AOL Inc

AOL — Proxy Contest (May 2012)

52 slides from AOL's proxy contest presentation, May 24, 2012

  1. Slide 1: AOL Inc. May 2012

    AOL Inc. MAY 2012

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements

    Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may contain ‘forward-looking statements" within the meaning of the federal securities laws, anticipated future events and expectations that are not historical facts. Words such as “anticipates,” “estimates,” “expects,” “projects,” “forecasts,” “intends,”

  3. Slide 3: Executive Summary

    Executive Summary We believe: AOL's stock is a top performing stock in our industry year-over-year and year-to-date AOL's stock is up 166% since its low as a direct result of the actions taken by AOL’s management and Board AOL has made significant operational and financial progress since spinning of

  4. Slide 4: Shareholder Value / Strategy / Execution / Governance

    Shareholder Value Strategy Execution Governance

  5. Slide 5: Shareholder Value

    Shareholder Value

  6. Slide 6: AOL's stock has significantly outperformed the major indices

    AOL's stock has significantly outperformed the major indices over the last twelve months and since AOL’s August low AOL actions have helped; Starboard’s have hindered AOL +166% Si mont 266.1% 119.2% 116.4% snort 1016/11 12a 4128112 312512 51202 aot ——-S8P Mid Cap 400 —NasDAg Composite

  7. Slide 7: AOL's stock has significantly outperformed our peers

    AOL's stock has significantly outperformed our peers over the last twelve months and since AOL’s August low AOL actions have helped; Starboard’s have hindered t twelve mont! 266.1% 113.2% anon 0/6/11 eet ean ‘325/12 S122 AOL: Online Peers (:) Soutce Facset520'2 () Onin Peer ze mice ase wine and inco

  8. Slide 8: We believe AOL's share price outperformance is being driven by 6 things

    We believe AOL's share price outperformance is being driven by 6 things i Improved operational performance which has led to beating Wall Street expectations in each of the last three quarters 2012 Adjusted OIBDA guidance released on May 9, 2012 that was approximately $40 million or 13% ahead of Wall

  9. Slide 9: AOL reduced its shares outstanding by 14% since 2009

    AOL reduced its shares outstanding by 14% since 2009 Reducing shares outstanding At very attractive prices Shrinking equity creates leverage Shares repurchased at very to the upside for shareholders attractive prices = 110 $30 2 105 407 $25 | = | = a $20 7 & $15 | g 9 Fs a $10 g 90 = $5 é | ~ 85 +—

  10. Slide 10: $1 Billion Cash Return to AOL Shareholders

    $1 Billion Cash Return to AOL Shareholders Patent transaction represented 60% of AOL’s market cap on the day of the transaction (Ss in Billions) 18 + AOL Shareholders to receive 100% of oS proceeds of the $1.056 billion patent transaction + 60% of the pre-announcement market cap 2 returned to shareh

  11. Slide 11: AOL hired advisors and initiated the process to realize the value of its non-strategic patents

    AOL hired advisors and initiated the process to realize the value of its non-strategic patents in July 2011, five months before Starboard’s first letter * Inanine page letter to AOL’s Board that was leaked to the Wall Street Journal prior to its delivery to AOL’s Board on December 21, 2011, the word

  12. Slide 12: AOL's management & Board have already made significant commitments to shareholders

    AOL’s management & Board have already made significant commitments to shareholders AOL has committed to returning 100% of the proceeds from the patent transaction to shareholders, representing over $1 billion (approx. 60% of AOL's market capitalization at the time of the transaction) AOL provided 20

  13. Slide 13: Independent, shareholder friendly and directly aligned corporate governance structure

    Independent, shareholder friendly and directly aligned corporate governance structure 7 out of 8 independent directors + All committees are 100% independent directors Independence + Lead independent director + Independent directors meet in executive session without management present + All directors

  14. Slide 14: Strategy

    Strategy CONTENT ADVERTISING LOCAL AOL SERVICES

  15. Slide 15: AOL's operations

    AOL's operations Continue Building Digital Brands to Provide Consumers With Unique Experiences at Scale + 80/80/80 Strategy » Destination Brands in Key Categories e.g., News, Tech, Auto, Style, Entertainment » Enhanced Consumer Experience e.g., Project Devil Leverage Brand Portfolio to Attack High R

  16. Slide 16: Strategy: Content

    Strategy CONTENT

  17. Slide 17: Consumers and advertisers are attracted to fewer and bigger brands

    Consumers and advertisers are attracted to fewer and bigger brands * ~70% of consumers have 20 or fewer sites in their Size of the Average Media Mix() core mix 50% 45% 40% 35% 30% 25% 20% 25% 15% ae a5 17% 5% 0% » 44% of the web audience limits their core media mix to 10 sites or less 10 Sites orfew

  18. Slide 18: AOL's Strategy: Building Brands for the Digital Century / 80/80/80

    AOL's Strategy: Building Brands for the Digital Century 80 / 80/ 80 Philosophy: AOL's Organizing Strategy 80 80 80 INFLUENCERS WOMEN LOCAL 74% of all decisions are made 85% of household spending is 86% of purchases are local consulting influencers controlled by women (under 10 miles from home) HUFFP

