Guidance Software — Proxy Contest (April 2016)
36 slides from Guidance Software's proxy contest presentation, Apr 14, 2016
Slide 1: Disclaimer
Disclaimer The views expressed herein represent the subjective opinions of The McCreight Living Trust UA 31-Mar-06 and its trustees (collectively, “the Trust”), who of record or beneficially own shares of Guidance Software, Inc. (the “Company” or “Guidance Software”). These views are based on public
Slide 2: Change is Urgently Needed at Guidance Software
Change is Urgently Needed at Guidance Software Reverse Sustained Track Record of Poor Financial Performance Reestablish Leadership and Strategic Direction Enhance and Maximize Value for All Stockholders Instill Sound Corporate Governance Our Nominees are Ideally Suited to Implement Necessary
Slide 3: Background
Background Company: Guidance Software provides digital investigative solutions to help clients defend their organization’s data assets Founded in 1997 by Shawn H. McCreight Enterprise products reach > 25 million endpoints Initial Public Offering in 2006 Gold Standard for Forensic, Cyber-Security, an
Slide 4: 5-year stock performance versus peers
6 Over the 5-year period ending 2/10/16, the Company’s stock price decreased 48%. During the same time period, peer* group valuation increased 89% *Peers: Check Point Software Technologies Ltd., CyberArk Software, Ltd., FalconStor International, Inc., Fortinet Inc., Imperva, Inc., Infoblox, Inc., Pr
Slide 5: The cyber-security opportunity
The cyber-security opportunity The U.S. government has implemented a $19 billion national Cyber-Security action plan Guidance Software Well Positioned to Capitalize on Enormous Opportunity 3 Years and $50 Million of Product Development for Next-Gen product Technology strategy widely accepted by cust
Slide 6: Industry Recognition and stock price increase during roadshow
Industry Recognition: SC Magazine’s “Best Computer Forensics Solution” at InfoSecurity Europe 8 GUID stock price increases 85 % during roadshow and promotion of Cyber-Security strategy "Receiving SC Magazine's awards in the United States and abroad is a tremendous honor given that winners are select
Slide 7: CEO promoted commitment to a Cyber-Security strategy
The CEO unquestionably bought into and actively promoted the Company’s commitment to a strategy focused on Cyber-Security In a May 2015 message to the Company’s senior leaders, the CEO communicated his commitment to Cyber-Security, stating the decision was based on careful consideration and input fr
Slide 8: CTO prepares for release of cyber-security product
Consistent with management/board direction, cTO prepares for release of cyber-security product From: Shawn McCreight To: GSI Senior Leaders Sent: July 21, 2015 All, After much discussion, the teams have decided to bring out an “alpha” version of EnCase 8 Cyber by no later than mid-September. This ve
Slide 9: CEO veers off course: switches from cyber-security to Risk Management
CEO veers off course without board input: switches direction from cyber-security to Risk Management CEO abruptly discontinues work on new Cyber-Security product September 2015 Cyber-Security product (set for Q1 2016 release) is scrapped Product is already being alpha tested on customer sites Disappo
Slide 10: Shift in sales strategy
Shift in sales strategy In Our View, Shift in Sales Strategy Had Significant Negative Repercussions 12 LOWER REVENUE Problems caused by shift in Sales strategy from Direct to Channel are exacerbated by CEO’s problematic decision to unilaterally scrap Cyber-Security product and enter undefined Risk M
Slide 11: Major strategic decisions made without board awareness
How could major strategic decisions be made without board awareness, evaluation, and approval? The Board’s job is to approve strategy and ensure management executes according to plan Major shifts in both product and sales strategies instituted without Board input To our knowledge, no analysis was co
Slide 12: Further lack of board oversight and accountability
Further lack of board oversight & accountability 14 Misguided Personnel Decisions Negative Impact Terminated prior CEO without contingency plan Took more than 6 weeks to engage executive search firm Took nearly 5 months to identify permanent replacement Took 3 months to fill critical Audit Chair vac
Slide 13: Formation of Special Committees
Formation of Special Committees “Special (Entrenchment) Committee” with 3 Directors Created in response to firing of McCreight Can meet without Board notification Pre-Authorization to spend unlimited funds on lawyers and advisors to aid entrenchment tactics Extra fees for committee members “Independ
Slide 14: Too many Committees
Too many Committees Formation of “Special” Committees are an overt attempt to exclude Shawn H. McCreight from the Company’s decision-making process 16 Director Special Committee M&A Committee Independent Committee Nominating & Governance Committee Audit Committee Compensation Committee Robert van Sc
Slide 15: Board and management entrenchment
Board and management Entrenchment Questionable Timing/Structure of Management Compensation Changes Changes made on Record Date provide management with a larger votable position at the Annual Meeting Establishment of Golden Parachutes Transfers substantial stockholder wealth to 3 executives in the ev
Slide 16: Improper Payments
Improper Payments From the Company’s Proxy Statement: On August 30, 2015, the Company entered into an Independent Contractor Agreement with Kathleen O'Neil, pursuant to which the Company paid to Ms. O'Neil a one-time lump sum payment of $45,000 in exchange for certain consulting services. What it Di
Slide 17: Lack of Transparency and Vaporware Hype
Lack of Transparency and “Vaporware” Hype Lead to Lack of Credibility Discontinued Guidance to the Investment Community Company has refused to provide 2016 financial guidance and key operational metrics leaving stockholders, and the investment community as a whole, unable to adequately evaluate the
Slide 18: Hype with no follow-through
hype with no follow-through 20 + 85 % - 62 % Run-up During Cyber-Security Hype Flat Q2 Missed Q3 Subsequent decline After lengthy roadshow hyping the Company’s Cyber-Security roadmap, lack of execution resulted in decreased confidence among the investment community
Slide 19: Executive Compensation not aligned with Company goals
Executive Compensation not aligned with Company goals In the midst of a Proxy Contest, the Compensation Committee approved the grant of new performance vesting restricted stock awards to senior management based on the level of achievement of the Company’s “Core Product Revenue.” Core Product Revenue
Slide 20: Executive Compensation questionable timing/structure
Executive Compensation questionable timing/Structure Significant modifications were made to the CEO’s compensation structure on the Record Date for the Annual Meeting (3/18/16) with, in our view, the intent of influencing the outcome In addition to 305,003 10-year options struck at $5.85 and 128,425
Slide 21: High Board Compensation
High Board Compensation 23 NACD 2015-2016 Director Compensation Report Guidance Software 2015-2016 Board Compensation Despite the Company’s poor performance, Directors Carnecchia, Poole, and van Schoonenberg receive > 35% above the median compensation for Directors of Micro-cap companies
Slide 22: Waste of time/money/resources
Waste of time/money/resources Seemingly oblivious to major shifts in product/sales strategies and providing no visibility on business prospects, in our view, the Board appears focused on self preservation and enrichment of themselves, former Directors, and management at the expense of stockholders W
Slide 23: What can the board point to as recent accomplishments?
