Ultratech — Proxy Contest (June 2016)
42 slides from Ultratech's proxy contest presentation, Jun 22, 2016
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Information - Ultratech Inc.
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ¨ Check the appropriate box: ¨ ¨ Pre
Slide 2: N/A
N/A
Slide 3: Ultratech: Enhancing Shareholder Value
ULTRATECH Enhancing Shareholder Value June 22, 2016
Slide 4: Safe Harbor
Safe Harbor This presentation may include forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, regarding future events or future financial performance of Ultratech. These forward-looking statements are based on our current expectations about our busi
Slide 5: Table of Contents
Table of Contents I. Executive Summary 1 I. A Leader in Technology Driven Markets 3 II. Focused on Enhancing Shareholder Value 10 III. Committed to Maintaining Open Dialogue with Shareholders 22 IV. Ultratech’s Board has Thoroughly Vetted Neuberger’s Nominees 30 V. Recommendation: VOTE The WHITE Pro
Slide 6: Executive Summary
Executive Summary Ultratech is a leader in capital manufacturing equipment for the semiconductor and nanotechnology markets Ultratech’s management and Board weathered industry challenges in 2013-2015 and took significant steps to protect shareholder value • Cost discipline: reduced expenses, shifted
Slide 7: Executive Summary (Cont'd)
Executive Summary (Cont’d) Ultratech has engaged with Neuberger Berman and welcomes its involvement in the Board refreshment process and other corporate governance matters • Ultratech has been engaging with Neuberger and other shareholders with regard to governance and board refreshment • The nomina
Slide 8: A Leader in Technology Driven Markets
A Leader in Technology Driven Markets 3
Slide 9: Ultratech Today
Ultratech Today • Founded: 1979 • IPO: 1993 (NASDAQ: UTEK) • Headquarters: San Jose, CA • Manufacturing: San Jose, CA and Singapore • Large Installed Base: >3000 tools • Strong IP Position: >1000 patents • Technology Driven Markets: – Advanced Packaging Lithography – HBLED Lithography – Laser Anneal
Slide 10: Ultratech is Poised for Growth and Success
Ultratech is Poised for Growth and Success Industry Strategy • Transition from Planar Logic to 3D FinFET • Device transition difficult and costly • Ultratech investment in R&D continues • Logic: LXA melt technology for transistor formation (new world record) • Middle-of-the-line laser applications •
Slide 11: 1Q16 Bookings and Sales
1Q16 Bookings and Sales ALD 2% Service 14% Greater China Southeast Asia 20% Advanced 72% Packaging 57% Europe 2% Laser North Processing America 6% 26% Bookings Sales 6
Slide 12: Sustained Industry Leadership in Major Product Lines
Sustained Industry Leadership in Major Product Lines Flash Others Anneal 30% 40% UTEK Laser 70% Anneal* 60% Advanced Packaging (AP) Laser Submelt Anneal Lithography (LSA) * Includes AMAT license Data based on FY2015 Revenues Sources: Financial Reports, Internal Data 7
Slide 13: Worldwide Production with LSA Increasing
Worldwide Production with LSA Increasing • Annual wafer volume on LSA continues to increase • Second wave of foundries entering the 40/28nm logic business • Leading edge capacity addition for millisecond expected in 2016-2017 • Technical advantages of LSA become more significant at future nodes Stea
Slide 14: Advanced Packaging Expansion
Advanced Packaging Expansion Cu Pillar Industry has transitioned away from solder bump technologies (~150um pitch) to Cu pillar (~50um pitch) Main Benefits: • Finer pitch capable down to 50 µm in-line and 40 µm / 80 µm staggered • Higher current capability (3x higher than solder) • Reduced signal im
Slide 15: Focused on Enhancing Shareholder Value
Focused on Enhancing Shareholder Value 10
Slide 16: Ultratech Has Significantly Outperformed Peers
Ultratech Has Significantly Outperformed Peers 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% (10.0%) (20.0%) (30.0%) (40.0%) (50.0%) (60.0%) 2016 YTD 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year UTEK Peers Peer Index reflects the median total shareholder return of the following: Axcelis Technologies, Cascade Microtech, Cohu, Electro Scie
Slide 17: 2012 - Forbes ranked Ultratech #49 fastest growing public company
2012 – Forbes ranked Ultratech #49 fastest growing public company 12
Slide 18: 2013 - Forbes ranked Ultratech #19 fastest growing public company
2013 – Forbes ranked Ultratech #19 fastest growing public company 13
Slide 19: Ultratech Began Warning of Industry Challenges in Early 2013
Ultratech Began Warning of Industry Challenges in Early 2013 Despite excellent Q1 2013 earnings results, we communicated the following on our conference call held April 18, 2013: Industry Challenges Clearly Articulated • “It’s well known that the semiconductor logic foundries are moving from one gen
Slide 20: What happened in 2013-2015?
