UL Solutions Inc. · NYSE:ULS
UL Solutions — Technical Presentation (June 2011)
35 slides from UL Solutions's technical presentation, Jun 9, 2011
Slide 1: IEC 61508 2nd Edition: Get Educated. Get Compliant
IEC 61508 2nd Edition: Get Educated. Get Compliant Welcome to the Webinar! Thursday June 9, 2011 11 am - noon Pacific noon - 1 pm Mountain 1 pm - 2 pm Central 2 pm - 3 pm Eastern Moderator: Lori Dearman, Webattract Kevin Connelly Thomas Maier UL Industry Manager UL Principal Engineer Power & Control
Slide 2: Featured Speaker
Featured Speaker Kevin Connelly UL Industry Manager Power & Controls, Functional Safety
Slide 3: Why are these changes important?
Why are these changes important? Changes provide benefits throughout the supply chain
Slide 4: Why are these changes important?
Why are these changes important? Component Manufacturer now have formal requirements for sensors, ICs or Software.
Slide 5: Why are these changes important?
Why are these changes important? Subsystem level will have more internal transparency and therefore better management of the product lifecycle.
Slide 6: Why are these changes important?
Why are these changes important? Now going to have a formal methodology for ASICs and FPGA
Slide 7: Why are these changes important?
Why are these changes important? End Users are going to have higher level of confidence.
Slide 8: Featured Speaker
Featured Speaker • Changes in summary • Increased focus on traceability • The concepts of elements and compliant items • Redundant channels in a single integrated circuit • Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) • Increased focus on EMC Thomas Maier UL Principal Engineer Functional Safety
Slide 9: In Summary
In Summary To better reflect and formalize how the standard mostly has been used To strengthen and clarify weakly or implicitly formulated requirements and loose ends
Slide 10: Increased focus on traceability
increased focus on traceability
Slide 11: Increased focus on traceability
Increased focus on traceability 1st edition: From a formal perspective, the requirement for full traceability already existed in the 1st edition: • As of tables B.2 and B.6, traceability can be considered ”highly recommended” for SIL3. • Part 3 of 1st edition explicitely required traceability betwee
Slide 12: Traceability and Construction of Safety Case
Traceability and Construction of Safety Case Implementing, refining Hazards and System Safety Validation test risks Requirements case and result HW safety Requirements Integration test Functional case and result failure modes SW safety Requirements SW qualifi. Test HW Block case and result Addressin
Slide 13: Traceability and Change Management
Traceability and Change Management Support of Impact Analysis for Complex Systems: System System System System SR1 SR2 SR3 SR4 SW SW SW SW SW HW HW HW SR1 SR2 SR3 SR4 SR5 SR1 SR2 SR3 SW SW SW SW SW SW HW HW HW HW Fct1 Fct2 Fct3 Fct4 Fct5 Fct6 Bl1 Bl2 Bl3 Bl4 SW SW SW SW SW SW HW HW HW HW HW loc1 loc
Slide 14: The concepts of elements and compliant items
the concepts of elements and compliant items
Slide 15: Elements and Compliant Items
Elements and Compliant Items E/E/PES consist of subystems, subsystems consist of elements: Subsystem (data communication) Subsystem Subsystem (sensors) (actuators) Elements Subsystem (logic unit) IEC 61508-4, Figure 3 ”Subsystem” and ”element” are defined now in the 2nd edition of IEC 61508.
