Portland General Electric Co · NYSE:POR
Portland General Electric — Technical Presentation (March 2016)
74 slides from Portland General Electric's technical presentation, Mar 9, 2016
Slide 1: Integrated Resource Plan 2016 Roundtable #16-1
INTEGRATED RESOURCE PLAN 2016 Roundtable #16-1 Wednesday, March 9, 2016 © 2016 Portland General Electric. All rights reserved.
Slide 2: Welcome
Welcome
Slide 3: Meeting Logistics
Meeting Logistics March 9, 2016 Slide 3 Local Participants: World Trade Center facility Wireless internet access Sign-in sheets Virtual Participants: Ask questions via ‘chat’ feature Meeting will stay open during breaks, but will be muted Electronic version of presentation: portlandg
Slide 4: Safety Moment – Distracted Driving
Safety Moment – Distracted Driving March 9, 2016 Slide 4 Source: Second Strategic Highway Research Program Naturalistic Driving Study Increase to Chance of Crashing 12 10 Risk Multiple 9 6 5 3 Browsing Reaching Texting Reaching Reading / Dialing a email for item for item writing phone (phone) (non-p
Slide 5: Safety Moment
Safety Moment March 9, 2016 Slide 5 Eight Ways to Avoid Distracted Driving 1. Stay off your phone. Do NOT text and 6. Avoid eating while you are behind the drive wheel. If you need to have breakfast or lunch, pull over to a safe place and take a 2. Use Bluetooth in your car or talk through break a B
Slide 6: Today's Topics
Today’s Topics March 9, 2016 Slide 6 Overview RPS Landscape Resource Adequacy Scoring Metrics Portfolios
Slide 7: Public Process Overview
Public Process Overview
Slide 8: IRP Guiding Philosophy
Guiding Philosophy March 9, 2016 Slide 8 Compliance Contingency Corporate Policy Reliability Regional Responsibility Adequacy IRP Efficiency Cost Effective Technology Price Diversity Stability Metric based-decisions Constraints which will be met Values that inform decisions
Slide 9: 2016 IRP Timeline
2016 IRP Timeline March 9, 2016 Slide 9 2016 2017 - 2020 2021 - 2050 March 9, 2016 2013 IRP Distribute File OPUC 20% RPS Clean 50% RPS Update IRP IRP Acknowledgement Power Boardman cease Plan coal operations (Dec 2015) (July 2016) (Sept 2016) (2017) (2020) (2022) (2040) Development (2015 – 2016) Act
Slide 10: Round Table Meeting Schedule
Round Table Meeting Schedule* March 9, 2016 Slide 10 Q1 – • RPS Landscape Resource Adequacy March 9 • Scoring Metrics Portfolios Q2 – • Resource Flexibility May 16 • RPS Strategy Q3 – • Discuss Draft IRP** August 17 Q4 – • Discuss Final IRP*** November • OPUC Process 16 Additional Meetings: Te
Slide 11: 2016 IRP: Status
2016 IRP: Status March 9, 2016 Slide 11 Item Status Round Table Meetings 8 Planned (5 complete, 3 scheduled) Commission Meetings 2 Planned (1 complete, 1 tentative) Feedback Forms 4 Received (0 since last meeting) 2013 IRP Action Plan 5 Actions (OPUC Order No. 14-415) Supply Side In progress (Hydro
Slide 12: RPS Landscape
RPS Landscape
Slide 13: Recent Happenings
Recent Happenings March 9, 2016 Slide 13 01 02 03 04 05 2013 IRP Update December 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 Federal tax credits 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Supreme Court Stay of CPP 01 02 Oregon Senate Passes SB 1547 03 10 04 11 05 12 06 13 07 14 08 15 09 16 January
Slide 14: Production & Investment Tax Credit
Production & Investment Tax Credit March 9, 2016 Slide 14 December 2015, Congress passes federal omnibus spending bill that includes: Five year extension of Production Tax Credit Three year extension of Investment Tax Credit
Slide 15: Clean Power Plan
Clean Power Plan March 9, 2016 Slide 15 February 2016, United States Supreme Court grants emergency stay on EPA’s implementation of CPP while reviewed by DC Circuit Court DC Circuit Court’s case begins June 2 Will be appealed to Supreme Court Supreme Court ruling expected early 2018 IRP wi
