Ultratech Inc

Ultratech — Proxy Contest (June 2016)

29 slides from Ultratech's proxy contest presentation, Jun 21, 2016

  1. Slide 1: The Need for Change at Ultratech, Inc

    THE NEED FOR CHANGE AT ULTRATECH, INC From a long - term investor’s perspective June 2016

  2. Slide 2: Disclosures

    Disclosures 2 On June 13 , 2016 , Neuberger Berman LLC, Neuberger Berman Fixed Income Holdings LLC, Neuberger Berman Investment Advisers LLC, Neuberger Berman Group LLC, Mr . Benjamin Nahum, Mr . James F . McAree and Mr . Amit Solomon (collectively, the "Neuberger Berman Participants") and Dr . Rona

  3. Slide 3: Table of Contents

    Table of Contents 3 Executive Summary 4 Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 10 Corporate Governance Concerns 17 The Need For a Refreshed Board 22 Ultratech’s Disappointing Response to Our Campaign 25

  4. Slide 4: Executive Summary: Overview of Neuberger Berman

    Executive Summary 4 Overview of Neuberger Berman □ Founded in 1939, Neuberger Berman is a private, independent, employee - owned investment manager with approximately 2,000 professionals in 19 countries □ Our US Small Cap Intrinsic Value Team employs a research - intensive strategy that seeks to ide

  5. Slide 5: Executive Summary: Overview of Ultratech, Inc.

    Executive Summary 5 Overview of Ultratech, Inc. □ Founded in 1992, Ultratech develops photolithography, laser thermal processing and inspection equipment for the semiconductor industry □ Despite its leading technology, Ultratech has failed to generate returns for stockholders over any meaningful per

  6. Slide 6: Twenty-year stock performance of Ultratech

    Executive Summary 6 Overview of Ultratech, Inc. Ultratech stockholders have nothing to show by way of stock price appreciation for their investment over the last twenty years 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

  7. Slide 7: Executive Summary: Our Concerns

    Executive Summary 7 Our Concerns □ Ultratech has vastly underperformed the broad market as well as its peer group □ Ultratech’s operating performance has been dismal for the past 20 years Revenue | Gross Margin | SG&A | Net Income | EPS □ Ultratech’s capital structure is inefficient » Over the last

  8. Slide 8: Executive Summary: Our Concerns

    Executive Summary 8 Our Concerns □ Despite poor stock and operating performance, there is seemingly no credible CEO succession plan » Ultratech’s CEO (77 years old) and CFO (69 years old) have been in office together since 2001 » For most of the Company’s history these two have been the only Named E

  9. Slide 9: Our Nominees: Two Exceptional Technology Executives

    Executive Summary 9 Our Nominees Two Exceptional Technology Executives Independent of Neuberger Berman Beatriz V . Infante has extensive technology leadership experience and has served on three public company boards . Dr . Ronald Black is currently the CEO of Rambus, Inc . , a $ 1 . 3 billion public

  10. Slide 10: Ultratech Has Underperformed the Market and Peers

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 10 Ultratech has underperformed the market and peers over all relevant timeframes 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 Aug-10 Aug-11 Aug-12 Aug-13 Aug-14 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 5 Year Total Return 10 Year Total Return 0 50 100 150 200 250 A

  11. Slide 11: Ultratech's Claim of Out-Performance Is Disingenuous

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 11 Ultratech’s claim of out - performance in its June 20 letter is disingenuous □ In a letter dated June 20, 2016, Ultratech claims to have “outperformed” its hand - picked peers for four periods: year - to - date and the 1 - , 5 - and 10 - years ending D

  12. Slide 12: Volatile Revenue and Gross Income, Fixed Costs

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 12 Ultratech has volatile revenue and gross income, but fixed (and growing) costs □ Ultratech’s business is subject to the cyclicality of the semiconductor industry » Known volatility of revenue and gross profit » Ultratech has “hit” the cycle correctly j

  13. Slide 13: Financial Performance in 1996 vs. Today

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 13 Ultratech had much more attractive financial performance in 1996 than today Ultratech generated more revenue in 1996 than it did in 2015 and more net income in 1996 alone than it has cumulatively generated since 2001 *Calculated by FactSet ($ in millio

  14. Slide 14: Peers from the 1990s Generated Better Results

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 14 Ultratech’s peers from the 1990s generated better results for stockholders Case Study : ASML Holding □ ASML was one of Ultratech’s principal competitors in 1995, with a slightly larger market cap than Ultratech □ ASML merged with competitor Silicon Val

  15. Slide 15: Ultratech Maintains Excess Cash on Its Balance Sheet

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 15 Ultratech maintains excess cash on its balance sheet □ Ultratech has historically maintained significant cash on its balance sheet » Average cash balance over last 20 years is $180 million; $250 million in cash at the end of 2015 » Cash appears excessi

