Bob Evans Farms — Proxy Contest (May 2014)
71 slides from Bob Evans Farms's proxy contest presentation, May 14, 2014
Slide 1: Investor Presentation
May 2014 (revised 5.14.14) Steve Davis, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Alan Ashworth, Interim Chief Financial Officer Scott Taggart, VP, Investor Relations Investor Presentation Exhibit 99.1
Slide 2: Safe Harbor Statement Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995
Safe Harbor Statement Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 Certain statements in this presentation that are not historical facts are forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements involve various important assumptions, risks and uncertainties. Actual results may differ
Slide 3: Important Additional Information
IMPORTANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The Company, its directors and certain of its executive officers are participants in the solicitation of stockholders in connection with the matters raised by Sandell Asset Management and its affiliates (“Sandell”). The Company may file a preliminary consent revocati
Slide 4: Growing Our Regional Brands into Powerful National Brands
GROWING OUR REGIONAL BRANDS INTO POWERFUL NATIONAL BRANDS “Discover farm-fresh goodness” “Come see what’s cooking” 5 191 60 16 21 3 51 31 39 8 23 3 17 7 4 48 Bob Evans Farms Investor Relations www.bobevans.com 8111 Smith’s Mill Road New Albany, Ohio 43054 2 COMPANY FACT SHEET FISCAL 2014 Q3 NASDAQ:
Slide 5: Powerful National Brands Make Our Regional Brands
BOB EVANS RESTAURANTS 6 Powerful NATIONAL BRANDS Make Our REGIONAL BRANDS BEF FOODS, INC. VISION
Slide 6: Business Segments (FY 2013)
Business Segments (FY 2013) 26% * 74% * * Excludes Mimi’s Café segment (sold 2-15-13)
Slide 7: Well-Positioned to Capture Both Grocery and Restaurant Consumption
Bob Evans is Well-Positioned to Capture Both Grocery and Restaurant Consumption $12 Billion+ (The value of a single share point) Source: IFMA Forecast & Outlook ‘82-’11 Percent Dollars Spent Over Time 35% 40% 45% 50% 55% 60% 65% Restaurant Grocery Technomic ‘12
Slide 8: Our Shareholder Value Creation Goal: Annual Diluted EPS Growth
Our Shareholder Value Creation Goal: 10 to 12 Percent Annual Diluted EPS Growth
Slide 9: Strategic Business Transformations
Strategic Business Transformations 10 Corporate Portfolio Management ERP Margin Innovation BEF Foods Side Dish Vertical Integration Network Optimization Transportation Consolidation Bob Evans Restaurants FFR 1.0 Completed 10-12 New Restaurants Annually 10-20 Bob Evans Express Units Annually
Slide 10: Key Components of 10-12% Long-Term Diluted EPS Growth Guidance
Key Components of 10-12% Long-Term Diluted EPS Growth Guidance Margin Innovation: (300-350 basis point improvement) workforce management food cost optimization FFR 2.0 side dish vertical integration implement Lean manufacturing w/side dish production transformational systems upgrades menu management
Slide 11: Strategic and Balanced Approach to Capital Allocation
INTERNAL FACTORS EXTERNAL FACTORS BOBE’S Strategic and Balanced Approach to Capital Allocation Drives Significant Shareholder Value Maximize flexibility Minimize financial risk Minimize cost of capital Maximize return to shareholders Minimize complexity DRIVE OPTIMAL CAPITAL STRUCTURE Between FY 200
Slide 12: A Track Record of Balanced Capital Allocation
A Track Record of Balanced Capital Allocation Dividends $270M $401M $110M Share Repurchases Debt Repayment $163M CapEx Fiscal 2008-2012 Fiscal 2013 Dividends $52M $30M Share Repurchases $124M Acquisition CapEx $63M
Slide 13: Weighted Average Diluted Shares Outstanding
