The Phoenix Companies — Phoenix Companies — Proxy Contest (April 2008)
38 slides from The Phoenix Companies's proxy contest presentation, Apr 11, 2008
Slide 1: Schedule 14A
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A PROXY STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SECTION 14(a) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ¨ Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy Statement ¨ Conf
Slide 2: Date Filed
(4) Date Filed:
Slide 3: Notice of slide deck use at meetings
Commencing on April 11, 2008, certain directors and members of senior management of The Phoenix Companies, Inc. will use the slide deck set forth below in connection with presentations at meetings: *****
Slide 4: Investor Briefing
* * * Investor Briefing * * * * * April 2008 * * * * *
Slide 5: Important Disclosures
Important Disclosures This presentation may contain forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 which, by their nature, are subject to risks and uncertainties. We intend for these forward-looking statements to be covered by the safe harbor pr
Slide 6: Agenda
Agenda • Profile and History of Phoenix • Value Creation Through Business Momentum • Oliver Press Campaign: Nothing New • Strong Governance Profile 2
Slide 7: Phoenix history and profile
Phoenix history and profile Profile • Life, Annuity and Asset Management business focus • $1.3 billion market capitalization History • PNX demutualization and IPO in June 2001 at share price of $17.50 • Difficult economic environment after September 11, 2001, compounded by concentrated equity market
Slide 8: Growing business with great potential
Growing business with great potential Actions taken to strengthen Phoenix Rebuilt balance sheet Recreated effective infrastructure for company - Established risk management framework - Rebuilt talent pool - Improved expense profile Reinvigorated growth engines of Life & Annuity business through stre
Slide 9: Rebuilt life company balance sheet
Rebuilt life company balance sheet PLIC Statutory Surplus + AVR • Increased statutory surplus while: $961.5 $1,040.7 { Supporting strong sales growth { Nearly $1 billion in cumulative annualized life premium { $2.4 billion in cumulative annuity deposits { Making $80.5 million in pension plan 2003 20
Slide 10: Life & Annuity business vibrant and growing
Life & Annuity business vibrant and growing • Successfully established partnerships with key Life Sales 36% insurance/annuity distributors Annualized Premium¹ $352 { State Farm $259 { National Life Group { Jefferson National $137 $117 { Brokerage General Agent channel $81 • Improved service and oper
Slide 11: Earnings and credit profile materially stronger
Earnings and credit profile materially stronger Operating Income Return on Equity $135.3 5.6% 5.0% $100.6 $87.1 4.2% 3.9% $78.9 3.0% $59.8 $(59.4) (2.9)% $(74.6) (3.5)% 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Net Income $(215.2) $(272.3) $(6.2) $86.4 $108.4 $99.9 $123.9
Slide 12: Rating agencies recognize our strength and prospects for growth
Rating agencies recognize our strength and prospects for growth Standard & Poor’s, April 7, 2008 The rating…reflects the company’s improving competitive position in the high-net-worth market, very strong operating company capital adequacy, strong liquidity, and improving operating performance. …Rest
Slide 13: Significant accomplishments in 2007
Significant accomplishments in 2007 Business Highlights Results • Extended State Farm contract to • Record operating income of $135.3 2016, five additional years million; 22% CAGR since 2003 • Entered BGA distribution channel • Record Life & Annuity pre-tax with strong results operating earnings of
Slide 14: Asset management stabilized and rebuilt
Asset management stabilized and rebuilt 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Significant • Purchased • Purchased • Purchased KAR • Harris Insight • 7 fund mergers restructuring Capital West Walnut minority minority interest funds adoption • 3 fund efforts undertaken minority interest • Purchased • 7 fund merger
Slide 15: The right time to spin off PXP
The right time to spin off PXP • PXP strategically well-positioned Multi-boutique asset manager; flexible with diverse investment and distribution capabilities Retail fund platform has broad, balanced product offerings, including high-quality sub-advisory relationships Strong investment performance
Slide 16: Illustrative impact of planned spin-off
Illustrative impact of planned spin-off Shareholders The Phoenix Companies, Inc. Asset Management SpinCo Aggregate Per Share¹ Book Value $1,693 $14.82 AUM $40.4 bn Operating Income² $134 $1.16 Revenues $203.2 Return on Equity 7.5% EBITDA³ $37 - $42 Phoenix figures reflect expected illustrative impac
Slide 17: Closed block: a significant opportunity for enhancing shareholder value
Closed block: a significant opportunity for enhancing shareholder value Closed Block Assets as a % • Created at time of demutualization to segregate of General Account Assets at IPO assets and liabilities of participating policyholders • Significantly larger structural constraint than other demutual
Slide 18: Closed block: a valuable asset to be deployed strategically
Closed block: a valuable asset to be deployed strategically Moody’s, May 2003 • Have continuously and actively assessed Phoenix recently announced that it will not implement a monetization opportunities since 2002 securitization of Phoenix Life’s closed block related assets at this time. While such
Slide 19: Opportunities to drive growth in earnings
Opportunities to drive growth in earnings Operational Excellence • Combines Lean and strict expense discipline to meet goal of providing high-quality products and services to customers and distribution partners, delivered cost effectively and with speed • 2008 Goal: $15-$20 million increase in pre-t
Slide 20: Key initiatives and goals
