Buffalo Wild Wings — Proxy Contest (April 2017)
23 slides from Buffalo Wild Wings's proxy contest presentation, Apr 27, 2017
Slide 1: 13-D Monitor Active-Passive Investor Summit April 2017
13-D MONITOR ACTIVE-PASSIVE INVESTOR SUMMIT APRIL 2017
Slide 2: Disclaimer
DisclAIMER The views expressed in this presentation (the “Presentation”) represent the opinions of Marcato Capital Management LP and/or certain affiliates (“Marcato”) and the investment funds it manages that hold shares in Buffalo Wild Wings, Inc. (the “Company”). This Presentation is for informatio
Slide 3: Certain information concerning the participants
Certain information concerning the participants Marcato International Master Fund Ltd. (“Marcato International”) and the other Participants (as defined below) have filed a preliminary proxy statement and an accompanying proxy card with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) to be used to
Slide 4: Buffalo Wild Wings (BWLD): a growing, distinctive restaurant brand
Buffalo Wild Wings (“BWLD”): a growing, distinctive restaurant brand Differentiated concept focused on “wings, beer, and sports” ~1,250 units with long-term potential to grow to 1,700 units in US & Canada and 400+ units internationally (~70% future unit growth) Consensus Estimates: 2017E EPS: ~$5.76
Slide 5: Why we invested in Buffalo Wild Wings
Why we invested in buffalo wild wings Differentiated concept with long runway for growth SSS declines, operational missteps, and poor capital allocation have hurt shares Opportunity to create substantial shareholder value by: Improving “4-wall” profitability and returns Transitioning to a 90%+ franc
Slide 6: Highlights from Marcato's Campaign
Highlights from Marcato’s Campaign
Slide 7: Same-store sales growth, traffic, and margins have all deteriorated
Same-store sales growth, traffic, and margins have all deteriorated SSS growth is at lowest levels in over a decade, due to deep & accelerating declines in traffic and mix Marcato believes “4-wall” margins have suffered due to expense mismanagement Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q4 2016 ‘13 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 2015 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q
Slide 8: When growth slowed, BWLD acquired franchised stores for high multiples
When growth slowed, BWLD acquired franchised stores for high multiples Total Acquisition Expense $33.7m $43.6m $4.3m $30.5 $205.2m # Units Acquired: 18 18 3 13 54 – – – 2 1 --Existing BWW --Existing R Taco – – – – 4 --BWW under Construction Estimated acquisition cost per restaurant | 2011 – 2016 Avg
Slide 9: BWLD's shares have underperformed against relevant benchmarks
BWLD’s shares have underperformed against relevant benchmarks Summary of shareholder returns “We believe the stock performance is compelling evidence of the effectiveness of the Board and management” -Buffalo Wild Wings Media Statement, 3/8/17 Source:Company filings, CapitalIQ. Market data as of 4/1
Slide 10: Marcato's key recommendations to BWLD
Marcato’s key recommendations to BWLD Improve “4-wall” Ebitda & returns Marcato recommendation: Target 90% mix by 2020; presentation articulates value creation from franchising BWLD management: Still working with advisors to determine optimal mix Over 2 months have passed since initial discussions;
Slide 11: Industry experts see multiple ways to improve margins
Industry experts see multiple ways to improve margins Source:Marcato’s presentation to BWLD management from June 2016, external consultants. A major consulting firm that evaluated BWLD at Marcato’s request identified several areas for potential margin improvement equivalent to 275 – 600bps Address F
Slide 12: BWLD's largest franchisee's 4-wall margins are materially higher
Wall Street Analyst: “[Franchisees] currently generate store margins that are up to 1000BP stronger than BWLD company stores” “[Franchisees] generate much stronger store margins even after paying royalties and advertising fees to BWLD corporate” –Jim Sanderson, Arthur Wood, 3/28/17 Source:Company fi
Slide 13: Highly franchised companies trade at higher multiples
Highly franchised companies trade at higher multiples 70+% mix = higher multiples BWLD is one of few “in the middle” BWLD’s growth would command a premium multiple if it were more highly franchised Source:Company filings, CapitalIQ. Market data as of 4/19/17. EBITDA multiples shown on an “NTM” basis
Slide 14: Industry-leading advisor says major refranchising is highly feasible
Industry-leading advisor says major refranchising is highly feasible Source:Marcato’s presentation at Sohn SF in October 2016. “We are highly confident BWLD could refranchise their owned stores at a multiple of 6.0x or higher and estimate a refranchising process to 90% could take as few as 18-24 mon
Slide 15: BWLD's stock price could rise by more than 2-3x under Marcato's proposal
We believe BWLD’s stock price could rise by more than 2-3x under marcato’s proposal Potential value creation for buffalo wild wings| 2016A – 2021E Source:Marcato’s June 2016 presentation to BWLD management. Market data as of 4/19/17. Note:Status quo case from June 2016 assumed no refranchising and n
Slide 16: Righting the Ship Requires New Leadership
Righting the Ship Requires New Leadership
Slide 17: BWLD management is not capable of executing
Let’s be clear: BWLD management is not capable of executing “4-Wall” profit margins lag largest franchisee International development targets have been missed & extended by 2-5 years Loyalty and Tablet Order & Pay still not fully rolled out, despite three years of planning and millions of dollars spe
Slide 18: Employees and franchisees offer proof that the business is being mis-managed
employees and franchisees offer proof that the business is being mis-managed Employees “Company retains a ‘small-company’ mentality that is lacking…structured corporate processes” “Buffalo Wild Wings senior management is taking the company down a path of no return” Franchisees “[M]y two supervisors
Slide 19: Insider open market transactions
Open Mkt. Transactions Sales Purchases Current + Recent Insiders 667 1 SENIOR MANAGEMENT Sally Smith 129 – James Schmidt 80 – Judith Shoulak 65 – TENURED DIRECTORS J. Oliver Maggard 48 – James Damian 16 – Michael Johnson – – Jerry Rose – – Cindy Davis – 1 RECENTLY-DEPARTED SENIOR MANAGEMENT Mary Twi
Slide 20: Top executives have unloaded 92% of shares granted
Sally Smith CEO & President James Schmidt COO Judith Shoulak EVP, N. America In aggregate, BWLD’s top executives have unloaded 92% of all shares they have been granted since IPO Does this behavior reflect alignment of interests with shareholders? Lee Patterson (EVP, North America) Shares sold as a p
Slide 21: A Culture of Complacency: Board has no oversight or accountability
NOMINATIONS SINCE IPO MEMBERS SINCE IPO A Culture of Complacency: Board appears to have no oversight or accountability over management This should be the slide showing Board Composition over time, and potentially committee composition: could have a timeline of all the Board members since the Company
Slide 22: Only one of BWLD's independent director nominees has worked at a restaurant
J. Oliver Maggard Only one of BWLD’s independent Director nominees has worked at a restaurant in the past decade Jerry Rose Cindy Davis Andre Fernandez Hal Lawton Harmit Singh Janice Fields Investment Banking Agribusiness Golf Media Big-Box Retail, eCommerce Apparel, Lodging, Restaurants Restaurants
Slide 23: Our nominees will make Buffalo Wild Wings a winning company again
Our nominees will make Buffalo Wild Wings a winning company again Sam Rovit Scott Bergren Lee Sanders Mick McGuire Prior Corporate Associations Roles and Expertise Former CEO of Pizza Hut’s Global Business Veteran Franchising, Marketing, & Operations Expert 20yrs. in Restaurant Supply Chain, Retail,