Arlington Asset Investment Corp
Arlington Asset Investment — Proxy Contest (May 2016)
65 slides from Arlington Asset Investment's proxy contest presentation, May 12, 2016
Slide 1: Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment, Spring 2016
This presentation shall not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any securities . Information contained herein is based on data obtained from recognized statistical services, issuer reports or communications, or other sources, believed to be reliable . However, we have
Slide 2: Agenda
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 2 I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Arlington Asset Investment III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion
Slide 3: An Introduction to Imation Corp.
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 3 An Introduction to Imation Corp. • Imation Corp. ("Imation") is a NYSE - listed company that has just completed a successful restructuring and is now poised to deploy its significant excess cash – Legacy business lines were in consumer
Slide 4: Overview of Arlington Asset Investment Corp.
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 4 Overview of Arlington Asset Investment Corp. (NYSE: AI) • Arlington Asset Investment Corp. (“Arlington” or the “Company”) is a publicly - traded investment firm that acquires and holds a levered portfolio of residential mortgage - back
Slide 5: Arlington's strategy cannot generate reasonable equity returns
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 5 • Arlington Asset Investment’s underlying investment strategy is unable to generate a reasonable equity return given the nature of the securities it owns, its limited capital base and the high expense load • The agency MBS it owns are
Slide 6: Board should be held accountable for strategic missteps
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 6 • We believe the Board of Directors should be held accountable for the strategic missteps and the failure of the executive team – Directors have overseen years of shareholder value destruction and poor financial results – The independe
Slide 7: Arlington Has Significantly Underperformed Its Peers
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 7 -50% -30% -10% 10% 30% 50% 70% 90% Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11 Apr-12 Aug-12 Dec-12 Apr-13 Aug-13 Dec-13 Apr-14 Aug-14 Dec-14 Apr-15 Aug-15 Dec-15 AI '15 Peer Group FTSE NAREIT mREITs Index S&P 500 Index Arlington Has Significantly Underperfo
Slide 8: We Believe the Board Has Failed As Fiduciaries to Shareholders
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 8 Issues Under Current Leadership Board Responsibility Results Corporate Leadership Setting the Strategy and Capital Allocation Managing Risk Corporate Governance We Believe the Board of Directors Has Failed As Fiduciaries to Shareholder
Slide 9: We Have Identified a Clear Plan to Execute
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 9 The Path Forward Board Responsibility Plans and Goals for the Future Corporate Leadership and a Better Management Model Overseeing Portfolio Management and Risk Management A Reduced SG&A Load Corporate Governance We Have Identified a C
Slide 10: Existing Board of Directors
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 10 Existing Board of Directors Arlington Asset Investment Corp. Directors Daniel J. Altobello Chairman, Altobello Family LP Former Chairman, Onex Food Services Daniel E. Berce CEO and President, General Motors Financial Company David W.
Slide 11: Our Vision for a New Board
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 11 Our Vision for a New Board Consists of Changing Five Members Our Group's Nominated Directors Scott R. Arnold Managing Director and Senior Portfolio Manager, Clinton Group, Inc. Former Board Member, Herald National Bank Former Chairman
Slide 12: History of Value Destruction at Arlington
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 12 I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Arlington Asset Investment III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion
Slide 13: Value Destruction: A Longer History Back to FBR's Troubles
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 13 -100.0% -90.0% -80.0% -70.0% -60.0% -50.0% -40.0% -30.0% -20.0% -10.0% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% Jan-06 Jun-07 Nov-08 Apr-10 Sep-11 Feb-13 Aug-14 Jan-16 Eric Billings Rock Tonkel Value Destruction: A Longer History Back to FBR’s Troubles
Slide 14: Value Destruction: Stock Price Last 5 Years
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 14 -50.0% -40.0% -30.0% -20.0% -10.0% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% 90.0% 100.0% 110.0% 120.0% Mar-11 Sep-12 Feb-14 Jul-15 Eric Billings Rock Tonkel Value Destruction: Stock Price Last 5 Years Source: Company filin
Slide 15: Calculating Returns on a Per Share Basis Since Inception
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 15 Calculating Returns on a Per Share Basis – Since Arlington’s Inception Source: CapitalIQ and Company Filings. Evolution of Tangible Book Value Per Share and Dividends Per Share • We calculated the returns to shareholders totaling tang
Slide 16: Measuring Performance on Their Metrics and Methodology
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 16 Measuring Performance on their Metrics and Methodology Source: CapitalIQ and Company Filings. Note: The Company changed its disclosure and definition of Non - GAAP Core Operating Income after 2012, and thus financial metric s for 2010
Slide 17: Disclosure in the Company's 2015 10-K
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 17 Disclosure in the Company’s 2015 10 - K Source: Company Filings. “The Company’s investment strategy for its agency MBS portfolio is to generate a net interest margin on the leveraged assets and hedge changes in the market value of the
