Meadowbrook Insurance Group Inc

Meadowbrook Insurance — Q4 2013 Earnings Presentation

31 slides from Meadowbrook Insurance's earnings presentation, Mar 4, 2014

  1. Slide 1: Investor Presentation Fourth Quarter 2013 Update

    Investor Presentation Fourth Quarter 2013 Update

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures

    MEADOWBROOK™ EES insurance Group Forward-Looking Statements & Non-GAAP Financial Measures This investor presentation may provide information including certain statements which constitute fonvard-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27Aof the Secunties Act of 1933, as amended, and Section

  3. Slide 3: Meadowbrook Overview

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Meadowbrook Overview Specialty niche focused commercial insurance underwriter and insurance administration services company Headquartered in Southfield, MI with 25 locations throughout the U.S. and ~954 employees Founded in 1955, organized as a holding company in 1985

  4. Slide 4: Meadowbrook Overview

    MEADOWBROOK™ Meadowbrook Overview A specialty, niche focused P&C carrier and insurance administration services company Balanced business model allows the Company to adaptto changing market conditions Product, program and geographic diversification E&S platform with industry leading technology capabi

  5. Slide 5: Meadowbrook Overview (continued) - Key Statistics

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Meadowbrook Overview(continued) Key Statistics Market Capitalization at 2/28/2014: Book Value at 12/31/2013: Tangible Book Value at 12/31/2013: Book Value per Share at 12/31/2013: Tangible Book Value per Share Stat Surplus at 12/31/2013 GWP to Statutory Surplus at 12/31/

  6. Slide 6: Business Overview

    Business Overview .& MEADOWBROOK™ ESS insurance Group Underwrites a broad range of insurance products to support selected specialty segments j (Sin milions) Food service industry Oil & gas senice contractors Small workers’ compensation Inland 2% Marine 3% Apartments, hotels and motels Contractors li

  7. Slide 7: Gross Written Premium

    2.6 MEADOWBROOK™ Gross Written Premium (Sin millions) Premium trajectory primarily driven by three major factors Implementing business specialties with established track recordssy 200 Achieved rate increases across book of business Decrease in 2013 reflects actions taken by management to terminate u

  8. Slide 8: Geographic Overview

    . MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Geographic Overview Geographically diverse premium base with strong local relationships Top 5 States GWP Breakdown 2013 GWP Geographic Breakdown nk [State/GAAP Line of Business [of BOWE 1 California Al Lines Em Workers Comp 2494 CMP / GL 5%] Commercial Auto x Other Lin

  9. Slide 9: Net Operating Income — 2013 Pro Forma Results

    . MEADOWBROOK™ ESS insurance Group Net Operating Income — 2013 Pro Forma Results Currentrun rate should positionus for an improved and profitable 2014 (Sin millions, except for per share share Simones) Net Operating fo ocrctin (Loss) Income Ue g (Loss) Income As Reported 2013 Results (8117.9) ($2.36

  10. Slide 10: Net Operating Income — 2013 Pro Forma Results

    . MEADOWBROOK™ Net Operating Income — 2013 Pro Forma Results Current run rate should positionus for an improved and profitable 2014 Per Share _— , ($ in millions, except for per share B - per MetOpeinny Income amounts) Income Contributions to Pro Forma 2013 Accident Year Net Operating Income Profits

  11. Slide 11: 2014 Guidance

    2.6 MEADOWBROOK™ 2014 Guidance Current run rate should position the business for an improved and profitable 2014 amounts) Pro Forma 2013 AY Net Operating Income (annualized front fee) $0140 $337 $0.67 (a) [2014 Guidance Top Range $8000 $350 90.70 Bottom Range $7750 $0.50 2014 Guidance Reflects Eamed

  12. Slide 12: Recent Activity & Management Actions

    MEADOWBROOK™ Recent Activity & Management Actions Management has taken corrective actions designed to return Meadowbrook to profitability Meadowbrook experienced a history of favorable reserve indications through 2010 Cumulative favorable loss & LAE development of $76.4 million in calendar years 200

  13. Slide 13: Recent Activity & Management Actions (Cont'd)

    MEADOWBROOK™ Recent Activity & Management Actions (Cont’d) Management has taken corrective actions designed to return Meadowbrook to profitability Meadowbrook’s continuing business has generated attractive statutory accident year loss & ALAE ratios 2011 ratio of 63.6%, 2012 ratio of 63.5% and 2013 r

  14. Slide 14: Statutory Surplus

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Statutory Surplus Since September 30, 2012, we have improved our premium to surplus leverage ratios through strengthening our capital position and terminating non-performing business. $600 38 $500 $426 $501 S498 $506 saee 128112 33113 6130/13 930/13 1238113 ‘Surplus —*-G

  15. Slide 15: Terminated Underperforming Business

    MEADOWBROOK™ € Binsurawce croup Terminated Underperforming Business

  16. Slide 16: Termination of Underperforming Business Commenced in 2012

    MEADOWBROOK™ ra 7 = = Termination of Underperforming Business Commenced in simian? 2012 Accident Year Combined Ratio (Re-Evaluated as of 12/31/2013) TELE 2010 2011 2012 “The Re-Evaluated AY combined ratio reflects reserve adjustments made following the accident year, for example, the 94.1% Re-Evalua

