Oak Hill Financial — Merger or Acquisition (July 2007)
18 slides from Oak Hill Financial's merger presentation, Jul 20, 2007

Slide 1: Strategic Expansion into Ohio Markets
July 20, 2007 & "Strategic Expansion into Ohio Markets"

Slide 2: Forward Looking Statements
Forward Looking Statements Forward looking statements in this presentation relating to WesBanco's plans, strategies, objectives, expectations, intentions and adequacy of resources, are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. The informatio

Slide 3: Introductions
James C. Gardill Chairman Paul M. Limbert President & CEO John D. Kidd Chairman Ralph E. Coffman, Jr. President & CEO Robert H. Young EVP, Chief Financial Officer Introductions

Slide 4: Combination Highlights
Combination Highlights Doubles WesBanco's Ohio Market Share Assists in developing existing markets Enhances Growth Profile of WesBanco's Footprint Financially Attractive Common Cultures Provides Additional Revenue Growth Opportunities

Slide 5: Transaction Summary
ransaction Summary Indicated Price Per Share: $38.00 per share Transaction Value $208 million Consideration Mix: 90% stock / 10% cash Exchange Ratio 1.256 WSBC shares for each OAKF share Cost Savings $7.2 million pre-tax (approximately 22.0% of OAKF projected 2007 non-interest expense base) Four 4)

Slide 6: Pricing Consistent with Recent Transactions
Pricing Consistent with Recent Transactions Source: SNL Financial and company filings Comparable transactions do not include merger of equals (1) OAKF LTM earnings as of 6/30/2007 (2) Forward 2008 earnings estimates per First Call median of $2.15 (3) Excludes CDs greater than $100,000 (4) Based on O

Slide 7: Oak Hill Financial, Inc. Overview
Oak Hill Financial, Inc. Overview Founded in 1902 Headquartered in Jackson, OH Assets of $1.3 billion Business lines: Community Banking, Insurance, Title Services

Slide 8: Oak Hill Financial, Inc. Overview: Markets and Financial Highlights
Markets 36 branches over 15 counties Central and Southern Ohio Key Counties (1) : Jackson, Scioto, Lawrence, Hamilton Financial Highlights (2) Net Loans ($M) Deposits ($M) ROAA: ROAE: NPAs/Assets: Reserves / Loans: NCO's / Avg. Loans: Tang. Equity / Tang. Assets: Oak Hill Financial, Inc. Overview (1

Slide 9: Transaction Rationale
Transaction Rationale Top 15 deposit market share in Ohio 51% of pro forma deposits located in Ohio Connects and fills the geographic gap in WesBanco's branch network Doubles presence in growth markets Significant increase in metropolitan deposit composition Increased scale enhances lending capabili

Slide 10: Creates a Powerful Community Bank Franchise
Creates a Powerful Community Bank Franchise Pro Forma Financial Highlights Assets: Deposits: Branches: $ 5.6 Billion $ 4.1 Billion 114 Source: Microsoft MapPoint and SNL Financial

Slide 11: Significant Market Share Gain
Significant Market Share Gain Source: SNL Financial Deposit data as of June 30, 2006; pro forma for pending acquisitions

Slide 12: Deposit Composition By State
West Virginia Ohio Pennsylvania East 1906737 1013741 49318 Deposit Composition By State WesBanco Pro Forma Pennsylvania Ohio West Virginia Source: SNL Financial

Slide 13: Financial Impact - Overview
Financial Impact - Overview Extensive due diligence completed Achievable cost savings identified Revenue opportunities identified but not assumed Commercial Banking Insurance Wealth Management and Trust Services Title Services

Slide 14: Sale of Criticized Loan Portfolio
As part of the transaction, the companies anticipate selling approximately $50 million in identified loans. After the sale, Oak Hill non-performing assets will equal $2.65 million or 0.21% of total assets, as compared to $16.56 million or 1.29% of total assets before the sale.(1) WesBanco has incorp

Slide 15: Financial Impact - Per Share
Financial Impact - Per Share (1) Based on First Call estimate of $2.10 per share and 8% EPS growth thereafter (2) Based on First Call estimate of $2.15 less income from sale of $50 million in loans and 8% EPS growth thereafter; eliminates Oak Hill's existing CDI amortization (3) Based on pre-tax cos

Slide 16: Capital Impact
Capital Impact 6.60 % 8.47 10.36 11.58 6.09 % 8.39 10.62 11.62 6.81 % 9.21 11.98 13.07 WSBC (1) OAKF (2) Estimated Pro Forma At 12/31/2007 Tangible Equity / Tangible Assets Leverage Ratio Tier I Capital Total Capital Capital Ratios (1) WSBC estimates as of 6/30/07 (2) OAKF estimates as of 6/30/07

Slide 17: Low Execution Risk
Low Execution Risk Consistent with WesBanco's expansion strategy Common community banking philosophy and culture Shared expertise in commercial lending Proven track-record integrating acquisitions Key Oak Hill management to be retained

Slide 18: Additional Information
Additional Information Shareholders of WesBanco and Oak Hill and other interested parties are urged to read the joint proxy statements/prospectus that will be included in the Form S-4 registration statement that WesBanco will file with the SEC in connection with the merger because it will contain im
Source: SEC EDGAR · 425 filed Jul 20, 2007