Slide 18: Our Approach to Measuring Performance is Simpler and More Practical
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 18 Our Approach to Measuring Performance is Simpler and More Practical Source: CapitalIQ and Company Filings. • We look at tangible book value creation over time, excluding dividends and stock issuances – We analyze the value contributor
Slide 19: History of Private Label MBS Investing
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 19 History of Private Label MBS Investing Source: CapitalIQ. AI Level 3 Asset Portfolio 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Private-label MBS Trading $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $0.0 $2.9 Available-for-sale Senior 51.0 170.1 7.5 7.1 0.0 0.0 Re-REMIC s
Slide 20: Can Money Be Made in this Business Today? Step I
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 20 A Threshold Question – Can Money Be Made in this Business Today? We Attempt to Construct A Theoretical Earnings Model: • Step I is to calculate the option adjusted spreads of the agency portfolio • We have identified comparable asset
Slide 21: Can Money Be Made in this Business Today? Step II
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 21 A Threshold Question – Can Money Be Made in this Business Today? We Attempt to Construct A Theoretical Earnings Model: • Step II is to examine the Company’s financing and further adjust it for the termination of FHLB advances Financin
Slide 22: Historical Hedging Strategy and Negative Contribution
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 22 Historical Hedging Strategy and Negative Contribution Source: CapitalIQ and Company Filings. * The Company also has minimal disclosure on a position in put options on Eurodollar futures with a notional value of $4 billion as of Decemb
Slide 23: 2015 Hedge Losses as a % of Adjusted Tangible Book
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 23 - 20% - 18% - 9% - 5% - 7% - 11% AI ARR EARN MITT MTGE WMC 2015 Hedge Losses as a % of Adjusted 2014 Tangible Book Note: We selected a subset of the peers in the FTSE NAREIT mREIT Index based on relatively similar market capitalizatio
Slide 24: Prospective Changes to Value Assuming a Parallel Shift in the Curve
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 24 Prospective Changes to Value Assuming a Parallel Shift in the Curve Note : We selected a subset of the peers in the FTSE NAREIT mREIT Index based on relatively similar market capitalization and por tfo lio composition (predominance of
Slide 25: Last Word on Risk: Dividend Foundation and True Leverage
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 25 $16.82 $10.08 $1.52 $0.77 $6.75 $11.52 $1.16 $23.25 FY 2013 Tangible Book per Share Interest Income Investment Losses SG&A and Opex Private Label MBS Contribution Other and Timing Differences Dividends Paid FY 2015 Tangible Book per S
Slide 26: Board Decisions Have Destroyed Value
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 26 Board Decisions Have Destroyed Value Board Responsibility Decision Made Consequences for Stockholders Investing in a portfolio of agency MBS and Private - Label MBS Setting Strategy ▪ - 15.3% in dividend - adjusted stock performance l
Slide 27: Current Compensation Practices
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 27 I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Arlington Asset Investment III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion
Slide 28: Executive Compensation Since 2011
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 28 • Since 2011, the Company has paid its three named executive officers (“NEOs”) a total of $36.8 million – A n average of nearly $7.4 million per year – Most of the compensation came from a non - equity incentive plan (cash bonus) base
Slide 29: Board Compensation Since 2011
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 29 Board Compensation Since 2011 • Since 2011, the Company has paid its Board of Directors a total of $4.9 million, and an average of $1.0 million per year ‒ Board Compensation has trended upward 7.1% per annum the last two years Source:
Slide 30: Cumulative Board and Executive Compensation vs. Book Value
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 30 Cumulative Board and Executive Compensation vs. Book Value • Cumulative compensation expense and benefits was $36.8 million, and cumulative board compensation was $4.9 million • During the same period, IRR to shareholders was 4.9% Cum
Slide 31: Has Bonus Pay Been Aligned with Shareholder Results?
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 31 Has Bonus Pay Been Aligned with Shareholder Results? Bonus and Performance Share Unit Compensation Do Not Seem to Match Shareholder Value Creation Our Take: • The bonus plan appears devoid of any connection to shareholder value creati
Slide 32: Bonus Payments and the Company's Adjusted ROE Construct
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 32 Fiscal Year End 12/31 2012 2013 2014 2015 Average Shareholder's Equity Stockholders' Equity $465.2 $551.8 $645.3 $484.0 Deferred Tax Asset (162.3) (165.9) (125.6) (97.5) Adj. Stockholders' Equity 302.9 386.0 519.7 386.5 Pro Rata Porti
Slide 33: Peer Comparison
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 33 Peer Comparison • 2015 p roxy peers have a mean market cap and tangible book value of $1.0 billion and $1.1 billion, respectively, w ell in excess of Arlington – Mean total director pay for directors serving a full year at Arlington w
Slide 34: Insider Ownership and Open Market Sales
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 34 Our Take: • The total economic ownership of the Company’s directors and officers is a paltry 2.7% • A low ownership level coupled with an attractive current cash salary and bonus may alter management’s tolerance for high leverage and
Slide 35: What if They Were Treated Like a Hedge Fund?