  17. Slide 17: Terminated Business Areas

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Terminated Business Areas Reserves on terminated business have been strengthened and premium has largely run off Unearned | (Sin millions) CiedealIN| | Premium|| Reserve Premium me ‘Strengthening 2012 2013 12/31/2013, 2012-2013, CA Territory Workers’ Compensation $9 $

  18. Slide 18: AY Loss and ALAE Ratio Summary

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP AY Loss and ALAE Ratio Summary The continuing book of business has generated strong Loss & ALAE results Continuing Business AY Loss & ALAE Ratio AY Loss & ALAE Ratio 100% 99.8% 90.8% 90.6% 3 sone 875% 80% 68.2% 63.3% 63.5% 63.6% 63.5% | | | | | | | 2009 2010 201120122

  19. Slide 19: AY Loss and ALAE Ratio by LOB Summary

    € MEADOWBROO! EES insurance Group AY Loss and ALAE Ratio by LOB Summary Continuing book of business has generated attractive loss & ALAE ratios across all lines of business CA Workers’ Comp. Non-CA Workers’ Comp, CMP/GL om pao s0.2% 5.0% 63.7% em 7.0% 29% AY Loss & ALAE Ratlo | | | | I Il 185.2543)

  20. Slide 20: Achieved Rate Increases

    € MEADOWBROOK~ EES insurance Group Achieved Rate Increases Significant rate increases have beenachieved across the book of business Meadowbrook achieved strong cumulative rate changes across the book of business since 2009 Driven by California workers’ compensation and commercial auto lines of busin

  21. Slide 21: Expense Ratio Analysis

    € MEADOWBROOK~ SE iNsuURANCE GROUP Expense Ratio Analysis Our expense structure, which is largely variable, allows us to quickly adaptto reduction: premium volume while maintaining an infrastructure that supports our business. 2012 2013 «=-Net% Variance Net% External Costs Commission $1876 220% $ 19

  22. Slide 22: Reaction to Shift in Incurred Loss Pattern

    MEADOWBROOK™ NSURANCE GROUP Reaction to Shift in Incurred Loss Pattern Strengthened reserves with a goal of returning to stability Significant rate increases in excess of the loss ratio trend across the entire portfolio, particularly in CA workers’ compensation, have improved more recent accident ye

  23. Slide 23: Development on Prior Year Loss Reserves

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Development on Prior Year Loss Reserves Meadowbrook experienced a history of favorable / stable reserve indications from 2006 through 2011 Cumulative favorable loss & LAE development of $86.3 million between 2006 and 2010 and modest (less than 1%) unfavorable development

  24. Slide 24: Reserve Development Shift - Emergence in 2012

    MEADOWBROOK™ EES insurance Group Reserve Development Shift - Emergence in 2012 Historic Calendar Year Reserve Development Reserve Development Adverse / (Favorable) ($m) 2006 2007 2008 2008 2010 Fercentonerior 4.0%) (23%) (4.98) LOH) «ASH 2013 Reserve Development Breakout ($m) A: $5.2M relates to an

  25. Slide 25: Reserves Beginning to Stabilize

    .6 MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Reserves Beginning to Stabilize Indicators thatloss reserves may be stabilizing Growth in recentyears from rate increases and increase in the average program maturity More certainty in estimating loss ultimates for mature business As programs and books of business mat

  26. Slide 26: Reserve Strengthening — 2013 Overview

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Reserve Strengthening — 2013 Overview Workers’ Compensation Favorable developmentin California book of $0.2M, excluding isolated L.A. territory where writings have been dramatically reduced (2013 NWP less than $2 million) Cumulative California rate increases in excess of

  27. Slide 27: Reserve Strengthening — 2013 Overview

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Reserve Strengthening — 2013 Overview CMP/General Liability Unfavorable development primarily relates to Excess & Surplus Lines business for accident years 2011 and 2012; olderaccident years appear generally stable Unfavorable development on older accident years primaril

  28. Slide 28: Reserve Strengthening — 2013 Overview

    MEADOWBROOK™ INSURANCE GROUP Reserve Strengthening — 2013 Overview CMP/General Liability - Excess and Surplus Lines Experienced favorable developmentin calendar years 2009, 2010, and 2011 on olderaccident years In 2012 a shiftin incurred loss patterns was identified Softer market pricing conditions

  29. Slide 29: Net Commission & Fee Business

    MEADOWBROOK™ € Binsurawce croup Net Commission & Fee Business

  30. Slide 30: Net Commission & Fee Revenue and Profit

    .6 MEADOWBROO! INSURANCE GROUP Net Commission & Fee Revenue and Profit $40 million of 2013 fee revenue generated through agency commissions and managed services | Net Commission & Fee Revenue and Profit 2013 Net Commission and Fee Revenue by Source $45 40 $40 s $35 $32 $30 $25 $20 sas 201 2012 2013"

  31. Slide 31: Agency Operations

    MEADOWBROOK™ Agency Operations Agency operations produced over $200 million of GWP for unaffiliated carriers in 2013 Provides insurance brokerage and risk management services Founded in 1955 in Southfield, MI Grown to a staff of 100+ across locations in 3 states and 6 cities Surplus Personal tines 7

Meadowbrook Insurance Group — Q4 2013 Earnings Presentation on 6ix