ALTERRA CAPITAL HOLDINGS Ltd

ALTERRA CAPITAL — Max Capital Group — Q1 2010 Earnings Presentation

28 slides from ALTERRA CAPITAL's earnings presentation, May 10, 2010

  1. Slide 1: First Quarter 2010

    Exhibit 99.1 First Quarter 2010 May 10, 2010

  2. Slide 2: Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-Looking Statements

    Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may include forward-looking statements, both with respect to Max and its industry, that reflect its current views with respect to future events and financial performance. Statements that include the words “expect,” “intend,” “pla

  3. Slide 3: Alterra – A Winning Combination

    Alterra –A Winning Combination Merger of Equals of two strong organizations Enhances position with clients and brokers Combines “best in class" reinsurance group with a global specialty platform Provides diversified and stable earnings over time Established platforms in all major insurance markets D

  4. Slide 4: Transaction Overview

    Transaction Overview Structure – Stock for stock merger of equals – 3.7769 shares of Max for each Harbor Point share Exchange Ratio – Fixed exchange ratio – 52% by Harbor Point shareholders (fully diluted) Pro Forma Ownership – 48% by Max shareholders (fully diluted) – $2.50 per share cash dividend

  5. Slide 5: Combining Strong Management With Deep Experience

    Combining Strong Management With Deep Experience Name Position Marty Becker President, Chief Executive Officer, Director John Berger Chief Executive Officer of Reinsurance, Vice Chairman of Board Peter Minton Chief Operating Officer Joe Roberts Chief Financial Officer Andrew Cook Chief Integration O

  6. Slide 6: World Class Board Led by Michael O'Reilly

    World Class Board Led by Michael O’Reilly Max Harbor Point Name Affiliations Name Affiliations Managing Partner of Blair Franklin Capital Michael O’Reilly Retired Vice Chairman and CFO of The Chubb Gordon Cheesbrough Partners, Inc. Former President and CEO of Chairman Corporation Deputy Chairman Alt

  7. Slide 7: Combination Enhances Market Profile

    Combination Enhances Market Profile Shareholders’ Equity (3/31/10) ($ in billions) Combination provides greater size and scale PRE $7.4 – Enhances valuation and ratings RE $6.0 profile AXS $5.4 – Provides greater financial flexibility ACGL $4.4 TRH $4.0 Enhanced position with clients and brokers RNR

  8. Slide 8: Global Reach Through Established Platforms

    Global Reach Through Established Platforms Reinsurance Insurance Lloyd’s U.S. Specialty Insurance Major – Agriculture – Aviation – Personal accident – General liability Classes – Aviation – Excessliability – Financial institutions – Marine – General casualty – Professional liability – Professional l

  9. Slide 9: Max Capital – Global Specialty Underwriter

    Max Capital –Global Specialty Underwriter Life & Annuity Lloyd’s 9% 3% Global underwriter of specialty insurance and Reinsurance reinsurance U.S. Specialty 21% 36% – Multiple operating platforms – Diversified business profile across specialty classes of business 31% – Highly experienced management w

  10. Slide 10: First Quarter 2010 Highlights Max Capital

    First Quarter 2010 Highlights Max– Capital Consistent financial performance with first quarter 2010 operating diluted EPS of $0.71 per share P&C premiums written declined 14.6% to $370.3 million as growth from new underwriting teams was offset by increasingly competitive market conditions Net invest

  11. Slide 11: Harbor Point – Best in Class Franchise

    Harbor Point "–Best in Class" Franchise Specialty Formed in 2005 with "A" A.M. Best rating 15% – No legacy exposures Casualty 49% Longstanding franchise led by John Berger 36% Property – Chubb Re management team and book of business Diversified reinsurer with an excellent track record 2009 GPW: $608

  12. Slide 12: First Quarter 2010 Highlights Harbor Point

    First Quarter 2010 Highlights Harbor – Point First quarter 2010 net income of $33.5 million $306.6millionofpremiumswrittenupfrom$228.5millionin thefirstquarter2009 Premium growth primarily in Specialty lines due to favorable opportunities in crop and trade credit Q1 2010 premiums written split betwe

  13. Slide 13: Conservative Operating Leverage

    Conservative Operating Leverage Strong operational flexibility, well positioned to support opportunistic growth over time As of March 31, 2010 Harbor Point Max (1) ($ millions) Gross Premiums Written $371.1 $306.6 $677.7 Net Premiums Written $217.9 $299.5 $517.4 Retention 59% 98% 76% Shareholders' E

  14. Slide 14: Strong Financial Position

    Strong Financial Position Well-positioned balance sheet with conservative financial leverage As of March 31, 2010 (1) Max Harbor Point ($ millions) Cash and Investments $5,344.6 $2,685.2 $7,725.8 Loss & LAE Reserves $4,527.3 $762.5 $5,289.8 Debt $90.5 $200.0 $290.5 Shareholders' Equity $1,613.1 $1,9

