PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (March 2019)
13 slides from PDC Energy's proxy contest presentation, Mar 7, 2019
Slide 1: A Path To Profitability
A Path To Profitability March 7, 2019
Slide 2: PDC Energy: Quality Assets Trapped in a Failing Structure
PDC Energy: Quality Assets Trapped in a Failing Structure • Kimmeridge believes PDC Energy owns and operates premier oil and gas assets. • Despite the underlying asset quality, PDC has consistently failed to generate a return on average capital employed (ROACE) that exceeds its weighted average cost
Slide 3: Consistently Poor ROACE vs Peers and vs the WACC
Consistently Poor ROACE vs Peers and vs the WACC • PDC’s ROACE over the past ten years has averaged 4% and has never been above 6%. This is materially lower than its WACC of 10.5%. • Elementary finance theory explains that investments should only be made if their expected return exceeds the cost of
Slide 4: Shareholder Returns are Depressed Due to Excessive G&A
Shareholder Returns are Depressed Due to Excessive G&A • The main driver of PDC’s bloated cost structure is overhead / SG&A. The company is near the top of the peer group on a per unit of production basis. • A telling metric is overhead per active rig running. PDC’s overhead in 2018 was 65% above th
Slide 5: Size and Scale
Size and Scale • Larger basin operators are able to achieve capital efficiency and cost savings through rig optimization, longer laterals, and lower service costs. PDC is not a major operator in either of its two basins, further diminishing returns on capital. Delaware Net Acres DJ Basin Net Acres 5
Slide 6: A History of Failing to Execute
A History of Failing to Execute • At the start of 2018, PDCE forecasted an outspend of less than $90 million for 2018. The actual result was nearly twice as high, with an outspend of $176 million despite materially higher commodity prices. February 2018 presentation 2018 Actuals vs. February 2018 Oi
Slide 7: PDC Energy: A Better Path
PDC Energy: A Better Path • Under Kimmeridge’s proposed plan, PDC would: – Develop a plan to return ROACE above the WACC at $50/bbl and $3/mcf. – Cut SG&A from ~20% of cashflow to industry leading levels. – Return cash to shareholders and implement a sustainable dividend. – Execute on the capital pr
Slide 8: The Kimmeridge Better Path
The Kimmeridge Better Path • PDC guidance for 2020 implies a ROACE below the cost of capital, further degrading equity value. • A better path for PDC is to implement aggressive controls on costs and spending. The company can and should return cash to shareholders, lower its capital employed, improve
Slide 9: Delivering ROACE above the WACC
Delivering ROACE above the WACC • PDC needs to build a path to meeting its WACC (10.5%) at $50/bbl oil and $3/mcf gas prices by lowering SG&A, improving operating performance, and delivering additional drilling efficiencies. • Over time, better capital allocation, lower capital costs and better oper
Slide 10: A New Board for a New Business Model
A New Board for a New Business Model • Kimmeridge is nominating three directors to stand for election at the Company’s 2019 annual meeting of shareholders. • Kimmeridge’s candidates have extensive experience as investors and asset owners. • Kimmeridge currently owns 5.1% of PDC. Kimmeridge has no he
Slide 11: Kimmeridge's Director Nominees
Kimmeridge’s Director Nominees Ben Dell is the founder of Kimmeridge where he leads the firm’s investment activities, including overseeing the screening and diligence of new geological opportunities as well as the negotiation and execution of investment strategies. In 2016, Mr. Dell led the sale of
Slide 12: Disclosures
Disclosures The views expressed in this presentation represent the opinions of Kimmeridge Energy Management Company, LLC and its principals and affiliates (Kimmeridge) including certain privately offered investment funds sponsored or advised by Kimmeridge that own shares of common stock of PDC Energ
Slide 13: Disclosures Continued
Disclosures Continued Custom peer group data presented in the chart on slide 3 was prepared by Kimmeridge using publicly available information for 75 publicly listed E&P companies chosen by Kimmeridge and is meant to be representative of the performance of the overall E&P industry (Broad Peer Group)