Avista Corporation · NYSE:AVA
Avista — Technical Presentation (June 2024)
40 slides from Avista's technical presentation, Jun 4, 2024
Slide 1: 2025 Electric Integrated Resource Plan TAC Meeting No. 8 Agenda
DRAFT 2025 Electric Integrated Resource Plan Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 8 Agenda Tuesday, June 4, 2024 Virtual Meeting – 8:30 am to 10:00 am PTZ Topic Staff Introductions John Lyons Electrification Scenarios James Gall Load & Resource Balance and Methodology Lori Hermanson New Resource
Slide 2: 2025 IRP TAC 8 Introductions
DRAFT 2025 IRP TAC 8 Introductions John Lyons, Ph.D. Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 8 June 4, 2024
Slide 3: Today's Agenda
DRAFT Today’s Agenda Introductions, John Lyons Electrification Scenarios, James Gall Load & Resource Balance and Methodology, Lori Hermanson Loss of Load Probability Study, James Gall New Resources Options Costs and Assumptions, Michael Brutocao 2030 Loss of Load Probability Study, Mike Hermanson 2
Slide 4: Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule
DRAFT Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 9: June 18, 2024: 8:30 to 10:00 (PTZ) o IRP Generation Option Transmission Planning Studies o Distribution System Planning within the IRP & DPAG update • Technical Modeling Workshop: June 25, 2024: 9:00 am to 12:00pm (PTZ) o PRiSM Model Tour o ARA
Slide 5: Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule
Remaining 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule DRAFT • TAC 12: August 13, 2024: 8:30 to 10:00 (PTZ) o Preferred Resource Strategy Results (continued) o Portfolio Scenario Analysis (continued) o LOLP Study Results (continued) o QF Avoided Cost • September 2, 2024- Draft IRP Released to TAC. • Virtual Publi
Slide 6: 2025 IRP Portfolio Scenario Update
DRAFT 2025 IRP Portfolio Scenario Update (DRAFT) James Gall Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 8 June 4, 2024
Slide 7: High Electric Transportation Scenario
DRAFT High Electric Transportation Scenario 450 2025 IRP EV Forecast 400 2025 IRP EV High Scenario 2023 IRP EV Forecast 350 2023 IRP EV High Scenario 300 250 aMW 200 150 100 50 0 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 2
Slide 8: State Electric Vehicle Load Projections
DRAFT State Electric Vehicle Load Projections Idaho Washington 300 300 Idaho- Expected Case Washington- Expected Case 250 Idaho- High Scenario 250 Washington- High Scenario 200 200 aMW aMW 150 150 100 100 50 50 0 0 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042
Slide 9: Space Heat Assumptions for Building Electrification
DRAFT Space Heat Assumptions for Building Electrification Space Heating Efficiency Curve 4.00 3.50 For homes with central heating, the homeowner 3.00 may find efficiency, cost, equipment longevity 2.50 challenges when Heat Pump Lockout Point for Gas Coupled Systems w/o retrofitting to fully electric
Slide 10: Building Electrification Electric Impacts
DRAFT Building Electrification Electric Impacts 80% Reduction in WA/ID System Natural Gas Usage by 2045 500 Load Forecast Impact (Energy) 450 Assumes 75% of WA 400 and 90% of ID 350 natural gas 300 customers use Avista electric aMW 250 200 Load impact is close 150 to even between 100 states 50 - 202
Slide 11: Load Forecast Comparison
DRAFT Load Forecast Comparison January Peak Forecast 3,500 3,000 Megawatts 2,500 2,000 1,500 1,000 Expected Case Energy Forecast 80% Washington Building Electrification by 2045 500 80% Washington Building Electrification by 2045 & High Transportation Electrification Scenario 3,500 Extreme Building/T
Slide 12: Load Forecast Scenarios Still Under Development
DRAFT Load Forecast Scenarios Still Under Development • Load forecast data will be posted on Teams site once finalized • Remaining scenario update: – Maximum Washington Customer Benefits: EV/Solar penetration to be increased in Named Communities – Data Center in 2030: Assume 200 MW in Idaho service
