Clarivate Plc · NYSE:CLVT
Clarivate — Technical Presentation (September 2020)
19 slides from Clarivate's technical presentation, Sep 24, 2020
Slide 1: Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Review
Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Review 24 September 2020 Josh Dahl Marc Domingo Product Product Director, Clarivate Manager, Clarivate josh.dahl@clarivate. marc.domingo@clarivate com .com Dave Evans Simon Harris Product Manager, IOP Managing Editor, IOP Publi
Slide 2: Questions during the webinar?
Questions during the webinar? • Enter them into the Webex chat box (be sure it’s set to go to “All Panelists”) • If we don’t get to your question during the Q&A, we will follow up via email • A link to the recording and slides will be sent to you in the following week Implementing Open Peer Review a
Slide 3: Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Review
Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Review 24 September 2020 Josh Dahl Marc Domingo Product Product Director, Clarivate Manager, Clarivate josh.dahl@clarivate. marc.domingo@clarivate com .com Dave Evans Simon Harris Product Manager, IOP Managing Editor, IOP Publi
Slide 4: Agenda
Agend 1. Clarivate & IOP Publishing Partnership a 2. Transparent Peer Review Service Overview 3. IOP Publishing Pilot: Set-up & Results 4. Future Plans 5. Questions Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 4 view
Slide 5: Clarivate & IOP Publishing Partnership
Clarivate & IOP Publishing Partnership Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 5 view
Slide 6: Peer Review and Research Transparency
Peer Review and Research Transparency o + provides greater visibility and recognition for reviewers o + potential to increase review quality o + potential to advance research integrity and reproducibility o + potential to impede research manipulation and fraudulent review Implementing Open Peer Revi
Slide 7: Interest in opening up peer review is growing
Interest Whilst many researchers maintain in opening reservations about opening up peer review, interest and support is growing… up peer review is growing Source: Publons, Global State of Peer Review Report (2018) Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer 7 Review
Slide 8: ...but, operating more open peer review workflows can be challenging
• There is a growing interest in transparent & open ...but, review models operating • However, many publishers face practical difficulties more open in adopting such models peer review • Complex, legacy workflows -> publishers have workflows can either avoided opening up peer review or used manual w
Slide 9: The Clarivate solution
The Clarivate • Clarivate's Publons have developed a robust and scalable model, working within established workflows and systems to solution support transparent peer review The Publons model… o Scalable and robust o Requires minimal work from the publisher o Configurable o Simpler process for resear
Slide 10: Workflow for Transparent Peer Review: In partnership with ScholarOne
Workflow for Transparent Peer Review In partnership with ScholarOne 1 2 3 4 5 ScholarOne Publisher Publons Publons creates Article collects sends feed of queries article peer publication author and accepted ScholarOne for review pages triggers reviewer articles to peer review and registers peer revi
Slide 11: Workflow for Transparent Peer Review: Displaying the peer review content
Workflow for Transparent Peer Review Displaying the peer review content IO Publons P Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 11 view
Slide 12: Workflow for Transparent Peer Review: Connecting the reviews with the reviewers
Workflow for Transparent Peer Review Connecting the reviews with the reviewers Publons Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 12 view
Slide 13: IOPP pilot set-up
o IOPP pilot set- o Aim was to test demand for TPR from our authors and reviewers Both the authors and all the reviewers have to opt-in for it up o If anyone opts out, no review content is published at all Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 13 view
Slide 14: IOPP pilot results
Popularity IOPP pilot o 58% of authors opt-in for TPR o 45% of reviewers opt-in for TPR results o 10% of articles are published with review content Author survey feedback positive: “I think that publishing the reviews online with the article is a big positive step forward and suggest that it be made
Slide 15: Future plans
Future plans • Publication badge improvements • File attachments support • IOPP to roll-out TPR on all open access journals • TPR available to all ScholarOne journals Further details of IOPP TPR pilot here: https://www.csescienceeditor.org/article/transparent-peer-review- a-practical-solution-to-imp
Slide 16: Other partners
Other partners Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 16 view
Slide 17: We're not just opening the scholarly record with transparent peer review
We’re not just opening the scholarly record with transparent peer review – we’re actively building it, putting a spotlight on community-led evaluation. Implementing Open Peer Review at Scale: A Case Study on Transparent Peer Re 17 view
Slide 18: Q&A
QA Josh Dahl Marc Domingo Product Product Director, Clarivate Manager, Clarivate Josh.dahl@clarivate. Marc.domingo@clarivate com .com Dave Evans Simon Harris Product Manager, IOP Managing Editor, IOP Publishing Publishing david.evans@ioppublishing simon.harris@ioppublishing .org .org © 2020 Clarivat
Slide 19: Thank you!
Thank you! Josh Dahl Marc Domingo Product Product Director, Clarivate Manager, Clarivate Josh.dahl@clarivate. Marc.domingo@clarivate com .com Dave Evans Simon Harris Product Manager, IOP Managing Editor, IOP Publishing Publishing david.evans@ioppublishing simon.harris@ioppublishing .org .org © 2020