Weighted Average Diluted Shares Outstanding (000’s) Ongoing Share Repurchase Programs have Reduced Diluted Shares Outstanding by 28% Since Fiscal 2007 Projected share count reduction of ~33% by FYE’14 36,484 33,315 30,744 30,890 30,422 29,781 28,094 26,377 25,000 27,000 29,000 31,000 33,000 35,000 3
Slide 14: Annual Dividend has Doubled Over the Last Five Years
Annual Dividend has Doubled Over the Last Five Years Current yield (4/7/14): BOBE – 2.6% S&P 500 – 2.0% $0.54 $0.56 $0.60 $0.68 $0.78 $0.95 $1.075 $1.205 FY 2007 FY 2008 FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014E
Slide 15: Transforming our Company and Rewarding Shareholders
Transforming our Company and Rewarding Shareholders $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 2014E 2015E ($ millions) Capital Expenditures Share Repurchases Since FY’07, annual capital expenditures have averaged nearly $90 million. $65 $64 $45 $41 $39 $81 $120 $85-$115 up to $100 $5 $69 $155 $225 $21 $19 $70 $63
Slide 16: Investing Efficiently with Prudent Debt Management
Investing Efficiently with Prudent Debt Management ($ millions) Capital Expenditures Restructuring/Rebuilding Transforming for Growth Note: excludes Mimi’s Café. Net Debt Since FY’07, net debt has averaged ~$178 million. $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $300 $45 $64 $65 $41 $39 $81 $120 $177 $276 $238 $17
Slide 17: Evolution of our Capital Allocation Strategy
Evolution of our Capital Allocation Strategy After significant capital investment in fiscal 2014 ($175-$200M), we expect to: increase free cash flow for share repurchase and dividend programs reduce annual capital expenditures to maintenance levels plus provision for future growth investments target
Slide 18: Evaluation of Debt Financing Alternatives
Evaluation of Debt Financing Alternatives Minimally restrictive Highly restrictive Low cost High cost Revolving Credit Facility Incremental Term Debt Secured Financing Unsecured Bonds Sale Leaseback
Slide 19: Target Leverage Ratio In-line with Other Restaurant Companies
Target Leverage Ratio In-line with Other Restaurant Companies Adjusted net debt peer average (ex-BOBE): 3.3 x PF FYE ‘14 Adjusted Leverage Benchmarking Analysis Note: Rent expense is capitalized at 8.0x.; LTM EBITDAR represents LTM EBITDA plus rent expense for the most recent fiscal year; balance sh
Slide 20: Mimi's Café Divestiture Improves Adjusted Operating Margin Profile
Mimi’s Café Divestiture Improves Adjusted Operating Margin 1 Profile BER: Severe winter weather - BER: FFR remodel costs - BEF: Supplier dispute - BEF: Plant startup inefficiencies - Corp: Mimi’s Café carryover costs - Corp: Strengthening internal controls - See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating
Slide 21: Key Drivers of FY'14 to FY'15 Margin Expansion
Key Drivers of FY’14 to FY’15 Margin Expansion Key FY ’15 Profit Drivers 1 BER • SSS: 3% to 3.5% (1% to 1.5% growth; 2%+ resulting from: lapping unusually severe winter weather and remodel closures, as well as expanding Thanksgiving Day hours of operation) • 8 to 10 new restaurants • 2014 costs not
Slide 22: Aggressively Managing Labor and G&A Costs
BENEFIT COST PER FULL TIME EQUIVALENT ($ 000’s) $20.6 $20.2 $19.0 $19.6 $19.6 $19.2 Aggressively Managing Labor and G&A Costs * * * *BOBE officers went without annual pay increases ($ millions) Source: Total Rewards Department, Bob Evans Farms, Inc. $10 million of annual overhead costs formerly allo
Slide 23: Farm Fresh Refresh Financial Impact Improves Free Cash Flow in FY2015
Farm Fresh Refresh Financial Impact Improves Free Cash Flow in FY2015 $0.0 -$1.1 -$2.5 -$3.0 -$1.6 -$3.4 -$3.8 * 40% sales flow-through assumed -$2.7 -$5.9 -$6.8 # of remodels Impact to P&L ($ millions) ** Includes incremental repair and maintenance expense associated with remodel construction. 4/25
Slide 24: Strategic Plant Network Optimization Leading to New Margin Trajectory