Slide 16: Elements and Compliant Items
Elements and Compliant Items Design requirements in the 2nd Ed. are very much built around the element concept. • Safe Failure Fraction, Systematic capability, are element properties • The subsystem is built by combining elements Elements can comprise hardware only, hardware and software combined, s
Slide 17: Safety manual for compliant items
Safety manual for compliant items Any item within the system hierarchy defined by IEC 61508:2010 can be a compliant item • Software components (e.g. RTOS, communication protocol stack) • Integrated circuits (microcontrollers, ASICs, FPGAs) A compliant item must be accompanied by a safety manual The
Slide 18: Redundant channels in a single integrated circuit
redundant channels in a single integrated circuit
Slide 19: On-chip redundancy
On-chip redundancy Channel 1 Channel 2 Trends: Multi-core processors and FPGA increasingly used Natural questions: • Why wouldn’t one multi-core SoC not implement multiple safety-related channels? This was up to now not allowed, had to be considered as one physical channel: • Electrical coupling, fo
Slide 20: IEC 61508-2 2nd Ed, Annex E
IEC 61508-2 2nd Ed, Annex E: How to realize physical redundancy on one single IC substrate Architectural requirements Separate physical blocks on substratum for each channel and each monitoring element such as a watchdog. • DC requirements for diagnostic elements, if only implemented once: 60%! Each
Slide 21: IEC 61508-2 2nd Ed, Annex E
IEC 61508-2 2nd Ed, Annex E: How to realise physical redundancy on one single IC substrate Safey integrity limitations • Highest SIL that can be claimed is SIL 3 • Systematic capability cannot be increased by combination of elements Layout requirements • Separation of channels is achieved by • Incre
Slide 22: Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs)
field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs)
Slide 23: Development of ASIC's and FPGA's
Development of ASIC’s and FPGA’s IEC 61508:2010 recognizes the similarity between complex IC development and software development. As a fundamental measure for fault avoidance, a more detailed lifecycle model is provided, in addition to the ”conventional” E/E/PES lifecycle: Source: IEC 61508-2:2010
Slide 24: Development of ASIC's and FPGA's
Development of ASIC’s and FPGA’s • Furthermore, IEC 61508-2:2010 refers to (informative) Annex F which provides techniques and measures to avoid the introduction faults in development of ASIC’s (and FPGA’s) Source: IEC 61508-2:2010
Slide 25: Increased focus on EMC
increased focus on EMC
Slide 26: Electromagnetic immunity
Electromagnetic immunity: Change from 1st to 2nd edition of IEC 61508 1st Edition IEC 61508-2 (in notes of clause 7.2.3.2) • Recognizes that SIL is a factor when determining immunity levels • Recognizes that it is difficult to determine the probability of immunity levels being exceeded • Recognizes
Slide 27: IEC/TS 61000-1-2
IEC/TS 61000-1-2 This standard is not only about EMC test – it is primarily about appropriate design • It is not feasible to demonstrate immunity by test only • Provides techniques and measures in Annex B The standard does recommend test against higher levels. • Even against low-probability very hig
Slide 28: IEC 61326-3-1: EMC Test Plan
IEC 61326-3-1: EMC Test Plan Configuration of EUT • Selection of most susceptible configurations and installations • Selection of I/O ports Operation conditions during test • representative ”worst-case” operation modes • EUT Software during test enables simulation of selected operation modes Perform
Slide 29: IEC 61326-3-1: Immunity Requirements
IEC 61326-3-1: Immunity Requirements Source: IEC 61326-3-1
Slide 30: Further Appreciated Changes
Further Appreciated Changes • New phase: System Requirements Specification, and new deliverables: system Safety requirements and System Design Requirements • Clearer definition of safe and dangerous failures (as related to SFF calculation) • Requirements for ”proven-in-use” and ”pre-existing softwar
Slide 31: Featured Speaker
Featured Speaker Kevin Connelly UL Industry Manager Power & Controls Functional Safety
Slide 32: Value add throughout the supply chain
Value add throughout the supply chain -Increased End User Safety -Access Technology Confidence in Ease of Technology System Integrator Elements Implementation Incorporated EMC Traceability Readily Use Subsystem Ensures Confidence Consistency Newer Technology EMC FPGA’s Element Traceability Complianc
Slide 33: Certification adds value through the supply chain
Certification adds value through the supply chain End User/System Integrator /Subsystem • Look for the UL Certification or Recognition Mark • UL mark will include the edition / date of publication
Slide 34: Getting Started
Getting Started For more information: Download UL's white paper on www.ul.com/functionalsafety To request a quote for the UL Functional Safety Mark: Contact: Kevin Connelly 1-631-546-2691 kevin.connelly@us.ul.com
Slide 35: Ask The Experts Panel
IEC 61508 2nd Edition: Get Educated. Get Compliant Ask The Experts Panel Moderator: Lori Dearman, Webinar Producer with Webattract Kevin Connelly UL Industry Manager Thomas Maier Power & Controls UL Principal Engineer Functional Safety Functional Safety For More Information: www.ul.com/functionalsaf