Box-Cox] radio button 2. Select [Box-Cox power transformation] 3. Select [Use Optional lambda] 4. Click OK 5. Select [Options] radio button 6. Add target value (if applicable) 7. Under Display select a. Parts per million or Percents b. Capability Stats or Benc
Slide 165: Using Box-Cox Transformation
Using Box-Cox Transformation Original Distribution Calculated Lambda Transformed Voice of the Customer Original Sample Data Transformed Voice of the Process Transformed Sample Data NCR Confidential 165
Slide 166: Using Box-Cox Transformation
Using Box-Cox Transformation Capability indices: Based on short term data Capability indices: Based on long Exp Within term data. Performance: Based on StDev (Within) and represents short term Exp Overall process capability. Performance: Based on Observed StDev (Overall) and Performance: represents