Wet Seal — Proxy Contest (September 2012)
37 slides from Wet Seal's proxy contest presentation, Sep 21, 2012
Slide 1: Enhancing Stockholder Value at The Wet Seal, Inc.
Enhancing Stockholder Value at The Wet Seal, Inc. September 2012 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies I N FRASTRUCTURE | AGILITY | EXPERTISE This presentation shall not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any sec
Slide 2: Important Information About The Solicitation
Important Information About The Solicitation CLINTON GROUP, INC., CLINTON SPOTLIGHT FUND, L.P., CLINTON SPOTLIGHT MASTER FUND, L.P., CLINTON MAGNOLIA MASTER FUND, LTD., CLINTON RETAIL OPPORTUNITY PARTNERSHIP, L.P., CLINTON SPECIAL OPPORTUNITIES MASTER FUND, LTD. AND GEORGE E. HALL (COLLECTIVELY, “CL
Slide 3: An Opening Thought
An Opening Thought “The problems that exist in the world today cannot be solved by the level of thinking that created them.” — Albert Einstein Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 2
Slide 4: Wet Seal Company Overview
Wet Seal Company Overview n The Wet Seal, Inc. (Nasdaq: WTSL.A) is a women’s specialty retailer that operates 551 stores in 47 States and Puerto Rico, and e-commerce sites § Company operates two concepts – Wet Seal o A junior apparel brand for girls and young women aged 15 to 23 o Trend-focused appa
Slide 5: The Company Has Performed Poorly In Recent Years
The Company Has Performed Poorly In Recent Years § Hallmarks of underperformance are objective and clear: – Stock has been cut in half under tenure of this Board(1) – Stock has underperformed peers in trailing 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 years – Stock is down 43% in the year leading up to our consent sol
Slide 6: This Board Is to Blame for the Company’s Performance
This Board Is to Blame for the Company’s Performance § Incumbent Board has little relevant experience – In the absence of such experience, the Board, we believe, has been unable to critically oversee management or to lend an independent, informed judgment to strategy – Competitors’ Boards are replet
Slide 7: Stockholders Can Empanel A New Board
Stockholders Can Empanel A New Board The Independent Nominees have the experience and expertise necessary to affect a turnaround at Wet Seal. Raphael Benaroya Dorrit Bern Lynda Davey Mindy Meads John Mills Founder, Former Former Chairman, Chairman and CEO Former President and Former President and Ch
Slide 8: Wet Seal’s Record of Underperformance
I Wet Seal’s Record of Underperformance II Responsibility for Underperformance Rests with the Incumbent Board of Directors III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Invest
Slide 9: Performance of Wet Seal Common Stock
Performance of Wet Seal Common Stock From January 1, 2007 to August 22, 2012,(1) Wet Seal’s common stock price declined by 58%. Source: Capital IQ. (1) After the close of trading on August 22, 2012, Clinton Group, Inc. announced publicly its intention to solicit fellow stockholders for their written
Slide 10: Wet Seal Is A Serial Underperformer
Wet Seal Is A Serial Underperformer Wet Seal has underperformed against an equal-weighted index of its peer companies over time. Source: Capital IQ and Company filings. All returns calculated through August 22, 2012 when Clinton Group, Inc. announced publicly its intention to solicit fellow stockhol
Slide 11: Total Company Comparable Store Sales Performance
Total Company Comparable Store Sales Performance Comparable store sales declined in 72% of the months from January 2007 to August 2012. Joel Waller (Feb. 05 - Susan McGalla (Jan. 11 - Jul. Ed Thomas (Oct. 07 - Jul. 10)(1)(2) May 07)(1) 12)(1)(3) Harriet Sustarsic Dyan Jozwick (May 06 - May 08) Maria
Slide 12: Performance Versus Peers
Performance Versus Peers(1) Compared to the performance of specialty apparel peers, Wet Seal’s performance has been weak. Quarterly Comparable Store Sales Growth Quarterly ROIC(3) SSS Growth ROIC Peers(2) Wet Seal Peers (2) Wet Seal Quarterly EBITDA Margin(4) FY11 Sales Per Square Foot(5) EBITDA Mar
Slide 13: Store Count Has Increased While Productivity Has Declined
Store Count Has Increased While Productivity Has Declined Wet Seal has invested in growing its store base but its merchandising decisions have negatively impacted store productivity. Wet Seal: FY End Store Count Vs. Sales / Sq. Ft. Source: Capital IQ and Company filings. Globally Diversified Investm
Slide 14: Capitalization and Return on Invested Capital
Capitalization and Return on Invested Capital Wet Seal is significantly overcapitalized on an absolute basis and relative to its peers, resulting in an inferior return on invested capital. (1) Selected Peers(2): Current Net Cash as Percentage of Market Capitalization Source: Capital IQ and Company f
Slide 15: Arden B. Presents An Unresolved Strategic Quandary
Arden B. Presents An Unresolved Strategic Quandary Arden B does not have the scale to be profitable and is a drag on the Company’s overall performance. Total Stores By Specialty Retail Brand Arden B. Comparable Store Sales SSS Growth Arden B. Estimated Free Cash Flow(1) Source: Individual company fi
Slide 16: Responsibility for Underperformance Rests with the Incumbent Board
I Wet Seal’s Record of Underperformance II Responsibility for Underperformance Rests with the Incumbent Board of Directors III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Invest
Slide 17: Incumbent Board Has Record of Poor Stewardship
Incumbent Board Has Record of Poor Stewardship We believe stockholders cannot rely on the incumbent Board to make good decisions. n The incumbent Board has overseen years of continuous underperformance – Try as they might, they have been unable to find a formula to create value for stockholders – We
Slide 18: Director Pay Is Excessive Given Performance
Director Pay Is Excessive Given Performance Over their tenure, the current Wet Seal directors have realized more than $16 million(1) in compensation, equal to $435k per director per year. 2011 Non-Chair Director Compensation 2011 Chairman Compensation 2004-2012 Stock Ownership(2) Source: Company fil
Slide 19: Board’s Independent Judgment Cannot Be Relied Upon - Part I
Board’s Independent Judgment Cannot Be Relied Upon - Part I The Board has repeatedly made the wrong decision, reversing course shortly thereafter (but only after prompting from stockholders) Original Decision Clinton Group Response / Feedback Board’s About-Face “We cannot wait … any longer for [Ms.