Strategic Plant Network Optimization Leading to a New Adjusted Operating Margin 1, 2 Trajectory at BEF Foods See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) in the Appendix of this presentation. For additional details concerning FY and FY guidance, see
Slide 25: 300-350 Basis Point Margin Improvement Backed by Past Productivity
300-350 Basis Point Margin Improvement Backed by Past Productivity Performance Sources of Recent Cost Savings Initiatives Reflect Enterprise-Wide Focus on Productivity supply chain cost of sales labor Categorization of cost savings initiatives reflects company estimates. Improvement 40bps 240bps 280
Slide 26: Transformations Drive Five-Year Adjusted Operating Margin Improvement
Transformations Drive Estimated Five-Year 300-350 Adjusted Operating Margin Basis Point Improvement 1 See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) in the Appendix of this presentation. For additional details concerning FY 2015 guidance, see the Compa
Slide 27: Come See What's Cooking
28 “Come see what’s cooking ” TM 562 restaurants in 19 states as of 1/24/14 Full-service family restaurants featuring a wide variety of menu items for both on-and-off premise dining
Slide 28: Overview: Bob Evans Restaurants
Overview: Bob Evans Restaurants * Excludes Mimi’s Café segment (sold 2-15-13) 33% 37% 30% Net Sales (FY 2013) $981 million (74% of total ) Average Annual Unit Sales (FY 2013) $1.74 million ALL THREE DAY PARTS SERVED (YTD 3Q FY 2014) Breakfast Lunch Dinner Avg. Dine-In Guest Check/Per Guest (3Q FY 20
Slide 29: Accelerated Farm Fresh Refresh Program
Accelerated Farm Fresh Refresh Program: Approximate % of Chain Remodeled by Fiscal Year CapEx Summary 44% 10% 22% - Completed April 2014 - (32 units) (87 units) (195 units) (230 units) Average capital investment per remodeled restaurant: ~$225k Dining Room & Lobby Restrooms Bakery, Catering & Carryo
Slide 30: Farm Fresh Refresh Transformation
Farm Fresh Refresh Transformation Old Exterior Old Interior New Interior New Exterior
Slide 31: Farm Fresh Refresh: Designed to Drive Dine-in and Off-Premise Sales
Farm Fresh Refresh: Designed to Drive Dine-in and Off-Premise Sales New Counter Expanded Dining Room New Bakery New Carryout
Slide 32: Aspirational Concepts Reimage their Brands to Remain Relevant
Aspirational Concepts Reimage their Brands to Remain Relevant Before After
Slide 33: Dine-In Value Sales Layers
Dine-In Value Sales Layers BREAKFAST Rise & Shine Breakfast of annual revenue. LUNCH $7.99 Knife & Fork and $6.99 Lunch Combos of annual revenue. DINNER 3-Course Dinners of annual revenue. ~ $70 million / 7% ~ $40 million / 4% ~ $70 million / 7%
Slide 34: Bold Goal: Drive Off-Premise to 25% of Sales Mix
Bold Goal: Drive Off-Premise to 25% of Sales Mix Growth % Bakery Family Meals to Go Catering/Carryout Off-Premise Sales Mix and Growth % by Year Sales Mix +8.6% +5.3% +8.5% +3.9% +0.6% +15.4% +12.9% +7.9% 8.0% 7.5% 6.5% 7.0% 8.5% 9.0% 9.5% 12.0% 11.5% 11.0% 10.5% 10.0%
Slide 35: Bob Evans' Off-Premise Opportunity
Bob Evans’ Off-Premise Opportunity Dine-In 39% Off-Premise 61% QSR 74% FULL SERVICE 15% 9% Annual Consumption of Restaurant Meals (per capita) Source: NPD Group - months ending 3/31/13 FAMILY SEGMENT
Slide 36: Off-Premise Sales Layers
Off-Premise Sales Layers CATERING FY 2013 Growth / Mix CARRYOUT FY 2013 Growth / Mix FY 2013 Growth / Mix BAKERY 20.4% / 0.5% 7.4% / 11.1% 30.5% / 1.4%
Slide 37: Digital Marketing Strategy
Digital Marketing Strategy Internal Sales Building Communications External Sales Building Communications
Slide 38: New Restaurant Opening Strategy
New Restaurant Opening Strategy New Albany, IN Altoona, PA NEW CONTIGUOUS MARKETS FILL-IN EXISTING MARKETS 4 new restaurants opened FY 2014. Open 8 to 10 new restaurants annually beginning FY 2015.
