Discovery Limited · JSE:DSY
Discovery — Discovery Health Medical Scheme — Shareholder Meeting (June 2014)
55 slides from Discovery's shareholder meeting presentation, Jun 6, 2014
Slide 1: Discovery Health presentation to Discovery Health Medical Scheme AGM
Discovery Health presentation to Discovery Health Medical Scheme AGM 6th June 2014 Dr Jonathan Broomberg, CEO, Discovery Health 1
Slide 2: 2013 key facts and figures
Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 key facts and figures 2 564 313 lives covered (2012: 2 469 023) 4.6% average increase in principal members (2012: 6%) 4.15% scheme lapse rate (2012: 4.1%) R9.9 billion in reserves (2012: R8.2 billion) R1.5 billion net surplus (2012: R789 million) 96.9% in-hospita
Slide 3: Discovery Health's vision
Discovery Health’s vision An organisation that makes people healthier, offers them the broadest and best benefit choices at the lowest cost per unit of benefit, inside a healthcare system that is seamless, accessible and brilliantly serviced within a broader sustainable healthcare system for all Sou
Slide 4: Agenda
Agenda #1 Key challenges facing Discovery Health Medical Scheme and SA private healthcare system #2 Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme 4
Slide 5: Key challenges facing the Scheme and SA private healthcare system
Key challenges facing Discovery Health Medical Scheme and SA private healthcare system Medical inflation rising faster than CPI 1 2 3 Rising burden of lifestyle Variable quality of care diseases and value for patients 5
Slide 6: Medical inflation is a global issue
Medical inflation is a global issue Out of 52 countries surveyed, SA had the 8th lowest net medical inflation 9.0 8.0 7.0 6.0 Net inflation (%) 5.0 8.5 8.4 4.0 8.0 6.8 3.0 5.7 5.4 5.4 5.1 5.0 2.0 4.6 3.8 3.3 3.3 3.0 2.7 1.0 0.0 Malaysia Brazil Canada France Italy Chile UAE Mexico Singapore Russia SA
Slide 7: SA medical inflation is not all about tariffs
SA medical inflation is not all about tariffs - volume of services is a critical cost driver Medical Inflation: 2009 – 2013 16% 14.8% A Supply-side drivers: 14% Fee for service system 3.9% 12.0% Fragmentation of care 12% 11.5% New technology & procedures 10.7% 10.1% New hospitals 10% 4.1% 9.6% 4.5%
Slide 8: High cost drugs and new technologies are driving costs
High cost drugs and new technologies are driving costs Rapid increases in use of high cost drugs and da Vinci™ Surgical System technology Spend per patient per annum High cost drugs R 40 858 R 34 462 10x 44 cases funded so far ~R186 000 per case >2 times the cost of the alternative Average chronic s
Slide 9: Ageing and increasing lifestyle disease burden are also driving costs
Ageing and increasing lifestyle disease burden are also driving costs Epidemic of lifestyle diseases Increasing disease burden in private schemes Disease burden index, % 17% Four controllable behaviours +6% 4 Unhealthy eating, physical inactivity, smoking & alcohol due to disease burden 11% Four chr
Slide 10: Variable quality and value for patients in our healthcare system
Variable quality and value for patients in our healthcare system Description Wastage – Low estimate1 % R’bn Total Wastage 21% 25 Overtreatment 5.9% 7.2 Administrative 4.0% 4.9 complexity Failures of care delivery 3.8% 4.6 Pricing failures 3.2% 3.9 Fraud and abuse 3.1% 3.8 Failures of care 0.9% 1.1 c
Slide 11: Variable quality of care between different private hospitals
Variable quality of care between different private hospitals Mortality rate for Acute Myocardial infarction (%), In hospital antibiotic utilisation 2008 - 2011 35% 200 30% 180 177 160 25% 140 20% 120 100 15% 80 Average = 77 10% 60 EU average = 5.5 - 7.8% SA average = 7.4% 40 39 5% 20 0% 0 N=111 hosp
Slide 12: Agenda
Agenda #1 Key challenges facing Discovery Health Medical Scheme and SA private healthcare system #2 Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme 12
Slide 13: Discovery Health's vision and strategies for the Scheme
