Morgans Hotel — Proxy Contest (May 2013)
53 slides from Morgans Hotel's proxy contest presentation, May 28, 2013
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement Information
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a
Slide 2: Filing fee and previous filing details
¨ Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the form or schedule and the date of its filing. (1) Amount previously
Slide 3: OTK Associates delivered presentation to investors and ISS
On May 28, 2013, OTK Associates delivered the following presentation to investors and Institutional Shareholder Services Inc.:
Slide 4: Last Chance for Change
1 \ May 2013 Last Chance for Change Click to edit Master text styles Click to edit Master text styles $20.00|$5.12 (-74.4%) Value Destruction 13 Feb 2006 15 Mar 2013
Slide 5: Important Information
Important SOLICITATION MORGANS AT (877) THE869-0171, SECURITIES Information HOTEL OR OF BY PROXIES GROUP STOCKHOLDERS AND EMAIL EXCHANGE CO. BY TOBECAUSE OTK INFO@OKAPIPARTNERS.COM. ASSOCIATES, ARE COMMISSION’S THEY ADVISED CONTAIN LLC TOWEBSITE AND READ IMPORTANT ITS THE 2AFFILIATES ATPROXY HTTP://
Slide 6: Table of Contents
Page #Interests CompensationMisaligned Align Section Membermichael@o-corp.com212 Executive IV: Conclusion andSummary Maximize 42Board Appendix: 3 Section ValueOTK of554 Directors OTK I:4620 Why AssociatesOur Slate and are Biographies we Poor here?Enormous Corporate Proposed 44 Table Governance Slate
Slide 7: Executive Summary
Executive enviable in Company below provide was Company’s 2006, anits obvious the the footprint, IPO All Summary appropriate attempt Company’s lodging price attempt iconic whereas toFive companies change oversight to share assets years place other the price ago in asuffered and annual large Hotel ma
Slide 8: Executive Summary
Executive compensation packages Mondrian contracts board athe regarding members with interests large Company’s world-class level, rights are With and have aSoHo Summary recent we fully offering proven and abrands fear in CEO track landlords aligned bid corporate New Morgans The that (~50% that for r
Slide 9: Table of Contents
Page #Interests CompensationMisaligned Align SectionExecutive IV: Conclusion andSummary Maximize 42Board Appendix: 3 Section ValueOTK of Directors OTK I: Why AssociatesOur Slate and are Biographies we Poor here?Enormous Corporate Proposed 44 Table Governance Slate Value ofand Contents Destruction, P
Slide 10: Enormous Value Destruction
Enormous Value Destruction 7
Slide 11: Morgans Has Significantly Underperformed Peer Groups
Morgans Hotel (74.4%) C-Corps +21.4% Has Significantly include +18.6%CHH, 5-Year Underperformed H, MAR, (63.3%) HOT, +56.8% Peer and Groups WYN +47.8%Proxy 83-Year (74.4%) Peers +2.4% Price include +59.1% Performance BYD,+98.4% RHP, Since H, 1-Year LGF, Initial (2.5%) RLH, Public SIRI, +16.6% Offeri
Slide 12: Morgans Has Significantly Underperformed Hotel C-Corps
Morgans and equals is the theHas only average Significantly stock price thatofhas the Underperformed not other recovered Hotel C-Corps (3.0%) Peers 9+18.4% at$5.12 the time Proxy (18.6%) (indexed Contest +2.1% toLaunched Morgans) +107.9%Price Stock (1) (1) Performance was Source not listed Capital S
Slide 13: Value Destruction Has Occurred Over a Long Period
Value Destruction CHH, Return Capital H,since IQMAR,IPO(1) HOT, hasTotal Occurred and Return WYNOverProxy sincea IPO(1) Long Peers Period include Morgans’ 1-Year BYD, returns Total RHP,are Return H,significantly LGF,(1)RLH, 1-Year SIRI, below Total HOT, peers Return WYN, over (1)all10 and time Total
Slide 14: Poor Strategic and Investment Decisions since IPO
Poor Strategic and Investment Decisions since IPO 11
Slide 15: Poor Execution of Asset-Light Strategy
Poorsold has management outlays, flow 12 Execution The in five order Company hotels andofto contracts brand “Asset-Light” compete andMorgans’ has company aggressively failed for management poor to Strategy This execute pursued operating wasOver characterized ancontracts management “Asset-Light” the
Slide 16: Operating Performance Has Suffered
Operating lead G&A toisdeclining right-sized Performance EBITDA for the Hasnew margins Suffered strategy .and as Source Morgans negativeCapital Net HasIncome Transitioned IQ Source (CHART) Capital to an(CHART) “Asset-Light” IQ Source Morgans’ Capital Strategy IQ “asset-light” Source Declining Capita
Slide 17: Poor Standalone and Comparative Operating Performance
Poor Standalone Proxy Peers Source andCapital Comparative IQ Source Operating CapitalPerformance IQ Source Capital vs. Hotel IQ C-Corps Source Capital vs. Hotel IQ C-Corps 14 EBITDA Growth (‘06-‘12 CAGR) Change in EBITDA Margin vs. Proxy Peers vs. Proxy Peers vs. Proxy Peers vs.