Slide 39: New Restaurant Prototype
New Restaurant Prototype: Brand relevant/lower investment Objectives: • • • 40 Accentuate Farm heritage Leverage Farm Fresh Refresh program insights Test new “back-of-the- house” technologies and layouts Reduced building cost by approximately 13% through efficient design in Finneytown, OH and Altoon
Slide 40: Bob Evans Express Licensing Opportunity
Bob Evans Express Licensing Opportunity • Partnering with AVI Food Systems, Inc. • Increases brand awareness in existing and new geographies and new venues • Popular favorites covering all day parts • High quality menu to ensure serving guests in a quick manner • Up to 10 new locations by the end of
Slide 41: FY 2014: Vital Few Priorities
Build bench strength and staffing to enable profitable expansion Drive profitable guest counts – dine-in and off-premise (bakery, carryout, and catering) Improve controllable expenses: Cost of Sales, Cost of Labor, Direct Operating Expenses Elevate the guest experience through execution of “Best for
Slide 42: Discover Farm-Fresh Goodness: Two Brands
“Discover farm-fresh goodness ” 43 TM TWO BRANDS distinct geographic strengths
Slide 43: Overview: BEF Foods
Overview: BEF Foods 29% 24% 39% 26% of total (excluding Mimi ’ s Caf é Segment) 14% 36% 29% 14% 7% FOUR KEY LINES OF BUSINESS Sausage, Refrigerated Side Dishes, Frozen and Food Service Sold at 30,000+ retail locations in 50 states and Mexico Side Dishes Other 3% Frozen 5% Food Service (5% insourced*
Slide 44: BEF Foods: Store/SKU Count
BEF Foods: Store/SKU Count Source: IRI # of stores 40,000 average SKUs per store 28,407 30,424 31,074 11.6 12.6 11.1 3Q13 3Q14 3Q13 3Q14
Slide 45: BEF Foods: SKU Count and ACV Distribution Core vs. Non-Core
BEF Foods: SKU Count and ACV Distribution Core vs. Non-Core CORE MARKETS NON-CORE MARKETS SKUs/Store ACV SKUs/Store ACV SKUs/Store ACV SKUs/Store ACV FY 10 FY14 Q3 FY 10 FY14 Q3 Opportunity in Non-Core Markets 23.5 20.5 7.5 8.5 75.6 81.1 65.8 68.1 SOURCE: IRI, FY14 Q3 - 13 weeks ending 1/26/14 Core
Slide 46: Sow Costs: Enterprise Risk
Sow Costs: Enterprise Risk (1) ~73% ~17% cost of goods sold ~10% Sales Volume impact A $1 change in average annual sow costs impacts cost of goods sold by approximately $1 million, allocated as detailed below. For additional detail concerning risks associated with sow costs, please refer to Item 1A,
Slide 47: Cumulative Sow Cost Impact on BEF's P&L
~$64 Million Cumulative Sow Cost Impact on BEF’s P&L: Versus Fiscal 2009 Average Sow Cost of $44.93/cwt $ avg cost/cwt $71+ $53.87 $42.18 $61.58 $57.17 ($ 000’s) ~$64 million cumulative annual cost impact relative to sow price levels. NOTE: daily sow cost information available at: http://www.ams.usd
Slide 48: Continued Impact of the PED Virus Drove Higher Sow Cost Guidance
The Continued Impact of the PED Virus Drove Higher Sow Cost Guidance $65-$70/cwt (issued 8/19/13) $60-$65/cwt (issued 6/4/13) $72-$77/cwt (issued 1/21/14) BOBE Guidance through 4/3 USDA Bob Evans