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme 1 Lowest healthcare costs of any medical scheme in SA 2 Make members healthier Build a Discovery healthcare system that ensures superior quality 3 and value for members 1st Best service experience and seamless patient journ
Slide 14: Lowest healthcare costs of any medical scheme in SA
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme 1 Lowest healthcare costs of any medical scheme in SA 1st 14
Slide 15: Significant increase in fraud recoveries and savings
1 Significant increase in fraud recoveries and savings 14% increase in fraud and forensic R467m cumulative Halo effect savings in 2013 14% 288 Post intervention impact on GP practice 700 83% 253 600 500 Paid per claimant 400 138 300 200 100 - 2011 2012 2013 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 1
Slide 16: Effective medicines management saves R600m per annum
Effective medicines management saves 1 Discovery Health Medical Scheme R600m per annum Out of hospital chronic medicines Significant drive to reduce the cost of statins R63m R73m Savings in 2013 Savings per annum 100% Average cost per script per annum 176 90% Brand 30% 27% 36% 80% 45% 42% 43% 48% 70
Slide 17: Interventions save R4.7bn per annum
1 Discovery Health and Vitality’s interventions save Discovery Health Medical Scheme R4.7bn per annum R38.2bn R1.4bn -3.8% R1.0bn -2.7% R1.0bn -2.6% R1.2bn -3.2% R33.5bn Potential claims Tariff savings Cost protection Risk Management Vitality Impact Actual claims expenditure through networks savings
Slide 18: Exclusive discounts through Discovery Health's partnerships
Scheme members also have access to a range of exclusive 1 discounts through Discovery Health’s partnerships Discovery Health Medical Scheme members saved ~R95m in 2013 MedSaver ChroniCare Optometry Stem cell cryogenics Optometry network Save up to 25% on Save up to 25% on Save up to 25% on Save up t
Slide 19: Cost inflation lower than all other open schemes
1 Cost inflation within Discovery Health Medical Scheme is lower than all other open schemes Open Schemes excluding Discovery Health Medical Scheme Discovery Health Medical Scheme (% growth in pabpm costs – 2008 baseline) (% growth in pabpm costs – 2008 baseline) Pathology 40% Specialists 33% Radiol
Slide 20: Admin and managed care fees: 2008-2014
1 Discovery Health Medical Scheme - admin and managed care fees: 2008-2014 R 154 4.2% R pabpm nominal increase per year R 120 R 105 2.2% real decrease per year 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Nominal (Rpabpm) Real (Rpabpm) 20
Slide 21: Make members healthier
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2 Make members healthier 1st 21
Slide 22: Making members healthier through Vitality
2 Making members healthier through Vitality Member gym visits (million) Significant increase in use of fitness devices 25.7 24.1 51% 24 768 21.4 16 373 19 2010 2011 2012 2013 December 2013 April 2014 Discovery sponsored walks Park Runs 22
Slide 23: 26% increase in health screenings between 2011 and 2013
2 26% increase in health screenings between 2011 and 2013 Glucose Cholesterol HIV counselling Blood Pressure Weight Pap Smear Prostate Screening Mammogram - 100 000 200 000 300 000 400 000 500 000 2013 2012 2011 23
Slide 24: Screening picks up cancer cases earlier and reduces costs
2 Screening picks up cancer cases earlier and reduces costs of treatment Proportion of members Average cost per cancer case Cancer stage at diagnosis undertaking screening 69% R62 300 5 823 -9% Stage 2,3 57% and 4 R57 000 5 328 39% Stage 1 58% 64% Blue Bronze Silver + No screen Screen No Screen Scre
Slide 25: New Discovery Wellness experience for members at work
New Discovery Wellness experience for 2 Discovery Health Medical Scheme members at work Measures 15 health metrics in 12 minutes Benefits of a successful corporate wellness strategy 1 Reduced absenteeism – 15% fewer sick days 2 Lower healthcare costs – 18% lower claims costs 3 Improved productivity
Slide 26: Build a Discovery healthcare system for superior quality and value
