Avalara — Proxy Contest (September 2022)
16 slides from Avalara's proxy contest presentation, Sep 28, 2022
Slide 1: Investor Presentation September 2022
INVESTOR PRESENTATION ntation Rein peniembe 2022 Zi.\\ = Altair US, LLC AVALARA, INC. (NYSE: AVLR)
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer CERTAIN INFORMATION CONCERNING THE PARTICIPANTS In connection with the proposed acquisition of Avalara, Inc. (the “Company”) (NYSE: AVLR) by affiliates of Vista Equity Partners Management, LLC (the “Merger’), the Company entered into an Agreement and Plan of Merger, dated as of August 8,
Slide 3: Executive Summary
Executive Summary = Avalara’s September 23, 2022 investor presentation reinforces our belief that the Board chose the wrong time to sell, oversaw a flawed sale process and endorsed an inadequate price = The tone of the investor presentation is in stark contrast to the optimism of the Company’s Analy
Slide 4: Avalara's Presentation Is a Dramatic Change of Tone from Analyst Day
Avalara’s Presentation Is a Dramatic Change of Tone from Analyst Day What Avalara Said Three Months Ago What Avalara Is Claiming Now 5 Why Avalara is a special company Clear, unified vision tobe par of every transaction in the world $93.50 % ternational rbd —y/ ee trough 203 per share Required US. G
Slide 5: We Believe Avalara Is Misrepresenting the Strength of Customer Demand
We Believe Avalara Is Misrepresenting the Strength of Customer Demand What Avalara Said Three Months Ago Strong core customer growth Core Customers by Segment Core Customer TTM Revenue Average TTM Revenue er Core Customer = 9 soe P om | se fl - $24 - alll Mil ll il | | “[Wle have had meaningful grow
Slide 6: Avalara Has Touted the Resilience of Its Business to Macro Factors
Avalara Has Touted the Resilience of Its Business to Macro Factors » Most compliance products fluctuate minimally with economic activity » Calculation products are insulated from economic activity because of our wide tiered pricing bands and compliance management products “Our business model has pro
Slide 7: Avalara Remains a Fundamentally Strong Business
Avalara Remains a Fundamentally Strong Business We do not believe a $500,000 revenue “miss” in one quarter has any bearing on Avalara’s ability to realize long-term value enging macroenvironment and high int aan A Avalara © Avalara Revenue Projections‘ 1 Tne led Ree Mule Sic Ane’ Po Lt Ta Da Pot cl
Slide 8: Avalara Appears to Be Manipulating the Data to Manufacture a "Premium"
Avalara Appears to Be Manipulating the Data to Manufacture a “Premium” We believe the “premium multiple” touted by Avalara’s Board is illusory and based on a fundamentally flawed analysis ‘an pe aaa) ia lea and ete myetes tO Avalara @ Illustrative EV/NTM Revenue Multiples with an Appropriate Control
Slide 9: Avalara Appears to Present an Inaccurate Revenue Multiple
Avalara Appears to Present an Inaccurate Revenue Multiple Avalara appears to be using an inaccurate revenue multiple. Based on our calculations (shown below), the Total Transaction Value / NTM EBITDA is 8.2x," ‘) not 8.8x, as Avalara optimistically states. (If the deal were truly at 8.8x, the value
Slide 10: Avalara Appears to Be Applying the Wrong Price to Its Post-Earnings Premium Analysis
Avalara Appears to Be Applying the Wrong Price to Its Post-Earnings Premium Analysis Even if Avalara’s stock had declined 10% after Q2 earnings, the Vista premium would still have been underwhelming, in our view jple and premium would be even higher if potent ee ee Avalara Illustrative Transaction P
Slide 11: In Our View, Avalara Overstates the Independence of Its Board
In Our View, Avalara Overstates the Independence of Its Board Avalara appears to count as “independent” two directors with longstanding relationships with Vista, its principals and its portfolio companies Marcela Martin serves on the Board of a Vista-controlled company, Cvent, with four other Vista
Slide 12: Avalara Appears to Misrepresent a Process with Limited Competitive Tension
12 Avalara Appears to Misrepresent a Process with Limited Competitive Tension an a robust 3 Avalara © ® © © Of the 7 parties involved in Goldman's “initial outreach,” 5 appear to have proactively and independently reached out to Avalara expressing an interest in the Company’ The 8 party appears to h
Slide 13: In Our View, Avalara's Board Did Not Negotiate "Heavily"; It Caved
In Our View, Avalara’s Board Did Not Negotiate “Heavily”; It Caved Avalara attempts to depict Party A as a genuine competitor to Vista, but Party A never submitted a final bid; by July 12, Vista was the only party left in the process Avalara heavily negotiated to ma tential shareholder value Avalara
Slide 14: Avalara's Claim That a Majority of Analysts Support the Deal is Misleading
Avalara’s Claim That a Majority of Analysts Support the Deal is Misleading ent, majority of endorsec puenecsarthed évalara This selective quote merely states that another offer is unlikely @ William Blair's full remarks on the deal, which Avalara omits, were: “Given Avalara’s leading position in the
Slide 15: Conclusion
15 Conclusion We remain convinced that Avalara is a fundamentally strong business with excellent long-term growth prospects Despite the Company’s near-term challenges — several of which seem to have been introduced for the first time in its recent investor presentation — we believe Avalara is well-p
Slide 16: Contact Information
Contact Information CKENZIE Shareholders Call Toll-Free: (800) 322-2885 Email: proxy@mackenziepartners.com PARTNERS, INC. 16 Altair US, LLC