  19. Slide 19: Case Study: Stylelist

    Case Study: Stylelist epee esi + Increase organic audience with SEO and social + Stylelistis where the fashionable come for style inspiration + Increase video content views and ads . + Profitable, growing site focused on higher income, + Increase percentage of premium format ads fashion conscious wo

  20. Slide 20: AOL has a model for creating profitable stand-alone properties

    AOL has a model for creating profitable stand-alone properties with attractive margins Direct Revenue 100% 0% 0% 15% 20% 24% 21% 30% Costs(") 80% 5% 24% 28% 31% 34% 10% 28% 31% 35% 37% % Revenue 20% 15% 32% 35% 38% 41% + Prior to shared corporate and technology costs, many + There is significant lev

  21. Slide 21: Strategy: Advertising

    Strategy ADVERTISING

  22. Slide 22: AOL's Strategy: Significant Shareholder Upside

    AOL's Strategy: Significant Shareholder Upside $20B Opportunity in Domestic Online Spend Online Activity Influences Offline Action © Ad Spend Is Rich Media & Video Shifting Online “) Growing The Fastest @) US Video & Total U.S. Retail Sales Online Influenced ‘x 2% Rich Media: Offiine Purchases: 21%

  23. Slide 23: AOL Strategy: Attack Growth Markets

    AOL Strategy: Attack Growth Markets Brand Choice In-Market Targeting Pages-to-Parking Lots AOL helps advertisers AOL matches advertisers with drive brand choice in-market intenders AOL can drive offline commerce: + Projected US Display + Projected US Behaviorally + Projected US Web- Advertising Sale

  24. Slide 24: We believe AOL has some of the best and fastest growing products

    We believe AOL has some of the best and fastest growing products in the industry ee + Devil interaction rates significantly outperform industry + AOLis the 6th largest video network in the U.S. () rich media formats + eMarketer projects >50% growth in ad spend on + Devil ad penetration is less than

  25. Slide 25: Ad.com Group provides scale and performance for advertisers

    Ad.com Group provides scale and performance for advertisers while maximizing yield for publishers An end-to-end solution 1 2010 for Advertisers and Publishers cline of -17% Advertising.com comScore: a leading ad network in US, UK and Canada Advertising.com: Pictela AOL's own premium ad format, IAB P

  26. Slide 26: Strategy: Local

    Strategy LOCAL

  27. Slide 27: We believe the local advertising opportunity is massive

    We believe the local advertising opportunity is massive $24B > am © $39B ( > Local Online Advertising @ Local Advertising Patch positions AOL to capitali 2010-2016,

  28. Slide 28: We believe Patch is AOL's organic "game changer"

    We believe Patch is AOL’s organic “game changer” Ahyper-local platform at the heart of what's Remaining Investment working best nationally + AOLhas made the difficult, but we believe the correct decision to invest in hyper-local through our P&L. al rather than through acquisition * 2011 was the high

  29. Slide 29: We believe Patch is a unique solution for local content

    We believe Patch is a unique solution for local content Ahyper-local platform at the heart Ofiiiat s wolklng Best nationally The Consumer + Hyper-local community platform & forum * Professional, local journalists + Easy-to-use self publishing functionality The Advertiser + Aunique, targeted, attract

  30. Slide 30: Patch has national reach and desirable demographic

    Patch has national reach and desirable demographic ‘tch’s footprint is well established BEE e valuable demographic » Reach approximately 30% of all US Retail & Food Sales () + $100k+ Household Income @) + 58% Women; 73% Married; 42% of HHs have children + 90% Within 10 miles of Big Box Retailer“) +

  31. Slide 31: We believe Patch's audience and revenue growth has been impressive

    We believe Patch’s audience and revenue growth has been impressive In Just 1.5 Years Patch Has Grown its Usage From Number 10 to Number 5 in Local Users. 12 10 0 Jan-10 May-10 Oct-10 Feb-11 Jul-11 Dec-11 Apr-12 NA #0 ource: comScore May 2012) #6 Local Ranking “4 We Believe That In Just 3 Years From

  32. Slide 32: Case study: Huntington, New York

    Case study: Huntington, New York Patch’s goal is to be profitable in every town fatch’s focus is growing and monetizing Bete an ume ame engaged local audiences + Launched February 2010 Increase Audience Engagement + Audience grows as town engaged + Increase visit frequency and content engagement (e.