What happened in 2013-2015? 10.0% • Memory was hot, Logic was not 0.0% • Logic capital spending slowed due to: (10.0%) • DRAM pricing and NAND Flash growth • Yield challenges at smaller nodes meant (20.0%) minimal performance improvement and higher cost at 20nm, 16/14nm (30.0%) (40.0%) • FinFET chal
Slide 21: Management and Board Weathered Industry Challenges in 2013-2015
Ultratech’s Management and Board Weathered Industry Challenges in 2013-2015 Diversified Business Disciplined Approach • Focused on Advanced Packaging • Revised management incentive and saw a new wave of activity from program to take costs out of the OSATs organization • Expanded Superfast line of pr
Slide 22: Operating Cash Flow
Operating Cash Flow 90 80 In good times: very positive 70 60 50 40 30 In bad times: minimally negative 20 10 0 -10 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 (3 mos.) 17
Slide 23: Significantly Outperforming Peers in the Near-Term
Significantly Outperforming Peers in the Near-Term 15.0% Recent strength vs peers due to: 10.0% • Advanced Packaging momentum • Expansion due to copper pillar and 5.0% fan-out wafer level packaging 0.0% • OSAT activity (5.0%) • Resurgence in LSA for 28nm • Most reliable performance at lowest cost (1
Slide 24: Financial Improvement in 2016
Financial Improvement in 2016 4Q15 1Q16 1Q16 2Q16 Actual Consensus Actual Guidance Sales $28.3M $39.1M $45.2M “up 5%-10% over 1Q16” “profitable on both a GAAP EPS ($0.33) ($0.11) ($0.04) and non-GAAP basis” 19
Slide 25: Positive YoY Growth Compared to Peers for 1Q 2016
Positive YoY Growth Compared to Peers for 1Q 2016 Sales Sales YoY 1Q16 1Q15 Growth Electro Scientific Industries, Inc. 51.5 37.6 37% Cascade Microtech, Inc. 34.8 31.7 10% Ultratech, Inc. 45.2 41.9 8% Rudolph Technologies, Inc. 54.4 52.6 3% Cohu, Inc. 65.8 68.1 -3% Nanometrics Incorporated 47.5 50.4
Slide 26: Positive Momentum in 2016
Positive Momentum in 2016 • Book to bill > 1.3 to 1 in 1Q16 • New systems bookings included several orders for LSA, Superfast 3D Inspection and Advanced Packaging • Total bookings in 1Q16 exceeded every quarter since 4Q12 • Strong bookings have continued into 2Q16 with another LSA order and several
Slide 27: Committed to Maintaining an Open Dialogue with Shareholders
Committed to Maintaining an Open Dialogue with Shareholders 22
Slide 28: Recent Engagement with Shareholders
Recent Engagement with Shareholders • In response to shareholder feedback from the 2015 Annual Meeting, the Board and the Compensation Committee expanded dialogue with shareholders to better understand their perspectives on compensation and corporate governance issues. • Since July 2015, we have eng
Slide 29: Significant Actions Based on Shareholder Feedback
Ultratech Has Taken Significant Actions Based on Shareholder Feedback Executive Compensation • Significantly lowered 2015 executive compensation Board Refreshment • Nominated Dr. Paramesh Gopi to replace Joel Gemunder, who is not standing for re-election • Instead of simply appointing Dr. Gopi to th
Slide 30: Executive Compensation Program Highlights
Executive Compensation Program Highlights Following shareholder engagement as well as meetings with ISS and Glass Lewis, we implemented the following changes: • Implemented performance measures into our named executive officer long-term incentives awarded in 2015 by making payouts dependent upon tar
Slide 31: Ultratech Actively Engaged with Neuberger Berman in 2015
Ultratech Actively Engaged with Neuberger Berman in 2015… August 2015 NB sends letter to UTEK October 2015 expressing disappointment NB sends another letter to with long-term shareholder UTEK reiterating prior value creation, tenure of concerns and reserving the current Board members right to put fo
