WCI Communities — Proxy Contest (May 2007)
23 slides from WCI Communities's proxy contest presentation, May 31, 2007
Slide 1: WCI Board and Management Investor Presentation May 2007
WCI Board and Management Investor Presentation May 2007 WCI Board and Management Investor Presentation May 2007
Slide 2: Forward-looking statements
Certain information included herein and in other company reports, Securities and Exchange Commission filings, statements and presentations is forward-looking within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, including, but not limited to, a potential sale of the Company, ex
Slide 3: Agenda
Who is WCI? Homebuilding sector challenges Background of discussions with Mr. Icahn Overview of WCI WCI’s Sale Process Carl Icahn’s Proxy Fight WCI’s Board and Corporate Governance WCI is listening and taking action Maximizing value through pursuit of a possible sale of the Company WCI’s current boa
Slide 4: Attendees
James Dietz Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Kathleen Shanahan Director James McDonald Director Don Ackerman Chairman of The Board Charles Cobb Vice Chairman of The Board Hilliard Eure Director Steven Zenker Vice President, Investor & Corporate Communication Jerry Starkey Directo
Slide 5: I. Overview of WCI
I. Overview of WCI I. Overview of WCI
Slide 6: WCI history, business summary and financial statistics
WCI began its operations in Florida through companies that principally focused on developing amenitized communities in the state In 1995, certain stockholders of Florida Design led a group of equity investors in acquiring Westinghouse Electric’s real estate business unit In 1998, the assets and mana
Slide 7: Homebuilding market softness, especially in Florida
The current softness in the North American homebuilding market, specifically in Florida, has adversely affected WCI’s operating performance Nationwide new home starts for homebuilders, including WCI, have fallen from 382,000 in the first quarter of 2006 to 259,000 in the first quarter of 2007 and ea
Slide 8: Background of discussions with Mr. Icahn
11 December: Mr. Icahn, a roughly 4% owner, indicated to the Company that he was interested in acquiring additional shares and that he believed the stock to be undervalued (close: $17.57) December 2006 January 2007 February 2007 March 2007 16 January: Mr. Icahn disclosed that the Icahn Group owned a
Slide 9: II. WCI's Sale Process
II. WCI’s Sale Process II. WCI’s Sale Process
Slide 10: WCI is Listening and Taking Action
Our Company is committed to an active and ongoing dialogue with all shareholders to ensure that we are delivering on our promises and are holding ourselves accountable We have consistently reached out to shareholders – including recently – to hear their views Our Board of Directors, assisted by its
Slide 11: Maximizing Value: Pursuit of a Sale
To protect and maximize value for ALL its shareholders, WCI is pursuing a sale process wherein all potential buyers, including the Icahn Group, can participate on equal terms without unfair advantages We have received interest from several parties who are potentially interested in acquiring the Comp
Slide 12: Current Board is Best Positioned to Direct the Sale of the Company
Eight of the current Board members have been involved in the sale of companies in the past Not all of Mr. Icahn’s nominees are independent of Mr. Icahn. Four of the nominees have publicly disclosed professional affiliations with Mr. Icahn. They may favor Mr. Icahn’s interests to the detriment of oth
Slide 13: III. Carl Icahn's Proxy Fight
III. Carl Icahn’s III. Carl Icahn’s Proxy Fight Proxy Fight
Slide 14: Mr. Icahn: Mixed Signals
Has not articulated a concrete action plan to enhance value for shareholders “Unlock shareholder value” Allowed his tender offer to expire “Offer to purchase any and all of the outstanding Shares at a price of $22.00 per Share” Offered $22 per share for “any and all” shares “Now is not the right tim
Slide 15: Icahn offered to buy any and all shares, then let offer expire
The Icahn Group offered to buy “any and all” of the Company’s shares and then let the offer expire. His actions send mixed signals to shareholders In initiating a tender offer, the Icahn Group stated that “clearly now is not the right time to sell” However, apparently Mr. Icahn believed that it was
Slide 16: The initial offer was structurally coercive
The initial offer, which Mr. Icahn allowed to expire, was structurally coercive No back-end transaction No post-offer protections Would trigger an event of default under WCI’s credit facilities and other debt The design of the Offer may have subjected shareholders who decided not to tender to substa
Slide 17: Current Board better positioned to deliver and protect value
The current Board is better positioned to deliver and protect WCI’s value for all shareholders in light of the Board’s significant operating experience in the industry and determination to pursue a sale process for the Company The business is highly dependent on relationships with our employees and
Slide 18: The Icahn Group Has Not Presented Any Plan for Maximizing Value
The Icahn Group has not presented any plan or proposal to shareholders that would suggest it intends or has the capability to deliver superior value to all shareholders Previously, Mr. Icahn has called for the elimination of procedural safeguards such as the limited-duration shareholder rights plan
Slide 19: IV. WCI's Board and Corporate Governance
IV. WCI’s Board and Corporate Governance IV. WCI’s Board and Corporate Governance
Slide 20: Strong Governance
8 of our 10 directors are independent; one director is a non-management insider who, along with his family, owns approximately 9.3% of WCI’s outstanding shares Separated positions of Chairman and CEO Independent Audit, Compensation and Corporate Governance & Nominating Committees Since Mr. Icahn's i
Slide 21: Mr. Icahn: Over-Boarded
In November 2006, Mr. Icahn said on CNBC, regarding a director that served on too many boards: “How can a guy be on eight boards and know what the hell he's doing? These companies are complicated and you have tremendous competition from abroad. How can somebody sit on a board - even if he's the smar
Slide 22: Director backgrounds and tenure
(8 years tenure) Former Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Eckerd Corporation (12 years tenure) President and Chief Executive Officer of Westport Advisors Chairman of the Board of Trustees of Clark University (6 years tenure) President and Chief Executive Officer of WCI Communities Former Presi
Slide 23: Conclusion
WCI’s Board has taken decisive action focused on the interests of, and designed to maximize value for, all shareholders WCI’s current directors are best suited to deliver value and navigate the challenging housing and real estate market The election of Mr. Icahn’s slate of director-nominees could je