Slide 49: Sow Cost: Nearly 200K Head Purchased in Fiscal 2013
Sow Cost: Nearly 200K Head Purchased in Fiscal 2013 Fiscal 2013 Quarterly Sow Purchases (% of annual purchases) A $1 change in average annual sow costs is estimated to impact annual operating profit by approximately $1 million. NOTE: daily sow cost information available at: http://www.ams.usda.gov/m
Slide 50: Publicly Available Sow Cost Pricing and Livestock Commentary
Publicly Available Sow Cost Pricing and Livestock Commentary (1) daily sow cost report: http://www.ams.usda.gov/mnreports/lm_hg230.txt daily livestock commentary: http://www.dailylivestockreport.com / Information provided by external entities. Bob Evans Farms Inc. disclaims any and all responsibilit
Slide 51: BEF Foods Inc. Network Optimization
BEF Foods Inc. Network Optimization Galva, IL Bidwell, OH Springfield, OH – Plant and distribution center Richardson, TX Xenia, OH Sulphur Springs, TX SWH Fullerton, CA Hillsdale, MI Lima, OH 9 Facilities, 2 co-packers 50% Vertical Integration Hillsdale, MI Xenia, OH Lima, OH Sulphur Springs, TX Ass
Slide 52: BEF Foods' Transformation Offset Estimated Sow Cost Impact
BEF Foods’ Transformation Offset +$25MM Estimated Sow Cost Impact in Fiscal 2014 & 2015 Adjusted Operating Income ($ millions) 1, 2 Avg Sow Cost $44.93 $61.58 $53.87 Est. Sow cost impact vs 2009 ($ millions) $17 $9 $26+ $25 See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (non-GAAP) to Reported Opera
Slide 53: BER and BEF: Synergies Drive Value Across Multiple Dimensions
BER and BEF: Synergies Drive Value Across Multiple Dimensions Brand and Advertising Synergies Product Innovation Supply Chain Savings Food Service Credibility/Expansion Margin Expansion at BER and BEF Restaurant Operational Efficiencies G&A Leverage
Slide 54: FY 2014: Vital Few Priorities
FY 2014: Vital Few Priorities Expand “in-source” supplier relationships for the restaurant segments and the food service industry Drive sales through new authorizations and geographic expansion Drive margin expansion through Lean efficiencies Optimize our plant and distribution network Drive best-in
Slide 55: Adjusted G&A In-line with Restaurant Peers
Bob Evans Farms, Inc.: Adjusted G&A In-line with Restaurant Peers BEF Transportation (13,624) BEF Advertising and Marketing (4,896) BEF (Adjusted) 29,421 Total BOBE G&A (ex-BEF adjustments) 87,404 8.7% Bob Evans G&A Reconciliation - Q3 YTD FY2014 ($ 000's) Non-GAAP SG&A (1) % of sales Total BOBE SG&
Slide 56: Management and the Board are Aligned with Shareholders
Management and the Board are Aligned with Shareholders 912,917 shares beneficially owned or held in deferred compensation plans by directors and officers Collective ownership interest places these directors and officers well within the “top ten” of all Company shareholders Represents approximately 2
Slide 57: es Bot Grane.
es Bot Grane.
