Vitacost.com Inc

Vitacost.com — Proxy Contest (May 2010)

21 slides from Vitacost.com's proxy contest presentation, May 26, 2010

  1. Slide 1: Schedule 14A Consent Statement

    UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Consent Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a Party other than the Registrant x Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Consent Statement ¨

  2. Slide 2: The Case for Change at Vitacost.com, Inc. (NASDAQ: VITC)

    * * * * * * * * * * * * The Case for Change at * Vitacost.com, Inc. * * (NASDAQ: VITC) * * * * * * * * *

  3. Slide 3: Executive Summary

    Executive Summary On March 23, 2010, Great Hill Equity Partners IV, LP and certain of its affiliates (“Great Hill”) acquired 5.4 million shares of common stock of Vitacost.com, Inc. (the “Company” or “Vitacost”), amounting to a 19.7% stake. Great Hill purchased the shares at a price of $11.25 per sh

  4. Slide 4: Why Vitacost needs better strategic oversight

    Why Vitacost needs better strategic oversight Operational underperformance since going public • Manufacturing problem in Q1 2010 during the Company’s seasonally strongest quarter and only months after the IPO (1,2) • Inability to manage shipping logistics / costs (split-shipping items to customers)

  5. Slide 5: Vitacost's Board lacks relevant experience relative to comparable companies

    Relative to the Boards of Directors at comparable companies, Vitacost’s Board lacks relevant experience REPRESENTATIVE EXAMPLES Total Board Members 7 8 6 Prior public or private company Board 0.0% 87.5% 100.0% experience (0 of 7) (7 of 8) (6 of 6) 0.0% 62.5% 83.3% Prior eCommerce experience (0 of 7)

  6. Slide 6: Stock price performance since IPO

    Stock price performance since IPO November 4, 2009: Issued Q4 2009 revenue guidance of $48.0-$49.0 million, implying flat growth on a March 24, 2010: sequential basis Board of Directors approved the adoption of “poison pill” February 18, 2010: Provided strong Q1 2010 and FY 2010 guidance April 21, 2

  7. Slide 7: Consent solicitation

    Consent solicitation Vitacost shareholders are permitted to act by written consent Great Hill is asking shareholders to consent to the following proposals: • Proposal 1:amend Vitacost’s bylaws to allow shareholders to fill vacancies on the Board • Proposal 2: remove four current directors (Eran Ezra

  8. Slide 8: Great Hill's nominees for Vitacost's Board of Directors

    Great Hill’s nominees for Vitacost’s Board of Directors Christopher Gaffney • Co-Founder and Managing Partner, Great Hill Partners • Private equity investor since 1986; over 20 years experience • Has delivered approximately $1 billion in sales proceeds to investors on Internet sector investments sin

  9. Slide 9: Great Hill's nominees will seek to:

    Great Hill’s nominees will seek to: Ensure that Vitacost’s growth and expansion plans are effectively implemented by management • Further automate distribution centers • Expand SKU count • Manufacture a higher proportion of products in-house • Integrate ERP system with existing software infrastructu

  10. Slide 10: Great Hill is not seeking control of Vitacost

    Great Hill is not seeking control of Vitacost Great Hill is subject to Delaware’s “interested stockholder” statute (DGCL Section 203) • Until March 23, 2013, Great Hill cannot acquire Vitacost without the approval of Vitacost’s Board and 66²/3% of the outstanding stock which is not owned by Great Hi

  11. Slide 11: Profile of Great Hill Partners

    Profile of Great Hill Partners About Great Hill Partners Great Hill Partners Funds Overview 2008 Great Hill Equity Partners IV, LP $1.1 billion Boston-based private equity firm 2006 Great Hill Equity Partners III, LP $750 million $2.7 billion under management 2001 Great Hill Equity Partners II, LP $

  12. Slide 12: Past Investments: BuscaPé.com, Inc.

    Great Hill Partners’ Representative Past Investments: BuscaPé.com, Inc. $374,000,000 • BuscaPé.com, Inc., (“BuscaPé.com”) founded in 1999 in São Paulo, is the leading eCommerce platform in Latin America, providing online comparison shopping services, free classifieds, lead generation, electronic pay

  13. Slide 13: Past Investments: IGN Entertainment, Inc.

    Great Hill Partners’ Representative Past Investments: IGN Entertainment, Inc. $650,000,000 • IGN Entertainment, Inc. (“IGN”) is the Internet's leading information, entertainment and eCommerce destination for video game enthusiasts, providing both free and paid content and services Online destination

  14. Slide 14: Past Investments: SmartMail, LLC

    Great Hill Partners’ Representative Past Investments: SmartMail, LLC $390,000,000 • SmartMail, LLC (“SmartMail”) is a leading provider of expedited shipping services for lightweight packages (less than 5 lbs.) and flat-sized mail. The company's logistics services allow business shippers to save up t

  15. Slide 15: History of Great Hill's involvement with Vitacost

    History of Great Hill’s involvement with Vitacost • Great Hill had several discussions with the management team of Vitacost and completed substantial due diligence of the Company in early-2008 when the Company was exploring a potential recapitalization and funding of an initial manufacturing in-sour

  16. Slide 16: The "opportunity cost" of shareholder inaction

    The “opportunity cost” of shareholder inaction • Vitacost currently trades at a significant discount to its peers based on a Firm Value / CY2010E EBITDA trading multiple (8.9x vs. peer median multiple of 17.7x) • Assuming Vitacost were to trade at the median peer multiple of 17.7x, that would imply

  17. Slide 17: Appendix

    Appendix Detailed profiles of Great Hill’s nominees • Christopher Gaffney (page 17) • Mark Jung (page 18) • Michael Kumin (page 19) • Jeffrey Stibel (page 20) 16

  18. Slide 18: Nominee profile: Christopher Gaffney

    Nominee profile: Christopher Gaffney Christopher Gaffney is one of the co-founders of Great Hill Partners, a Boston-based private equity firm with $2.7 billion under management focused on growth companies under $1 billion in enterprise value. As a Managing Partner, he shares responsibility for the g

  19. Slide 19: Nominee profile: Mark Jung

    Nominee profile: Mark Jung Mark recently served as the CEO of VUDU, Inc., a privately-held Internet digital entertainment company that was subsequently acquired by Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (NYSE: WMT). Prior to joining VUDU, Inc., Mark served as the Chief Executive Officer of IGN Entertainment, Inc. (N

  20. Slide 20: Nominee profile: Michael Kumin

    Nominee profile: Michael Kumin Michael Kumin is a partner at Great Hill Partners, a Boston-based private equity firm with $2.7 billion under management focused on growth companies under $1 billion in enterprise value. Michael focuses on originating and evaluating investment opportunities in the medi

  21. Slide 21: Nominee profile: Jeffrey Stibel

    Nominee profile: Jeffrey Stibel Jeffrey Stibel currently serves as the CEO of the consulting firm Stibel Solutions. Jeffrey is an entrepreneur and business executive that has helped to start and to grow a number of publicly-traded and private companies. He was previously CEO of Interland (NASDAQ: IN

Vitacost.com — Proxy Contest (May 2010) on 6ix