Slide 13: 2025 Loads & Resource Balance & Methodology
DRAFT 2025 Loads & Resource Balance & Methodology Lori Hermanson Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 8 June 4, 2024
Slide 14: Portfolio Realignment
DRAFT Portfolio Realignment 2
Slide 15: Monthly Net Energy Position
DRAFT Monthly Net Energy Position Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual 2026 (35) (3) 141 26 436 398 183 97 211 143 63 13 140 2027 (34) 14 170 315 392 429 233 132 248 173 82 40 183 2028 (44) 47 155 277 359 318 227 126 249 177 86 29 167 2029 (23) 47 194 299 492 526 228 122 253 185 94
Slide 16: Winter Peak Loads & Resource Position
DRAFT Winter Peak Loads & Resource Position Note: Excludes maintenance 4 22% Planning Margin + 10 MW Regulation
Slide 17: Summer Peak Loads & Resource Position
DRAFT Summer Peak Loads & Resource Position Note: Excludes maintenance 5 13% Planning Margin or Largest Single Contingency + 10 MW Regulation
Slide 18: Outstanding Issues
DRAFT Outstanding Issues • Maintenance Planning – IRP traditionally does not “build” resources due to forecast maintenance schedules for peak planning – Should we plan for a minimum maintenance assumption? – For energy planning, maintenance will be included • Planning Margin – Further discussion • 3
Slide 19: CETA's Clean Energy Goals
DRAFT CETA’s Clean Energy Goals 7
Slide 20: Washington Clean Energy Position
DRAFT Washington Clean Energy Position 1,200 Idaho Legacy Hydro Available for Alternative Compliance 1,000 Washington CETA Primary Load Estimate Compliance Washington Average Megawatts 800 Retail Load CETA Shortfall Idaho Allocated 600 Clean Energy Transferable to Allocated Wind Washington 400 Alloc
Slide 21: Supply Side Resource Options
DRAFT Supply Side Resource Options 2025 Electric IRP, 8th Technical Advisory Committee Meeting June 4, 2024 Michael Brutocao, Natural Gas Analyst 1 DRAFT
Slide 22: Overview and Considerations
Overview and Considerations DRAFT • IRP supply-side resources are near commercially available technologies with potential for development within or near Avista’s service territory. • Resource costs vary depending on location, equipment, fuel prices and ownership; while IRPs use point estimates, actu
Slide 23: IRA Details
IRA Details DRAFT • Production Tax Credits ($2022 USD) – Geothermal, Wind and Biomass – $0.026 per kWh tax credit – Nuclear – $0.015 per kWh tax credit plus $0.003 base credit ($0.018 total per kWh credit) • Investment Tax Credit (Battery Storage, Pumped Hydro, Solar) – Costs incurred thru 2032 qual
Slide 24: Resources Not Modeled
Resources Not Modeled DRAFT • Carbon Sequestration • Coal • Landfill Gas (except as RNG fuel for CT Frame) • Sodium, Vanadium, and Zinc Bromide Batteries • Wave 4 DRAFT
Slide 25: Resources Modeled
Resources Modeled DRAFT Resource Fuel Source MW Capacity Factor Capital $/kW (2026) Frame CT Natural Gas 180 $831 Reciprocating Engine Natural Gas 185 $1,272 Combined Cycle Natural Gas 312 $1,271 Small Nuclear Modular Reactor Uranium 100 93% $8,224 Wind (On System) Wind 100 35% $1,500 Wind (Off Syst
Slide 26: Resources Modeled (continued)
Resources Modeled (continued) DRAFT Resource Fuel Source MW MWh Capacity Factor Capital $/kW (2026) Residential PV (New Construction) Solar 0.006 16% $3,810 Residential PV Solar 0.006 16% $4,141 Commercial PV Solar 1 17% $2,297 Low-Income Community PV Solar <1 30% $369 Utility PV (Fixed) Solar 5 30%
Slide 27: Solar PPA Price/Implied Energy Payment
Solar PPA Price/Implied Energy Payment DRAFT $350 $300 $250 $200 $/MWh $150 $100 $50 $- 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 Residential PV (New Construction) Residential PV Commercial PV Low-Income Community PV Utility PV (Fixed) Utilit
