Avista Corporation · NYSE:AVA

Avista — Technical Presentation (September 2023)

76 slides from Avista's technical presentation, Sep 26, 2023

  1. Slide 1: 2025 Electric IRP TAC Meeting No. 1 Agenda

    2025 Electric Integrated Resource Plan Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 Agenda Tuesday, September 26, 2023 Virtual Meeting Topic Time Staff Introductions 8:30 John Lyons CEIP Update 8:45 Kelly Dengel TAC Process and Methods Proposals 9:15 James Gall PLEXOS Overview and Back Cast Analysis 9

  2. Slide 2: 2023 IRP TAC 1 Introductions

    2023 IRP TAC 1 Introductions John Lyons, Ph.D. Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 September 26, 2023

  3. Slide 3: Meeting Guidelines

    Meeting Guidelines • IRP team is in office Monday - Wednesday and also available by email, phone and Teams for questions and comments • Stakeholder feedback responses shared with TAC at meetings, in Teams and in Appendix • Working IRP data posted to Teams • Virtual IRP meetings on Teams, in person a

  4. Slide 4: Virtual TAC Meeting Reminders

    Virtual TAC Meeting Reminders • Please mute mics unless speaking or asking a question • Raise hand or use the chat box for questions or comments • Respect the pause • Please try not to speak over the presenter or a speaker • Please state your name before commenting for the note taker • This is a pub

  5. Slide 5: Integrated Resource Planning

    Integrated Resource Planning The Integrated Resource Plan (IRP): • Required by Idaho and Washington* every other year – Washington now requires IRP every four years and update at two years • Guides resource strategy over the next twenty years • Current and projected load & resource position • Develo

  6. Slide 6: Technical Advisory Committee

    Technical Advisory Committee • The public process piece of the IRP – input on what to study, how to study, and review of assumptions and results • Wide range of participants involved in all or parts of the process – Ask questions – Always looking for help with soliciting new TAC members • Open forum

  7. Slide 7: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 8:30 Introductions, John Lyons 8:45 CEIP Update, Kelly Dengel 9:15 TAC Process and Methods Proposals, James Gall 9:45 PLEXOS Overview and Back Cast Analysis, Mike Hermanson 10:45 Break 11:00 Available Resource Options Discussion, Lori Hermanson 11:30 Work Plan, John Lyons 12:00 Adjour

  8. Slide 8: Clean Energy Implementation Plan

    Clean Energy Implementation Plan Biennial Report Update September 26, 2023 – IRP TAC Meeting

  9. Slide 9: Agenda

    Agenda  CETA/ CEIP Background  CEIP Biennial Update:  Energy Supply Specific Actions  Customer Benefit Indicators  Energy Efficiency & Demand Response Specific Actions  Named Communities Investment Fund  Public Participation  Conditions 2

  10. Slide 10: CETA / CEIP Background

    CETA / CEIP Background Clean Energy Transformation Act (CETA) Law – May 2019 Clean Energy Implementation Filed October 1, 2021, for 2022-2025 compliance period Plan (CEIP) – Every 4 Years Clean Energy Progress Filed June 29, 2023, for 2022 compliance period Report – Annually Biennial CEIP – Every Tw

  11. Slide 11: Washington Clean Energy Targets

    Energy Supply Specific Actions Washington Clean Energy Targets 100 Clean Energy Target 90 Available Clean Generation 83.5 Percent of Retail Load 80 76.7 71.6 70 66.0 62.5 60 55.0 50 47.5 40.0 40 30 20 10 0 2022 2023 2024 2025 Notes: 1) Available generation through July 1, 2023, is actual generation;

  12. Slide 12: Energy Efficiency & Demand Response Specific Actions

    Energy Efficiency & Demand Response Specific Actions  Demand Response Pilots for 2024-2025  Small Business Lighting Direct-Install Program  Avista-Spokane Tribe Energy Partnership  Low Income Weatherization & Deferred Maintenance Pilot  Named Communities Investment Fund https://www.myavista.com

  13. Slide 13: Customer Benefit Indicators

    Customer Benefit Indicators Affordability Energy Security Access to Environmental Community Public Health & Resilience Clean Energy Development Participation in Energy Availability Methods/Modes of Outdoor Air Quality Named Community Employee Diversity Company Programs Outreach & Clean Energy Commun

