Willdan Group, Inc. · NASDAQ:WLDN

Willdan — League of California Cities Conference (2010)

31 slides from Willdan's conference presentation, 2010

  1. Slide 1: Underfunded Landscape and Lighting Districts - Balloting Considerations

    League of California Cities Conference UNDERFUNDED LANDSCAPE AND LIGHTING DISTRICTS - Balloting Considerations for New Assessments Habib Isaac; Catherine Lew; Tom Tait

  2. Slide 2: Introductions

    Introductions • Habib Isaac – Principal Consultant, Willdan Financial Services, Special Taxes / Assessments and Proposition 218 Consultant • Catherine Lew – President & CEO, Lew Edwards Group, Public Outreach and Education Consultant • Tom Tait – Public Works Director, City of Arcadia | 2

  3. Slide 3: Presentation Overview

    Presentation Overview • Background • Options • Assessment Principles • Assessment Structure • Assessment Implementation • Public Outreach • Notice and Ballots • Results • Conclusion | 3

  4. Slide 4: Discussion Point – Underfunded Districts

    Discussion Point – Underfunded Districts • Focus on landscaping, lighting assessments • Costs for maintenance of improvements increase each year • Changes to district or funding • Assessments being levied at maximum • Lack of inflators, no ability to increase • Budget stress limits ability for citie

  5. Slide 5: Discussion Point – Methodology & Structure

    Discussion Point – Methodology & Structure • Some assessment structures merit evaluation for compliance with recent court decisions/Prop 218 • Districts grew over time through development and annexations • Missing or incomplete documentation • Methodologies need to be reviewed and updated in light o

  6. Slide 6: Methodology and Structure - continued

    Methodology and Structure - continued • Districts with annexations may have potential benefit issues – property annexed in a way that creates inequities • Recent court decisions have complicated matters • Need to have well developed methodology • Assessment must be equitable | 6

  7. Slide 7: Legal Landscape

    Legal Landscape • Prop 218 around since 1996 – not new • Santa Clara case changed everything – – First Supreme Court Decision – New standard of review • Increased emphasis on separation of general benefit • Special benefits must be well defined and substantiated | 7

  8. Slide 8: More Legal Landscape

    More Legal Landscape • Examples of relevant recent cases: Buetz, Pomona, Tiburon, West Point • Good news – some guidance relative to methodology and approach (Tiburon, Pomona) • Not so good news – larger districts under increasing scrutiny • Carrying forward with old approach no longer works | 8

  9. Slide 9: Legend

    LEGEND [______] cry Bounpary [A Leven parcets Tettt E LEW EDWARDS

  10. Slide 10: City Boundary / Levied Parcels

    (JJ CITY BOUNDARY [oJ LEVIED PARCELS LEGEND

  11. Slide 11: Existing Lighting District

    Existing Lighting District pa | 1 i COST SHARE (%) } | ZONES CITY/OWNER Urea ZONE A | $ ZONE B “a DUA *, ZONE C a et) ZONE D || || ¢\ Zonee = pn = | UNZONED ean i lll). =< NO STREETLIGHTS f+ Existing district will expire in June 2010 es IW

  12. Slide 12: Existing Streetlight Funding

    Existing Streetlight Funding • Original assessment calculated as percentage of assessed value, based on 1919 Act – Issues for equity and revenue stability • Assessment had been in place for more than 50 years • Total annual streetlight maintenance costs exceed $1MM • Assessment generated approximate

  13. Slide 13: Considerations and Options

    Considerations and Options • Needed to implement a new stable revenue stream • Needed to convince property owners to approve • Understand policy and political framework • If no new funding – City would need to identify streetlight maintenance costs to eliminate • Limited control over energy costs –

  14. Slide 14: More Considerations and Options

    More Considerations and Options • Fund entire budget through General Fund – General Fund resources already limited – Must submit balanced budget – Revenue would be taken from other services – Public safety, library, street sweeping, etc. – Funding shortfall would simply be moved to another area • Es

  15. Slide 15: Funding Solutions Considered

    Funding Solutions Considered • Special Tax – Also dedicated – Some additional disclosure required – Requires 2/3rds approval or registered voters • Funding objectives – Fund entire maintenance budget amount – Continue same funding level, with some City assistance • Assessment structure – More equita

  16. Slide 16: Funding Solutions Considered

    Funding Solutions Considered • Assessment – Is dedicated revenue stream and not subject to fluctuation – Assessment already in place – terminology the same – Only affected property owners would cast ballots • i.e. property owners rather than registered voters – Simple majority (weighted by assessmen

