Owens Realty Mortgage — Proxy Contest (June 2018)
35 slides from Owens Realty Mortgage's proxy contest presentation, Jun 28, 2018
Slide 1: Driving Performance & Maximizing Stockholder Value
June 27, 2018 ee =) WEN. MORTGAGE, INC, ee Driving Performance & Maximizing Stockholder Value
Slide 2: Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements
CAUTIONARY STATEMENT REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS, IMPORTANT NOTICE: This presentation contains forwerdtoaking statements, within the mening of the sate harbor provisions ofthe United States Private Securities tigation Reform Act of 1995 (the Reto Act"). All such fonwordooking statements a i
Slide 3: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS Company Overview Executive Summary Strategy Execution Delivering Stockholder Value Highly Qualified Board & Strong Corporate Governance Hovde Group: Short-term Mandate Could Destroy Your Investment Appendix
Slide 4: Company Overview
COMPANY OVERVIEW Owens Realty Mortgage, Inc. is a specialty finance REIT that focuses on the origination, investment and management of small-balance and middle-market commercial real estate loans. In May 2013, ORM completed a reorganization into a publicly-traded REIT Provides customized, short-term
Slide 5: Executive Summary
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY + ORMisin tonstion: decreasing realestate assets andinereosing loon portfofo + ORM decreased Management Fee folowing a9-month review of shotegic oitematives + ORMis closing the gap between our NAV and stock pce Hotes Delivering Sling by 8 petcantoge pohs| epi] and.applsrespecivey S
Slide 6: Strategy Execution
- ~ z0 WENS Wiottéace ne —r Strategy Execution
Slide 7: Owens Is Amid a Significant Positive Transition
OWENS IS AMID A SIGNIFICANT POSITIVE TRANSITION We are executing the transition strategy according to plan, despite significant constraints * Following the financial crisis, we held an illiquid real estate portfolio due to borrower defaults = The Board later approved the REIT conversion in order to
Slide 8: Owens Is Amid a Significant Positive Transition
OWENS IS AMID A SIGNIFICANT POSITIVE TRANSITION We are executing the transition strategy according to plan despite significant constraints We have sold a significant portion of our real-estate assets and expect the disposition of remaining real estate assets to be complete by the end of 2019 = We mu
Slide 9: Significant Competitive Advantages
SIGNIFICANT COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES Origination and asset management experlise provide significant speed and flexibility advantages. SONG BRAND gxteRUNceD MECOGNTION MANAGEMENT ssc TrAM rege pee alcreative RELATIONSHIPS INvestMent SmRUCTURES iecr FASTIUNDING —_onlgtNation ‘Caranmes eServicine
Slide 10: Strategic Highlights
STRATEGIC HIGHLIGHTS Long-term focus on delivering a consistent, competitive risk-adjusted yield fo stockholders Grow Commercial Loan Investment Portfolio + Capitalize on strong real estate market fundamentals and growing demand for fast and flexible Capital solutions + Focus primarily on fist lien
Slide 11: Growing Dividend Yield
GROWING DIVIDEND YIELD Opportunity to increase leverage up to 2x resulting in a marked increase in pro forma dividend yield* Pro Forma Loan Portfolio Leverage and Return Analysis i ‘Conservative Estimates } £ “Target Estimates: Description Description [Balance Sheet (SM) Equiy capital base m0 $220 «
Slide 12: ORM's Reasonable Risk/Return Profile Results in Leverage Significantly Lower Than Peers
