Zale — Proxy Contest (May 2014)
7 slides from Zale's proxy contest presentation, May 16, 2014
Slide 1: Zale: A Turnaround Story Cut Short? The Right Deal But The Wrong Price
Zale: A Turnaround Story Cut Short? The Right Deal But The Wrong Price TIG Advisors’ Response to the ISS Presentation filed by Zale May 16, 2014 TIG ADVISORS, LLC Registered Investment Adviser
Slide 2: Merger Fails to Provide Compelling Value
Merger Fails to Provide Compelling Value On 5/13/14 Zale filed presentation materials for use in a meeting with Institutional Shareholder Services in support of their agreed upon deal with Signet Jewelers for $21 per share in cash. We believe these materials present a flawed analysis in a number
Slide 3: Flawed Comparable Transactions Analysis
Flawed Comparable Transactions Analysis Zale’s 5/13/14 presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services includes a range of precedent transactions that omit some surprisingly obvious transactions for comparison. In formulating F2013 executive compensation, the Zale Board amended their previous
Slide 4: Flawed Premium-Paid Analysis
Flawed Premium-Paid Analysis The premium paid analyses shown in Zale’s slide presentation are flawed for at least four reasons: A reliance on LTM figures is a flawed approach for a business in turnaround. The Street’s expectations for Zale’s margin expansion potential were significantly below
Slide 5: Compelling Standalone Prospects
Compelling Standalone Prospects Zale’s 5/13/14 presentation appears to make the point that the base case F2016 plan is a “stretch” objective that may be difficult to achieve – we do not believe these projections should be dismissed. In our view, even the “Alternative” case would represent extrem
Slide 6: Merger Fails to Provide Fair Value
Merger Fails to Provide Fair Value In our opinion, valuing Zale (or any business undergoing a turnaround) based on LTM figures is a flawed approach. This is particularly the case given the successful turnaround Management has been executing over the past three years and the robust margin expansion
Slide 7: Zale – A Turnaround Story Cut Short? Right Deal, Wrong Price
Zale – A Turnaround Story Cut Short? Right Deal, Wrong Price TIG Advisors is a 9.5% holder of Zale Corporation and intends to vote AGAINST the transaction with Signet. Financial projections disclosed with Zale’s proxy materials are compelling and make it clear that the standalone value of Zale i