Slide 16: Summary of Senate Bill 1547
Summary of Senate Bill 1547 March 9, 2016 Slide 16 Senate Bill 1547 Passed the Oregon House March 1st Passed the Oregon Senate March 2nd Awaits Governor Brown’s signature Three primary components: No coal in PGE’s Oregon customer resources by 2035 RPS standard elevated to 50% by 2040
Slide 17: SB 1547 - Colstrip
SB 1547 - Colstrip March 9, 2016 Slide 17 PGE’s share of Colstrip Units 3 & 4 to be fully depreciated in 2030 Five years following full depreciation, Colstrip is removed from PGE customer rates Removal from portfolio reflected in 2016 IRP load resource balance
Slide 18: SB 1547 - RPS Targets
SB 1547 - RPS Targets March 9, 2016 Slide 18 15% by 2015 20% by 2020 27% by 2025 35% by 2030 45% by 2035 50% by 2040
Slide 19: SB 1547 – REC Banking Provisions
SB 1547 – REC Banking Provisions March 9, 2016 Slide 19 Existing banked RECs retain infinite life RECs generated by existing units, following passage of the act, may be used in the contemporaneous compliance year, or the following five compliance years New qualifying units or contracts deliver
Slide 20: REC Banking Deferral Potential
REC Banking Deferral Potential March 9, 2016 Slide 20 Number of RPS years coverable by existing REC bank
Slide 21: REC Banking Strategy
REC Banking Strategy March 9, 2016 Slide 21 Banked RECs facilitate: Temporary alternatives to physical compliance necessary to accommodate resource delays or avoid adverse market conditions RPS compliance following periods of renewable generation below forecasts RPS compliance following peri
Slide 22: REC Banking Strategy
REC Banking Strategy March 9, 2016 Slide 22 Three Factor Annual REC Risk Analysis REC Requirement (MWa) 2015‐2019 2020‐2024 2025‐2029 2030‐2034 2035‐2039 Annual RPS Deferral Risk 0 95 195 251 327 Annual Wind Forecast Risk 59 80 122 175 246 Annual Load Forecast Risk 6 10 13 16 27 One-Year Adjusted
Slide 23: REC Banking Strategy
REC Banking Strategy March 9, 2016 Slide 23 Three Factor Annual REC Risk Analysis
Slide 24: REC Banking Pathways
REC Banking Pathways March 9, 2016 Slide 24 2013 IRP Update Recommendation
Slide 25: REC Banking Pathways
REC Banking Pathways March 9, 2016 Slide 25 Forecasted REC bank following earlier action
Slide 26: RPS Compliance Strategy Summary
RPS Compliance Strategy Summary March 9, 2016 Slide 26 2016 IRP will revisit RPS compliance strategy PGE’s compliance strategy will weigh: The benefits of federal tax incentives CPP compliance REC bank adequacy and forecast risk Year-over-year rate impacts 2016 IRP will test 2019-2024
Slide 27: Resource Adequacy
Resource Adequacy
Slide 28: Resource Adequacy Topics
Resource Adequacy Topics March 9, 2016 Slide 28 Energy Load-Resource Balance and RPS Need RECAP review Capacity Need Capacity Contribution Future Considerations
Slide 29: Energy Load-Resource Balance
Energy Load-Resource Balance March 9, 2016 Slide 29 3500 3000 2017: 149 MWa Surplus 2035: 1238 MWa 2030: 793 MWa Deficit 2500 2021: 419 MWa Deficit 2000 MWa 1500 1000 500 0 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 20
Slide 30: Energy and RPS Needs
Energy and RPS Needs March 9, 2016 Slide 30 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 MWa 600 400 200 0 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 2041 -200 Energy Need RPS Need SB 1547 coal and RPS requirements included
Slide 31: Capacity Need and Contributions
Capacity Need and Contributions March 9, 2016 Slide 31 PGE is using E3’s RECAP model for the 2016 IRP to assess capacity need and capacity contribution RECAP calculations are based on a loss-of-load probability (LOLP) study for all hours of the test period Study assesses hourly capacity need.