Slide 32: Actively Engaged with Neuberger Berman in 2016
…and Has Actively Engaged with Neuberger Berman in 2016 April 2016 March 2016 NB notifies UTEK of its NB proposes Ms. Beatriz intent to nominate Ms. Infante and Dr. Ronald Infante and Dr. Black to Black for appointment as be elected to the Board directors. at the Annual Meeting. February 2016 April
Slide 33: Significant Progress in Succession Planning
Ultratech Has Made Significant Progress in Succession Planning In February 2016, we announced the promotion of two executives to executive officers as part of our ongoing leadership succession process Tammy D. Landon, Senior Vice President of Operations • Currently leads human resources, information
Slide 34: Do Not Be Fooled by Neuberger's False and Misleading Statements
Do Not Be Fooled by Neuberger’s False and Misleading Statements on Ultratech Neuberger used selective time periods and stock indices to place Ultratech’s stock performance in a negative light • When compared to our semiconductor capital equipment peers, Ultratech has outperformed this group year-to-
Slide 35: Ultratech's Board Thoroughly Vetted Neuberger's Nominees
Ultratech’s Board Thoroughly Vetted Neuberger’s Nominees 30
Slide 36: Nominee Dr. Ronald Black is Not Additive to Board
Neuberger’s Nominee Dr. Ronald Black is Not Additive to Ultratech’s Board Dr. Ronald Black • Zafiropoulo and Child, in their respective capacities as CEO and Chair of the NCG Committee, met in person with Dr. Black, discussing his background and exploring possible issues presented by his appointment
Slide 37: Nominee Ms. Beatriz Infante is Not Additive to Board
Neuberger’s Nominee Ms. Beatriz Infanteis Not Additive to Ultratech’s Board Ms. Beatriz Infante • Zafiropoulo and Child met in person with Ms. Infante, discussing her background, experience and qualifications. • Mr. Child provided Ms. Infante with a questionnaire to be returned and evaluated by the
Slide 38: Ultratech Has An Experienced, Independent and Diverse Board
Ultratech Has An Experienced, Independent and Diverse Board Noted for both his leadership skills and technical expertise throughout the semiconductor industry with over Chairman and CEO, Art Zafiropoulo five decades of industry experience Ultratech Currently a Top 10 shareholder with over 3% of the
Slide 39: New Board Member Identified through an Independent Shareholder
Ultratech Has Proposed a New Board Member Identified through an Independent Shareholder Paramesh Gopi, PhD President and Chief Vice President and Principal Engineer Principal Engineer Executive Officer General Manager (June 2008 – present) Key Attributes • Seasoned executive with deep knowledge of c
Slide 40: Recommendation: VOTE The WHITE Proxy Card
Recommendation: VOTE The WHITE Proxy Card FOR Ultratech’s Highly-Qualified Nominees 35
Slide 41: Ultratech is Poised for Continued Growth and Success
Ultratech is Poised for Continued Growth and Success Sustained Industry Segment Leadership Portfolio of High-value Products Addressing Industry Needs Positive Momentum in 2016 leading into an “up” cycle Focused on Improving Financial and Operational Execution 36
Slide 42: Vote the WHITE Proxy Card Today
Vote the WHITE Proxy Card Today • Ultratech is a leader in technology driven markets • Management and Board are focused on enhancing shareholder value • Management and Board are committed to strong corporate governance and maintaining an open dialogue with shareholders • Board's Corporate Governance