Evans Bancorp Inc

Evans Bancorp — Investor Presentation (June 2020)

29 slides from Evans Bancorp's investor presentation, Jun 5, 2020

  1. Slide 1: Evans Bancorp

    EVANS BANCORPixc. David J. Nasca John B. Connerton President & CEO Executive Vice President & CFO

  2. Slide 2: Safe Harbor Statement

    Safe Harbor Statement This presentation includes "forward looking statements" within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such forward-looking statements include, but are not limited to, statements concerning future business, revenue and earnings. These statements are

  3. Slide 3: Evans Bancorp, Inc. (NYSE American: EVBN)

    Evans Bancorp, Inc. (NYSE American: EVBN) Building a preeminent community financial institution Creating scale and sophistication to take advantage of opportunities Increasing comp e advantages with the best talent and top tier client experiences A Century of serving Western New York Established: 19

  4. Slide 4: Operational Response During COVID-19 Pandemic

    Operational Response During COVID-19 Pandemic OPERATIONAL CONSISTENCY PROACTIVE CLIENT SUPPORT « Adherence to guidelines and * Direct contact with over 1,500 clients and recommendations for continued safety prospective clients during reopening processes * Leveraging technology and infrastructure * M

  5. Slide 5: Supporting Customer Relief

    Supporting Customer Relief Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) + ~$140 million equating to2+ years of Processed 616 growth completed in 13 days Total loans ~$140 million . - * Provided loans to 930 new customers Average size ~$220,000 Jobs retained (est.) 17,000 * Creates opportunity to expand custome

  6. Slide 6: Commercial Business Loan Portfolio and Deferrals

    Commercial Business Loan Portfolio and Deferrals Commercial Loan Portfolio by Industry Loan Deferrals by Industry | =] Total: $997.9M" ™ Manufacturing | Total: $372.1M" ™ Restaurant/Food Service Se g ® Health Care and Social Assistance co © Multi-Family (5+ Units) | ™ Other | Retail/Wholesale Trade

  7. Slide 7: Commercial Business Loan Deferral Detail

    Commercial Business Loan Deferral Detail * 426 deferred facilities (20% of total) % of Total % of Total . Pitaveueiimineci ° Deferred balances collateralized Multi-Family (5+ Units) 37% 9% by property: $321.6 million Hotel/Motel 92% 1% (86% of total deferred) Retail/Wholesale Trade eS oR Weighted Av

  8. Slide 8: Building a Premier Financial Institution - Bolstered WNY Presence

    8 Building a Premier Financial Institution - Bolstered WNY Presence Combined Companies’ ca SS $1.85B in Assets Walworth | © $1568 in Deposits [s) $1.50B in Loans ry Z 75 miles reach 4 2.2millionin population Current Branches tie. @ Evans Bancorp, Inc. (EVBN) Bey one @ FSB Bancorp, Inc. (FSBC) Solid,

  9. Slide 9: Value creation

    Value creation Enhanced scale Expand into a strategically prioritized, contiguous market Lower cost with fewer resources than de novo effort - better ROIC Complementary business lines Expand commercial platform in Western New York Leverage FSB’s strength in mortgage and enhance Evans’ consumer lendi

  10. Slide 10: Transaction Highlights

    10 Transaction Highlights Transaction Evans Bancorp, Inc. (“Evans”) acquired 100% of FSB Bancorp, Inc’s (“FSB”) outstanding common stock Merger Consideration’ 50% Cash at $17.80 per share 50% Stock at 0.4394 fixed exchange ratio Total Merger Value at announcement” $34.7 million Implied Pricing Multi

  11. Slide 11: Competitive Environment

    1 Competitive Environment 2.6% Market Share By Deposits $46.1B All Others (12) Citizens Northwest Bank Bank of America Key Bank M&T Bank 63.6% ‘owingin market do ted by two top 25 banks Source: FDIC, as of June 30, 2019 (Metropolitan Statistical Area: Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY) EVANS ©2020 Evans Banco

  12. Slide 12: Significant Asset Expansion

    Significant Asset Expansion {in millions) $1,524.8 $1,460.2 $1,388.2 $1,295.6 $1,100.7 11% CAGR 2016 2017 2018 2019 Qi20 ©2020 Evans Bancorp, Inc. 12 * 5% Q1 20 YOY Building platform for increased future earnings power EVANS BANCORP

  13. Slide 13: Core Funding Supports Loan Growth

    13 Core Funding Supports Loan Growth {in millions) Deposits Loans $1,327.6 $1,226.5 $1,246.2 $1,155.9 $1,065.3 $942.5 ; 9% CAGR $1,215.1 $1,267.4 $1,051.2 : i : 2016 2017 2018 2019 §=Q120 2016 2017 2018 2019 §=Q120 crDRevio (RIREIOGEENN INNO) SS Se 11% CAGR EVANS ©2020 Evans Bancorp, Inc. BANCORP.

