NorthWestern Energy Group, Inc. · NASDAQ:NWE
NorthWestern Energy — Corporate Update (February 2023)
36 slides from NorthWestern Energy's corporate update, Feb 22, 2023
Slide 1: February ETAC Meeting Agenda
February ETAC Meeting Agenda February 22, 2023 Item Lead Start Time End Time Kickoff and Introductions S. Schmitt, NorthWestern 9:00 9:15 IRP Draft Document Overview S. Schmitt, NorthWestern 9:15 9:30 Model Results B. Mauch, Ascend Analytics 9:30 10:30 Open Comments / Responses S. Schmitt 10:30 10:5
Slide 2: IRP Status and Timeline
IRP Status and Timeline • Resource plan delivered to MT PSC March 31, 2023 • Updated inputs to cover • NorthWestern’s participation in the Western Resource Adequacy Program • Colstrip acquisition of 222 MW beginning 2026 • Inflation Reduction Act Tax Credits • Updated technology price forecasts
Slide 3: The Role of the IRP in NorthWestern Resource Procurement
The Role of the IRP in NorthWestern Resource Procurement • Balance reliability, affordability, and sustainability • Identify NorthWestern’s capacity and energy position and determine the least-cost resources to meet future requirements • Supply planning must follow rules set forth in Montana Law • M
Slide 4: IRP Draft Document Chapters – Volume 1
IRP Draft Document Chapters – Volume 1* 1. Executive Summary 2. Planning and Process History 3. Regional Outlook 4. Energy and Environmental Policy 5. Load Service Requirement 6. Existing Resource Portfolio 7. Transmission System 8. Resource Planning Analysis 9. Emerging Technologies 10. Action Plan
Slide 5: Major Themes in 2023 Plan
Major Themes in 2023 Plan 1. Balancing reliability, affordability, and sustainability. 2. Achieving Resource Adequacy with short-term contracts and completing Yellowstone. 3. Participating in the WRAP program for reliability and regional coordination. 4. Markets assessments – impacts of joining an o
Slide 6: Balancing reliability, affordability, and sustainability
Balancing reliability, affordability, and sustainability The 2023 Plan shows • NorthWestern is long on energy • Adoption of QFs and retirements is a major uncertainty in the portfolio • NorthWestern is capacity sufficient after the Colstrip acquisition until 2029 • No fossil fuel resource procuremen
Slide 7: Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position
Existing Resource Portfolio – Capacity Position Winter Summer NorthWestern expects to meet WRAP planning reserve requirements until 2028 with a very slight winter shortfall from 2029 to 2032. Short-term contracts coupled with expected resource additions contribute to the capacity position.
Slide 8: Existing Resource Portfolio – Energy Position
Existing Resource Portfolio – Energy Position 12,000 10,000 Annual Energy (GWh) 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 - 2023 2026 2029 2032 2035 2038 2041 Coal Natural Gas Contracts Hydro Wind Solar Load NorthWestern will be long on energy until 2036
Slide 9: Load Growth
Load Growth • NorthWestern expects annual load growth at 0.3% inclusive of DSM and NEM • Peak demand will also increase at 0.3% per year • Winter peaks will be slightly higher than summer peaks Annual Energy Annual Winter and Summer Peak Demand
Slide 10: Regional Outlook
Regional Outlook The Pacific Northwest faces tightening supply driven mainly from coal retirements • The Northwest Power Conversation Council estimates as much as 2800 MW of capacity will be needed by 2024 • NorthWestern’s reliance on markets for imports is risky going forward
Slide 11: Western Resource Adequacy Program (WRAP)
Western Resource Adequacy Program (WRAP) • NorthWestern’s participation in the WRAP benefits customers through increased resource adequacy from pooling of resources across WRAP participants • NorthWestern plans to enter the binding phase of the WRAP in 2025 or 2026 • WRAP includes a forward showing
Slide 12: WRAP PRM values for NorthWestern
WRAP PRM values for NorthWestern Winter Summer Month PRM Month PRM November 21.6% June 16.5% December 17.7% July 10.4% January 19.0% August 10.3% February 19.9% September 17.9% March 26.9% WRAP PRM values provide the reserve margin requirements in ARS. Winter PRM was set to 20% while summer was set
Slide 13: WRAP ELCC
WRAP ELCC Resource Summer ELCC Winter ELCC Wind 13% 31% Solar 30% 3% 4-hr storage 80% 80% 8-hr storage 100% 100%
Slide 14: Modeling Inputs
r hh 1 1 1001 111101 9 0 200101 00 0 01% Modeling Inputs 0 00010 101 0 0 @ 01100 011 0 NorthWestern Energy Delivering a Bright Future
Slide 15: Commodity Price Forecasts
Commodity Price Forecasts Natural Gas Power 10 250 9 8 CIG 200 AECO Mid-C - Heavy Load 7 Natural Gas Price ($/MMBTU) Power Price ($/MWh) Mid-C - Light Load 6 150 5 4 100 3 2 50 1 0 0 2023 2025 2027 2029 2031 2033 2035 2037 2039 2041 2023 2025 2027 2029 2031 2033 2035 2037 2039 2041
Slide 16: Scenario Approach – Core Cases
Scenario Approach – Core Cases Core Assumptions • No QFs in queue are built • NorthWestern share of Colstrip increases to 444 MW in 2026 Core Scenarios 1. Base Case – no Colstrip retirement 2. Colstrip retires in 2030 3. Colstrip retires in 2035 4. Colstrip retires in 2025 – Replacement with renewab
Slide 17: Sensitivities for Core Scenarios