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 35 Last Word on Comp – What if they were treated like a Hedge Fund? Source: Company Filings, Bloomberg and CapitalIQ . Note: Our analysis assumes management gets the benefit of earnings generated from new equity raised. High Water Mark C
Slide 36: The Path Forward
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 36 I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Arlington Asset Investment III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion
Slide 37: Our Vision for a New Board
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 37 Our Vision for a New Board Consists of Changing Five Members Our Group's Nominated Directors Scott R. Arnold Managing Director and Senior Portfolio Manager, Clinton Group, Inc. Former Board Member, Herald National Bank Former Chairman
Slide 38: Plan Going Forward
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 38 Plan Going Forward Assist / oversee key activities: ▪ Reconstitution of investment portfolio ▪ Recalibration of current hedging strategies − Hedging risk across the curve − Not taking a directional bet on the market ▪ Expand the asset
Slide 39: The Path to New Management
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 39 The Path to New Management • The newly composed Board of Directors will solicit the best management deal from outside asset managers based on qualificatio ns, business strategy and proposed compensation in an RFP process – The incumbe
Slide 40: Repositioning the MBS Book: Portfolio Construction
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 40 Agency MBS RMBS 2.0 CMBS Repositioning the MBS Book – Portfolio Construction Source: JP Morgan and Citigroup research. Note: Pie chart is for graphic purposes only and not intended to indicate any portfolio construction by the relativ
Slide 41: Retooling their Hedging Strategies
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 41 $750 $750 $1,065 $1,335 $980 $1,000 $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000 $3,500 9/30/2015 Retooling their Hedging Strategies What They Did What We Would Do • At end of Q3 2015, Arlington reduced Euro futures hedge significantly
Slide 42: Corporate Overhead Rationalization
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 42 Corporate Overhead Rationalization Employee Compensation Corporate Overhead • Large salaries to be reduced • Bonus compensation is tied to performance metrics aligned with tangible book value creation • Bonus compensation paid in stoc
Slide 43: Recalibrating Compensation Practices
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 43 Recalibrating Compensation Practices Proposal for Board Compensation • Our Nominees will make the following proposals regarding compensation Proposal for Executive Compensation • Large salaries are eliminated • Legacy bonus structures
Slide 44: Other Initiatives: Improving Risk Management
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 44 Other Initiatives Improving Risk Management • How are positions monitored? • How are risk models overlaid to the portfolio? • How are hedges sized across the curve? • What are the investment committee functions? • What Board oversight
Slide 45: Conclusion
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 45 I Executive Summary II History of Value Destruction at Arlington Asset Investment III Current Compensation Practices IV The Path Forward IV Conclusion
Slide 46: Our Nominees will be Fiduciaries to All Shareholders
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 46 Our Nominees will be Fiduciaries to All Shareholders Aggregate numerous losses Raise dilutive capital Payout unsustainable dividends Enrich fiduciaries with excessive compensation Existing Paradigm Company underperforms on a variety o
Slide 47: Conclusion
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 47 • In the boardroom, the Company’s fiduciaries appear to lack the expertise in MBS and hedging to understand the risks of the strategy • In the executive suite, the Company’s fiduciaries have increased the risks to the business – high
Slide 48: Contact Information
Page 48 Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Contact Information Imation Corp. 1099 Helmo Avenue Suite 250 Oakdale, MN 55128 Joseph A. De Perio, Chairman of the Board Tel: +1 (212) 825 0400 riseuparlington@imation.com Okapi Partners 1212 Avenue of the Americas 24th Floor New Yor
Slide 49: Appendix
Page 49 Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment APPENDIX Macroeconomic Factors to Mortgage REITs Historical Underperformance and Comparisons to Peers Q1 2016 Discussion
Slide 50: Industry Commentary: Positive Macroeconomic Trends
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 50 Industry Commentary: Positive Macroeconomic Trends - Last 5 Years • The U.S. h ousing market remains strong as home prices nationwide increased 4.8% per annum in the last five years • Steady employment gains and job creation over the
Slide 51: Industry Commentary: Recent Dynamics Have Not Been Ideal
