Swiss Re AG · SIX:SREN
Swiss Re — Investor Presentation (October 2023)
46 slides from Swiss Re's investor presentation, October 2023
Slide 1: Seed Oils: History and Mechanisms
Seed Oils: History and Mechanisms By Nina Teicholz Author, Science journalist Founder, Nutrition Coalition Inve stigative science journalist © Nina Teicholz Author, The Big Fat Surprise
Slide 2: Disclosures
Disclosures • I am an independent journalist. Receive no funds from any industry or interest group. © Nina Teicholz
Slide 3: What are Seed Oils?
What are Seed Oils? • Corn oil • Cottonseed oil • Soybean oil • Safflower oil • Peanut oil • Canola oil © Nina Teicholz
Slide 4: The original, natural fats
The original, natural fats Tallow Suet © Nina Teicholz
Slide 5: Lard, Butter
*Lard* *Butter* © Nina Teicholz
Slide 6: © Nina Teicholz
www.bimb.freeserve.co.uk They're young... They're in love... BP) | They cat LARD XO British Lard A ©1957. issued by The British Lard Marketing Board in conjunction with the Department of Health. Marketing Board Ss
Slide 7: Olive oil
Olive oil Greek archaeologist Yannis Hamilakis: “despite conventional wisdom, there is almost no evidence which could indicate with certainty” that olive oil was made for “culinary use” in Greece until the 19th century. © Nina Teicholz
Slide 8: Oils used as lubricants for machinery in industrial revolution
Oils used as lubricants for machinery in industrial revolution
Slide 9: Cottonseed oil
Cottonseed oil ED alt el cipal Off ice WINTER & SUMMER YELLOW OILS, SALAD, COOKING & MINERS OILS, COTTOLENE, A VEGETABLE COOKING FAT.
Slide 10: Chemistry of fatty acids
Chemistry of fatty acids Omega-6 fatty acids © Nina Teicholz
Slide 11: Hydrogenation
Hydrogenation © Nina Teicholz
Slide 12: Process of Hydrogenation
Process of Hydrogenation Pressure, heat, hexane (solvent) + a metal catalyst. Resulting rancid mixture must be steamed to eliminate bad odors, b, bleached to remove the gray color, “winterized” for stability and enhanced artificial colors and synthetic vitamins © Nina Teicholz
Slide 13: “BADE.EARE Jom cooxmeesan
“BADE.EARE Jom cooxmeesan 4935+ 227,704, Registeroa Jnty 24,1917, pass sary 2 Avuitontion tied Desomber 25, 1914, Borin we. 88,803, naar ese pogistere D4 SmaCaoae ‘70? To git whom it may concern, fh German bes bean contionozaly se eae | atten, Paciean peters yall abet Jon tee contents wane ee as Sap
Slide 14: The marketing of Crisco
The marketing of Crisco : pee. | Economical 4 a. ay ao > Digestible
Slide 15: Margarine
Margarine THE FINEST SPREAD FOR BREAD What the housewife should know about JELKE GOOD LUCK MARGARINE oefennd ™ Clemuigaine feial and banetia © Nina Teicholz
Slide 16: Vegetable cooking oils
Vegetable cooking oils © Nina Teicholz
Slide 17: American Heart Association recommends polyunsaturated oil to fight heart disease
1961: American Heart Association recommends polyunsaturated oil to fight heart disease © Nina Teicholz
Slide 18: AHA alliance with P&G
AHA alliance with P&G © Nina Teicholz
Slide 19: Procter & Gamble and the American Heart Association
Procter & Gamble and the American Heart Association 1948. $1,740,000, or 17 million in today’s dollars. “suddenly the coffers were filled…. It was the “bang of big bucks” that “launched” the group. Source: Big Fat Surprise, pp. 47-48 © Nina Teicholz
Slide 20: Polyunsaturated fats as medicine
Polyunsaturated fats as medicine © Nina Teicholz
Slide 21: Distributed free of charge to thousands of doctors
Distributed free of charge to thousands of doctors. Dr. Stamler thanks The Corn Products Co. and the Wesson Fund for Medical Research for “significant” research support. Stamler in an interview: “Scientists in public health must make alliances with industry…it’s tough. © Nina Teicholz
Slide 22: © Nina Teicholz
a, a, wo “%, = é 5 Ng : . = %e, - ¢ E % = Ye, = <é a So, 5 ty, oO %, <q % : % raid “< ; Yy, ® ts 2 % & 40 35 3 2 2 1 Aep sad swes6 © Nina Teicholz
Slide 23: Sources of omega-6 fatty acids in our diet
Sources of omega-6 fatty acids in our diet © Nina Teicholz
Slide 24: Changes in Fat Consumption in U.S.
Changes in Fat Consumption in U.S. 1909-1999 Source: Blasbalg et al, American©Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2011 Nina Teicholz
Slide 25: What are the health effects?