  14. Slide 14: Named Communities Investment Fund

    Named Communities Investment Fund  Specific action dedicated to the $2M $1M equitable distribution of energy Supplement Investments in Energy Efficiency Distribution Resiliency and non-energy benefits and reduction in burdens to Named Communities $1M $500,000 Incentives & Grants Outreach & Customer

  15. Slide 15: NCIF Application

    NCIF Application  Open to government/community/non-profit agencies and organizations  Establish a user ID and password  Information about the applicant and proposal  Application is open continuously  Award decisions communicated within 45 days of submission https://www.cybergrants.com/pls/cyber

  16. Slide 16: Equity Advisory Group's NCIF Prioritization

    Equity Advisory Group’s NCIF Prioritization Rank EAG NCIF Prioritized Initiatives 1 Focus efforts on improving energy efficiency (and EE awareness/education) for schools, community centers, and other places where Named Communities spend time 1 Focus efforts on improving energy efficiency for Spokane

  17. Slide 17: NCIF Requirements

    NCIF Requirements Affordability Energy Access to Environmental Community Public Health Proposal assessments include: Security & Clean Energy Development Resiliency  Serving Named Communities Customer Benefit Indicators  Equity Areas Participation in Company Programs Number of households with a hig

  18. Slide 18: Named Communities Investment Fund Projects

    Named Communities Investment Fund Projects Energy Efficiency Distribution Resiliency Incentives & Grants  Health & Safety for Mobile Homes  MLK Center – Solar & Battery  Kids Making Sense – Air Monitors  EE for Affordable Housing Storage  EE for Homes in Malden, WA  Town of Malden – Solar & Gr

  19. Slide 19: Public Participation Updates

    Public Participation Updates Avista’s Public Participation Plan was filed May 1, 2023  Mitigate public participation barriers  Implement meaningful strategies to engage all customers including vulnerable populations and highly impact communities,  Ensure the equitable distribution of energy and n

  20. Slide 20: Public Participation Updates

    Public Participation Updates  Multi-Language Strategy  CEIP Newsletter  Public Comment Form  Frequently Asked Questions & Answers  Public Participation Meeting  Equity Advisory Group (EAG) 13

  21. Slide 21: Conditions

    Conditions 38 Conditions across 11 categories  Interim & Specific Targets  Baseline Conditions  Specific Actions  Demand Response  Distributed Energy Resources & Distribution Planning  Energy Efficiency  Customer Benefit Indicators  Public Participation & Equity Advisory Group  Incremental

  22. Slide 22: TAC Biennial CEIP Review

    TAC Biennial CEIP Review  Post on IRP Teams site October 1  Deadline for comments/questions October 13, 2023  Contact Kelly Dengel, Kelly.dengel@avistacorp.com  Include comments/questions in filing Biennial CEIP November 1, 2023 15

  23. Slide 23: Thank You

    Thank You www.myavista.com/ceta ceta@avistacorp.com 16

  24. Slide 24: Appendix

    Aw AIVISTA Appendix

  25. Slide 25: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 1 Once the Commission has adopted final “use” rules in Docket UE-210183, in its Clean Energy Implementation Plan (CEIP) docket, if different than Table 2.1 on page 2-3 in the CEIP, Avista shall update its CEIP to reflect the percentage of retail sales of electricity supplie

  26. Slide 26: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 5 In its 2023 Biennial CEIP Update and in future CEIPs, Avista will include descriptions of quantitative (i.e., cost based) and qualitative (e.g., equity considerations) analyses that support interim targets to comply with the Clean Energy Transformation Act’s (CETA) 2030 a

  27. Slide 27: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 9 Avista agrees to update and expand its Vulnerable Populations areas within its 2023 Biennial CEIP Update taking into account the additional criteria developed by the EAG and Energy Assistance Advisory Group (EAAG) and to ensure updates are in line with the definition of V

  28. Slide 28: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 13 Avista will initiate its Distribution Planning Advisory Group (DPAG) no later than the end of 2022, and it must invite all existing advisory groups to participate in the new group. Avista acknowledges that stakeholders have limited resources and will consult between exis

  29. Slide 29: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 17 As part of its CBI Participation in Company Programs, Avista agrees to track the number of residential appliance and equipment rebates provided to customers residing in Named Communities and the number of residential rebates provided to customers residing in rental units

