Tri-Continental Corp · NYSE:TY
Tri-Continental — Proxy Contest (September 2006)
26 slides from Tri-Continental's proxy contest presentation, Sep 8, 2006
Slide 1: Tri-Continental Corporation
Tri-Continental Corporation September 2006
Slide 2: Tri-Continental
Tri-Continental I. Special Meeting II. Lipson’s Slate — The Wrong Choice I. Interests Not Aligned with Stockholders — Conflicted Loyalties II. A History of Misleading and Conflicting Statements III. Detrimental to Long-Term Stockholders III. Tri-Continental’s Slate — The Right Choice I. Improved Inv
Slide 3: Special Meeting: September 28, 2006
Special Meeting: September 28, 2006 1. Election of Three Directors 2. Amend Quorum Threshold
Slide 4: Lipson’s Slate — The Wrong Choice
Lipson’s Slate — The Wrong Choice Interests Not Aligned with Stockholders — Conflicted Loyalties A History of Misleading and Conflicting Statements Detrimental to Long-Term Stockholders
Slide 5: Interests Not Aligned with Stockholders — Conflicted Loyalties
Interests Not Aligned with Stockholders — Conflicted Loyalties Lipson’s hedge funds have 38% of their public equity securities invested in Tri-Continental Lipson’s hedge funds’ positions in Tri-Continental are hedged Actual Tri-Continental investment results are of little consequence to Lipson and h
Slide 6: A History of Misleading and Conflicting Statements
A History of Misleading and Conflicting Statements Mischaracterization of Seligman regulatory inquiry Misrepresents nature and length of Tri-Continental stock ownership Knowingly omits extensive prior financial services experience of William C. Morris, Chairman Now claims he does not intend to open-
Slide 7: Detrimental to Long-Term Stockholders
Detrimental to Long-Term Stockholders What are Lipson’s Actual Objectives? Additional Market Purchases? Self Tender Offers? Liquidating the Corporation? Open-ending the Corporation? Any of these actions would favor investors who currently plan to liquidate their shares to the detriment of continuing
Slide 8: Tri-Continental’s Slate — The Right Choice
Tri-Continental’s Slate — The Right Choice Improved Investment Results Addressing the Discount Quality and Integrity of Directors Responsive to Long-Term Stockholders A Vote of Confidence
Slide 9: Improved Investment Results
Improved Investment Results Investment Results as of August 31, 2006 Performance data quoted in this presentation represent past performance and does not guarantee or indicate future investment results. The rates of return will vary and the principal value of an investment will fluctuate. Shares, if
Slide 10: Improved Investment Results
Improved Investment Results Lead Portfolio Manager: John B. Cunningham Joined Tri-Continental in September 2004 Seligman’s Chief Investment Officer Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Former Group Head of Salomon Brothers Asset Management Equity Team Former Portfolio Manager for the highly regarded Sa
Slide 11: Improved Investment Results
Improved Investment Results The Investment Team: 90 Years of Combined Experience Sector Responsibility Industry Experience Title Senior Vice President Francis Fay Equity Trader Consumer Staples, Discretionary, Industrials, and Materials Vice President Edward Mehalick Security Analyst Consumer Staple
Slide 12: Addressing the Discount
Addressing the Discount Discounts are a well-known feature of closed-end funds Continuous consideration of alternatives to address the discount In depth annual discount review presented to Tri-Continental’s Board of Directors since 1994 Virtually all of Tri-Continental’s stockholders acquired their
Slide 13: Addressing the Discount
Addressing the Discount Steps taken that benefit all stockholders: Stock Repurchase Program since 1998 Investor Relations Program Founding member of the Closed-end Fund Association Ongoing marketing activities
Slide 14: Quality and Integrity of Directors
Quality and Integrity of Directors 75% of Directors are Independent (6 out of 8 currently) Highly Qualified Independent Directors with experience as: Chairman/CEO of Fortune 500 company Directors of multiple NYSE listed companies Dean of leading college Director, New York Regional Office, Federal Tr
Slide 15: Quality and Integrity of Directors
Quality and Integrity of Directors Nominees proposed by the Director Nominating Committee Extensive experience in investments and business General John R. Galvin: Independent TY director since 1995; Dean Emeritus o f Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy of Tufts University; Formerly Supreme Allied C
Slide 16: Quality and Integrity of Directors
Quality and Integrity of Directors Six regularly scheduled Board meetings each year (only four required by law) Recent ICI study shows 72% of funds have four regularly scheduled meetings Independent Board committees meet in executive session at each meeting Board Operations Committee Audit Committee
Slide 17: Quality and Integrity of Directors
Quality and Integrity of Directors Board Operations Committee All six Independent Directors Directs operation of the full Board In existence for 25 years Chaired by Frank A. McPherson, Lead Independent Director Audit Committee Four Independent Directors Oversight of financial reporting process Chair
Slide 18: Responsive to Long-Term Stockholders
Responsive to Long-Term Stockholders Closed-end fund structure has been fundamental to meeting the Fund's investment objective since 1929 Closed-end fund structure is necessary to maintain the Fund’s low expense ratio Improved investment results The Board has taken steps that benefit all stockholder
Slide 19: A Vote of Confidence
A Vote of Confidence Stockholders have voted to keep Tri-Continental’s closed-end structure on nine prior occasions (most recently in 1999) 63% of registered stockholders participate in one of Tri-Continental’s investment plans Multiple surveys of Tri-Continental stockholders over recent years shows
Slide 20: A Vote of Confidence
A Vote of Confidence In the May 2006 contested election, stockholders voted overwhelmingly to reelect Tri-Continental’s existing Directors
Slide 21: Amend Quorum Threshold
Amend Quorum Threshold Safeguards the Democratic Process Protects stockholder voting rights Promotes good corporate governance Lipson has a History of Subverting the Democratic Process Refused to cast votes in an attempt to deny a necessary quorum Disenfranchises other stockholders Impairs a corpora
Slide 22: Board Recommendations
Board Recommendations Proposal 1: FOR election of General John R. Galvin, Mr. William C. Morris and Ambassador Robert L. Shafer Proposal 2: FOR amendment of quorum threshold to one-third
Slide 23: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 24: History and Tradition
History and Tradition A closed-end investment company established in January 1929, by J. & W. Seligman & Co. One of the nation’s oldest and largest diversified equity closed-end funds with $2.5 billion in assets Listed on the New York Stock Exchange for 77 years (NYSE: TY) The average stockholder ha
Slide 25: Independent Directors
Independent Directors General John R. Galvin Independent TY director since 1995; Dean Emeritus of Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy of Tufts University; Formerly Supreme Allied Commander, NATO, and Commander-in-Chief, United States European Command; Formerly Director of Raytheon Co. and USLIFE Co
Slide 26: Independent Directors
Independent Directors Leroy C. Richie Counsel, Lewis & Munday, P.C.; Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Q Standards Worldwide, Inc.; Director, Kerr-McGee Corporation; Director, Infinity, Inc.; Director, Vibration Control Technologies, LLC; Lead Outside Director, Digital Ally Inc.; Director and Ch