ORM'S REASONABLE RISK/RETURN PROFILE RESULTS IN LEVERAGE SIGNIFICANTLY LOWER THAN PEERS Debt to Equity (multiples) 3 25 2 15 1 05 7 2x 0 ABR ACRE LAD} STAR Pro forma based on recent equity raise Source: ORM Commercial Mortgage REIT Matkel Updated 6/25/18
Slide 13: Delivering Stockholder Value
- ~ z0 WENS Wiottéace ne —r Delivering Stockholder Value
Slide 14: Delivering Stockholder Returns
DELIVERING STOCKHOLDER RETURNS ORM Outperformed Peers and SNL US REIT Index Since 2013 Public Listing* by 93ppts and 69.4ppts, respectively. 7a nT ORM TSR —=Peer Medion ~——=SNL US REIT INDEX ‘Through May, 2018 [he day beter the Hove Group's ist pubs tier, Source: Facet peer group compiked of Arbor R
Slide 15: Delivering Stockholder Returns
DELIVERING STOCKHOLDER RETURNS ORM Outperformed Peers and SNL US REIT Index on a 3 -Year Basis* by 38.1ppts and 21.4ppts, respectively. os oa 03 02 ol 0 ge 05/08/16 osygs/7 02 03 ORM ——Peer Median © ——=SNL US REIT INDEX ‘since May 8.2015 heough May’, 2018 he day bette the Howe Group's fist pub lete)
Slide 16: Increasing Dividends
INCREASING DIVIDENDS Dividends Per Share 5-Year CAGR 35.0% 31.2% 0.0% 25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 7.3% 5.0% 0.6% 0.0% ORM ABR ACRE “5.0% -10.0% 6.9% * BicudesLADR ana STAR, Neher compony poic.cvidendt in F201, Bees
Slide 17: Repurchasing Shares
Repurchasing Shares “$36 Bn |-53 SINCE PUBLIC LISTING Increasing the Dividend 100%* “SHARE as2017 gi 2018 G2 2018 Paying Dividends
Slide 18: Highly Qualified Board & Strong Corporate Governance
- ~ z0 WENS Wiottéace ne —r Highly Qualified Board & Strong Corporate Governance
Slide 19: Effective Board Leadership
EFFECTIVE BOARD LEADERSHIP Our Board and Management remain significant stockholders of the Company owning a combined 4.48% of outstanding shares. Publ Company Bryan Draper James Kessler ‘Ann Marie Mehium. William Owens Dennis Schmal Gary Wallace v v inane Real Est ‘Commer Corporate Accounting fendin
Slide 20: Permanent Management Fee Reduction
PERMANENT MANAGEMENT FEE REDUCTION Summary of Management Fee reductions: In November 2015, prior to Hovde Group's submission of nominees, the Compensation Committee engaged leading independent advisors, FTI Consulting to conduct an analysis of the Management Fee From July 1, 2017 through March 31, 2
Slide 21: Permanent Management Fee Reduction (cont.)
PERMANENT MANAGEMENT FEE REDUCTION (cont.) Second lowest among its Peer Group. Last Quarter’s Management Fee 4500000 ss4c00.000 s3s00.000 ssc00.000 ses00.000 sec00.000 1,500.00 si,cc0.000 ssc0000 [] $ orm aa ACRE tao si sta
Slide 22: Governance Enhancements
GOVERNANCE ENHANCEMENTS Your Board and Management are committed to Corporate Governance Best Practices and have demonstrated their commitment through a series of governance enhancements: = Adopted Board Diversity policy = Adopted Majority voting standard in uncontested elections = Adopted Director a
Slide 23: Vote For Your Highly Qualified Directors
VOTE FOR YOUR HIGHLY QUALIFIED DIRECTORS y Bryan Draper v James Kessler ‘Mr, Draper has served as the President and Chief Executive Officer of Owers Really Mortgage, Inc. since January 216 ond is responsible for the overall activities and operations of the ‘Company, including loan investments, opera
Slide 24: Hovde Group: Short-term Mandate Could Destroy Your Investment
- ~ z0 WENS Wiottéace ne —r Hovde Group: Short-term Mandate Could Destroy Your Investment
Slide 25: The Hovde Group's Short-Term Mindset and Plan Will Derail Our Progress