  30. Slide 30: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 21 Avista agrees that the CBI – Energy Availability will include a metric related to the frequency of customer outages for all customers, Vulnerable Populations, and Highly Impacted Communities. Condition 22 Avista agrees to add the following CBI and metrics related to Ener

  31. Slide 31: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 26 For the CBI – Named Community Clean Energy Avista agrees to eliminate the current metric on “percent non-emitting renewable energy located in Named Communities,” and instead measure the following in Named Communities: (1) total MWh of distributed energy resources 5 MW an

  32. Slide 32: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 30 On or before October 1, 2022, Avista must file with the Commission: a. A progress report on what actions have been taken since October 2021 to reduce barriers to public participation (e.g., steps taken to reduce barriers including but not limited to non-English speaking

  33. Slide 33: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 34 For its 2023 IRP Progress Report, Avista commits to reevaluate its resource need given acquisitions the Company has made since its 2021 IRP (e.g., Chelan PUD hydro slice contracts) and include those proposed changes in its 2023 Biennial CEIP Update. Condition 35 Avista r

  34. Slide 34: CEIP Conditions

    CEIP Conditions Condition 37 In order to provide a means of recovery of prudently incurred costs associated with implementing this CEIP and associated conditions, the Company will file a separate accounting petition to address deferred accounting for such costs until they are reviewed and deemed pru

  35. Slide 35: IRP TAC Process Change Ideas and Modeling Change Ideas

    IRP TAC Process Change Ideas and Modeling Change Ideas James Gall Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 September 26, 2023

  36. Slide 36: TAC Communication

    TAC Communication Propose to use Microsoft Teams for primary TAC communication • Advantages – File sharing ease – Open communication via chat function on files or questions to Avista or other TAC members – Eliminates email traffic for passive TAC members – TAC meeting recordings and chat messages ar

  37. Slide 37: New IRP TAC Teams Site

    New IRP TAC Teams Site Search EO) Toe TT oe Ce + | 0 ia @ Hecie

  38. Slide 38: WUTC Notice on Electric IRP's

    WUTC Notice on Electric IRP’s • Commission is discontinuing its practice of issuing acknowledgment letters for electric utility IRPs in all cases. • Under CETA, the CEIP must be “consistent with the utility’s long-range integrated resource plan” and “informed by the investor-owned utility’s clean en

  39. Slide 39: Action Item Update

    Action Item Update • Incorporate the results of the DER potential study • Continue to work with the Western Power Pool’s WRAP where appropriate for resource planning and load process to develop both Qualifying Capacity Credits (QCC) forecasting. and Planning Reserve Margins (PRM) for use in resource

  40. Slide 40: Plexos Introduction

    Plexos Introduction • PLEXOS is a production cost model • Why did Avista bring in Plexos? developed by Energy Exemplar – More sophisticated hydroelectric • The model benefits from a mixed modeling capability than Aurora integer-based design – Allows for proper valuation of energy storage benefits an

  41. Slide 41: Load Forecast Update

    Load Forecast Update • Avista has brought on Applied Energy Group (AEG) to conduct a long-term forecast of customer loads (Natural Gas & Electric) • End use load forecast technique to better understand how loads will change due to electrification potentials • Forecast will be consistent with DER pot

  42. Slide 42: PRiSM Update

    PRiSM Update • Avista plans to continue to use PRiSM in the 2025 IRP • Avista will test PLEXOS and compare results for potential replacement in the 2027 IRP – Why not now? • Time to build/test models • Energy efficiency modeling • Speed • Testing Natural Gas IRP in PRiSM – Co-optimize natural gas sy

  43. Slide 43: Resiliency and HHI Score

    Resiliency • How should we include resiliency? • Potential Metrics – Feeder or customer level seems out of – Seasonal plant & unit (shaft risk) scope for an IRP – Location fuel source – Generation sources and delivery seems – Transmission path plausible – Wildfire risk level areas • Can resource div

  44. Slide 44: PLEXOS Overview and Back Cast Analysis

    PLEXOS Overview and Back Cast Analysis Mike Hermanson, Senior Power Supply Analyst Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 September 26, 2023

  45. Slide 45: Power Supply Modeling in the IRP Process

    Power Supply Modeling in the IRP Process • Analytical framework to determine the long-run economic and operational performance of alternative resource portfolios • Modeling is used to simulate the integration of new resource alternatives within our existing resource mix, thereby informing the select

