MutualFirst Financial Inc

MutualFirst Financial — MFB — Merger or Acquisition (January 2008)

21 slides from MutualFirst Financial's merger presentation, Jan 8, 2008

  1. Slide 1: Creating a Stronger Indiana Banking Franchise: Transaction Overview

    Go Ahead! Creating a Stronger Indiana Banking Franchise Transaction Overview January 8, 2008

  2. Slide 2: Forward Looking Statements

    Forward Looking Statements When used in this presentation and in filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, in other press releases or other public shareholder communications, or,in oral statements made with the ‘approval of an authorized executive officer, the words or phrases “believe,”

  3. Slide 3: Additional Information

    Additional Information MutualFirst will file a registration statement on Form S-4 with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC’) in connection with the proposed transaction. The registration statement will include a joint proxy statement of MutualFirst and MFB that also constitutes a prospe

  4. Slide 4: Key Transaction Terms

    Key Transaction Terms Transaction Value = $37.08 average price per share(1) = Approximate aggregate transaction value of $52.7 million = MEB Financial merged with and into Mutual Federal Savings Bank Form of Consideration = 80% stock / 20% cash = MEB shareholders may elect to receive 2.590 shares of

  5. Slide 5: Compelling Transaction Rationale

    Compelling Transaction Rationale = Consistent with MutuaiFirst strategic expansion plan into attractive Northern Indiana markets of South Bend- Mishawaka and Elkhart = 11th largest depository institution based in state = New markets bring compelling relative demographics and population exceeding 520

  6. Slide 6: Compelling Transaction Rationale

    Compelling Transaction Rationale Low Execution Risk Financially Attractive Go Ahead! Experienced management team dedicated to successful execution and integration Complementary business philosophies, cultures and management depth Conservative, achievable cost savings assumptions Thorough due diligen

  7. Slide 7: Complementary Branch Franchises

    Complementary Branch Franchises " Dep. Markt fank Rank compan rcs, _(Gi_‘Sre { WPMowantharee.cu ai) tet Sings 1208 0 2 atin! Sy Sop cord ta "WSme ‘Ger & Ranting Banc (Or) ie aoa 7 4&4 Gland sane S S590 be 52 ‘etsouce cop cn) @ 3aue Sar Elica & 8 KeyCorp (OH) i 25689 290 7 Hettegondanshares neon Hams

  8. Slide 8: Enhanced Demographic Profile

    Enhanced Demographic Profile = Relative Demographics: Two largest MSAs for each company e271 cette 1.78% 2.4% South Bend Elkhart = Muncie. === Marion South Bend Elkhart. = Muncie. Marion Median Household Income 5 Year Projected HHI Growth 176886 $64,588 South Bend Elkhart = Muncie Marion SouthBend E

  9. Slide 9: Pro Forma Franchise

    Pro Forma Franchise = Top Indiana MSA Markets MFSF MFBC Projected Median Projected MFSF MFSF Make MFBC MFBC Market Tota Total _—Total Pop. HH HH : Growth Income Growth Indianapotis-Carmel, IN $25,082 8.44% $60,100 Fort Wayne, IN 4,959 ag 54.598 Evanarille, INKY. 5923 495 48,495, ‘South Bend-Mishawak

  10. Slide 10: Loan Portfolio Diversification

    Loan Portfolio Diversification =" More bank-like loan portfolio further diversifies Mutua/First’s loan composition 0.1% 11.9% 9.3% 13.0% 50.7% 16.7% 10.0% Yield: 6.57% Yield: 6.76% Yield: 6.63% mu 1-4 Family mg CRE m Consumer = C4! and Cther Note: Based on 9/30 LTM data oN Go Ahead!

  11. Slide 11: Enhanced Funding Profile

    Enhanced Funding Profile " Better diversified deposit portfolio lowers MutualFirst’s deposit costs MutualFirst - Deposit Profilegij MFB Corp. - Deposit Profile Pro Forma Deposit Profile 74% 21.9% 148% 12.3% as% 19.1% 17.8% 23.7% 12.2% 44.8% 127% s22% Cost: 3.50% Cost: 2.97% Cost: 3.33% Demand mg NOW

  12. Slide 12: Experienced Management Team

    Experienced Management Team = Talent from both organizations combine for a deep, experienced management team dedicated to integration and growing the pro forma institution Banking Name Title Experience (yrs.) Age (yrs.) David Heeter CEO 29 46 Patrick Botts President & COO 22 43 Charles Viater Region

  13. Slide 13: Increased Fee Income Contribution

    Increased Fee Income Contribution = Focus on wealth management and pickup of approximately 1,000 trust accounts representing more than $400 million of assets under management improves revenue mix Estimated Revenue Impact Assets Under Management $553 $413 74% . % % 65% T1% 73% $140 MFSF MFB Pro Forma

  14. Slide 14: Credit Quality

    Credit Quality = Consistency in credit quality NCOs / Avg Loans 1.20% 1.00% 0.80% a 0.60% x 0.40% 0.20% 0.00% 2002 2003 2004 2006 2006 yD

  15. Slide 15: Reasonable Transaction Pricing

    Reasonable Transaction Pricing Average Offer Price Per Share $37.08 MFBC Values Per Share Midwestem Median (1) Transaction Multiples Price / Book Value $31.25 118.7% Price / Tangible Book Value $28.29 131.1% Price /LTM Core EPS (2) $1.48 25.1x Core Deposit Premium $254.10 5.5% Market Premium (3) $26

  16. Slide 16: Meaningful Earnings Improvement

    Meaningful Earnings Improvement =" Estimated Cost Savings & Earnings Per Share Accretion 2008 2009E 2010E Estimated Pre-Tax Cost Savings: Salary, Benefits & Employee Expenses $816 $2,277 $2,391 Data Processing Expense 196 546 574 Professional Fees 176 491 515 Occupancy & Equipment Expense 19 331 37

  17. Slide 17: Financial Assumptions

    Financial Assumptions = 2.590 fixed exchange ratio on 80% of MFB shares = $41.00 per share in cash on 20% of MFB shares =" MEB options rolled into equivalent MFSF options = 24.0% cost savings; $4.5mm 2009 pre-tax = 7.00% opportunity cost of cash = $4.7mm pre-tax deal related expenses ™ 3.00% core de

  18. Slide 18: MFB Perspective

    MFB Perspective Charles J. Viater MFB Corp. President & CEO

  19. Slide 19: Questions

    Questions

  20. Slide 20: Appendix: Additional Financial Detail

    Appendix: Additional Financial Detail = Pro Forma Financial Analysis Standalone (1) MatualFirst MFB Financial Pro Forma (2) Balance Sheet Assets $966,789 $510,448 1,482,941 Loans 812,954 403,070 1,283,462 Deposits 706,397 333,803 1,051,544 Equity 87,771 41,057 130,338 Capital Tang. Equity / Tang. As

  21. Slide 21: Appendix: Additional Financial Detail

    Appendix: Additional Financial Detail =" M&A Midwest Transaction Comparable Groups ‘Announce Target Ded Price’ Price)—-Price/ CoreDep Market Date Buyer Target Heaiquarters Value LTMEPS Book TEV Prem Prem 92/2007 tea Berk Com /Pecples Cammunty Bencom Ino. WestCheste,OH «S87S—ONM=—= 005% «151.2% «48%

MFB — Merger or Acquisition (January 2008) on 6ix