Slide 18: Excessive Cost Structure and Management Compensation
Excessive Cost Structure and Management Compensation 15
Slide 19: A Major Management G&A Load
A Major Management load 60% is 30%still Driver 43% disproportionately has 40% ofbeen Negative Asvery at 15slow Earnings March high, to cut even 2013 isexpenses Outsized after Source cutting and G&A Capital right-size G&A 16IQ Consistently by Source 12% the Company’s Capital in 2012 HighIQ As G&A G&A
Slide 20: Morgans' G&A Load is Significantly Higher than Peers
Morgans’ Corp Source Avg. Company G&A = 41% Load Filings, Proxy is Significantly Peer Capital GroupIQAvg. Source Higher = 43% Company thanHotel PeersFilings, C-Corp 17 2012Capital Avg. G&A = 7% as IQaProxy % of Current Peer Group Equity Avg.Market = 13%Capitalization Despite reducing (1) 2012 G&AG&A
Slide 21: Largest Line Item is Executive Compensation
Largestit G&A declined 2012, compensation Company was 35% continues still Line Proxy increased three Item to advisory times generate is 10%Executive higher in services negative 2012than Compensation During have the cash indicated average 2012 flow the every In ofthat Company’s 2011 other quarter Mor
Slide 22: Executive Compensation is Not Tied to Performance
Compensation Executive $21.3MM to reflect that Compensation, $21.2MM stock is Not and $9.0MM Tied option =toNormalized Performance $10.4MM awards granted Executive +3% 19 19 (13%) onExecutive March Comp (68%) 20, (1), Compensation (0%) 2011 = Total (58%) vestEBITDA ratably +16% vs. Share in$17.5MM S
Slide 23: Highest Hotel C-Corp Compensation for Lagging Performance
Highest Hotel C-Corp Industry Avg.Compensation = 0.4% Proxyfor Peer Lagging GroupPerformance Avg. = 0.9%20 Morgans’ 2011 Executive executive Comp compensation as a % of was 2011egregiously Year-End Equity above Market its peersCapitalization in 2011 Source2011 Company Executive Filings, CompCapital
Slide 24: Highest Compensation Despite Lagging Performance in 2012
Highest Avg. Morgans = 0.4% Industry overProxy 2012 Compensation Peer Source Group Company Avg. for Lagging =Filings, 0.6% Performance Despite Capitalcutting IQ 21executive 2012 Executive compensation Comp as73% a %inof2012, Current Morgans’ Equity executive Market Capitalization compensation2012 is
Slide 25: Proxy advisory say-on-pay results
Proxy say lag was This of ashareholder lot alignment behind onnot of plan Advisory pay dilution strongly failed index vs. interests between average for several Services performance-based.” andthe are industry the support shareholders important being Agree company’s peers. carefully of Morgans’ ~90%
Slide 26: Misaligned Board of Directors and Poor Corporate Governance
Misaligned Board of Directors and Poor Corporate Governance 23
Slide 27: Current Board Members Have Overseen Value Destruction
Current board Company’s lodging Stockholders members directors sector largest orHe have Serve have had, convertible been on overseen however, aon Public the debt the worked board Company and actions since preferred forthat Ron Board 2008 have Burkle security or resulted earlier from holder Only in 2
Slide 28: Board Misaligned Through Yucaipa Connections
Misaligned Partnered President Board through connected Needs OTK and with toBoard Ron the CEO Only Yucaipa vote Burkle ofof Board Directors of Americold, since the member Yucaipa 2004 25 aMichael Sourced truly Yucaipa block representing Gross inopportunities portfolio order Jeffrey toshareholders co
Slide 29: Existing Directors are not Qualified to Serve on the Morgans' Board
Existing Directors are not Qualified to Serve on the Morgans’ Board Board Board 26
Slide 30: Table of Contents
Page #Interests CompensationMisaligned Align SectionExecutive IV: Conclusion andSummary Maximize 42Board Appendix: 3 Section ValueOTK of Directors OTK I: Why AssociatesOur Slate and are Biographies we Poor here?Enormous Corporate Proposed 44 Table Governance Slate Value ofand Contents Destruction, P