  46. Slide 46: Plexos

    Plexos • Plexos is a widely used energy modeling software suite designed for electricity market analysis and power system optimization. It is used to make informed decisions about energy production, transmission, and distribution. Key aspects of the model include: – Market Simulation: allows users t

  47. Slide 47: Plexos

    Plexos – Integration of Renewable Energy: Plexos can incorporate renewable energy sources like wind and solar, assisting planners to assess the impact of variable generation on the power grid. – Transmission Planning: It supports transmission system planning and expansion studies allowing the inclus

  48. Slide 48: Plexos Implementation of Avista System

    Plexos Implementation of Avista System – The Plexos IRP model is a 20-year simulation to meet native load and contractual obligations with Avista owned generation, contracted generation, and market purchases. Avista owned & Market Hourly Native Load contracted generation Purchases/Sales Native load

  49. Slide 49: Plexos Representation of Transmission System & Generation

    BPAT-N Lancaster– CCCT Noxon Rapids Cabinet Gorge Kettle Falls Noxon Biomass/CT Douglas Northeast Boulder Park Rathdrum Lancaster Stratford Spokane CdA Chelan Chelan Hot Springs Columbia Basin Hydro Pine Creek Long Lake Upper Falls Post Falls 9-Mile Monroe Grant Larson Little Falls Benewah Mid C BPA

  50. Slide 50: Plexos Implementation of Avista System

    Plexos Implementation of Avista System Results System Components Properties of each component

  51. Slide 51: Plexos Implementation of Avista System

    Plexos Implementation of Avista System – Modeling challenges • Model has perfect foresight • Difficult to capture the myriad of constraints on a hydro storage system. – For example, management of a reservoir that is used for recreation and has residences on much of the shoreline • Balance between mo

  52. Slide 52: 2021 Backcast – Plexos vs Actual Dispatch

    2021 Backcast – Plexos vs Actual Dispatch • To verify that our model represented our system operation and dispatch we utilized 2021 inputs and compared the output of Plexos to actual 2021 data. In the model we utilized: – 2021 Hourly Load – Hourly hydro inflows – Hourly run-of-river generation – Hou

  53. Slide 53: 2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison (aMW)

    2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison (aMW) Facility Actual Gen Plexos Gen Difference Production Cost Comparison Noxon Rapids 179.8 178.5 -1.3 0.96% difference between mark to market of generation subtracting fuel Cabinet Gorge 113.8 112.4 -1.4 costs Long Lake 54.6 54.4 -0.2 Little Falls 23.7 23.2 -0.5

  54. Slide 54: 2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

    2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

  55. Slide 55: 2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

    2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

  56. Slide 56: 2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

    2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

  57. Slide 57: 2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

    2021 Backcast Dispatch Comparison

  58. Slide 58: 2021 Backcast Reservoir Elevation Comparison

    2021 Backcast Reservoir Elevation Comparison

  59. Slide 59: 2021 Backcast Reservoir Elevation Comparison

    2021 Backcast Reservoir Elevation Comparison

  60. Slide 60: Available Resource Options

    Available Resource Options Lori Hermanson Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 September 26, 2023

  61. Slide 61: Turbine Resource Options

    Turbine Resource Options Peakers Baseload • Simple Cycle Combustion Turbine • Combined Cycle CT (CCCT) (CT) – 312 MW (1x1 w/DF) – CT Frame – 180 MW (2 units) Fuels • Reciprocating Engines • Natural gas – 185 MW (10 units) • Renewable natural gas • Hydrogen • Ammonia • Synthetic natural gas -Natural

  62. Slide 62: Renewable Resource Options – Solar and Wind

    Renewable Resource Options – Solar and Wind All Purchase Power Agreement (PPA) Options Solar Wind • Residential (6 kW AC) – w/ and w/o battery • Commercial (1 MW AC) – w/ and w/o • Wind (100 MW) battery • Montana wind (100 MW) • Fixed PV Array (5 MW AC) – w/ and w/o • Offshore wind (100 MW) battery

  63. Slide 63: Other "Clean" Resource Options

    Other “Clean” Resource Options • Geothermal PPA (20 MW) – Off-system • Biomass (58 MW) – i.e. Kettle Falls 3 or other • Nuclear PPA (100 MW) – Off-system share of a mid-size facility • Fuel Cell (25 MW) 4