Slide 58: Board Composition and Governance Track Record
Board Composition and Governance Track Record • Board Composition, Skills and Tenure • Governance Ranking • Peer Group Comparisons
Slide 59: Bob Evans Farms, Inc. Board of Directors
Bob Evans Farms, Inc. Board of Directors Pre - FY2007 FY2007 - Present • Elected 2007. Managing Director, Major Lindsey & Africa. • Previously Chief Legal Officer and EVP, Cardinal Health, Inc. (revenue: $93.6B) • Skillset: legal and regulatory matters, healthcare, human resources, leadership develo
Slide 60: Strong Corporate Governance is a Priority at Bob Evans Farms
Strong Corporate Governance is a Priority at Bob Evans Farms ISS Overall Governance Quickscore versus Selected Peers¹ • Institutional Shareholder Services (“ISS”) has awarded Bob Evans’ overall corporate governance the highest possible score per QuickScore rankings. • Highlights include superior sha
Slide 61: Strong Balance Sheet Enables Above-Average Returns of Capital
BOBE’s Strong Balance Sheet Enables Above- Average Returns of Capital 14% 13% 3% 2% 15% 21% 18% 5% 8% 11% 21% 9% 19% 35% 54% 54% 67% 93% Return of Capital by Casual Dining Companies Dividends Net Share Repurchase (c) Source: FactSet and company filings. (a) Payout ratio calculated as a percentage of
Slide 62: Valuation Relative to other Restaurant and Branded Protein Companies
BOBE’s Valuation Relative to other Restaurant and Branded Protein Companies: EV/CY 2014E EBITDA Differentiated Mature Casual Family Dining Other Mature Casual Branded Protein Mean: 9.6x Mean: 9.3x Mean: 9.2x Mean: 9.1x Source: Company filings and FactSet as of 2/14/14. 9.2x 10.3x 9.4x 9.0x 9.8x 9.4x
Slide 63: Over $125 Million of Strategic Asset Dispositions
Over $125 Million of Strategic Asset Dispositions • Consolidation of Three Home Office Locations into One State-of-the-Art Facility • Business Dispositions • Restaurant Closures • Plant Closures/Consolidations • Real Estate Sales and Disposals • Business Transformations • DSD to warehouse conversion
Slide 64: New Corporate Campus Consolidates Three Former Locations Into One
New Corporate Campus Consolidates Three Former Locations Into One (acquired 2004) (acquired 1987) New Corporate HQ New Albany, Ohio (constructed 2013) (constructed 1968) Mimi’s Café Divisional HQ: Irvine, California Owens Sausage Divisional HQ: Richardson, Texas Previous Corporate HQ: Columbus, Ohio
Slide 65: Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions
Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions: Every business segment subject to review every quarter. Bob Evans Restaurants Corporate Bob Evans Restaurants Bob Evans Restaurants Bob Evans Restaurants Bob Evans Restaurants Bob Evans Restaurants Corporate Corporate: Disposals/divestitures to improve margin
Slide 66: Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions (continued)
Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions: $125M+ since FY 2006 Every business segment subject to review every quarter. Bob Evans Restaurants Bob Evans Restaurants Corporate Bob Evans Restaurants Corporate Bob Evans Restaurants Close underperforming locations to improve local market performance and re
Slide 67: Additional Information
Additional Information • ERP Implementation Schedule • Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Slide 68: ERP Implementation Schedule
ERP Implementation Schedule Fiscal Yr. Key Actions $ millions Capex Expense Benefits - RFP Completed & Software Purchased - Team Formulation (3.8) (1.0) 0.0 - Project Planning and Scoping Defined Corporate: Financials Design (8.3) (3.4) 0.0 Foods: Manufacturing and Supply Chain Design Corporate: Fin
Slide 69: Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café GAAP Segments as reported Net Sales 1,608,909 $ 981,418 $ 348,808 $ 278,683 $ 1,654,413 $ 973,6
Slide 70: Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) ($ thousands) Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café Consolidated Restaurant Foods Café Non-GAAP Adjustments Net Sales (19,968) (19,968) (6,985) (5,086) (1,899) Cost of s
Slide 71: Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) 2009 BEF Foods’ (formerly “Food Products”) Operating Income Reconciliation Fiscal 2009 BEF reported operating income (GAAP) $15,571 Non-GAAP adjustment: Other operating expenses Fiscal 2009 BEF reported operat