Sensitivities for Core Scenarios • High load • High gas price forecast • High gas and power price forecast • Carbon price added to NorthWestern resources
Slide 18: Additional Runs
Additional Runs Additional runs using the Base Case portfolio • Half QFs in queue are built • All QFs in queue are built • SMR replaces Colstrip in 2030 • NorthWestern does not increase ownership in Colstrip
Slide 19: ARS Constraints
ARS Constraints 1. Reserve Margin – Requires portfolio to meet annual peak demand plus seasonal reserve margins of 11% in summer and 20% in winter based on the WRAP assigned PRMs for the year 2023. 2. Energy Generation – Requires portfolio to supply no more than 150% of NorthWestern’s load to addres
Slide 20: Candidate resource list
Candidate resource list Technology/Fuel Resource Size Wind 50 MW Renewable Solar 50 MW Stand Alone Storage 25 MW (4- hour) Stand Alone Storage Storage 25 MW (8-hour) Pumped Hydro 100 MW (9 - hour storage) Aeroderivative gas turbine 50 MW Natural Gas Combined Cycle (2x1) 250 MW RICE 18 MW Uranium Sma
Slide 21: Technology Costs
Technology Costs Renewable Resources Energy Storage = $4,000 = $4,000 a a % $3,000 % $3,000 8 8 = nS ca % $1,000 ° $1,000 2S S E $0 a) 6} 2022 2026 2030 2034 2038 2042 6 2018 2022 2026 2030 2034 2038 2042 Geothermal Wind Solar ——PHES = =mBattery Storage 8-hr =eBattery Storage 4-hr Natural Gas $4,000
Slide 22: Modeling Results
r hh 1 1 1001 111101 9 0 200101 00 0 01% Modeling Results 0 00010 101 0008 01100 011 0 NorthWestern Energy Delivering a Bright Future
Slide 23: ARS Results – Core Scenarios
ARS Results – Core Scenarios Results show flexible energy storage and natural gas provide the most value in NorthWestern’s portfolio
Slide 24: Base Case Cost Breakdown
Base Case Cost Breakdown • Annual costs are discounted and summed to get the net present value • Market sales are added as a negative cost • Total cost in Base Case model is estimated at $4.3 Billion over 20 years
Slide 25: Total Supply Costs – Core Scenarios
Total Supply Costs – Core Scenarios
Slide 26: Total Supply Costs – Additional Colstrip studies
Total Supply Costs – Additional Colstrip studies The 222 MW Colstrip acquisition from Avista is estimated to save NorthWestern’s customers $500 million over 20 years
Slide 27: Thermal Operations
Thermal Operations Base Case: Thermal Resources • Market price volatility 100% CELP and YELP growth coupled with 90% declines in average market 80% 70% prices lead to lower capacity 60% Colstrip factors over the next ten 50% years 40% 30% • Colstrip remains above a 20% Basin Creek Dave Gates 50% cap
Slide 28: Energy Position - Base Case
Energy Position - Base Case • Added storage helps absorb the energy oversupply • Wind and hydro resources combine to serve roughly 50% of NorthWestern load.
Slide 29: Carbon Emissions - Base Case
Carbon Emissions - Base Case • The Base Scenario emissions increase in 2026 due to the Colstrip expansion • YELP and CELP have higher emissions per MWh, but lower overall generation • After 2031, emissions remain at 2.5 million tons with Colstrip providing the majority of the emissions
Slide 30: Carbon Emissions - Core Scenarios
Carbon Emissions - Core Scenarios • The overall emissions for the core scenarios depends on the retirement assumption of Colstrip • The Joint Environmental Scenario provides the greatest carbon reduction
Slide 31: Key Take-aways from Resource Planning Modeling
Key Take-aways from Resource Planning Modeling • NorthWestern is “long” energy and capacity adequate until 2029 • This long energy position increases for every added QF • Model favors adding 200 – 300 MW long-duration storage to manage the “energy long” position. • We limit the long energy position
Slide 32: Action Plan
Action Plan 1. Participate in the ongoing development of the WRAP program 2. Maintain construction schedule for Yellowstone completion 3. Continue to monitor the need for an RFP, evaluate Opportunity Resources, and track QF development while maintaining a resource adequate portfolio 4. Continue to e
Slide 33: ETAC Comments and Resolution
ETAC Comments and Resolution • Evaluate early retirement and/or low carbon portfolios • Multiple scenarios were modeled by Ascend and are presented in Chapter 8 • IRP should model with WRAP values • The Plan’s base case is now evaluated using the most recent WRAP accreditations and load estimates. •
Slide 34: ETAC Comments and Resolution, continued
ETAC Comments and Resolution, continued • Consider IRA • NorthWestern accommodated stakeholder feedback in IRP filing to incorporate resource cost reduction in the PowerSimm Modeling • The IRA tax credits were included in all applicable resource cost projections • Desire for renewables, energy conse
Slide 35: New Website
New Website • Supply Planning Website: • https://www.northwesternenergy.com/about-us/gas-electric/electric-supply- resource-procurement-plan • Please sign up for the email distribution list: • https://lp.constantcontactpages.com/su/XE0SdNG • Submit portfolio requests and other feedback via the new f
Slide 36: NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting
NorthWestern Energy – ETAC Meeting February 22, 2023 Thank you. 36
NorthWestern Energy Group — Corporate Update (February 2023) on 6ix