What can the board point to as recent accomplishments? $500,000 for a New Logo! 25 Rather than focusing on profitability, corporate resources are diverted to unnecessary and lower priority initiatives such as creation of new logo, interior re-design of facilities, and costly replacement of building
Slide 24: Our plan: The Plan to Maximize Value for All Stockholders
Our plan The Plan to Maximize Value for All Stockholders 26
Slide 25: Take advantage of existing market leadership
We anticipate that the Endpoint Detection and Response (“EDR”) market will reach an estimated $400M by 2016 - Gartner Competitive Landscape November 2014 Guidance had 18% market share 27 TAKE ADVANTAGE OF EXISTING MARKET LEADERSHIP
Slide 26: Refocus the Company's Business Strategy
Refocus the Company’s Business Strategy Leverage the Company’s Established Customer Base: 25 Million Endpoints Run the EnCase Agent 50,000 customers worldwide 5,000 students trained every year Software interface and documentation have been translated into 13 different languages Leverage the Company’
Slide 27: Implement Disciplined Operational Measures
Implement Disciplined Operational Measures Reduce G&A (currently 17.9 %) Cut legal expenses by settling ongoing lawsuits Streamline inefficient corporate structure: reduce management layers Sell SAAS eDiscovery business (we believe it is worth $10 million) Shrinking business in non-core market Enorm
Slide 28: Resolve Governance Shortcomings
Resolve Governance Shortcomings Adequately evaluate and approve what we believe are appropriate strategic plans Consults with CEO in establishing strategy Adjust Board compensation to fall at median Disband superfluous committees and eliminate padded fees Structure Management compensation to incenti
Slide 29: Reestablish Credibility with the market
Reestablish Credibility with the market Immediately return to regular reporting of financial guidance Report – don’t hide – segment performance Highlight customer win rates Disciplined approach to product announcements Announce real products when they are ready to ship No more Vaporware announcement
Slide 30: Explore ALL Strategic Alternatives
Explore ALL Strategic Alternatives Take Advantage of the Company’s Strategic Value, including through a potential sale of the Company Endpoint Detection & Response (EDR) market is growing strongly EnCase has > 25 million endpoints covered and counting Strong base of marquee customers and maintenance
Slide 31: Revenue multiples suggest substantial value in a sale
LTM Revenue Multiples for transactions in the security software sector suggest GUID could garner substantial value in a sale Even using a conservative multiple, a sale could potentially generate significant gains for all stockholders when compared to the Company’s current stock price The Choice
Slide 32: Highly Qualified Proposed Slate of Directors
Highly Qualified Proposed Slate of directors Shawn McCreight Jonathan Mather Michael McConnell John Colbert Roberto Medrano Founder of Guidance Software and served as Chairman, CEO, and CTO Ran development team at Guidance for 19 years Invented EnCase® and related technologies Invented new technolog
Slide 33: Plan to revitalize the company and maximize stockholder value
Plan to revitalize the company and maximize stockholder value Month 1: Align CEO and management team to execute on new strategic direction (new budget and goals) Announce new plan at EnFuse conference and discuss with large customers Redirect development team to refocus on Cyber-Security product Mon
Slide 34: Conclusion: Change is Urgently Needed at Guidance Software
conclusion Change is Urgently Needed at Guidance Software Reverse Sustained Track Record of Poor Financial Performance Reestablish Leadership and Strategic Direction Enhance and Maximize Value for All Stockholders Instill Sound Corporate Governance Our Nominees are Ideally Suited to Implement Necess
Slide 35: Contact information
Contact information Shawn H. McCreight shawn@mccreights.net Okapi Partners 1212 Avenue of the Americas 24th Floor New York, NY 10036 Patrick McHugh or Michael Fein Tel: +1 (212) 297 0720 info@okapipartners.com 37
Slide 36: Contact information
CONTACT INFORMATION Shawn H. McCreight shawn@mecreights.net Okapi Partners 1212 Avenue of the Americas 24th Floor New York, NY 10036 Patrick McHugh or Michael Fein Tel: +1 (212) 297 0720