  14. Slide 14: Net Income

    14 Net Income (in millions, except per share data) $17.0 $16.4 $13.5 Pa Elevated provision for loan loss $10.5 of $3.0 million in Q1 20 Included $2.2 million reserve buildin response to economic trends and conditions due to COVID-19 16% CAGR 2016 2017* 2018 2019 Q120TT™M Earnings per Share - Diluted

  15. Slide 15: Results Accruing to Shareholders

    15 Results Accruing to Shareholders Dividend Payment Book Value per Share [0 $29.96 $0.92 2015 = 2016 = 2017 2018 = 2019 2016 2017 2018 2019 Qi 20 4/2/20: Paid semi-annual dividend of $0.58, up 12% Current Dividend Yield Dividend Payout Ratio 4.7% orm) - 40.6% 3.8% SNL* Peers EVEN Peers SNL* EveN EV

  16. Slide 16: Non-Interest Income Opportunity

    16 Non-Interest Income Opportunity Q1 2020 TTM Non-Interest Income: $17.9 Million* Acquisitions: Richardson & Stout Insurance in 2018 Benefit Brokers of Western New York in 2020 60% Emphasis on expanding: Insurance Service & Fees 1. Insurance 2. Employee benefits 3. Cash management Bank-owned Life 4

  17. Slide 17: Evans Strategic Objectives

    | Evans Strategic Objectives | i. f] © EVANS

  18. Slide 18: Evans Strategic Objectives

    Evans Strategic Objectives ®@8®O®e@ Drive top tier EARNINGS GROWTH = Organic growth engine Turn clients into loyal PROMOTERS Digital marketing and social media - Relationship focused business development Differentiated experience DEEPEN RELATIONSHIPS with our customers Cross pollination with clients

  19. Slide 19: Evans Strategic Objectives

    Evans Strategic Objectives Intentional, consistent CULTURE = Asgrowth continues, remain focused — _ Differentiators for staff as competitive advantage Geographic Diversity = Acquisition of Rochester Community Bank Acquire, develop and retain Top TIER TALENT = Talents as catalyst for differentiation

  20. Slide 20: City of Buffalo Business and Relationship Center New Corporate Administrative Office

    20 City of Buffalo Business and Relationship Center New Corporate Administrative Office Relocated Community Investment Team Consolidating three facilities ao. Better position our organization to operate more efficiently and effectively while assisting in growth and the attraction and retention of ta

  21. Slide 21: Work/Life Solutions

    24 <2 Work/Life -/ Solutions EVANS BANCORP,

  22. Slide 22: Investment Highlights

    Investment Highlights Strong and growing franchise in resurgent WNY * Diverse revenue mix, strong operating fundamentals * Core deposit and loan growth * Lower-risk balance sheet with solid capital base Value creation with acquisition of FSB Bancorp * Creates scale * Leverages strength of Evans comm

  23. Slide 23: Evans Bancorp

    EVANS BANCORPixc.

  24. Slide 24: Supplemental

    Supplemental x ie © EVANS

  25. Slide 25: Strategic Plan Results (2016-2019)

    Strategic Plan Results (2016-2019) (S in millions, except EPS) 25 YE 2015 YE 2019 A Assets S$ 939,107 S$ 1,460,230 + 56% Loans S$ 773,984 $ 1,226,531 +58% Deposits $ 802,982 S$ 1,267,440 +58% Efficiency Ratio 71.83% 67.21% 462 bps FTE 258.0 308.5 +20% YE 2015 YE 2019 A Net Income S 7,843 $ 17,014 +1

  26. Slide 26: Solid Credit Fundamentals

    26 Solid Credit Fundamentals NPAs to Total Loans + OREO 1.64% Solid underwriting discipline and proactive portfolio management 2016 2017 2018 2019 Q1 20 Deep customer relationships Net Charge Offs (Recoveries) to Average Loans 06% 0.02% 0.01% 0.03% 2016 2017 2018 2019 Q1 20 mm EVBN — SNL>S$1B <$58 P

  27. Slide 27: Deposit Composition and Product Growth

    27 Deposit Composition and Product Growth Q1 2020 Composition 4% YOY Demand: * 13% 0rS31M NOW: + 30% or $37M Savings: *1%0rS7M Time: ™8% or $S24M Municipal deposits: *2%orS5SM Wy savings & Money Market HH Time Deposits pemand & NOW EVANS ©2020 Evans Bancorp, Inc. Deposit changes compare Q12019 vs Q1

  28. Slide 28: Net Interest Margin and Efficiency Ratio

    28 Net Interest Margin and Efficiency Ratio NIM Efficiency Ratio* 73.4% 3.79% ai19 Qi 20 ai19 i 20 = Community Bank Peer Group per SNL Data = Community Bank Peer Group per SNL Data mEVBN =EVBN *The calculation of the non-GAAP efficiency ratio excludes amortization of intangibles, gains and losses fr

  29. Slide 29: Management Team

    29 Management Team David J. Nasca, President and Chief Executive Officer John B. Connerton, EVP Chief Financial Officer Mary Ellen Frandina, EVP Chief Administrative Officer Dale M. McKim III, EVP Chief Risk Officer Kenneth D. Pawlak, EVP Chief Commercial Banking Officer Nicholas J. Snyder, EVP Reta

Evans Bancorp — Investor Presentation (June 2020) on 6ix