  16. Slide 16: After Three Bad Years, Shouldn't Ultratech Aim Higher?

    Ultratech’s Track Record of Underperformance 16 After three bad years, shouldn’t Ultratech aim higher? □ Ultratech’s CEO has admitted to poor performance for three years running… » “[ 2013 ] was a challenging year.” (January 2014 investor conference call) » “I believe that 2014 was a transitional ye

  17. Slide 17: Despite Poor Performance, Not Much Has Changed

    Corporate Governance Concerns 17 Despite poor performance and broken promises not much has changed □ The average board tenure is more than 15 years □ For most of the last 15 years, the Company has only had CEO Art Zafiropoulo and CFO Bruce Wright (Age 69) as Named Executive Officers □ Despite the ag

  18. Slide 18: Executive Compensation Is Excessive and Not Tied to Performance

    Corporate Governance Concerns 18 Executive compensation is excessive and not tied to performance □ Over the last 15 years, Ultratech’s Board, its CEO and CFO have been paid a total in excess of $57.8 million, which is more than double the cumulative net income over that period □ The CEO’s employment

  19. Slide 19: ISS and Glass Lewis Shared Our Concerns on Compensation

    Corporate Governance Concerns 19 ISS and Glass Lewis shared our concerns about excessive compensation in 2015 □ In 2015, both ISS and Glass Lewis expressed significant concern about excessive compensation and the failure to link pay with performance ISS 2015 Vote Recommendation Item 3. Advisory Vote

  20. Slide 20: Management's and Shareholders' Interests Continue to Diverge

    Corporate Governance Concerns 20 Management’s and shareholder’s interests continue to diverge □ We estimate that the CEO has liquidated three - quarters of his ownership interest in the Company » Ten years ago Mr. Zafiropoulo held more than 2.3 million shares » He has been awarded additional stock a

  21. Slide 21: CEO Appears More Devoted to Personal and Family Interests

    Corporate Governance Concerns 21 CEO appears more devoted to personal and family interests □ CEO’s employment contract requires “substantially all of his business time, energy and skill” to be applied to Ultratech , Inc. » CEO owns Ferrari Silicon Valley » CEO owns Scuderia Corsa , a Ferrari racing

  22. Slide 22: Ms. Infante and Dr. Black Will Make an Immediate Impact

    The need for a refreshed Board 22 Ms. Infante and Dr. Black will make an immediate impact in Ultratech’s boardroom We recruited Ms . Infante for her immense technology experience and proven track record as a positive agent for change . Ms . Infante has served in various executive management position

  23. Slide 23: We Do Not Support Two Longest-Tenured Incumbent Directors

    The need for a refreshed Board 23 We do not support two of the longest - tenured incumbent directors □ Mr . Nicholas Konidaris » Mr. Konidaris has been a director since July 2000 » Mr. Konidaris is 71 » Mr. Konidaris generated negative shareholder value in over 10 years as CEO of ESIO and was termin

  24. Slide 24: Our Nominees' Early Agenda

    The need for a refreshed Board 24 Our nominees’ early agenda □ Key areas of focus for Ms. Infante and Dr. Black within the first 90 days: » Work with the Board and management to examine immediate opportunities for financial performance improvement □ Increase focus and eliminate non - profitable acti

  25. Slide 25: Ultratech's Board Had a Disappointing Response to Our Campaign

    The need for a refreshed Board 25 Ultratech’s board had a disappointing response to our campaign □ We have engaged with the Company since August 2015, seeking to foster change » The Board has been wholly unresponsive and unwilling to accept our input □ We have suggested several new directors, includ

  26. Slide 26: Please Vote for Change: Vote the GOLD Proxy Card

    The need for a refreshed Board 26 Please vote carefully this year and vote for change Vote the GOLD proxy card We believe Neuberger Berman’s director nominees can deliver significant value for shareholders and help to hold management accountable for results

  27. Slide 27: Appendix: Our Nominees Full Biographies

    Appendix 27 Our Nominees Full Biographies

  28. Slide 28: Beatriz V. Infante

    Appendix 28 Beatriz V . Infante Since 2009 , Ms . Infante has served as Chief Executive Officer of BusinessExcelleration LLC which provides management consulting services to companies at strategic inflection points . Since 2008 , Ms . Infante has also served as a limited partner and advisor to Tande

  29. Slide 29: Ronald Black, Ph.D.

    Appendix 29 Ronald Black, Ph . D . Since 2012 , Dr . Black has served as chief executive officer and president of Rambus Inc . (“Rambus”), a technology company creating cutting - edge semiconductor and IP produces, spanning memory and interfaces to security, smart sensors and lighting . Dr . Black w

Ultratech — Proxy Contest (June 2016) on 6ix