Swiss Re AG · SIX:SREN
Swiss Re — Technical Presentation (October 2023)
34 slides from Swiss Re's technical presentation, Oct 17, 2023
Slide 1: Evidence on dietary saturated and total fat
Evidence on dietary saturated and total fat Arne Astrup Professor, MD, DMSc Senior Vice President Dept. Obesity and Nutritional Sciences The Novo Nordisk Foundation, Hellerup, Denmark 1
Slide 2: Contents
Contents Saturated fat and CVD Obesity and Nutritional Sciences
Slide 3: Dietary Guidelines 2015-2020
Dietary Guidelines 2015-2020 Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Dias 3
Slide 4: Hierarchy in Scientific Evidence
Hierarchy in Scientific Evidence High Systematic Reviews (Meta-analysis) Randomized Controlled Trials Other Controlled Trials Prospective Cohort studies Case – Control studies Prevalence studies Low Ecological studies Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Animal studies
Slide 5: The WHO evidence
Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports The WHO evidence Cochrane analysis by Hooper et al 2020 reviewed RCTs with a minimum of 24 months duration. The review included 15 studies involving approximately 59,000 people and was focused on the impact of saturated fat reduction dying, heart disease
Slide 6: Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 17 October 2023
Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Dias 17 October 2023 6
Slide 7: WHO 2023
WHO 2023 Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 7
Slide 8: Questions ?
Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports Questions ? • Is it justified to treat Saturated fat as one group ? - When we now that they are composed of several different fatty acids with different chain length ? - And very different food matrices ? Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Dias 17 October 2
Slide 9: Which foods contribute to SFA intake?
Whích foods are making a contribution t SFA intake ? 6 g/100 gram 21 g/100 gram 3 g/100 gram 14 g/100 gram 19 g/100 gram 30 g/100 gram 7 g/100 gram Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 7 g/100 gram Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports
Slide 10: No effect of saturated fat – but effects of food sources
No effect of saturated fat – but effects of food sources 10
Slide 11: Yogurt consumption in relation to mortality
novo nordisk fonden Yogurt consumption in relation to mortality from cardiovascular disease, cancer, and all causes: a prospective investigation in 2 cohorts of US women and men Daniela Schmid,'? Mingyang Song,**°% Xuehong Zhang,” Walter C Willett,**” Rita Vaidya,® Edward L Giovannucci,*#” and Karin
Slide 12: Contents
Contents Saturated fat and CVD Obesity and Nutritional Sciences
Slide 13: The lipid hypothesis and CHD
The lipid hypothesis and CHD Saturated fat High blood cholesterol Atherosclerosis Obesity and Nutritional Sciences CHD
Slide 14: LDL is comprised of subclasses of particles with differing properties
LDL is comprised of subclasses of particles with differing cholesterol content and atherogenic properties Large 1 more cholesterol/particle 2 Medium 3 Small and very small Reduced plasma clearance less cholesterol/particle Greater entry into artery 4 Greater retention Faster oxidation Distribution o
Slide 15: Small, dense LDL predicts CHD in ARIC
Small, dense (sd)-LDL but not large, buoyant (lb)-LDL predicts CHD in ARIC (n=11,419; ~11 yr f/u)) Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Effects independent of total LDL-C Hoogeveen et al., ATVB 34:1069, 2014
Slide 16: Divergent effects of dietary carbohydrates and saturated fat on LDL subclasses
Divergent effects of dietary carbohydrates and saturated fat on LDL subclasses: higher carbohydrate (blue) raises only small LDL; higher saturated fat (red) raises larger LDL Change from Baseline Diet mg/dL 30 20 10 0 -10 -20 Standard LDL chol test -30 primarily reflects larger LDL -40 -50 26 39 54
Slide 17: The lipid hypothesis and CHD
The lipid hypothesis and CHD Saturated fat High blood cholesterol Atherosclerosis Obesity and Nutritional Sciences CHD
Slide 18: Contents
Contents Saturated fat and CVD Role of the food matrix Obesity and Nutritional Sciences
Slide 19: Saturated fat intake and CVD risk - the most recent evidence
Saturated fat intake and CVD risk - the most recent evidence Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 19
Slide 20: Dairy & Cardiometabolic Health: Potential Mechanisms
Dairy & Cardiometabolic Health: Potential Mechanisms Mozaffarian & Wu, Circulation Res 2018 Obesity and Nutritional Sciences
Slide 21: Ice Cream – No evidence of adverse CMD effects
Ice Creme – No evidence of adverse CMD effects: A role for ”Milk Fat Globule membrane” ? 21
Slide 22: If this had been a patented drug
Screen clipping taken: 03-05-2023 12:35 •”If this had been a patented drug”, he continued, “you can bet that the company would have done a $30 million randomized controlled trial to see if ice cream prevents diabetes.” Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 22
Slide 23: Updated meta-analysis of fermented dairy and CVD and mortality
Updated meta-analysis of fermented dairy and CVD and mortality Relative % author year exposure gender risk (95% CI) Weight Kahn 1984 Cheese Women/Men 0.99 (0.94, 1.04) 2.77 Mann 1997 Cheese Women/Men 1.02 (0.90, 1.17) 0.51 Fortes 2000 Cheese Women/Men 1.30 (0.36, 4.68) 0.01 Engberink 2009 Cheese Wom
Slide 24: Dairy contributes to prevent obesity: Childhood and adult
Dairy contributes to prevent obesity: Childhood and adult Meta-analyses of observational studies and RCT’s find that dairy in children reduce risk of obesity with beneficial effect on body composition Obesity and Nutritional Sciences
Slide 25: Effect of high vs low dairy on fat loss
Effect of high vs low dairy on fat loss Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports
Slide 26: Dairy Foods and Risk of Diabetes
Dairy Foods and Risk of Diabetes 340,234 Europeans, 8 countries, 12,403 cases 1.2 Probiotics, P-trend=0.50 Fermentation ? 1.1 Relative P-trend=0.06 P-trend=0.01 Risk of 1 Diabetes 0.9 0.8 0.7 Milk Yogurt Cheese Quintiles of Consumption Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Sluijis et al., AJCN 2012
Slide 27: Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 17 October 2023
Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Dias 17 October 2023 27
Slide 28: Effect of high vs low dairy on fat free mass
Effect of high vs low dairy on fat free mass Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports
Slide 29: From single nutrients to whole foods: the importance of the food matrix
Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports From single nutrients to whole foods: the importance of the food matrix Obesity and Nutritional Sciences
Slide 30: Obesity and Nutritional Sciences October 2023
Obesity and Nutritional Sciences 17 October 2023 Dias 30
Slide 31: Previous advice vs current evidence base on SFA
Previous advice: restrict SFA intake to reduce risk of CVD Current evidence base: health effects of SFAs depend on the interacting effects from naturally occurring food components and from unhealthy compounds introduced by processing Unprocessed red meat Complex food matrix with = = high SFA content
Slide 32: Pure fats for cooking ?
Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports Pure fats for cooking ? Obesity and Nutritional Sciences Dias 17 October 2023 32
Slide 33: Conclusions
Department of Nutrition, Exercise and Sports Conclusions • Different SFA have very different biological effects on cardio- metabolic health • SFA are rarely consumed in a pure form, and the food matrix completely alters the health effects (dark chocolate, ice crème, cheese, yoghurt, olive oil) • The
Slide 34: Thank you for your attention
Thank you for your attention Obesity and Nutritional Sciences