What are the health effects? © Nina Teicholz
Slide 26: In nearly a dozen of the "Core Trials" studies…
In nearly a dozen of the “Core Trials” studies… L.A. Veterans Trial NIH-funded Editors, “Diet and Atherosclerosis” 1969, 940 Oslo study Leren 1966, 88 “MRFIT” Trial NIH-funded Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial Research Group, Journal of the American Medical Association, 1982 © Nina Teicholz
Slide 27: Deaths from cancer
“Side effect” of death from cancer “L.A. Veteran’s Study” 35 30 Experimental Deaths from cancer 25 20 15 Cumulative carcinoma deaths in experimental 10 Control and control group from time of randomization 5 to time of death 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1 2 Years in Diet Phase Post Diet Phase Dayton, Seymour, Mor
Slide 28: Conclusion: vegetable oils did not present a public health challenge
Workshops: 1981, 1982, 1983, 1985 Conclusion: Vegetable oils … • did “not present a public health challenge” • did not “contradict” the more urgent, “commonsense” public health message for everyone to lower their cholesterol. Sources: multiple papers, see: Teicholz, N., The Big Fat Surprise, (Simon
Slide 29: Other possible health effects
Other possible health effects • Gallstones • 2x higher in the L.A. Veterans trial • Also found in cholesterol-lowering drug trial Source: Report from the Committee of Principal Investigators,” Heart 40, no. 10 (1978), 1069–1118 • Strokes • Japanese with low cholesterol (<180mg/dL) had 2-3 times high
Slide 30: Late 1970s-1990s: Partially hydrogenated soybean oils found to contain trans fats
Late 1970s-1990s: Partially hydrogenated soybean oils found to contain damaging trans fats Mary Enig, University of Fred Kummerow, University of Illinois Maryland © Nina Teicholz
Slide 31: FDA Bans Trans Fats, effective Jan, 2020
FDA Bans Trans Fats, effective Jan, 2020 © Nina Teicholz
Slide 32: What Replaces Trans Fats?
What Replaces Trans Fats? © Nina Teicholz
Slide 33: Basic instability of polyunsaturated fats
Basic instability of polyunsaturated fats © Nina Teicholz
Slide 34: Trans fat replacements
Trans fat replacements 1. Genetically modified soybeans 2. Sunflower oil © Nina Teicholz
Slide 35: Mainly: Back to Regular Oils (non-hydrogenated)
Mainly: Back to Regular Oils (non-hydrogenated) © Nina Teicholz
Slide 36: Toxic Oxidation Products
Toxic Oxidation Products © Nina Teicholz
Slide 37: Basic instability of polyunsaturated fats
Basic instability of polyunsaturated fats © Nina Teicholz
Slide 38: © Nina Teicholz
© Nina Teicholz
Slide 39: Toxic Substances Produced by Heated Oils
Toxic Substances Produced by Heated Oils Aldehydes ◦4-hydroxynonenal (HNE) ◦ HNEs are a formal marker for cancer ◦ “rapid cell death,” interfering with DNA and RNA and disturbing basic cell functioning ◦ extreme oxidative stress ◦ Implicated in neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer’s ◦Acrolein ◦
Slide 40: Hundreds of oxidation products are absorbed by food and into our bodies, brains
Hundreds of oxidation products are absorbed by food and into our bodies, brains Conclusion: Frequently consumed foods containing considerable amounts of HNE, a toxic aldehyde, may be a public health concern since HNE toxicity is related to a number of common pathological conditions. Source: Csallany
Slide 41: McDonald's used to fry their French fries in tallow
McDonald’s used to fry their French fries in….tallow © Nina Teicholz
Slide 42: Where to find summary of studies on inflammation, oxidation
Where to find summary of studies on inflammation, oxidation © Nina Teicholz
Slide 43: What we know and don't know about seed oils
What we know and don’t know about seed oils • Cancer •There is evidence from multiple RCTs showing that they cause cancer •Supported by mechanistic evidence (aldehydes) • Heart disease • Some support by the RCT evidence (Minnesota Survey, MARGARIN). • Strokes consistently higher in diets low in satu
Slide 44: What we know and don't know about seed oils
What we know and don’t know about seed oils • Gallstones—could be vegetable oils or low cholesterol • Obesity •Evidence from at least 3 RCTs (incl. MARGARIN Trial) • At least one mechanistic hypothesis (M. Eades) • Diabetes • Not supported by the RCT evidence (?) © Nina Teicholz
Slide 45: Take-away lessons about oils
Take-away lessons about oils • Avoid omega-6 polyunsaturated fats • For salad dressings, use olive or avocado oil • For cooking, use stable fats (lard, tallow, coconut oil, ghee, suet) • Avoid fried food in restaurants © Nina Teicholz
Slide 46: Thank you!
Thank you! Nina Teicholz Science journalist, Researcher Founder, The Nutrition Coalition @bigfatsurprise ninateicholz ninateicholz Unsettledscience.substack.com © Nina Teicholz