Slide 31: Yucaipa Transaction Overview
Yucaipa Continue maximize common have $100MM depressedTransaction information $230MM selling a mere a Transaction significant stock transition rights of valueDelano relating 2.375% debt, Will offering simplifies to strengthen amount to Overview coupon enables “asset-light” the South at $7.50 $6.00/s
Slide 32: Timeline of Recent Events
Boardataction declined vote dominated Taubman Offering OTK swift holding Timeline filed of the originally the was Directors of Kalisman, ameeting board Recent and motion offer “critical voluntarily announce stating scheduled received had Events to Morgans to join been the the March the aagreed aComp
Slide 33: Court Ruling on Yucaipa Transaction
duty attempting large size rights benefit case, of and either Court taint. time the the of and when based stockholder So aRuling Sides offering resolutions the of record full ifchange an rights their you to on trial with open “On reset date. would the act actions is the offering OTK and taken April
Slide 34: Re-Electing Current Board Would Be Destructive
Re-Electing 21% margin performance, Burkle’s with the including continue words the over business company’s friend its the of“oversight” the current conduct executive same Andrew Current Seven period own director exposed assets compensation Sasson during Board governance TheJeff previously in Company
Slide 35: Table of Contents
Page #Interests CompensationMisaligned Align SectionExecutive IV: Conclusion andSummary Maximize 42Board Appendix: 3 Section ValueOTK of Directors OTK I: Why AssociatesOur Slate and are Biographies we Poor here?Enormous Corporate Proposed 44 Table Governance Slate Value ofand Contents Destruction, P
Slide 36: Introduction to OTK Associates
Introduction common footprint, management shares) iconic to to OTK squander assets in Morgans Associates in resources major more markets, OTK than andisfive miss aand partnership years opportunities potential ago of and forfamilies significant has to capitalize solddeeply nogrowth shares on involved
Slide 37: We Can Right the Ship
We Balance the Can Right Sheet the Ship 34 First: Replace Board of Directors Second: Reduce Excessive Cost Structure Successfully Execute “Asset-Light” Strategy Re-Establish Brand Value & Explore Growth Opportunities Restructure
Slide 38: Why Our Slate is More Qualified
Why Our lodging Robert lodging, estate experience FriedmanBackground experience and Slate leisure is Ira More Ronald Jeffrey TochnerPartner Qualified W. M.inBurkleFounder GaultPreviously the Why entertainment at Our the Yucaipa Slate and Division isindustry Managing Companies More President Qualifie
Slide 39: Committed to Smooth Management Transition
Committed However, operating duties 4as needed as directors responsibilities we totohelp recognize Working newly We would with the hired and risk Existing begin provide professionals thataexisting formal Management a permanent get search management up to solution To process, speed ensure may A in em
Slide 40: Immediately Take Action to Right-Size G&A Expenses
Immediately has creating the experience valueTake for shareholders Action and relationships to Right-Size Only to approximately work G&Awith Expenses management $4MM 37 $6.15/sh of G&A to right-size $16.35/sh in 2012expenses is (CHART) relatedby to cutting public Value Creation company excessive Thr
Slide 41: Asset-Light Strategy Done the Right Way
“Asset-Light” cities, properties, properties asset-light and (excluding final whooffers should model, in change have the Strategy We aevent be but desire of are identical control only only we Done toare by pay interested events) the to testing elected Morgans the Right underwriting Utilize the Capit
Slide 42: Delano Market Value and Further Deleveraging