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme Build a Discovery healthcare system 3 that ensures superior quality and value for members 1st 26
Slide 27: Healthcare 2020: Patient centred care focused on quality and value
3 Healthcare 2020: Patient centred care focused on quality and value 1 Integrate practice units & delivery systems Quality best Value = max Cost 3 lowest 2 Move to Measure bundled outcomes payments and costs 4 Source: Modified from The Strategy That Will Fix Health Care Michael E. Porter and Thomas
Slide 28: Listening to the patient's voice is a key step to improve quality
3 Listening to the patient’s voice is a key step to improve quality Discovery Health Patient Hospital Experience Survey Nursing staff 6% 15% 79% Responsiveness of staff 12% 21% 67% Doctors 13% 85% Hospital environment 14% 19% 65% Pain management 10% 19% 69% Medication info 26% 20% 50% Never Usually
Slide 29: Monitoring and improving quality of care in private hospitals
3 Monitoring and improving quality of care in private hospitals Decrease in hospital antibiotic utilisation Decrease in hospital infections Utilisation for extended treatment of 7 DDDs CLABSI Rates / 1000 central days 35.0% 31.9% 2008 - Q1 2008 - Q2 2008 - Q3 2008 - Q4 2009 - Q1 2009 - Q2 2009 - Q3
Slide 30: Discovery Health's KidneyCare Programme
3 Discovery Health’s KidneyCare Programme ~4,200 kidney failure patients ~1,500 renal dialysis patients Kidney disease mortality rate for Population distribution of average member scores Discovery Health Medical Scheme 16% 16% 14% 14% 5% Improvement in 12% 4.2% 12% scores 10% 1.6% 10% 8% 13.8% 8% 6%
Slide 31: Best in industry service experience and seamless patient journeys
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme Best in industry service experience 4 and seamless patient journeys through the healthcare system 1st 1st 31
Slide 32: Industry leading service measures
4 Industry leading service measures First Call Resolution rate outperforms Claims Efficiency industry averages 90% 6 4.84 Days 85% Received to Paid – Health Professional 83% 5 80% 4 77% 75% 3 1.75 Days 70% Received to Paid - Member 2 Industry Average: 68% 65% 1 0.17 Days Received to Processed 60% 0
Slide 33: Independent evaluations confirm best in industry service performance
4 Independent evaluations confirm Discovery Health’s best in industry service performance FIA Healthcare ‘Product Supplier for the Year’ since 2008 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2008 2011 Discovery Health Independent Survey Ratings Industry average Industry (excl DHMS) Discovery 8.6 9% 9% 12% 9% 8.1
Slide 34: Building a world class digital eco-system for members and doctors
Further progress on building a world class digital 4 eco-system for members and doctors Member app HealthID Telemetry Website “I need medicine” “I need a doctor” SmartAdvisor 34
Slide 35: HealthID is a critical strategy to improve quality and efficiency of care
HealthID is a critical strategy to improve the quality and 4 efficiency of care HealthID new features Doctor Notes Hospital summary Telemetric Diabetic Glucose Monitoring Vitality measures Current progress > 1,200 active doctor users (target of 3000) > 450,000 members consented 35
Slide 36: Case Study: Saving lives in the operating theatre
4 Case Study: Saving lives in the operating theatre Dr Atiya (anaesthetist) Patient: 5 year old child undergoing a dental procedure When asked, the parent did not mention any past surgeries “When I unbuttoned the child's pyjama top, I was faced with a large midline sternotomy scar” Parent: "Oh, that
Slide 37: Extensive new features in Discovery Member App
4 Extensive new features in Discovery Member App Carry an electronic Track claims and medical membership card spend Personal health records Request a document Take a photo of a claim and View information on hospital send it to us procedures Order door-to-door medicine Translate cover into one of del
Slide 38: Cleveland Clinic MyConsult online medical second opinion program
