FBR & — Proxy Contest (May 2016)
43 slides from FBR &'s proxy contest presentation, May 25, 2016
Slide 1: Investor Update May 2016
aii FBR Investor Update May 2016
Slide 2: Cautionary Statement
Cautionary Statement FBR & Co. was formed as a Virginia corporation in June 2006 to be the holding company for FBRC. This document is intended for information purposes only, and shall not constitute a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell, any security or services, or an endorsement of any particu
Slide 3: Table of Contents
Table of Contents FBR & Co. Overview …………………………………………….… 4 Performance vs. Close Peers …………………………….……... 14 Corporate Governance …………………….…………..………... 22 Executive Compensation ……………………………….……….. 31 Voce Catalyst Partners’ Proxy Campaign …………….……….. 35 Summary and Conclusions ……………………………………… 41 I II
Slide 4: Section I: FBR & Co. Overview
Section I: FBR & Co. Overview
Slide 5: FBR & Co. at a glance
Ticker: FBRC Founded: 1989 Employees1: 287 Headquarters: Arlington, VA Offices: Boston, MA Dallas, TX Houston, TX Los Angeles, CA New York, NY San Francisco, CA Top Tier Middle Market Equities Franchise Unique small cap expertise in initial equity underwriting focused on seven core industry groups r
Slide 6: Key Milestones & Achievements
Key Milestones & Achievements Management proactively implemented a plan to build greater resiliency into the platform while prudently positioning the company for future opportunities Restructuring Period
Slide 7: Business Transformation
Business Transformation In 2008, prior to the major restructuring of the firm, FBR’s business was in need of change, with: A loss of nearly $200 million pre-tax on net revenues of $182 million Fixed costs running at almost $250 million annually, including: Headcount over 750, more than twice the siz
Slide 8: 2008 vs. Today – More Focused & Cost Effective
2008 vs. Today – More Focused & Cost Effective 2008 1Q 2016 758 Full-time Employees Front office (538 or 71%) Back office (220 or 29%) 287 Full-time Employees Front office (240 or 84%) Back office (47 or 16%) Arlington (569) New York (74) San Francisco (19) Los Angeles (16) Houston (7) Boston (18) D
Slide 9: Investment Banking Market Fee Opportunities
Investment Banking Market Fee Opportunities Source: Dealogic, ECM Analytics, PIPO and IPO, U.S. issuers, SEC-Registered, Rank Eligible Transactions, Market Value less than $1.5B The initial equity market for small cap companies experienced a dramatic 44% decline in 2015. This is the segment of the m
Slide 10: Summary Financials: 2008 vs. Post–Restructuring
Summary Financials: 2008 vs. Post–Restructuring Operating Income was $17.4M in 2014 vs. a loss of nearly $200M in 2008 on nearly identical net revenue 2008 principal investing produced $42M in merchant bank impairments; $34M loss on MBS trade; $5M write-down on mutual fund seed investments From 2008
Slide 11: Expense Discipline Has Been a Key Driver in Stabilization
Expense Discipline Has Been a Key Driver in Stabilization Non-Compensation Fixed Costs ($ millions) Compensation-to-Net Revenue Ratio Restructuring Period Restructuring Period Dramatic 65% decline in non-comp fixed expenses from 2008 – 2015 Significantly reduced comp-to-net revenue post-restructurin
Slide 12: ~60% of FBR outstanding shares repurchased since December 09
~60% of FBR outstanding shares repurchased since December 2009 – steady approach over time resulted in accretive impact to book value per share of ~$5.49 Reflects common shares outstanding for book value per share purposes and 1 for 4 reverse stock split effected on 2/28/13. This non-GAAP presentati
Slide 13: Tangible book value growth since 2011
Tangible book value has grown by $12.03 per share since 2011 reflecting the positive impact of earnings, share repurchases, Asset Management divestiture, and recaptured DTA, partially offset by shareholder dividends Earnings and Capital Allocation Decisions Produced 76% Growth in Tangible Book Value
Slide 14: Section II: Performance vs. Close Peers
Section II: Performance vs. Close Peers
Slide 15: FBR vs. Close Peers Analysis
FBR vs. Close Peers Analysis The appropriate time frame for analysis and comparison begins in 2012 after FBR management had completed restructuring Following restructuring, FBR delivered three consecutive years of profitability – an average of $197 million in revenue – and significant outperformance
Slide 16: Revenue Per Head vs. Close Peers
Revenue Per Head1 vs. Close Peers FBR $639 Peers $581 FBR Close Peer Group Average 2012 – 2014 Adding 2015 2012 – 2014 Adding 2015 FBR $717 Peers $571 1. Based on average head count and $ in thousands.