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 51 Industry Commentary: Recent Dynamics Have Not Been Ideal • Residential MBS markets experienced a challenging year as MBS credit spreads widened throughout 2015 − Widening credit spreads were driven largely by fears of global economic
Slide 52: Historical Underperformance and Comparisons to Peers
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 52 APPENDIX Macroeconomic Factors to Mortgage REITs Historical Underperformance and Comparisons to Peers Q1 2016 Discussion
Slide 53: Dividend Adjusted Performance Last 5 Years
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 53 -50% -30% -10% 10% 30% 50% 70% 90% Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11 Apr-12 Aug-12 Dec-12 Apr-13 Aug-13 Dec-13 Apr-14 Aug-14 Dec-14 Apr-15 Aug-15 Dec-15 AI '15 Peer Group FTSE NAREIT mREITs Index S&P 500 Index Dividend Adjusted Performance Last 5
Slide 54: Accelerating Underperformance during Tonkel's Tenure as CEO
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 54 -60% -50% -40% -30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20% Jun-14 Sep-14 Dec-14 Mar-15 Jun-15 Sep-15 Dec-15 Mar-16 AI '15 Peer Group FTSE NAREIT mREITs Index S&P 500 Index Accelerating Underperformance during Rock Tonkel’s Tenure as CEO • The stock is
Slide 55: Stock Price Underperformance Against Peers in Every Period
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 55 Stock Price Underperformance Against Peers in Every Period 1 - Year Performance 3 - Year Performance 2 - Year Performance Performance is adjusted for dividends. Source : CapitalIQ. 4 - Year Performance Since the Onset of Mr. Tonkel’s
Slide 56: Performance Since 2010
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 56 • Since 2010, tangible book value per share is down (40.5%) – Investment losses have soared, leverage is at an untenable level Performance Since 2010 Tax Adjusted Net Income Investment Losses Tangible Book Value Per Share Leverage Mul
Slide 57: The Trend Has Worsened During Mr. Tonkel's Tenure
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 57 $23.89 $24.00 $22.63 $19.91 $18.83 $16.27 $16.82 Q2 '14 Q3 '14 Q4 '14 Q1 '15 Q2 '15 Q3 '15 Q4 '15 • Since the appointment of Mr. Tonkel, all relevant metrics have worsened – The risks to this business have all increased The Trend Has
Slide 58: Comparative Performance Last Years
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 58 Comparative Performance – Last 5 Years Tangible Book Value Per Share Growth Average Dividend Yield Average ROE Increase in Leverage Multiple Source: CapitalIQ. • Arlington has underperformed its peers on every relevant performance met
Slide 59: Underperformance Versus Peers Has Accelerated the Past Two Years
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 59 Underperformance Versus Peers Has Accelerated the Past Two Years Tangible Book Value Per Share Growth Average Dividend Yield Average ROE Increase in Leverage Multiple Source: CapitalIQ. • Arlington has underperformed its peers on ever
Slide 60: Recent Performance vs. Analyst Estimates
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 60 • “…the company's results were below expectations for shareholders,” Mr. Tonkel, Q4 2015 Earnings Call • “…the company recorded an increase to the valuation allowance against its deferred tax asset. The increase is attributable primar
Slide 61: Q1 2016 Discussion
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 61 APPENDIX Macroeconomic Factors to Mortgage REITs Historical Underperformance and Comparisons to Peers Q1 2016 Discussion
Slide 62: Q1 2016 Recap
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 62 • Non - GAAP Core Operating Earnings were $0.80 per share and the GAAP Loss Per Share was ($1.38) • Tangible book value declined 14% from December 31, 2015 – Of the $2.37 per share decline, $0.63 per share was attributable to the divi
Slide 63: Evolution of the Agency MBS Book from Q4 to Q1
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 63 Q4 2015 Q1 2016 Change Market Value/ Market Value/ Market Value/ MBS Securities Notional Duration Notional Duration Notional Specified Agency MBS $3,865.0 4.4 $3,417.9 3.3 ($447.2) Net long TBA positions 389.0 4.5 729.8 2.8 340.8 Tota
Slide 64: The CEO's Comments on the Q1 2016 Earnings Call
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 64 The CEO’s Comments on the Q1 2016 Earnings Call Source: Q1 2016 Earnings Call Transcript, dated May 10, 2016. “In a falling interest rate and wider spread environment such as this past quarter , this hedging strategy will likely resul
Slide 65: Important Information About The Participants
Enhancing Shareholder Value at Arlington Asset Investment Page 65 Important Information About The Participants Solicitation IMATION CORP., ROBERT B. FERNANDER, CLINTON MAGNOLIA MASTER FUND, LTD., CLINTON GROUP, INC., JOSEPH A. DE PERIO, AND GEORGE E. HALL, SCOTT R. ARNOLD, BARRY L. KASOFF, W. BRIAN
Arlington Asset Investment — Proxy Contest (May 2016) on 6ix