Slide 32: Capacity Need and Contributions
Capacity Need and Contributions March 9, 2016 Slide 32 Annual capacity need based on reliability target Reliability target is industry standard of 1-day-in-10 years (2.4 hr/yr) Adequacy determined as ability to meet hourly load and required operating reserves Existing renewables included based
Slide 33: Resource Adequacy Process Improvements
Resource Adequacy Process Improvements March 9, 2016 Slide 33 2016 IRP methodology improves analysis of capacity needs and contributions in a system with increased complexity Captures and variability impacts from Increased location, visibility into technology, nature of correlation with capacity nee
Slide 34: Challenges: Complexity, New Tool
Challenges: Complexity, New Tool March 9, 2016 Slide 34 Significant increase in input data needs, processing time Complexity in interpreting and applying results Learning curve to develop best methods to use tools Externally run model, ability to run at PGE soon!
Slide 35: RECAP Capacity Need – 2021, 2025, 2030
RECAP Capacity Need – 2021, 2025, 2030 March 9, 2016 Slide 35 Annual capacity need must be met to achieve the annual reliability target Winter and summer values are seasonal minimums Shortage (need) defined in terms of CU (100 MW unit, 5% FOR) Load growth and contract expirations reflected i
Slide 36: Capacity Need 2021-2030
Capacity Need 2021-2030 March 9, 2016 Slide 36 RECAP results for 2021, 2025, 2030 Estimated values for intermediate years based on changes to load and resources 1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 MW 800 600 400 200 0 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 RECAP Annual Need Summer Min Need Winte
Slide 37: Existing Portfolio 2021 – Loss of Load Expectation
Existing Portfolio 2021 – Loss of Load Expectation March 9, 2016 Slide 37 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec 1 0.006 0.005 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.003 0.000 0.000 0.005 0.025 2 0.001 0.002 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.001 0.007 3 0.001 0.001 0.000 0.000 0.00
Slide 38: Wind – 2021 Marginal ELCC
Wind – 2021 Marginal ELCC March 9, 2016 Slide 38 Values below are for specific scenarios and do not apply to all technologies, locations, quantities, or time frames ELCC is expressed as percent of nameplate based on avoided CU Incremental Annual Winter Summer Renewables ELCC ELCC ELCC Wind, Gorg
Slide 39: Solar – 2021 Marginal ELCC
Solar – 2021 Marginal ELCC March 9, 2016 Slide 39 Values below are for specific scenarios and do not apply to all technologies, locations, quantities, or time frames ELCC is expressed as percent of nameplate based on avoided CU Incremental Annual Winter Summer Renewables ELCC ELCC ELCC Solar, Fi
Slide 40: Portfolio – 2021 Marginal ELCC
Portfolio – 2021 Marginal ELCC March 9, 2016 Slide 40 Values below are for specific scenarios and do not apply to all technologies, locations, quantities, or time frames ELCC is expressed as percent of nameplate based on avoided CU Incremental Annual Winter Summer Renewables ELCC ELCC ELCC Wind,
Slide 41: Capacity Contribution – Increased RPS
Capacity Contribution – Increased RPS March 9, 2016 Slide 41 Initial examination of increased RPS scenarios indicates capacity value of diversified renewables Annual Incremental Renewables ELCC Wind, Gorge, 300 MW 12% Wind, Gorge, 900 MW 9% Wind, Gorge, 300 MW Wind, Montana, 300 MW 26% Solar, Trac
Slide 42: Future Considerations: Near-term
Future Considerations: Near-term March 9, 2016 Slide 42 Ability to run model in-house Investigate additional incremental resources Continue developing process to interpolate/extrapolate Investigate impacts of increased RPS Characterize declining marginal values Align with demand response
Slide 43: Future Considerations: Long-term
Future Considerations: Long-term March 9, 2016 Slide 43 Expand and improve input data sets Examine EE modeling options (currently embedded in load) Examine import assumptions Examine thermal capacity temperature modeling Investigate time-sequential modeling
Slide 44: Conclusion
Conclusion March 9, 2016 Slide 44 Significant improvements to assessments and evaluation tools Substantial increase to process complexity Continued work to improve data, tools, and analysis Sellwood Bridge Construction, en.wikipedia.org
Slide 45: Scoring Metrics
Scoring Metrics
Slide 46: Portfolio evaluation guidelines