  15. Slide 15: Diversified and Balanced Business Mix

    Diversified and Balanced Business Mix A compelling strategic fit, with limited overlap Max Harbor Point 2009 GPW = $1,375 million 2009 GPW = $608million 2009 GPW = $1,983 million Life & Annuity Life & Annuity Lloyd’s Lloyd’s 3% 9% 7%2% U.S. Specialty 14% U.S. Specialty 21% 36% Reinsurance 55% Reinsu

  16. Slide 16: Alterra Will Have a Diversified Portfolio of Business

    Alterra Will Have a Diversified Portfolio of Business Line of Business Other Other Short-Tail Agriculture Europe 6% Marine & Energy 5% 1% 16% 5% Aviation 6% 30% Property Auto 3% 78% North America Professional Liability 21% 4% 2% Other Long-Tail 5% Life 3% 15% Workers’Comp / Medical Malpractice Clash

  17. Slide 17: Complementary Portfolio of Business: Reinsurance

    Complementary Portfolio of Business: Reinsurance Max -Reinsurance Harbor Point Credit Other Specialty Agriculture Credit Other Specialty Other Specialty Marine & Energy Agriculture 3% 2% Agriculture 10% Property Property Marine & Energy Aviation Property 2% 28% Marine & Aviation 5% Auto Energy Medic

  18. Slide 18: Conservative Investment Posture

    Conservative Investment Posture As of March 31, 2010 Max Harbor Point Cash / Short Cash / Short Term Term Cash / Short Term 13% 16% 22% Other Other Investments 6% Investments 6% 4% Other Investments 74% 78% 81% Fixed Income Fixed Income Fixed Income $5.3 Billion $2.7 Billion $8.0 Billion 18

  19. Slide 19: High Quality Fixed Income Portfolio

    High Quality Fixed Income Portfolio As of March 31, 2010 Conservatively positioned Average rating of "AA“ BB or Lower BBB Cash and Short- Term Investments 68% in cash and short-term investments, 3% 3% 17% U.S. Government and Agencies, and AAA A 18% securities 18% U.S. Gov’t and Duration of 3.8 years

  20. Slide 20: Compelling Transaction for Alterra Shareholders

    Compelling Transaction for Alterra Shareholders Max shareholders mergewitha “bestin class”reinsurancefranchise HarborPointshareholders mergewitha globalspecialtyinsurerandreinsurer Capitalof ~$3billionenhancesmarketpositionwith clientsandbrokers Abilityto fullycapitalizeon marketopportunitiesin a so

  21. Slide 21: Alterra means "high ground" — a place of security

    Alterrameans"highground"— a placeof security AlterraCapitalHoldingsLimited Bermuda Ireland United States Lloyd’s Latin America 21

  22. Slide 22: Appendix

    Appendix 22

  23. Slide 23: Shares Outstanding

    Shares Outstanding As of March 31, 2010 Millions, except per share amounts Max Harbor Point (1) (2) Primary Shares Outstanding 57.4 62.5 119.9 Warrant Shares 0.7 8.9 9.6 Weighted average strike price $16.01 $22.62 $22.12 Option Shares 1.7 2.2 3.9 Weighted average strike price $22.32 $26.64 $24.76 __

  24. Slide 24: Harbor Point – Financial Highlights

    Harbor Point F – inancial Highlights 2009 Gross Premiums Written Premiums Written ($ in millions) Specialty $700 $642.6 $672.5 $607.5 15% $600 $511.7 $500 Casualty 49% $400 $590.4 $601.9 $567.9 $506.8 $300 36% Property $200 $100 $0 2006 2007 2008 2009 Total = $608 Million NPW GPW Combined Ratio Shar

  25. Slide 25: Harbor Point Has A Well-Diversified Portfolio of Business

    Harbor Point Has A Well-Diversified Portfolio of Business Property Casualty Specialty Total Per Risk Excess of Loss Multi-line Credit Casualty Specialty Quota Share 5% 14% 26% 23% 15% 20% 49% 16% 36% 75% 31% 86% Aviation 4% Catastrophe Quota Share Crop Marine/Energy Property 2009 GPW: $221 million 2

  26. Slide 26: Max – Financial Highlights

    Max –Financial Highlights 2009 Gross Premiums Written Premiums Written ($ in millions) U.S. Specialty $1,500 $1,375.0 Reinsurance $1,254.3 21% $1,200 $1,078.3 36% $865.2 $900 Max at Lloyd’s 9% $600 $894.5 3% $796.6 $840.2 $634.7 Life & Annuity $300 Reinsurance 31% Insurance $0 2006 2007 2008 2009 To

  27. Slide 27: Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes

    Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes … Insurance Reinsurance (31% of GPW) (36% of GPW) Property Aviation Workers Comp. Agriculture 15% 16% 16% 17% 7% Aviation 18% Property 6% Excess Liability 27% 4% 42% Excess Marine & Liability Energy 15% 14% Professional 3% Liability Professional

  28. Slide 28: With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd's

    …With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd’s U.S. Specialty Max at Lloyd’s (21% of GPW) (9% of GPW) General Accident Casualty 18% & Health 31% Aviation 2% Property 47% Property 47% 18% Fin. Institutions 1% 21% 15% Marine Professional Prof. Liability Liability 2009: $285 million 2009:

Max Capital Group — Q1 2010 Earnings Presentation on 6ix