  33. Slide 33: Patch Summary

    Patch Summary » We believe that over the next 12 to 18 months the value of Patch will increase significantly as AOL and its shareholders reap the benefit of prior Patch investment. We believe Starboard wants to shut down Patch immediately, which represents a short-sighted view that would reduce pote

  34. Slide 34: Strategy: AOL Services & Search

    Strategy AOL SERVICES & SEARCH

  35. Slide 35: We have made significant operational improvements in subscription operations and search

    We have made significant operational improvements in our subscription operations and search performance wnier have created significant Subscriptions: Subscriptions: + Single dial-up product with 60+ price points + Bundled suite of services with 6 core price points * Subscription churn at 3.0% + Subs

  36. Slide 36: Execution

    Execution

  37. Slide 37: AOL's Board and management have a demonstrated track record of creating shareholder value

    We believe AOL’s Board and management have a demonstrated track record of creating and unlocking shareholder value Profit Actions / Financial Results Strategic / Operational Actions Divestitures/ Capital Return + Reduction of ~2,300 employees and Sale of Dulles, VA real estate + Exited unprofitable

  38. Slide 38: AOL is a stronger company today than in 2009

    AOL is a stronger company today than in 2009 FAL Late 2008 AOL Today Revenue Q4 2009 Year-over-Year Results Q1 2012 Year-over-Year Results Total Revenue ex-subscription +3% growth in total revenue ex-subscription declined 8% ‘Subscription revenue declined 28% 1,300 basis points improvement in subscr

  39. Slide 39: AOL reduced its expense base by $0.5 billion

    AOL reduced its expense base by $0.5 billion or is} ae Ase, ongoing cost review process and accountability throughout the organization Annual Operating Expense Reduction Headcount Reduction (excl. Patch) ae Ax3; 7% $2.5 cs SS 3 20 5,000 gis) i / 4,000 4,250 E 4.072 8 10 Patch o Sas Cc} ya , S05 1,00

  40. Slide 40: Wall Street analyst perspectives support our progress

    Wall Street analyst perspectives support our progress Clay Moran Benchmark ter Stabler Wells Fargo Ben Schachter Macquarie Tom Forte Telsey Laura Martin Needham Anthony DiClemente Barclays *AOL is a tum-around story with a solid balance sheet, positive cash flow, a recognized brand, and a sizable us

  41. Slide 41: Governance

    Governance

  42. Slide 42: We believe AOL's Board has unique and relevant public company experience

    We believe AOL’s Board has unique and relevant public company experience Tim Armstrong + Chairman & CEO, AOL Ine. + Director since December 2009 =sri com omer 92" aslo mleeet as coumcee” =|=AR + Drecersicesemsey 2011 Bini Head © Pepsico Susan Lyne + Chal, Git Grou, PREMIERE + Drees Decenter2000 BEA

  43. Slide 43: AOL believes Starboard's nominees would decrease the Board's level of industry expertise

    AOL believes Starboard’s nominees would decrease the Board’s level of industry expertise, public company experience Alberto tbarguen President & CEO of John S, & James L. Knight Foundation Patricia Mitchell . President & CEO of The Paley Center for faye} ; « sa James Stengel President & CEO, The im

  44. Slide 44: Alberto Ibargüen: Leading Media Industry and Local News Expert

    Alberto Ibargiien: Leading Media Industry and Local News Expert / Fortune 500 Company Board Member a Alberto Ibarguen President & CEO of John S. ‘& James L. Knight Foundation Expertise in local media and journalism Extensive public company board experience Former Publisher of The Miami Herald, one o

  45. Slide 45: James Stengel: Leading Global Advertising Expert

    James Stengel: Leading Global Advertising Expert Dennis Mies ‘+ No public company board experience ata James Stengel pear o ‘company with greater than $500 million in President and CEO, + revenue The Jim Stengel Company, LLC Enteneiament Named to Fortune magazine's “Executive Dream Team” + Extensive

  46. Slide 46: Patricia Mitchell

    Patricia Mitchell: a be Patricia Mitchell President & CEO of ‘The Paley Center for Media ‘Named “One of the most influential female ‘executives in media’ by Hollywood Reporter Extensive expertise and experience in the entertainment industry, telecommunications and broadcasting Extensive public compa

  47. Slide 47: AOL is actively seeking new Board members, but believes Starboard's slate will damage the Company

    AOL is actively seeking new Board members, but believes Starboard’s slate will damage the Company Negative impact on employee morale resulting in employee departures — We believe Starboard has already caused talent departures based on their attack of our core business and strategy Negative impact on

  48. Slide 48: Summary

    Summary

  49. Slide 49: AOL's continued focus on maximizing shareholder value

    AOL's continued focus on maximizing shareholder value AOL Management and Board’s Next Steps For Value Creation: Return 100% of the patent transaction proceeds to shareholders Grow Adjusted OIBDA in 2013 - This would be the first time AOL has grown Adjusted OIBDA in 6 years Continue to aggressively m

  50. Slide 50: Conclusion

    Conclusion We believe: AOL's stock is a top performing stock in our industry year-over-year and year-to-date AOL's stock is up 166% since its low as a direct result of the actions taken by AOL's management and Board AOL has made significant operational and financial progress since spinning off from

  51. Slide 51: Appendix

    Appendix

  52. Slide 52: Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Measures

    Reconciliation of Non-GAAP Measures “) (mions) Aa tod operating incom before depreciation and amarization (OIBDA). ‘Operating income ss) S18) $68) ‘Ad: Depreciation 444 24 383 358 ‘Ads Amortization ofitangbie assets 242 mr _26 105 ‘Ad: Restructuring costs 218 08 ia} 28 ‘Ads Equty-basedcompensation 1

AOL — Proxy Contest (May 2012) on 6ix