Portfolio evaluation guidelines March 9, 2016 Slide 46 Guideline Status (07-047) The primary goal must be the selection of a portfolio of resources with the 1 (c) best combination of expected costs and associated risks and uncertainties for the utility and its customers. Utilities should use present
Slide 47: IRP Guiding Philosophy
IRP Guiding Philosophy March 9, 2016 Slide 47 Compliance Contingency Corporate Policy Reliability Regional Responsibility Adequacy IRP Efficiency Cost Effective Technology Price Diversity Stability Metric based-decisions Constraints which will be met Values that inform decisions
Slide 48: Guiding Philosophy – Portfolio Scoring
Guiding Philosophy Portfolio Scoring March 9, 2016 Slide 48 Policy • Environmental Impact Reliability • Resource Adequacy Price • Balance Financial Cost and Risk Technology • Diversification
Slide 49: Portfolios
Portfolios
Slide 50: Portfolios: Resource alternatives
Portfolios: Resource alternatives March 9, 2016 Slide 50 Central Distributed Demand Integration Wind Solar Energy Storage Efficiency Solar Combined Demand Other Geothermal Heat & Power Response (CHP) Market Biomass Position Conservation Dispatchable Voltage Standby Gen. Existing Natural Gas Reductio
Slide 51: Portfolios: Common Assumptions
Portfolios: Common Assumptions March 9, 2016 Slide 51 Renewable Portfolio Standard compliance by 2025 Compliance strategy refresh for 2016 IRP Obligations currently assume SB 1547 timing and quantity ETO Energy Efficiency Demand Response Short-term/Mid-term market procurement – Energy an
Slide 52: Portfolios: Energy (2021)
Portfolios: Energy (2021) March 9, 2016 Slide 52 MWa 2021 Incremental Energy Resources (MWa Availability before Economic Dispatch) 800 Residual 700 Gas 600 Bio 194 130 130 130 130 130 125 367 Geo 500 367 27 25 25 367 324 324 450 Solar 400 194 219 194 194 287 MT Wind 300 256 262 81 94 94 94 94 94 PNW
Slide 53: Portfolios: Capacity (2021)
Portfolios: Capacity (2021) March 9, 2016 Slide 53 MW 2021 Incremental Annual Capacity 1,400 Position (MW) Residual 1,200 Summer 95 106 113 105 98 108 109 114 111 106 114 104 Cap 145 Winter Cap 166 145 145 136 166 159 203 212 212 180 166 1,000 Gas 30 800 865 Bio 368 368 368 525 425 525 425 475 625 5
Slide 54: Portfolios: Filling Capacity Need Example
Portfolios: Filling Capacity Need Example March 9, 2016 Slide 54 MW 2021 Incremental Annual Capacity 1,400 Position (MW) Residual 1,200 Summer 95 106 113 105 98 108 109 114 111 106 114 104 Cap 145 Winter Cap 166 145 145 136 166 159 1,000 3. Seasonal to seasonal minimum (summer) 203 212 212 180 166 G
Slide 55: Portfolios: Capacity Need Distinctions Example
Portfolios: Capacity Need Distinctions Example March 9, 2016 Slide 55 Portfolio 5 vs. Portfolio 4 190 MWa MT Wind replaces PNW Wind 3. Increases summer-only need 2. Reduces year-round need 1. Increases VER contribution
Slide 56: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 57: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 57 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed For stakeholder questions, provide a General Passing the mic was cumbersome. stationary microphone at a podium or 4/13/2015 mics at each table. Update schedule slides to account for automation. Plan to revi
Slide 58: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 58 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE to address questions about EE Load Forecast For future discussion, how is the ETO Est. 7/15/15 and projection in the future. Refer to April 2nd Methodology forecast in later years developed? 7/16/15 Sli
Slide 59: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 59 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is engaging the ETO on a number of DR programs, particularly with Energy Partner and the smart thermostat pilot. Our current plan is to How is PGE using the convergence of only attribute incremental dem
Slide 60: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 60 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Would PGE provide a copy of the DR The report is currently under review. Our Demand study, along with the assumptions plan is to have this report finalized by the Est. 12/31/15 Response (particularly materi
Slide 61: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 61 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed PGE is willing to host detailed modeling Can there be discussions about the discussions; we look forward to receiving Futures Clean Power Plan and mass vs. rate- detailed feedback regarding the specific 12/