  64. Slide 64: Storage Technologies

    Storage Technologies Lithium-Ion Other Storage Options • Assumes: 86% round trip efficiency (RTE), 15- • Assumes Avista ownership year operating life • 25 MW Vanadium Flow (70% RTE) • Assumes Avista ownership – 4 hours (100 MWh) • 5 MW Distribution Level • 25 MW Zinc Bromide Flow (67% RTE) – 4 hours

  65. Slide 65: Resource Option Currently Being Researched

    Resource Option Currently Being Researched • Carbon capture and storage • Fusion reaction (no real costs yet) • Organic Solid Flow energy storage – proprietary nonflammable mixture of solid and water-based electrolytes • Molten salt heat storage (using existing steam turbines) • New hydro • Regional

  66. Slide 66: 2023 IRP Work Plan

    2023 IRP Work Plan John Lyons, Ph.D. Technical Advisory Committee Meeting No. 1 September 26, 2023

  67. Slide 67: 2025 IRP Work Plan

    2025 IRP Work Plan • IRP regulations require an IRP to be filed in Idaho by June 1, 2025, and an IRP in Washington on January 1, 2025. • Work Plan shows process and timing of key IRP events • Overview discussion • TAC meetings and topics • Document outline by chapter • Timeline of major assumptions

  68. Slide 68: 2025 IRP Work Plan – Modeling

    2025 IRP Work Plan – Modeling • PLEXOS will be used to model resource dispatch, resource option valuation, and market risk analysis. • PRiSM will be used for resource selection. • Continue to use Aurora for electric market price forecasting, will evaluate other options for the 2027 Progress Report/I

  69. Slide 69: Tentative 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule

    Tentative 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 1 (Tuesday, September 26, 2023): Washington CEIP Biannual Update; available resource options discussion; PLEXOS overview and backcast analysis; TAC feedback on changes to process methods and assumptions; and 2025 IRP Work Plan IRP Process Review. • TAC

  70. Slide 70: Tentative 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule

    Tentative 2025 Electric IRP TAC Schedule • TAC 4 (May 2024): IRP Generation Option Transmission Planning Studies; Distribution System Planning within the IRP & DPAG update; transmission and distribution modeling in the IRP; Load & Resource Balance and methodology; and new resource options costs and

  71. Slide 71: 2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline Executive Summary 1. Introduction, Stakeholder Involvement, and Process Changes 2. Economic and Load Forecast – Economic Conditions – Avista Energy & Peak Load Forecasts – Load Forecast Scenarios 3. Existing Supply Resources – Avista Resources – Contractual Resources

  72. Slide 72: 2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline 5. Distributed Energy Resource Options – Energy efficiency potential – Demand response potential – Generating and energy storage resources options and potential – Named Community Actions – Distributed Energy Resources Study Conclusions 6. Supply-Side Resource Options

  73. Slide 73: 2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline 8. Market Analysis – Wholesale Natural Gas Market Price Forecast – Wholesale Electric Market Price Forecast – Scenario Analysis 9. Preferred Resource Strategy – Preferred Resource Strategy – Market Exposure Analysis – Avoided Costs 10. Portfolio Scenarios – Portfolio

  74. Slide 74: 2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline

    2025 Electric IRP Draft Outline 11. Washington Clean Energy Action Plan (CEAP) – Decision Making Process – Resource Need – Resource Selection – Customer Benefit Indicators 12. Action Plan 9

  75. Slide 75: Major 2025 Timeline

    Major 2025 Timeline Exhibit 1: Major 2025 Electric IRP Assumption Timeline Task Target Date Market Price Assumptions December 2023 CCA/Other GHG Pricing Assumptions Natural gas price forecast Regional resources and roads forecast Electric price forecast March 2024 New Resource Options Cost & Availab

  76. Slide 76: 2025 Electric IRP Draft and Submission Dates

    2025 Electric IRP Draft and Submission Dates • Draft IRP will be available to the public on August 30, 2024, for comment • Comments from TAC members due by November 15, 2024, or through Washington’s public comment timeline • IRP team will be available for conference calls or email to address comment

Avista — Technical Presentation (September 2023) on 6ix