Slide 20: Board’s Independent Judgment Cannot Be Relied Upon - Part II
Board’s Independent Judgment Cannot Be Relied Upon - Part II The Board has repeatedly made the wrong decision, reversing course shortly thereafter (but only after prompting from stockholders) Original Decision Clinton Group Response / Feedback Board’s About-Face “The act of granting one another this
Slide 21: Board’s Recent Hail Mary Pass Is No Touchdown For Stockholders
Board’s Recent Hail Mary Pass Is No Touchdown For Stockholders § On September 20, 2012, the Board took steps to correct its errant ways: – Suddenly, the Board believes it is overpaid and is cutting its pay – Suddenly, the Board has decided it should not have adopted a poison pill with a 10% threshol
Slide 22: Summary: The Case For Change
Summary: The Case For Change n The Company has no CEO: the most critical decision now facing the Company is picking the right leader – Current Board has made a series of costly mistakes (many of which they recognized only later and reversed), including mistakes in hiring – Company needs a Board with
Slide 23: Independent Research Analysts Agree That Change is Required
Independent Research Analysts Agree That Change is Required "We simply do not believe that the current team has the skill set necessary to successfully execute a turnaround/return to fast fashion and that represents the greatest risk to salvaging shareholder value in our view. We feel that this situ
Slide 24: Introduction to the Independent Nominees
I Wet Seal’s Record of Underperformance II Responsibility for Underperformance Rests with the Incumbent Board of Directors III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Invest
Slide 25: Credentials of Independent Nominees and Long-Tenured Directors
Credentials of Independent Nominees and Long-Tenured Directors (1)Source: Capital IQ. Excludes membership on audit committee of Wet Seal. (2)Source: Capital IQ. Excludes membership on compensation committee of Wet Seal. Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investme
Slide 26: Raphael Benaroya
Raphael Benaroya Relevant Experience Mr. Benaroya founded the United Retail Group, Inc., a multi-channel fashion retailer of women's apparel and accessories, in 1987. He served as a Chairman, CEO and President of the United Retail Group, growing it to 550 stores in malls and shopping centers in 36 s
Slide 27: Dorrit Bern
Dorrit Bern Relevant Experience Ms. Bern is the former Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer and President of Charming Shoppes Inc., a specialty retailer specializing in women's plus-size fashion, where she served from 1995 to 2008. Ms. Bern formulated a new business strategy to save Charmi
Slide 28: Lynda Davey
Lynda Davey Relevant Experience Ms. Davey has served as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Avalon Group Ltd, a boutique investment bank, and Avalon Securities Ltd, one of the few woman-owned FINRA and SEC-registered broker-dealers, since she co-founded the companies in 1992. She has broad exper
Slide 29: Mindy Meads
Mindy Meads Relevant Experience Ms. Meads was President and Co-Chief Executive Officer of Aeropostale, Inc. from 2007 to 2010, where she reinvigorated the merchandise assortment, strengthened the fashion value equation and led the development and successful launch of "P.S.," Aeropostale's Kids Divis
Slide 30: John Mills
John Mills Relevant Experience Mr. Mills has been President of SDE, a consulting firm that specializes in the retail sector, store operations and growth strategies, since 2006. From 2004 to 2006, he served as Chairman of the Board of G and G Stores Inc., a specialty retailer focused on teenage women
Slide 31: How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
I Wet Seal’s Record of Underperformance II Responsibility for Underperformance Rests with the Incumbent Board of Directors III Introduction to the Independent Nominees IV How the Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Invest
Slide 32: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value n With deep operating experience, the Nominees can provide active oversight and direction to management – Dorrit Bern and Mindy Meads have the merchandising experience to reconnect with the company’s core customers – Raphal Benaroya has already stud
Slide 33: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value With active oversight, the Nominees are ready, willing and able to chart a path to success and implement change Day 1. Identify and Hire a CEO (Entire Board) § A new, independent Board (absent of a long history of § A strong candidate will want indu
Slide 34: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value With active oversight, the Nominees are ready, willing and able to chart a path to success and implement change Day 1. Optimizing Store Operations (Raphael Benaroya and John Mills) § The nominees have visited numerous stores and have done § Adjust i
Slide 35: How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value
How Our Nominees Can Help Create Stockholder Value With active oversight, the Nominees are ready, willing and able to chart a path to success and implement change Day 1. Rationalize Real Estate Footprint (John Mills) § Identify optimal four-wall store economics § Opportunistically negotiate more fav
Slide 36: Contact Information
Contact Information Clinton Group Corporate Office: 9 West 57 Street 26th Floor New York, New York 10019 Contacts: Gregory P. Taxin, Managing Director Tel: +1 (212) 825 0400 Globally Diversified Investment Institution Specializing In Alternative Investment Strategies Page 35
Slide 37: Disclaimers
Disclaimers THIS PRESENTATION IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY, OR THE PARTICULAR NEED OF ANY SPECIFIC PERSON WHO MAY RECEIVE THIS PRESENTATION, AND SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS ADVICE ON THE MERITS O