Slide 62: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 62 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed The definition is dependent on the What is PGE's definition of dependable particular capacity assessment question. PGE presented an overview hydro capacity or what does it mean in PRM Study of the treatment
Slide 63: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 63 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Can PGE provide clarification on the net The plant capacities were discussed in the PRM Study 12/17/15 capacities used in winter and summer? 12/17/15 Public meeting. As in the 2013 IRP, the PRM Study models
Slide 64: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 64 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Yes. PGE’s correspondence with EPA Is PGE going to treat Carty as an regarding Carty is ongoing. PGE is Clean Power existing resource? Can PGE provide willing to share the letter dated 12/17/15 Plan the cor
Slide 65: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 65 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Can the report be provided to Yes. The report will be included in the Climate Study Est. 7/29/2016 stakeholders? 2016 IRP. Is the study providing information about plant cooling requirements? No. The focus
Slide 66: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 66 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed You note the large number of use cases for the Salem Smart Power project. Initially 6, now 14. The large number is interesting and implies more value to be derived from storage but any analysis/quantificati
Slide 67: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 67 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed What is your estimate per household reduction for the Pricing Pilots for the estimated 3,500-7,000 customers? Why Integrated Grid is the range of households participating so large? Which pilot has the most
Slide 68: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 68 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Please share your evaluation of the Energy Partner Pilot. You noted overlap with energy savings and Energy Trust’s work. How is energy savings realized at DR Potential these sites attributed to Energy Partn
Slide 69: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 69 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed If the High Case programs are cost effective, listing the barriers to acquisition and risk factors and any specific actions that may help overcome those barriers would be DR Potential helpful. The differenc
Slide 70: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 70 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Slide 89 (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015) states that generalizations will be made for capacity needs and capacity contributions for other years and Resource resource combinations. Does this mean Adequacy that
Slide 71: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 71 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Please clarify assumptions used for market depth for energy and capacity. Recommend limiting the amount of market purchases to a level in line with historical capabilities or justified future Futures & mark
Slide 72: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 72 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Slides 99 and 100 differentiate between Capacity and Summer or Winter capacity. Please explain the difference between the two and how they were Futures & determined. Suggest showing capacity Portfolios need
Slide 73: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 73 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Slide 98 (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015), portfolio 3 shows 600aMW of PNW Wind. This resource then equates to just 127 MW winter VER capacity and 235 MW summer VER capacity. Compare that to portfolio 2 where F
Slide 74: 2016 IRP: Feedback Status
2016 IRP: Feedback Status March 9, 2016 Slide 74 Topic Feedback Received Resolution Completed Consistency in labeling between all three plots would be helpful. VER Futures & should remain differentiated by type of Portfolios wind and solar added (Public Meeting, 12/17/2015) Scenarios (or “Futures”)
Portland General Electric — Technical Presentation (March 2016) on 6ix