Evans Bancorp Inc

Evans Bancorp — IPO Roadshow (January 2017)

27 slides from Evans Bancorp's IPO roadshow presentation, Jan 17, 2017

  1. Slide 1: Common Equity Offering

    Common Equity Offering January 17, 2017 David J. Nasca President & CEO John B. Connerton Executive Vice President & CFO NYSE MKT: EVBN www.evansbank.com Issuer Free Writing Prospectus Dated January 17, 2017 Filed Pursuant to Rule 433 Registration Statement No. 333-210443

  2. Slide 2: Disclaimer

    This presentation has been prepared by Evans Bancorp, Inc. (“Evans Bancorp” or the “Company”) solely for informational purposes based on its own information, as well as information from public sources. This presentation has been prepared to assist interested parties in making their own evaluation of

  3. Slide 3: Offering Summary

    Offering Summary Issuer: Evans Bancorp, Inc. Offering: Follow-on common stock Gross Amount Offered: $14 million Over-Allotment Option: 15% Exchange / Symbol: NYSE MKT / EVBN Market Capitalization¹: $152 million Current Semi-Annual Dividend: $0.38 Dividend Yield¹: 2.1% Use of Proceeds: To support our

  4. Slide 4: Corporate Profile

    Corporate Profile Evans Established: Headquarters: Hamburg, NY Bank Branches: 14 Insurance Agency Locations: 7 © 2017 by Evans Bancorp Community-based diversified financial services company Provides banking, insurance and investment services in Western New York Achieved $1 billion in assets on recor

  5. Slide 5: Financial Summary – Q3 2016

    Total Assets: $1.1 billion Net Loans: $899 million Total Deposits: $898 million Loans / Deposits: 102% Nonperforming Assets / Total Assets¹: 1.41% Total Stockholders’ Equity²: $95.2 million Stockholders’ Equity / Total Assets: 8.8% Tier 1 Leverage: 9.55% Common Equity Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital: 10.8

  6. Slide 6: Management Profile

    Management Profile Executive Position Experience David Nasca President and Chief Executive Officer 34 Years John Connerton Chief Financial Officer 15 Years John Eagleton Chief Lending Officer 32 Years Robert Miller Jr. President of The Evans Agency, LLC 40 Years Paul Ulrich Chief Credit Officer 43 Y

  7. Slide 7: Strategic Plan

    Strategic Plan Refocus Community Banking Model Executed Strategic Plan (Fiscal Years 2013 - 2015) Effective Risk Management Effective Lending Strategy Fee Based Income Growth Strengthen Operating Model Optimize Technology: Execute core conversion 33% Loans 2013 - 18% Deposits 2013 - 2015 Non-Interes

  8. Slide 8: Stock Performance

    Stock Performance 3-Year Total Return (1/13/2014 thru 1/13/2017) 5-Year Total Return (1/13/2012 thru 1/13/2017) +62% +67% +241% +129% Note: Market data as of January 13, 2017; list of companies included in Peer Group can be found in the Appendix Source: SNL Financial 70% 80% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10%

  9. Slide 9: Results – Q3 2016

    Results – Q3 2016 Net Income of $2.2 million or $0.51 Per Diluted Share ROAA: 0.84% ROAE: 9.23% Net Interest Income of $9.1 million Net Interest Margin: 3.67% Total Loans of $913 million¹ Growth of $60 million in Q3 2016 or 28% annualized Deposits of $898 million with Average Cost of 0.45% Growth of

  10. Slide 10: Q3 2016 Performance vs. Peers

    Q3 2016 Performance vs. Peers Note: List of companies included in Peer Group can be found in the Appendix Source: SNL Financial, Company documents Return on Average Assets Return on Average Equity Efficiency Ratio Net Interest Margin 0.84% 0.84% EVBN Peer Group 9.23% 8.59% EVBN Peer Group 70.23% 64.

  11. Slide 11: Over $1 Billion in Assets

    $809.7 $833.5 $846.8 $939.1 1,084.7 Q3 2016 8% CAGR (2012 – Q3 2016) 8% CAGR (2012 – Q3 2016) Over $1 Billion in Assets (in millions) 18% YOY Q3 16 vs Q3 15 Driven by organic loan and deposit growth Platforms increased future earnings power

  12. Slide 12: Record Loan Growth

    $581.3 $647.0 $695.7 $774.0 $912.9 Q3 2016 Record Loan Growth High quality in-market commercial loans Capturing strong credits from competition Supports core business strategy Strong loan pipeline (in millions) 86% 92% 98% 96% 102% Loan to Deposit Ratio 13% CAGR (2012 – Q3 2016) (1) Excludes $1.6 mi