Slide 17: Compensation-to-Net Revenue Ratio vs. Close Peers
Compensation-to-Net Revenue Ratio vs. Close Peers FBR Close Peer Group Average 2012 – 2014 Adding 2015 2012 – 2014 Adding 2015 FBR 56% FBR 58% Peers 67% Peers 67%
Slide 18: Operating Margin vs. Close Peers
Operating Margin vs. Close Peers FBR 5% Peers 9% FBR Close Peer Group Average 2012 – 2014 Adding 2015 2012 – 2014 Adding 2015 FBR 11% Peers 10% 2015
Slide 19: Capital Management vs. Close Peers
Capital Management vs. Close Peers January 1, 2012 – December 31, 2015 ($ millions) Financial Metric FBR & Co. Piper Jaffray Cowen Group JMP Group Total share repurchases $196 $262 $121 $28 Common dividends paid $4 - - $22 Change in share count (48%) (15%) (6%) 4% Change in TBV / share 76% 36% 35% 1
Slide 20: Total Return vs. Close Peers
Total Return1 vs. Close Peers January 1, 2012 (Post-Restructuring) to December 31, 2015 Jan 1 - 12 Cowen Group: 48% JMP Group: (8)% FBR & Co: 148% Piper Jaffray: 100% 1 Total return includes share price performance plus dividends.
Slide 21: Tangible Book Value / Share vs. Close Peers
Tangible Book Value / Share vs. Close Peers January 1, 2012 (Post-Restructuring) to December 31, 2015 Jan 1 - 12 FBR & Co: 76% Piper Jaffray: 36% Cowen Group: 35% JMP Group: 1%
Slide 22: Section III: Corporate Governance
Section III: Corporate Governance
Slide 23: Experienced and Independent Board, Dedicated to Responsible Governance
Experienced and Independent Board, Dedicated to Responsible Governance Key Board and Governance Information:
Slide 24: Board Composition & Compensation
Board Composition & Compensation 1 Includes a $1.0 million annual payment of a strategic advisory fee to Crestview Advisors LLC pursuant to a professional services agreement under which, in exchange for ongoing strategic advice and assistance, we agreed to pay Crestview Advisors LLC starting in 2007
Slide 25: Alignment with Shareholders
Alignment with Shareholders Board members, executives, and employees are significant stockholders – a total of 25% of shares outstanding - whose interests are aligned with outside holders (percentage ownership as of May 6, 2016) Independent Board Members – 4.3% Executive Committee – 10.0% Non-Execut
Slide 26: Exceptional, Independent Board Members with Required Skills and Experience
Exceptional, Independent Board Members with Required Skills and Experience to Direct our Business Reena Aggarwal Director since: 2011 The Robert E. McDonough Professor of Business Administration and Professor of Finance at Georgetown University’s McDonough School of Business; former Deputy and Inter
Slide 27: Exceptional, Independent Board Members (continued)
Exceptional, Independent Board Members with Required Skills and Experience to Direct our Business (continued) Mark R. Patterson Director since: 2015 Former Managing Director and Equity Analyst, NWQ Investment Management Co., LLC Former Vice President Investor Relations, U.S. Bancorp Extensive experi
Slide 28: Board & Management Business Model Review
Board & Management Business Model Review Is each industry group performing as expected? Can we expect each to contribute to earnings and enhance overall profitability, maximizing the likelihood we achieve our targeted returns? Which, if any, do not - is there justification for preserving the optiona
Slide 29: Business Model Review Methodology
Business Model Review Methodology Deconstructed current model into component industry verticals Quantified the infrastructure costs necessary to execute the core ECM business Rebuilt business model to assess the accretive impact of each component on the financial results of the firm Evaluated two re
Slide 30: Capital Allocation & Management Review
Capital Allocation & Management Review The foundation of that analysis is the determination of the range of total capitalization that not only supports business operations, but also meets regulatory requirements and instills confidence with counterparties and investors Following on that foundation,