39EBITDA in Market per management Morgans key Value Based as could fees); Based on a result $46.5MM generate and onof90% equity contracts an acquisition ofadditional research the signed $15.0MM from of~$385MM with 90%JMP acquisition Delano of Securities thebyequity South running of the on interests
Slide 43: Re-establish Morgans' Brand Value
Re-establish Morgans’ independent, non-flagged Brand portfolios Value 40thatUtilize are actively the vast looking network to of be our flagged proposed Understand slate toand signcapitalize new dealsonand thegrow core strengths the platform of the prudently CompanyProtect whencurrent signingmanageme
Slide 44: Restructure the Balance Sheet
Our Slate Morgans solutions balance Obligation sheet will available has Includes likely for the future Experience tohave $172MM thegrowth—% Company difficulty toofRestructure Convertible refinancing and of Total to help Morgans’ Debt Notes debt restructure 36% Includes at Balance attractive 36%the 1
Slide 45: Table of Contents
Page #Interests CompensationMisaligned Align SectionExecutive IV: Conclusion andSummary Maximize 42Board Appendix: 3 Section ValueOTK of Directors OTK I: Why AssociatesOur Slate and are Biographies we Poor here?Enormous Corporate Proposed 44 Table Governance Slate Value ofand Contents Destruction, P
Slide 46: Conclusion
Conclusion value company Skillset of time deals toofact to negotiated, its faces restructure isbrands IfNOW! we a number doIfthe 43 not this the restructuring take of board forthcoming credit action is allowed challenges now that balance to will toeffectuate continue over be sheet required thematuri
Slide 47: Table of Contents
Page #Interests CompensationMisaligned Align SectionExecutive IV: Conclusion andSummary Maximize 42Board Appendix: 3 Section ValueOTK of Directors OTK I: Why AssociatesOur Slate and are Biographies we Poor here?Enormous Corporate Proposed 44 Table Governance Slate Value ofand Contents Destruction, P
Slide 48: OTK Slate Biographies
Lieb 2006 4S Mor 2013 $20.00] $5.12 (-74.4%) Volue Destruction OTK Slate Biographies OTK Associates, LLC 45
Slide 49: Proposed Board Member Bios
Proposed development, which residential particular, Chief founding Stanford with Mr. director expertise business Kalisman aExecutive is Bachelor of aof address Graduate The in Board Mr. subsidiary units, Morgans Morgans theTalisman operations has Dougherty real of Member Officer and isalso School Ar
Slide 50: Proposed Board Member Bios
Proposed estateinvestment business his 2010 University Mr. turnaround 2011, square Operating Harvard managing Avenue, Candidate experience Langer’s to Ms. feet March University New address Board member Olshan Officer Bios of of experience. business Pennsylvania York, office in 2011, üMember is compa
Slide 51: Proposed Board Member Bios
48 OTK sectors multi-billion Mr. laude industries, investment public advised Management. Masters expertise Olshan from and such real of Candidate inincluding private Business Harvard firm, firm also the estate as dollar Mr. real real with serves since Vora companies and Bios investment estate,infras
Slide 52: Information relating to participants in this proxy solicitation
Information relating to the above-named participants in this proxy solicitation is filed herewith as Exhibit 1. STOCKHOLDERS ARE ADVISED TO READ THE PROXY STATEMENT FILED BY OTK ASSOCIATES, LLC ON MAY 22, 2013 AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO SOLICITATION OF PROXIES BY OTK ASSOCIATES, LLC AND ITS AFFI
Slide 53: Exhibit 1: Interests of participants in the solicitation
EXHIBIT 1 Direct and indirect interests of participants in the solicitation. Securities of Morgans Hotel Group Participant Co. beneficially owned Other Interests OTK Associates, LLC 4,500,000 common shares John Dougherty None Jason Taubman Kalisman None Mr. Kalisman is currently a director of Morgan