4 Cleveland Clinic MyConsult online medical second opinion program Providing members the opportunity to consult with experts from Cleveland Clinic Giving doctors access to second medical opinions from international healthcare experts and members peace of mind 38
Slide 39: Discovery MedXpress service expanding to specialised high cost medicines
4 Discovery MedXpress service expanding to specialised high cost medicines Home New service: Procurement, dispensing and delivery of specialised Work high cost medicines Benefits: Improved access Holiday High quality medicine delivery service Door-to-door medicine delivery Extending patients benefit
Slide 40: Ensure outstanding financial performance and sustained healthy growth
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme Ensure outstanding 5 financial performance and sustained healthy growth 1st 40
Slide 41: Scheme continues to deliver exceptional financial performance
5 Discovery Health Medical Scheme continues to deliver exceptional financial performance in all areas Healthy net surplus Increasing reserves Highest credit rating 1534 24.3% solvency 9.9 8.2 7.3 6.8 6.1 791 789 5.3 594 4.3 570 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Improving lo
Slide 42: Sustained high growth rates coupled with low lapse rates
5 Sustained high growth rates coupled with low lapse rates Net growth in lives Low withdrawals and lapses (31 Dec 2007 – 31 Dec 2012) 554 239 24.6% 10.8% 4.2% -745 562 Open Schemes excl. Industry DHMS DHMS Discovery Health Discovery Health withdrawal rate withdrawal rate lapse rate Medical Scheme Me
Slide 43: Addressing loss making benefit options
5 Addressing loss making benefit options Significant improvement in loss making 2013 Surplus and Deficit plans plans 1 Classic Comprehensive 2012 2013 Surplus plans R2 258 m -R 384m +31% -R 558m 2 KeyCare Plus Deficit plans R 724 m 2012: R1 057m -R 90m +63% -R 242m 2013 Actual Surplus R1 535 m 3 Exe
Slide 44: Discovery Health's vision and strategies for the Scheme
Discovery Health’s vision and strategies for Discovery Health Medical Scheme 1 Lowest healthcare costs of any medical scheme in SA 2 Make members healthier Build a Discovery healthcare system that ensures superior quality 3 and value for members 1st Best service experience and seamless patient journ
Slide 45: Discovery Health presentation to Discovery Health Medical Scheme AGM
Discovery Health presentation to Discovery Health Medical Scheme AGM 6th June 2014 Dr Jonathan Broomberg, CEO, Discovery Health 45
Slide 46: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 47: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 48: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 49: Board of Trustee Appointment
Discovery Health Medical Scheme Board of Trustee Appointment Mr. Giles Waugh Qualification: FIA (Fellow of the Institute of Actuaries UK) FASSA (Fellow of the Actuarial Society of South Africa) Number of years experience : 33 years – 6 in a Life Insurer, 9 consulting in UK and Europe, 18 years consu
Slide 50: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 51: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 52: Motions
Motions The motion proposes that all trustees, both current and future declare on an oath binding on their conscience that: 1. They were duly elected by the members of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme with votes generated by them without the assistance of any related parties, especially parties o
Slide 53: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 54: Agenda
Agenda 1. Welcome and quorum 2. Minutes of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme 2013 Annual General Meeting – for approval 3. 2013 Annual Financial Statements 3.1 Financial performance of the Discovery Health Medical Scheme for the year ended 31 December 2013 3.2 Discovery Health (Pty) Ltd strategic
Slide 55: 2014 Annual General Meeting
2014 Annual General Meeting 6th June 2014
Discovery Health Medical Scheme — Shareholder Meeting (June 2014) on 6ix