  13. Slide 13: Loan Portfolio Diversification

    22% $64 Loan Portfolio Diversification 27% 16% 23% 12% Q3 2016 Commercial Loan Portfolio Non-owner occupied CRE Owner occupied CRE C & I Multi-family Construction / Development $546 $187 $2 $113 Q3 2016 Total Loan Portfolio: $913 million¹ Average Yield: 4.39% Commercial & Multi-Family² Commercial &

  14. Slide 14: Solid Credit Fundamentals

    ALLL/ NPLs¹/ NCOs/ ALLL/ Total Loans Total Loans Avg. Loans NPLs¹ © 2017 by Evans Bancorp Solid Credit Fundamentals Booking high quality assets Solid underwriting discipline Strong customer relationships Note: List of companies included in Peer Group can be found in the Appendix (1) Nonperforming lo

  15. Slide 15: Conservative Securities Portfolio

    Conservative Securities Portfolio 10% of Total Assets 94% of Obligations of States and Political Subdivisions Rated A or Higher Effective Portfolio Duration is 3.9 Years $105 million Total Securities

  16. Slide 16: Strong Core Deposit Growth

    32% $679.0 $706.6 $707.6 $803.0 $898.0 Q3 2016 8% CAGR (2012 – Q3 2016) 8% CAGR (2012 – Q3 2016) 55% 13% Strong Core Deposit Growth 15% YOY Q3 16 vs Q3 15 15% Demand 9% NOW 14% Savings (in millions) Q3 2016 Deposit Composition Savings & Money Market Time Deposits Demand & NOW Average Cost of Deposit

  17. Slide 17: Non-Interest Income Opportunity

    5% 15% Q3 2016 TTM Non-Interest Income: $11.5 million Non-Interest Income Opportunity 25% of total Q3 2016 TTM revenue Emphasis on expanding: Financial services Employee benefits Insurance Cash management 21% Other Income 59% Insurance Service & Fees Bank-owned Life Insurance Bank Charges

  18. Slide 18: Capital Overview

    Capital Overview Both the Company and the Bank have consistently maintained regulatory capital ratios significantly above the federal “well capitalized” standards indicates minimum level to be considered “well capitalized” 5.00% 8.00% 10.00% 5.00% 8.00% 10.00% Bank Consolidated 16.00% 14.00% 12.00%

  19. Slide 19: Returning Capital to Shareholders

    $0.26 2.1% 1.8% EVBN Peer Group Current Dividend Yield Returning Capital to Shareholders $0.65 $0.72 $0.76 $0.24 2013¹ Dividend Payment History $0.50 Note: Market data as of January 13, 2017; list of companies included in Peer Group can be found in the Appendix (1) One semi-annual dividend of $0.24

  20. Slide 20: Market Opportunity / Future Vision

    Market Opportunity / Future Vision NYSE MKT: EVBN www.evansbank.com

  21. Slide 21: Public/Private Project: The Bank for a Resurgent WNY

    Public/Private Project Evans committed $1 million Housing Opportunity Fund (Joint with City of Buffalo) $475 thousand over 2 years The Bank for a Resurgent WNY Seneca Street Lofts Tim Hortons Café & Bake Shop Stanton Building Community Reinvestment - Buffalo Information Technologies Innovation and C

  22. Slide 22: Opportunity from Market Disruption

    Opportunity from Market Disruption Note: Market share data for Buffalo-Cheektowaga-Niagara Falls, NY Metropolitan Statistical Area as of June 30, 2016; market share does not sum to 100% due to rounding (1) Reflects Northwest Bank’s purchase of 18 FN branches, consisting of $1.6B in Deposits, in Sept

  23. Slide 23: Transformative Growth Phase of Strategy

    Transformative Growth Phase of Strategy New Four-Year Plan (2016 – 2020) Organic Market Growth: Lead with Business Market Disruption Fee-Based Income Growth Retail Transformation Talent Acquisition & Retention Capital Management IT Optimization

  24. Slide 24: Investment Highlights

    Investment Highlights Strong and growing franchise in resurgent WNY Diverse revenue mix, strong operating fundamentals Core deposit and loan growth Lower-risk balance sheet with solid capital base Sophisticated / experienced management team Shareholder return orientation Historically reasonable valu

  25. Slide 25: Appendix

    Appendix NYSE MKT: EVBN www.evansbank.com

  26. Slide 26: Peer Group

    Peer Group Note: Includes banks that trade on a major exchange (NYSE, NYSE MKT, or NASDAQ) with Total Assets between $1 billion and $3 billion that are headquartered in the Northeast or Mid-Atlantic Regions; exclude targets of announced merger transactions; financial data for the quarter ended Septe

  27. Slide 27: Common Equity Offering

    Common Equity Offering January 17, 2017 NYSE MKT: EVBN www.evansbank.com

Evans Bancorp — IPO Roadshow (January 2017) on 6ix