Slide 31: Section IV: Executive Compensation
Section IV: Executive Compensation
Slide 32: Compensation vs. Proxy Compensation Peers
Compensation vs. Proxy Compensation Peers Executive compensation at FBR directly accountable to performance. Highest TSR among proxy peers. Dramatic reductions in 2014 and 2015 (down 67% and 77%, respectively, from 2013) Note: Amounts in all cases are taken from supplemental company proxy tables tha
Slide 33: Compensation vs. Proxy Compensation Peers (continued)
Compensation vs. Proxy Compensation Peers (continued) The tables below provide the same measures, but based on the firms’ “summary compensation table,” which by SEC requirements include the value of share grants made in each year Note: Amounts in all cases are taken from summary company proxy tables
Slide 34: Compensation Multiples vs. Proxy Compensation Peers
Compensation Multiples vs. Proxy Compensation Peers 2012 – 2015 CEO / Average Employee Note: Calculations reflect data publicly available in respective company’s annual SEC 10-K and proxy statement filings. Named Executive Officers (Top 5) / Average Employee 2012 – 2015
Slide 35: Section V: Voce Catalyst Partners' Proxy Campaign
Section V: Voce Catalyst Partners’ Proxy Campaign
Slide 36: Timeline
Timeline May 5, 2015 May 26, 2015 June 25,2015 July 16,2015 July 23, 2015 ‘August 4, 2015 ‘September 8, 2015 September 16, 2015 September 21, 2015 October 1, 2015 October 6, 2015 October 21, 2015 ‘Almost 4 months later February 12- February 18, 2016 March 28, 2016 FBR & CO) Mr. Hendrix and Mr. Me He
Slide 37: Problems with Voce Campaign – Misleading Shareholders
Problems with Voce Campaign – Misleading Shareholders Voce claims management and Board have “recklessly diversified” business, when the facts are clearly to the contrary and the firm has narrowed its focus Voce has never made any suggestions directly to the Company about its business other than to l
Slide 38: Problems with Voce Campaign – Flawed Ideas
Problems with Voce Campaign – Flawed Ideas FBR is not capitalized in a way where a large, one-time return of capital is prudent or advisable Total equity is down from over $400 million to $190 million as we have steadily returned capital to shareholders If the company was able to return capital in s
Slide 39: Problems with Voce Campaign – Their Nominees Would Dilute the Board
Problems with Voce Campaign – Their Nominees Would Dilute the Capabilities and Expertise of Our Board The Company’s nominees represent a diverse mix of talents and backgrounds and deep leadership experience We have refreshed our Board significantly and through that process added: Significant M&A and
Slide 40: Voce-Directed Companies Have Posted Negative Returns
Voce-Directed Companies Have Posted Negative Returns The companies listed below include each instance where Voce has been successful in putting one or more of their nominees onto the Board of Directors. While every company has its own industry and economic dynamics – the addition of Voce director no
Slide 41: Section VI: Summary and Conclusion
Section VI: Summary and Conclusion
Slide 42: Summary and Conclusion
Summary and Conclusion FBR has performed, is focused on growing shareholder value, and actively engages with shareholders Highest growth in TBV/share and highest shareholder return of close peers Return of $228 million in capital through repurchases and dividends Introduction of quarterly dividend t
Slide 43: Office locations and contact details
Metropolitan Washington, D.C. Headquarters 1300 North 17th Street Arlington, VA 22209 703.312.9500 . www.fbr.com Boston Houston Los Angeles New York San Francisco One International Place, Suite 1350 Boston, MA 02110 617.951.6900 9 Greenway Plaza, Suite 2050 Houston, TX 77046 713.226.4700 Dallas 100