THE HOVDE GROUP’S SHORT-TERM MINDSET AND PLAN WILL DERAIL OUR PROGRESS AND DESTROY LONG-TERM VALUE The Hovde Group's real goals to liquidate ORM, destroying value: + The Hovde Group's campaign is based on one ultimate theme: reckless share repurchases which will lead to liquidation * liquidation wou
Slide 26: The Hovde Group Engagement Timeline
THE HOVDE GROUP ENGAGEMENT TIMELINE man7 rons aise sngs Comper pays > Company pays > Company} > compar Sidon Siivesvisend Sorvanioesd Smeurets inerecreaebend orgie wens November 2015 Company snc pugut2or7 8/8/17 Steven tlovde sige Componyengooss 13/17 Goardbagins Company 2/17 na omer ive ACEO areten
Slide 27: The Hovde Group Engagement Timeline (cont'd)
THE HOVDE GROUP ENGAGEMENT TIMELINE (cont'd) ane 1 cor ans peaks sine mean Company anwnees/2018 srnomness Company FEOEEne Company aproes tors pono ® — fegvctonte poner ERO ey wong tre, Cope Nenopementfee Src tothe tondntisledaropalcy Sonmitcs, SPAT aLthe ove croup fo Spat le peveuty ‘tontowrsomes EV
Slide 28: Setting the Record Straight
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT Tne Hovde Group made several false claims in its proxy materials. Here is the truth: The Hovde Group's False Claims to book value through aggressive shore buybacks x The Management Fee is excessive i “ORM's Directors’ interesis are not aligned with stockholders The Facts
Slide 29: The Hovde Group Nominees — Unfit to Serve Interests of All Stockholders
THE HOVDE GROUP NOMINEES — UNFIT TO SERVE INTERESTS OF ALL STOCKHOLDERS = Steven Hovde - Lacks Bandwidth * He is chairman and CEO of a full service investment bank; chairman of a full service real estate firm; owner of a bank holding company; director of two bank holding company boards and two of th
Slide 30: The Hovde Group Nominees — Unfit to Serve Interests of All Stockholders
THE HOVDE GROUP NOMINEES — UNFIT TO SERVE INTERESTS OF ALL STOCKHOLDERS = Your Board Conducted Extensive Interviews After extensive interviews, your Board remains concerned that the nominees, as owners of the Hovde Group, were singularly focused on driving strategies to sell the Hovde Group's shares
Slide 31: Vote on the WHITE Proxy Card Today
VOTE ON THE WHITE PROXY CARD TODAY = The Board has a clear plan that the Company has been successfully executing since public listing = Owens has been returning capital to stockholders through increasing dividends and share repurchases = The Board has taken a number of significant steps to enhance t
Slide 32: Appendix
- ~ z0 WENS Wiottéace ne —r APPENDIX
Slide 33: Pro Forma Loan Portfolio Leverage and Return Analysis
PRO FORMA LOAN PORTFOLIO LEVERAGE AND RETURN ANALYSIS Pre Ferma Loan Petfolo Leverage and Retum Analyse = ‘ey oiler somos =m = Steuer ewes mm te (ings CR en pariio 5 —ay ESS] CR opaio—F is) i ks, isecreore sour sos 8 22 heen sour sas 8 as Nato —ar no ar Neen —ar ao Canvas ‘3 “8 20 Unarecs 3 ‘8 20 Ul
Slide 34: Our Public Company Peers
OUR PUBLIC COMPANY PEERS For purposes of comparing performance, the Company uses the following public company peers: Arbor Realty Trust, Ares Commercial Real Estate Corporation, Ladder Capital Corporation, Sutherland Asset Management, and iStar Inc. Peers were chosen based on portfolio mix and relat
Slide 35: Management Fee Logic
MANAGEMENT FEE LOGIC get i - {i} one-twelfth [1/12] mulipied by [il (9) 1.50% oF the fist $600,000,000 of the Companys| Slockholdets' Equity, ond [b} 1.25% of the Stockholders’ Equity that is greater than 9 . ‘Ares Commerical Real Estate The base management fee is equal fo 1.5% of Ihe Company's stoc