Key initiatives and goals 2008 2010 • Increase pre-tax operating earnings $15-$20 million through Operational Excellence - Building on operating expense • Double-digit ROE: 10% by 2010 reductions of $108 million from • Double-digit CAGR in operating EPS, 2004-2006 2008-10 • Continue to invest in Lif
Slide 21: Executive compensation
Executive compensation Compensation aligns with shareholder interests CEO Compensation • In 2003, Board established a pay-for-performance • 80% of targeted compensation through policy with overhaul of long-term and short-term plans performance-based incentives - Heavily weighted total comp to variab
Slide 22: Executive change in control practices
Executive change in control practices Source: Proxy Severance Severance Multiple Applied to 280G Retirement Benefit Company Year Multiples Base Pay Plus: Reimbursement Provision Enhancement Phoenix 2008 CEO: 3.0x Target annual incentive Modified gross-up CEO: 3.0 years Other NEOs: 2.5x (10% threshol
Slide 23: Impact of service on retirement benefits
Impact of service on retirement benefits $14 $12.8 • This graph illustrates the impact years of service has on the retirement benefit in the $12 Phoenix retirement plans in which the CEO participates $10 • If a hypothetical CEO had been hired on $8 January 1, 2003, at the same age and salary as Dona
Slide 24: The Oliver Press campaign: no new ideas
The Oliver Press campaign: no new ideas Oliver Press “proposals” lag PNX Board’s actions to enhance shareholder value Oliver Press Criticisms The Facts • Company should undertake a • PNX Board has reviewed, and continues to actively and “complete strategic review” thoroughly review, strategic and fi
Slide 25: Oliver Press criticisms mischaracterize facts
Oliver Press criticisms mischaracterize facts Oliver Press Criticisms The Facts • Phoenix cost structure is “out • We believe that the $90 million in expense reductions Oliver of step” with comparable Press has spoken about are unrealistic companies • Comparisons with companies with different produc
Slide 26: Oliver Press criticisms mischaracterize facts
Oliver Press criticisms mischaracterize facts Oliver Press Criticisms The Facts • “Since 2001 company has had no fewer • Mostly old news; only S&P has acted since April than 5 downgrades” 2005; recent S&P comments on “improving competitive position in the high-net-worth market, very strong operating
Slide 27: Adding risk to Phoenix's business
Adding risk to Phoenix’s business Oliver Press “proposals” seem to add risk to our business • State Farm { In 2007, 14% of PNX life sales and 62% of annuity deposits Relationships with { 5.1% owner of PNX stock, with long-term perspective Key { Publicly expressed concerns regarding Oliver Press’s di
Slide 28: Phoenix commitment to strong governance
Phoenix commitment to strong governance • 12 out of 13 directors are independent Independent • Lead independent director chairs Executive Committee, conducts all meetings of Oversight independent directors, can call a meeting of the Board • Independent directors meet without CEO • Five directors add
Slide 29: Phoenix directors: the right choice
Phoenix directors: the right choice Phoenix’s directors are actively involved in driving the business, have the support of major shareholders and are responsive to shareholder concerns • PNX directors have proactively undertaken initiatives to resolve performance and structural issues, the same init
Slide 30: Strong governance, board and lead director
Strong governance, board and lead director • Outstanding CGQ scores: 99% v. Russell 3000; 95% v. Insurance Peers • Board all independent except CEO; all independent key committees • Established governance principles • Lead director designated and elected by and from the independent directors with cl
Slide 31: Phoenix directors: deep experience, independence & continuity
Phoenix directors: deep experience, independence & continuity Alfiero Haire Johnson • Shares: 208,667 • Shares: 45,114 • Shares: 61,312 • Director since 1988 • Director since 1999 • Director since 2000 • Previous lead • Extensive media/ • Former Chairman/ Phoenix director internet expertise CEO Gree
Slide 32: Summary: "New blood" – Can it hurt?
Summary: “New blood” – Can it hurt? • Phoenix’s core life business is sensitive to the stability and strength of • Oliver Press has denigrated one of our the company – real and perceived. Distribution partners, independent largest shareholders and distribution agents and current and prospective poli
Slide 33: Vote Your Blue Proxy Card
Vote Your Blue Proxy Card Phoenix Directors Oliver Press Nominees Experience Constructive Strategic Plan Building Long- Term Value Disruption and Cost Increased Risk Extracting Short- Term Value 29
Slide 34: Appendix
Appendix Sy PHOENIX
Slide 35: Reconciliation of Income Measures
Reconciliation of Income Measures December 31, 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Total Operating Income (74.6) (59.4) 59.8 78.9 100.6 87.1 135.3 Net Realized Investment Gains (43.0) (39.3) 3.2 11.8 25.5 21.8 (8.9) Realized Gains (Losses) - Investments Pledged as Collateral Consolidated Under FIN 46
Slide 36: Reconciliation of Operating Income to EBITDA
Reconciliation of Operating Income to EBITDA December 31, 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Asset Management Pre-tax Operating Income (Loss) $ (8.7) $ 0.1 $ (10.5) $ (28.6) $ 7.4 Adjustments for: Intangible asset amortization and impairments 33.2 33.8 43.8 64.5 30.4 Depreciation 2.7 2.2 1.7 1.0 1.1 EBITDA $
Slide 37: Phoenix
Sy PHOENIX
Slide 38: Important Information Regarding the Solicitation and Participants Therein
IMPORTANT INFORMATION REGARDING THE SOLICITATION AND PARTICIPANTS THEREIN In connection with its 2008 Annual Meeting, The Phoenix Companies, Inc. has filed a definitive proxy statement, BLUE proxy card and other materials with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The Phoenix Companies, Inc.