Slide 28: Wind PPA Price/Implied Energy Payment
Wind PPA Price/Implied Energy Payment DRAFT $200 $180 $160 $140 $120 $/MWh $100 $80 $60 $40 $20 $- 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 On System Off System Montana Off Shore/System 8 DRAFT
Slide 29: Base Load Clean Energy
Base Load Clean Energy DRAFT $250 $200 $150 $/MWh $100 $50 $- 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 Small Nuclear Modular Reactor Geothermal (Off System) 9
Slide 30: Energy Storage PPA Price/Implied Capacity Payment
Energy Storage PPA Price/Implied Capacity Payment DRAFT $800 $700 $600 $500 $/kW-year $400 $300 $200 $100 $- 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 2042 2043 2044 2045 Distribution Scale 4hr Lithium-ion Distribution Scale 8hr Lithium-ion 4hr Lithium-ion 8hr L
Slide 31: Dispatchable Resource Variable vs Fixed Cost
Dispatchable Resource Variable vs Fixed Cost DRAFT Resources with lighter and darker shades indicate costs in Washington and Idaho, respectively 11 DRAFT
Slide 32: NEI Cost Studies to Be Added
NEI Cost Studies to be Added DRAFT • Avista obtained licenses to run the IMPLAN model for Washington and Oregon to be able to run our own economic impact studies for each of the new resource types • Still learning and configuring the model as this time and will report back to the TAC as the studies
Slide 33: 2030 Loss of Load Probability Study
DRAFT 2030 Loss of Load Probability Study (DRAFT) Mike Hermanson Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 8 June 4, 2024
Slide 34: Purpose of Loss of Load Study
DRAFT DRAFT Purpose of Loss of Load Study • Determine the ability of our system to meet load and reserves each hour when subjected to 1,000 iterations with different combinations of: – Water years – Load – Temperature – Maintenance – Forced outages – VER production • Utilized currently expected port
Slide 35: Modeling Framework
DRAFT DRAFT Modeling Framework • Avista Reliability Assessment Model (ARAM) - Excel based model with VBA code and linear optimization Excel Add-in What’s Best! Renewable generation based on wind speed that is random Run of river generation number that is auto correlated based on hydro year and influ
Slide 36: Reliability Metrics
DRAFT DRAFT Reliability Metrics • Studies are conducted with 1,000 iterations of the ARAM Model • Model metrics provide insights and targets to achieve a reliable system • Metrics – LOLP – Loss of Load Probability: Calculated by counting the number of iterations where there is unserved load or unmet
Slide 37: Reliability Metrics
DRAFT Reliability Metrics DRAFT Metric Use LOLP Can be used to determine the probability or likelihood of events due to insufficient capacity. LOLE The majority of entities conducting LOLE studies primarily use it to establish resource adequacy criteria. Industry standard is 0.1 days per year LOLE.
Slide 38: 2030 Existing Portfolio 12x24 Resource Deficiency
DRAFT DRAFT 2030 Existing Portfolio 12x24 Resource Deficiency • The following chart presents the sum of the hourly average over 1,000 iterations of unserved load by month and hour in MWhs: Scenario Name Hour Month 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 To be compl
Slide 39: Summary of Metrics
DRAFT DRAFT Summary of metrics • Planning margin determined by running model with increasing values of additional dispatchable resource Additional Dispatchable Resources Metric Target Base 50 MW 100 MW 150 MW 200 MW LOLP 0.05 LOLE 0.1 LOLH To be completed in final version LOLEV EUE (with reserves) E
Slide 40: Process to Establish Planning Margin
DRAFT DRAFT Process to establish planning margin • Iterative process – Run model with increasing additional dispatchable resources until LOLP is 0.05 and LOLE is 0.1 – Quantity of additional resources is used to quantify the planning margin