  17. Slide 17: Assessment Principles

    Assessment Principles • Subject to provisions of State Law for specific type of assessment, and Prop. 218 (Constitution and Gov Code) • Identify and quantify special benefits vs. general benefits – General benefits cannot be funded through assessment • Determine amount of total budget that may be fu

  18. Slide 18: Legend

    Legend EL 2 Acosta city Boundary — hetorais ‘Avene wth No Lighting EBB Areas wth Sparse Ligntng HE zone (zone HR zones

  19. Slide 19: Assessments

    Assessments • Methodology based on special benefits that properties receive from services and improvements – Assessments must be proportional to benefits received – Assessments must not exceed any parcels proportional benefit • Two benefit zones established to fairly apportion costs – Properties tha

  20. Slide 20: Legend

    Legend [7] Accaaia city Boundary — aerials [ID Zone + -Artenal Parcels: [J] Zone 2 - Non Artenal Parcels ‘Aces with No Lighting ‘Aceas win Sparse Lightna

  21. Slide 21: Assessments

    Assessments • Arterial streets serve public at large as well as parcels being assessed – Meets definition of general benefit – General benefit calculated based on trip generations • Total budget: $1,019,595; General benefit: $214,661 • Authorized budget: $804,934 – Two benefit zones established to f

  22. Slide 22: Outreach and Messaging

    Outreach and Messaging • Well coordinated public outreach is critical component of a successful effort • Important to understand resident and property owner perceptions of the issue – and of city • Try to gauge potential level of support • Educate public about assessment balloting process • Educate

  23. Slide 23: Key Messages

    Key Messages • In Arcadia, we emphasized that this is NOT a new tax, but an update and extension of an existing local revenue source • Emphasized fairness and equity for all taxpayer property owners, including the City –which continued to pay a significant share of lighting costs. • Defined “what wa

  24. Slide 24: Key Public Information Activities and Collaterals

    Key Public Information Activities and Collaterals • Message Development • City/Internet Vehicles – City Website and Cable Scroll, “Hot Sheet” and Newsletter • Speakers’ Trainings and Speakers’ Bureau Presentations – Frequently Asked Questions – Sticky Qs/As – Power Point Presentation • Large Propert

  25. Slide 25: Arcadia's Local Citywide Lighting District

    Arcadia’s Local Citywide Lighting District IMPORTANT VOTING INFORMATION PLEASE NOTE: This is an issue that affects us locally and is not related to the recent California Statewide Primary election. Arcadia’s current local assessment for street lights will expire on June 30, 2010. How Do I Vote? Ball

  26. Slide 26: City of Arcadia Ballot Reminder Mailer

    City of Arcadia 240 W. Huntington Drive Arcadia, CA 91006 RETURN YOUR LOCAL LIGHTING ASSESSMENT BALLOT BY JULY 20TH! Arcadia’s Lighting Assessment District has been in place for 57 years — but funding to repair and maintain street lights will expire June 30, 2010. On June ist the Arcadia City Counci

  27. Slide 27: Assessment Formation

    Assessment Formation • Must provide Notice and Ballot to affected properties • Additional communication through: – News letters – Property owner workshops – Major stakeholder correspondence – Press releases – Web links • LEG harmonizes technical components with key messaging for all public outreach

  28. Slide 28: Due Diligence

    Due Diligence • Notice and Ballots must be mailed out at least 45 days prior to holding public hearing – Time period while ballots are out – No time to waste • Check with major stakeholders to confirm receipt of ballots • Establish process to send replacement ballots efficiently – New property owner

  29. Slide 29: Results

    Results • 16,597 assessment ballots mailed • 5,490 ballots returned (33%) • Simple majority required to implement assessment – 60% of returned assessments in favor (weighted by assessment) – No majority protest – Council approved assessment • Assessment will continue in perpetuity • Generate $428K i

  30. Slide 30: Conclusion

    Conclusion • City involvement • Technically sound • Key Messaging • Multiple media resources • Educate property owners on process • Due diligence • Holistic Approach | 30

  31. Slide 31: Contact Us

    Contact Us: • Habib Isaac: Principal Consultant, Willdan Financial Services, hisaac@willdan.com or 951-587-3574 • Catherine Lew, President/CEO, The Lew Edwards Group Catherine@lewedwardsgroup.com or 510-594-0224 • Tom Tait: Public Works Director, City of Arcadia ttait@ci.arcadia.ca.us or 626-305-138

Willdan Group — League of California Cities Conference (2010) on 6ix