Carmike Cinemas — Merger or Acquisition (June 2016)
17 slides from Carmike Cinemas's merger presentation, Jun 16, 2016
Slide 1: Carmike Cinemas, Inc. Exhibit 99.1
Carmike Cinemas, Inc. Exhibit 99.1
Slide 2: AMC's acquisition of Carmike: Transaction overview
AMC’s acquisition of Carmike: Transaction overview Price per share On 3/3/16, Carmike agreed to be acquired by AMC for $30.00 in cash per share for each outstanding share of Carmike’s common stock Equity value2 $756 million Enterprise value3 $1,115 million Anticipated timing The transaction will be
Slide 3: Transaction maximizes value for Carmike stockholders
Transaction maximizes value for Carmike stockholders Outsized implied offer multiple compared to historical trading multiples Offer price implies 8.0x 2016E consensus EBITDA1 Notably higher than Carmike’s average forward trading multiple over the past 1-, 2-, 3-, 5- and 10-years FV / 2017E consensus
Slide 4: Outsized implied offer multiple compared to historical trading multiples
Outsized implied offer multiple compared to historical trading multiples Historical valuation: FV / NTM EBITDA Source: FactSet, Company filings and equity research as of 6/9/16 Note: Analysis excludes Cineplex because of alternate lines of business (gaming, alternate programming, etc.) May-16 Carmik
Slide 5: Average historical NTM trading multiple vs. peers
Average historical NTM trading multiple vs. peers 1-year average Carmike’s discount (1.1x) 17% 17% 15% 17% 16% 21% 18% 3-year average 5-year average 10-year average (1.4x) (1.4x) (1.2x) (1.4x) (1.2x) (1.6x) (1.4x) 1 Carmike has traded at a discount to peers over almost all relevant timeframes No rea
Slide 6: Implied Carmike share price based on average historical NTM EBITDA trading multiples
Implied Carmike share price based on average historical NTM EBITDA trading multiples 17% 17% 15% 17% 16% 21% 18% Carmike price as of 3/3/16: $25.11 Offer price: $30.00 5-year average 10-year average 3-year average 1-year average Unaffected (3/3/16) Source: FactSet as of 6/9/16, Company press release
Slide 7: Highest large-scale transaction multiple in the sector in the past 10 years
($mm) TV/LTM EBITDA Mean: 6.5x Median: 5.9x 8.8x LTM EBITDA Source: Public filings, equity research Transaction value ($mm): $1,115 $2,600 $1,041 Acquirer: Target: Screens: 2,954 4,865 1,017 TV / Screen ($000s) $377 $534 $1,024 Transaction value ($mm): 2,600 1,041 $36 172 67 32 191 52 238 13 91 240
Slide 8: Highest large-scale transaction multiple in the sector (cont'd)
Mean: 6.5x Median: 5.9x 8.8x LTM EBITDA Source: FactSet as of 3/3/16, Public filings, equity research Note: Attendance, Revenue and Adj. EBITDA per screen metrics are calculated using average screens for trailing twelve months; Adj. EBITDA as reported Transaction value ($mm): 2,600 1,041 $36 172 67
Slide 9: Share price performance over time
Source: FactSet as of 3/3/16, Company press releases Share price performance over time 4/1/09: $2.55 Note: VWAPs calculated as of 3/3/16 3/13/15 – Reuters article reports Carmike is exploring a sale process; rumor drives share price to $34.05 - +10% in one day 3/3/16: $25.11 $30.00 offer 2/29/16 – A
Slide 10: Industry's stock price performance correlated to domestic box office expectations
Source: FactSet, Company filings, equity research and Box Office Mojo as of 6/9/16 Note: Analysis excludes Cineplex because of alternate lines of business (gaming, alternate programming, etc.) DBO for Apr. 2015 DBO for Dec. 2016 Apr. & May 2016 – Key misses: Batman vs. Superman $325mm vs. $380mm exp
Slide 11: Select analyst commentary
Select analyst commentary “2Q16 Domestic Box Office: We now estimate that the industry box office benchmark for the quarter will likely end down -11% (had been -3%). Quarter to date the industry is down 9% and at a high level, while we view "Finding Dori" as generating a stronger box office than "In
Slide 12: Analyst commentary on AMC transaction
– Wedbush, 04/06/16 – Macquarie, 04/03/16 – RBC Capital Markets, 03/08/16 – Macquarie, 03/04/16 “We believe AMC will complete its acquisition of Carmike by the end of 2016. AMC intends to acquire all outstanding shares of Carmike for $30 per share in cash, valuing Carmike at $1.1 billion, including
Slide 13: Board compared standalone plan to AMC's $30 all cash offer
The Board carefully compared the potential benefits and risks of Carmike’s standalone plan to AMC’s $30 all cash offer – among the Board’s considerations were: Industry structure – Carmike’s scale, footprint and strategy relative to competitors Investing in upgrades to existing theatres Competition
Slide 14: J.P. Morgan assessed third-party interest in the sale process
At the direction of the Board and management, J.P. Morgan thoroughly assessed third-party interest in participating in the sale process Dec 2014 Feb 2016 Jan 2015 April 2015 Jan 2016 Carmike contacts parties A, B, C, D and E: Party B, C, D and E decline to execute confidentially agreements and pass
Slide 15: Fully independent Board actively engaged in the transaction process
Carmike has a fully independent Board that was actively engaged in the transaction process 6 of 7 Carmike directors are independent, including the Chairman of the Board Board held 12 meetings to discuss the transaction, with all directors present at these meetings Negotiations with AMC were conducte
Slide 16: Carmike has scheduled a Special Meeting on June 30, 2016
Carmike has scheduled a Special Meeting on June 30, 2016 Stockholders of record at the close of business on May 18, 2016 are entitled to vote at the special meeting Stockholders will vote on the following matters: Adoption of the merger agreement Advisory vote regarding merger-related named executiv
Slide 17: Disclosure regarding forward-looking statements
Disclosure regarding forward-looking statements This presentation contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the federal securities laws. Statements that are not historical facts, including statements about Carmike Cinemas, Inc.’s (“Carmike”) beliefs, expectations and future performan